1. Anyone in those conditions isn't seeing violence glorified the way it is in movies, where the guys you were rooting for win at the end and you rarely see prolonged consequences. Someone in a refugee camp knows all too well that the bad guys can leave people broken and pay no consequences for it.
2. Perhaps not serial killers out of a horror film but it's not like the concept of cycles of violence is unknown: children who grow up in horrible conditions do have a higher rate of either becoming gang/cartel/etc. members, soldiers, etc.[1] or have escalated rates of suicide, domestic violence, substance abuse, etc. because they've never recovered from what happened.
1. either because they have no choice or because they're all too familiar with what happens when you don't represent enough of a threat to deter violence. Closer to home, This American Life had a great interview with kids talking about how they had to join gangs because they'd be getting attacked either way so it was a question of either being afraid to leave your house or having enough allies to be relatively safe most days:
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/487/h...
That's not why most people want to restrict the amount of violent content their children watch.
See, for example, the "You've been Tango'd" ads in the UK. There's a soda called "Tango". One advert showed someone drinking the can, than a fat near naked man painted orage runs in, and slaps the drinker's face with both hands. Children imitated this, causing several perforated eardrums. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Man_%28advertisement%2... (see controversy section). That's one example of children imitating what they saw on tv, and other children being harmed as a result.
EDIT: i'm not saying children copy everything. But this example proves that children do imitate some behaviours; that children are influenced by some things they watch. Ask any parent about the children's show "Caillou" and the change of their children into whiners. Parents realise that some content will cause mild behaviour changes or nightmares and they want to be prepared.
We should be at least overrun by car-jackings at this point thanks to Grand Theft Auto.
A lot of those games involve hardware the children do not have access to. The games also often portray consequences in a way which the kids still know to be very bad. (As much as children play "war," they know viscerally that being in pain and bleeding is generally not fun.
We should be at least overrun by car-jackings at this point thanks to Grand Theft Auto.
There was one young man who enacted a GTA scenario and shot his way out of a police station with a gun he stole from a police officer. However, he is very much the exception.
What the orange advert did was to portray an activity with bad consequences as a trivial and harmless one, in a way that specifically worked around the built in understanding that otherwise deters kids from doing things like that. (Unless they mean harm. That's also within the possible range of behaviors of children. However, it's not so common in many places for children to want to really harm their playmates.)
You mean things like fists, feet, pipes, kitchen knives, crowbars, hammers, that kinda thing? Like others said, if video games made normal people violent you'd see a lot more violence.
That anecdote about the 'enacting a GTA scenario' would also have happened just like that without the GTA link. Then it becomes a guy with a gun in a police station.
Yes. Actually, there was an incident I was personally witness to involving someone's 8 year old son and an ordinary clawhammer. There is clearly such a thing as "desensitization," and opposition to the notion is usually the kind of unconscious bias one generally sees in politics. < http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/ > Note that my position is not so simpleminded as to be simply placed on one side or another of the typical Internet argument.
If you believe that widespread gun ownership generally increases the incidence of gun injuries, then you are subscribing to the same general theory, that availability increases likelihood. Do I believe that's a justification for banning things? No, but we should be honest about the existence of such effects. (Also, fists and feet are an entirely different category, as they are naturally part of your body. And while I said it wasn't common in some places, in others kids do use those to enact violence.)
Like others said, if video games made normal people violent you'd see a lot more violence.
I would put good odds on your repeating what lots of people angrily repeat on the Internet in defense of their hobby. In the grand scheme of things, people are violent! We are extraordinarily violent as animals. In particular, we have an ability to band together in groups and murder each other in a coordinated fashion, one that probably predates our getting language! We also accomplish fantastic things living together, so we also have fantastic mechanisms for coexisting. Seeing things in media does have the effect of reinforcing the portrayed actions and scenarios in our minds. However, human minds are very complex and robust. We have mental defenses, much as we have homeostatic mechanisms.
That anecdote about the 'enacting a GTA scenario' would also have happened just like that without the GTA link. Then it becomes a guy with a gun in a police station.
Read up on the incident and honestly tell me that GTA had nothing to do with putting the idea into his head. Of course, one could also find other pieces of media he was exposed to conveying much the same message. The systemic problems resulting in his violence are probably more serious and of greater import to society than the content of some video game.
I guess that's one theory.
The same goes with what you put in your brain; if you watch slime, slime is more acceptable to you and what comes out of you is only a product of what goes in - slime. Just because someone in the past did horrific things doesn't mean we need to expose ourselves to a barrage of horrific things.
?! Is this some leftover trauma from not being allowed in to an R-rated film when you where 13? The only people who are constrained by ratings are producers, and then only in the sense that producers push for an R rating (thereby pushing the envelope of what's acceptable for an 'R') because many theater chains refuse to show NC-17 movies for commercial reasons.
The second, more serious criticism I have is that the moral panic associated with exposure to children to onscreen violence, sex, and drugs can only diminish the real outrage that we ought to feel when kids in war-torn countries, inner-city slums, and refugee zones actually experience real-life violence and horror beyond anything Hollywood can conjure, and on a daily basis. If most of those kids don't grow up to be serial killers, I somehow doubt a movie is going to do it.