News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:57AM (#8996211)
As someone who went from 430 ng/dl to 1024 ng/dl naturally in about two years time (from age 23 to 25) the only thing I can say is don't jump to too many conclusions here.

- Your testosterone should be naturally high if you're below 30 (and male)

- If not, something is wrong and you need to fix it (start with blood work, check your diet, move)

- If you testosterone is in the normal ranges (blood work recommends between 600 and 1200, which is ridiculous), you'll feel good 80-90% of the time

- the 10-20% are probably psychological worries that you might have, start meditating

- I didn't get huge muscles or less body fat with more testosterone (huge myth that I thought would change for me)

- TRT is used heavily in pro-sports (look for UFC fighters and bodybuilders, they have the most experience, since a lot of them are doing it)

- TRT is a problem if you keep going for too long, because your body just doesn't produce testosterone as it used to, because it expects it from the outside, so below 35 or rather below 40 year olds: don't sign up for this too quickly.

- Cold showers/baths do work, but probably not for increasing your testosterone, still, do it from time to time :)

- Intermittent Fasting helps immensely with boosting your testosterone naturally.

I can provide more info or details/specifics if wanted/needed.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by johnward on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:39AM (#8996701)
" I didn't get huge muscles or less body fat with more testosterone (huge myth that I thought would change for me)".

For me I almost always drop 20lbs on T and am much leaner than I am off or on clomid. On clomid I generally gain weight.

"- TRT is a problem if you keep going for too long, because your body just doesn't produce testosterone as it used to, because it expects it from the outside, so below 35 or rather below 40 year olds: don't sign up for this too quickly."

You can counteract this by taking ancillaries while on T. There are drugs that can restore the LH and FSH that get suppressed by testosterone but this is a valid concern. 100mg of T per week made me basically infertile but clomid brought me back to normal after a few weeks.

Diet and nutrition is very important if you want to keep optimum T levels. This forum post, not written by anyone in the medical field, has a pretty list of possible causes outside of supplementing with T. http://tnation.t-nation.com/free_online_forum/sports_trainin...

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by driverdan on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:43PM (#9000125)
> For me I almost always drop 20lbs on T and am much leaner than I am off or on clomid. On clomid I generally gain weight.

Were you working out? Taking test isn't a panacea, you still need to be active to get significant body composition changes.

> You can counteract this by taking ancillaries while on T. There are drugs that can restore the LH and FSH that get suppressed by testosterone but this is a valid concern. 100mg of T per week made me basically infertile but clomid brought me back to normal after a few weeks.

The body's endocrine system is closed, it has a tight feedback loop. It sounds like you're referring to cycling on / off which is different than taking it continuously long term.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by droopyEyelids on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:02AM (#8997102)
How did you test your fertility
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by johnward on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:12PM (#8998473)
I am working with a fertility clinic but it's a standard lab test. You do your thing in a cup and they run it through some tests for count, motility, shape, etc. They want more than 15m sperm per ml. I had initial tests on 0, 2m, 5m. After treatment with 25mg of clomid for a few months I had 65m. My wife is also on letrozole and we tried IUI and still haven't got pregnant. It's more difficult than I thought it would be.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gadders on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:56AM (#8997925)
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by voidlogic on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:56AM (#8997533)
I'm guessing its a sperm count / motility test.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by toolz on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:19AM (#8996261)
>- I didn't get huge muscles or less body fat with more testosterone (huge myth that I thought would change for me)

The many studies done on this subject show that testosterone makes a huge impact on muscle growth. Take this 10 week study for instance, http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199607043350101. The placebo group working out didn't experience nearly as much muscle gain as those taking testosterone did when they were not working out.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:28AM (#8996453)
I can only answer with my personal experience here: During the intermittent fasting time (age 25), where I went from from 6xx to 1024ng/dl, I didn't gain significant amount of muscle, although I was working out with heavy (free) weights, 3x per week.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by manmal on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:40AM (#8996478)
Did you also lose bodyfat at that time? Because it's hard to gain mass if you fast and are at a caloric deficit. That's what Leangains' bulking period is all about - eat 10-20% above maintenance so you do gain mass.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:00PM (#8997951)
Definitely lost some body fat at the right places and even gained some mass, but not in crazy amounts.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by atom-morgan on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:22AM (#8996896)
What's the frequency of your fasting how long do you do it?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:58AM (#8997936)
I did do it 6 days per week, although the 7th was naturally a fasting day because I went to bed later and got up later. So you could say almost every day. It gets very easy with time.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by atom-morgan on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:05PM (#8997983)
6 days per week? How many meals are you skipping?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:27PM (#8998608)
You do skip breakfast every day essentially.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by markeroon on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:40AM (#8997409)
I am interested in this also.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by paganel on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:24AM (#8996273)
> The many studies done on this subject show that testosterone makes a huge impact on muscle growth

Genuine question: Why this emphasis on increasing "muscle growth"? What benefits does it bring us (men)?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:02AM (#8996543)
I do power lifting (non-competitive), and while I'm noticeably muscular and lift more than most people at my gym (no competitive lifters there, so doesn't say all that much), I'm not nearly at peak muscle volume nor do I look nearly as big as body builders much smaller than me - leanness makes a huge difference to perceived muscle size. Still, from an hour 2-4 times a week (2 times a week at the moment), with no steroids, these are some of the benefits I've noticed that makes the time investment well worth it for me:

- More attention from people I'd want to find me attractive (and from some I don't...). E.g. after I started lifting weights I got my first "wow" responses when people saw pictures of me. I also saw a massive difference in how people responded when I went out to bars/nightclubs, ranging from comments to people suddenly opting to slider their hand on my stomach or chest when they wanted to get past me instead of tapping me on the shoulder, as well as getting my butt pinched. For the first time I had a woman pick me up from a club.

- Being able to do a lot of movements that I'd struggle with before without thinking about it, and lifting heavy stuff, whether it is sliding that 40kg sever into rails above head height without having to get someone to help me keep it stable, or casually lifting my son up or playing with him in ways that I couldn't have if I didn't have the strength I do (he's nearly 6 - he likes to climb onto my back when I'm sitting on the sofa and stand on my shoulders and jump down; people think both of us are crazy and that he'll hurt me, but it feels nice).

- Far fewer situations makes me feel tired or makes my muscles feel fatigured. E.g. I sprint up stairs where I used to walk up slowly (in fact, when I first started exercising, my knees were so weak that it had started to become painful for me to walk up a single flight of stairs, at age 25, because I was sitting all day and used elevators both at work and at home).

- Feeling safe in a lot of situations I'd have been scared in before. Just a few weeks ago someone was assaulted near our house, and I felt safe enough to run out and confront the guy while we waited for police (I'm in the UK, guns are not a concern; I was aware of the risk of knives, though, and made sure to keep my distance until I felt sure)

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gadders on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:39AM (#8996988)
I don't know about your first point, but definitely all the rest apply to me. I don't look like a body builder, but I definitely feel and look more solid at 43.

Basically for the cost of a few hours a week you can +1 or +2 you strength and consitution scores.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by whitewhim on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:39PM (#8998714)
I also notice calming and de-stressing effects from working out as well. I work long hours normally but I would still much rather go to the gym and workout then go home and lie on the couch, as I'd go insane at the lab if I didn't.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by saiya-jin on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:31AM (#8997334)
Yeah, definitely, but there are drawbacks too. if you already have a woman by your side that you want to spend rest of your life with (and judging by your comment about son, you should be there) - extra ladies attention is annoying as hell. If you are actually mentally a grown up, this ain't an impressive result as it might seem :) (Yes, been/am there, but to impress ladies you don't need to be creepy muscular type. Just a sporty one. Especially if you care about quality of your partner, not just quantity).

as for strength - I find it much better to have real world-usable one, combined with endurance. Examples you describe are OK, but better use cases for me are - being able to climb that mountain (or just hike it), full day of of-piste skiing (its damn hard on quads) etc. In many sports, too much muscles has negative impact. For high altitude, common knowledge is that gym type muscular types struggle more up there. For climbing same. But that's me. It also brings freedom in eating - keeping huge amount of muscles while doing some 3-week effort on Aconcagua... not really possible.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by graeme on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:19PM (#8998995)
>to impress ladies you don't need to be creepy muscular type. Just a sporty one.

This is setting up a false dichotomy. Women (and men) generally don't find an inflated look attractive.

The parent was talking more about strength, rather than muscle volume "I'm not nearly at peak muscle volume nor do I look nearly as big as body builders much smaller than me".

I'm 150 pounds, but I can lift 250. I look strong, sure, but I'm even stronger than I look. I do barbell training, which I'm guessing is what the original comment's author does too.

Women seem to find this lean strength primally attractive. It's true the female attention could cause a problem, but this kind of strength will also make you more attractive to your partner, which is hardly a bad thing.

Strength is versatile too. I can hike a mountain, ski, run, and do pretty much any physical activity you can name. Chronic pain disappeared too. I'm sure I'd lose a bit of strength on a three week trip, but who cares? You can always get that back.

I can't comment on high altitude performance, but it sounds like you're referring to the inflated types there too.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by sanoli on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:45PM (#9000865)
He has a son, probably also a wife, he probably has a steady job. And he goes to the gym 2-4 times a week, for 1 to 2 hours each time. Lifting weights is one of the best things he can do, exercise wise, to his health. A 3-week effort on Aconcagua? When do you think the parent does that, and how often? Does he take his 6 year old son with him? I don't really see any drawbacks from him being powerlifting strong.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by whitewhim on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:34PM (#8998671)
I do agree that the extra attention can be unwanted and negative sometimes. For example, I've worked out the whole time I've dated my girlfriend of around ~5 years. However, at the start we were in high school and I was super lean due to MMA and rugby. Now, that I'm older and lifting has finely started to obtain noticeable results/ having lost a bit of baby-face my girlfriend started to become a bit jealous/insecure with herself. No matter what I said, she wouldn't believe that I found her more attractive then everyone else. She understands its irrational but its hard to fight insecurities. At this point she has started going to the gym and is a much harder worker then me there.

With regards to fitness, I definitely agree that I prefer a practical definition of fitness level. I may not look gigantic compared to some of the guys in the gym, but I can both lift a lot of weight, run fast sprints and long distance runs. Its that type of fitness that is great for rugby.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by nl on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:04PM (#9001521)
Testosterone has a benefit in endurance sports too. It can help with the growth of both slow-twitch (lean, endurance muscles) as well as fast-twitch (bulk, power muscles).

Even if you ignore the muscle building, it can help with recovery which leads to being able to recover from harder (endurance) training sessions.

That's often the reason that endurance cyclists use it (illegally of course).

See http://www.outsideonline.com/fitness/Drug-Test.html for a amateur cyclist and journalist who took testosterone (along with HGH and EPO) to see what it would do.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mattlutze on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:08AM (#8996565)
Increasing muscle mass, and maintaining that muscle mass, will/may:

- decreases stress on tendons and ligaments

- protect delicate or complicated joints from injury

- help maintain healthy weight and body fat levels

- improve bone density, and help maintain bone density

- increase stamina / reduce fatigue

- support attention

- get up out of the bathtub or off the couch when you're older

- improve sleep

- improve mental health

[1]: http://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-living/fitness/in-depth/st...

[2]: http://www.cdc.gov/physicalactivity/growingstronger/why/

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by laichzeit0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:30AM (#8996944)
Not to mention that a large percentage of females find muscle mass attractive when combined with a low body fat percentage in males. Indirectly this can lead to a boost in self-confidence levels in an individual, which has other positive spinoffs.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by sanoli on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:54PM (#9000906)
This. Times ten. I can't stress this enough to my non-lifting, skinny, geek friends who wish they were more attractive to women. I always tell them that the number one thing they can do is to begin lifting weights. They'll look healthier, more athletic, manlier, and their self-confidence will go up. Oh, actually weights are number two. Number one is to ditch the anti-girlfriend geek t-shirts with programmer's inside jokes (you know, the 'only 10 people who know binary' stuff) ;-)
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by VLM on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:52AM (#8996757)
Benefit to everyone, not just men, is running my back muscles occasionally at 200% percent safe capacity in general daily life, lead to punishing pain though I was still a teen at that time. Under advice and monitoring of the docs, following all the trainer recommendations, good form and trainer approved plans etc, I bulked up to the point that daily life occasionally peaked my back muscles at maybe 50% of safe capacity. You can guess the effect on my quality of life. Sometimes simply not feeling pain anymore is a gift from the gods. I suppose it was either lift, or start a life long opiate addiction.

On the other hand, I know most of the guys at the gym with me were just addictive personalities. Rather than wanting that lvl80 in WoW, or feeling the uncontrollable desire to get drunk, they wanted to bench 300. There certainly are worse grind addictions than lifting.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by brational on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:00AM (#8997095)
There are studies that show an inverse correlation between lean body mass and all cause mortality.

So the tongue-in-cheek 'strong people are harder to kill' has some actual data behind.

The problem is of course stats 101, correlation =/= causation. It could simply be that genetics or some other factor X increases lean mass and decreases all-cause mortality.

Pragmatically speaking though, quality of life in old age is a big deal that benefits from more lean mass.

[edit: http://www.reddit.com/r/AdvancedFitness/comments/1bo5xm/asso... this has a study link and comments and links to previous HN discussion]

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gabemart on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:02AM (#8996393)
"Strong people are harder to kill than weak people, and more useful in general."
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by joncrocks on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:00PM (#8998387)
Rip?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by jcfrei on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:00AM (#8996389)
Strength is significantly correlated with life expectancy. See here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2938886/ and here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2453303/
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by nailer on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:23AM (#8996441)
Many women find physically strong men more attractive than weaker men. The benefit this brings men is allowing their DNA to replicate.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gadders on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:32AM (#8996297)
Well, muscle growth normally means being more strong, and being more strong is generally better than being less so.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by driverdan on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:49PM (#9000168)
Something others haven't mentioned is better quality of life as you age. One of the biggest causes of decrease in life quality in the elderly is reduced mobility. As you age your muscle mass decreases. By increasing your muscle mass when you're younger (and able) and maintaining physical activity you will have a much better life when you're older.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Shivetya on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:35AM (#8996302)
increased metabolism meaning your less likely to get fat.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Jimmed on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:28AM (#8996287)
Genuine answer: Feeling better about our self-image / placating the fear that we're "not manly enough".
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gadders on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:42AM (#8996319)
I also find that being strong(er) is more useful in my daily life than increased aerobic capability i.e. picking my nine year old daughter up and carrying her on my shoulders, moving heavy stuff in the garden etc.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by GFK_of_xmaspast on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:08AM (#8996563)
Another reason to dismantle the patriarchy and gender binary.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mycroft-holmes on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:35AM (#8996971)
The self image is derived from feedback in society so for straight men, blame other women.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:59AM (#8996383)
more eyes
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by johnward on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:43AM (#8996718)
The original poster had High T levels to start with. Maybe he didn't notice much of a change. I noticed a significant change going from <120ng/dl to 500ng/dl (still less than OP). I always drop weight when I am on T and get much leaner without changing anything else. Well it does make it easier to work out and diet but even without any changes it makes a big difference. Each time I go off and onto something else like clomiphene I gain 20-30lbs that is not lean at all.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:33AM (#8997759)
For a 23 year old, I wouldn't consider 4xx high, to be honest.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by johnward on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:05PM (#8998426)
I believe he said he got close to 1000ng/dl naturally, which I consider on the high side based on lab ranges. 400ng/dl is actually interpreted by some doctors as low depending on symptoms even though it's "in range".
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:28PM (#8998614)
Ah yeah, sorry, the 1024 was definitely on the high side for me, but I thought you were referring to the 400
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by johnward on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @03:15PM (#8999409)
Yeah most of what I read seems to indicate you should be on the high side in your early twenties but ultimately if you are at 400-500ng/dl and you don't have symptoms that is probably normal for that person.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by raverbashing on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:38AM (#8996309)
Depends on a lot of factors.

1 - Exercise

2 - The dosage. Having a slight amount over the normal dosage won't cause a big gain in muscle mass. (600mg is a significant dosage, see Table 3 on the article for the sorological difference)

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by toolz on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:51AM (#8996354)
I'm not sure I'm understanding your point. Of course exercise changes muscle gains, but the surprising result was that the men who did not exercise had more muscle gains than those on the placebo who did exercise.

As for the dosage, yes, this study had really high dosage and reports no negative side effects for the 10 week period it was used.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by danielbarla on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:25AM (#8996442)
Personally, I'm not very surprised by this (testosterone causing larger increases than exercise). There are plenty of examples in nature of relatively "lazy" animals with large amounts of muscle (e.g. gorillas, lions, etc).

Of course, we're comparing animals with large genetic differences to each other, but my point is that exercise does not seem to be the primary cause of muscle, in general. It just happens to be the main parameter we're in control of.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by raverbashing on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:38AM (#8996474)
Not really surprising, I remember seeing a study with similar results, but I can't find it right now.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by gadders on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:23AM (#8996268)
I guess it also depends on what exercises you're doing. Body Pump and Nautilus machines wouldn't cut it.

//edit// Or rather would help the OP a lot.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by JohnBooty on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:35PM (#9000051)

   TRT is a problem if you keep going for too long, because your body just doesn't produce testosterone as it used to, because it expects it from the outside, so below 35 or rather below 40 year olds: don't sign up for this too quickly.
This is the reason why my doctor wouldn't prescribe it for me (38 year-old male, hoping to have a kid with my wife in the next year or two). When on testosterone supplements, the body can start to rely on the outside testosterone and gradually stops producing its own. He said it can result in a situation where you're essentially locked into taking testosterone forever.

Strangely, I didn't see that risk mentioned in the linked article. Did I simply miss it?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by henryaj on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:12AM (#8996245)
What are the details of your intermittent fasting?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:29AM (#8996459)
in terms of timing you mean? I fasted for 14 hours and simply delayed/skipped breakfast, still eating 3 meals at around 2400 calories.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mej10 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:26AM (#8997296)
Can you link to any studies showing IF increased T levels substantially? I am genuinely curious. I have been considering doing IF (since I am half way there already) just for the longevity boosts and general body composition benefits.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:55AM (#8997918)
http://fitness.mercola.com/sites/fitness/archive/2012/07/27/... (has also studies at the bottom)

and this is also an interesting experiment, where it actually drops with fasting:

http://www.precisionnutrition.com/intermittent-fasting/chapt...

But the hypothesis is that the body uses the testosterone more efficiently

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by pervycreeper on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:48AM (#8996345)
>I can provide more info or details/specifics if wanted/needed.

Please do. Some references to further reading would also be appreciated.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:44AM (#8996489)
Sure, what are you looking for specifically?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Simp on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:10AM (#8996241)
"start meditating"

Research has not shown that meditation beats a placebo

Studies about meditation are usually of poor quality.

Source: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/2013/03/08/r...

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by callum85 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:52AM (#8996357)
How could there be a placebo for meditation? A placebo has to replicate the experience of going through the 'real' treatment being trialled. How could you create the experience of meditation without the subject actually meditating? The claim being tested is simply that the experience of meditation is beneficial, so I don't know what form a placebo could take.

It would be OK to do a trial where one group is instructed to meditate and the other is not given any instructions, and you check back with each group in a couple of weeks and ask them how they feel. If there's a difference in the meditation group, that proves there is value in meditating. Placebo doesn't come into it, because no one is claiming there is any benefit to meditation that doesn't come from simply experiencing it.

For comparison, I once heard of a way of testing acupuncture against a placebo – someone invented needles that look and feel the same but don't actually penetrate the skin. So they could compare the reported benefits of 'fake acupuncture' with real acupuncture, and see if there's any health benefit to the physical intervention, or if it's all just theatre. And if it is all just theatre, that's OK – it doesn't negate the health benefits of acupuncture, it just helps us understand that it's all about the experience of having someone slowly and dramatically stick pins in you, which is interesting. It's not the same as saying that acupuncture doesn't work.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by bjterry on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:59PM (#8999306)
There are a mountain of studies that have been done on meditation. Among those that are controlled, there a few different strategies.

The best strategy is an "active control" group which receives some combination of education, attention from instructors, group therapy and the like which is matched with the meditation group for time and attention. This has subsets of "specific active control" in which the control is a known procedure (like exercise or progressive muscle relaxation) or "non-specific active control" in which the control procedure is not a known effective procedure and so is expected not to have any effect.

The other main control group used is a "wait list" or "usual care" control, in which the participants don't receive any treatment or only receive the treatment you would usually get for the condition under study, which isn't matched with the meditation group for time and attention.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:58AM (#8996380)
i think you 're supposed to compare the claimed effects on people who meditate vs people who don't (control group)
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:03AM (#8996395)
A control group that does not do anything and does not receive anything is not using a placebo.

A placebo is very specifically a substitute for whatever you want to measure the effect of.

You can have both a control group and a group using a placebo and get substantially different results for them, and that's exactly why placebos are used: People report substantial effects from sugar pills and the like when they believe there should be an effect.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:21AM (#8996436)
well yeah , you would then have to have a "sugar pill" group. I wonder whether these studies include an third" no intervention" group.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:53AM (#8996358)
Your source does not support your claim that research has not shown that meditation beats a placebo.

Apart from pointing out that "meditation" is a wide ranging concept that includes a vast number of different, often contradictory, practices, and that a lot of the research is of poor quality (given the number of "research" papers coming out of TM affiliated sources alone - see blow -, that should not be a surprise), it relates a claim in a report from 2007 that amongst others claim "Firm conclusions on the effects of meditation practices in healthcare cannot be drawn based on the available evidence". Without looking at what was covered in the papers that report looked at, this is not enough to support your claim.

The closest the article comes to dealing with the issue of placebo explicitly, is in referring to another article focusing on TM. TM is a cult-like money-grabbing business promoting one very specific form of meditation, and hardly representative of all forms of meditation practices. They're also one of the groups doing a lot of work to assist in churning out pseudo-science research papers to support their business, and as such did a lot to damage the overall quality of meditation research.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by jschwartzi on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:17AM (#8997226)
It might be possible to do a double-blind study on meditation, but you would have to be incredibly strict about the procedure for achieving a meditative state, and you would have to select people who know nothing about "meditation" as a practice both to administer bouts of meditation and to participate in the study. Then your part in the study would be to teach the controls the "placebo" practice and to teach the non-controls the strictly-defined meditative practice, and to convince all of the participants that they're meditating either way.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by stolio on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:46PM (#8998282)
Unless you're testing Zen meditation in which case the placebo group and the real group may not (should not?) be distinguishable from one another.

It's often taught as "just sitting" so by the time you get the control group to sit down, shut up and hold still for half an hour every day they're doing the practice. Heck, they may be doing it better than the Zen meditators because they won't have anything extra attached to it at all :)

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:04AM (#8996399)
Conversely though, claiming the opposite is also wrong. Many people feel that meditation is good for many things, but that emotion is not science.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by r00fus on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:44AM (#8997435)
> "emotion is not science"

However, study of emotional response can be part of the scientific process. In fact, that's the basis of the advertising industry.

If I have tested meditation and found it predictably alters my moods (and similar examinations have been done for friends/family), is it fair to claim that is not science?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:04AM (#8996554)
It is not science, but in the context of the original "start meditating" quip on this thread, it is what matters: If it works, it solves the original problem, whether or not it works because o the placebo effect or something else.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by stinos on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:16AM (#8996253)
Research has not shown that meditation beats a placebo

Isn't that sort of irrelevant here? I think the OP's point is that it helps, not that it helps better than something else (wahtever that may be, even a placebo)?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:40AM (#8996315)
If it doesn't help more than a placebo, then it doesn't help at all.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:59AM (#8996382)
A placebo often helps substantially. That is why we tend to test with a placebo rather than nothing at all, in order to measure the effect of what we want to test rather than the ability of our mind to influence our body.

And the effect is not merely psychological. Often placebo produces measurable responses.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:12AM (#8996415)
Still though, the idea behind placebos is that they 're the most convenient thing to do compared to the alternative. It doesn't justify the suggestion to "meditate to increase T" more than "take a sugar pill to increase T"
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:32AM (#8996673)
The idea of placebos is to attempt to introduce a "noise floor" of sorts that lets you get an idea for how much of the measured effect is actually caused by what is being measured.

Generally you want a placebo that makes the test subject unable to tell which is the placebo. That will not be the case with just handing people a sugar pill and being honest about what it is. To have an effect of a sugar pill in such a setting you would have to tell people there is a chance the pill is some form of medication intended to produce similar effects.

The problem with that is that if the effects of meditation are just placebo, what you end up measuring is the strength of peoples beliefs about the efficacy of meditation vs. the efficacy of drugs - you're not comparing like with like, and can't rule out additive effects of combining the two (whether or not they're both caused by the placebo effect) either.

And even if it is all placebo, that does not mean it may not be justified to suggest to meditate. In fact, it is a long standing debate of medical ethics whether - and if so when - it might sometimes be justified to utilize placebos as medical treatment, because it can often have real, measurable physical effects on peoples health.

The issue with that is that you'd be lying to a patient, and it might undermine peoples trust in the medical profession. That is not an issue with an off the cuff suggestion to people to meditate from someone not claiming to be a doctor.

Also, I haven't seen anyone here suggest meditating to increase T, but giving an off the cuff remark suggesting meditating to address "psychological worries" people might have 10-20% of the time. Serious psychological issues needs professional treatment, but I took his comment, given the context, the term "worries", and the implication they'd only be there 10-20% of the time to mean general stress and light performance anxieties, in which case meditation either works for you or it doesn't.

If it does, it does not matter if it works because of the placebo effect or not. If it doesn't, then no harm done and you can consider TRT.

The point of his comment seemed to be that most people do not need TRT, but fall in the normal range and should consider other factors first. I'm saying that as someone who will seriously consider TRT when I'm older (I'm turning 40 this year)

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by stinos on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:49AM (#8996348)
Wordplay? If it helps just as much (which technically is also 'not more'), it could still help since a placebo might help. Hell, even if it would help 'less' than a placebo it might still be helping since I didn't quantify exactly how much :P
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:55AM (#8996364)
By that logic meditation also harms T levels. Not more than a placebo, but still harms them. Zero can be a positive or negative number.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:31AM (#8996463)
Yeah again, if you only want to go after research, you might run in circles. Meditation has helped me and a lot of people I know, a lot. Whether it will work for you in your circumstances is a different question. But then: The study won't be much help, because you might have different variables in your life.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by collyw on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:24AM (#8996274)
Placebo is an effective harm free way of improving many conditions. Why dismiss it so readily?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mackwic on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:43AM (#8996324)
The question is not if Placebo is an efficient method. We know for sure that it is. The question is if training and practicing meditation is better than doing nothing.

If you don't beat the placebo, it could mean that there's nothing to train and practice.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:25AM (#8996445)
It is meaningless to speculate on this without a concrete paper doing a concrete comparison of a specific concrete form of meditation vs. a concrete form of placebo, and without knowing whether or not the placebo was compared to a control group doing nothing.

You're right, it could mean there's nothing to train and practice. It also could mean there'd be a substantial placebo effect and a big gap from "doing nothing" to either the placebo or meditation, in which case, even if meditation were to turn out to be 100% placebo effect it would still be worthwhile to train and practice unless said researchers were to come up with a placebo that works just as well with less time spent.

What I know is that meditation has substantial subjective benefits for me. I don't care if that's 100% placebo effect and/or if I'm just tricking myself in other ways.

Because you know what? It doesn't matter.

Meditation makes me feel relaxed. It makes me feel as if I get insights into my mind and thought processes. It makes me feel like I have more energy. It make me feel more in control and in touch of my emotions and the world in general.

No matter the actual biochemical and psychological reasons for those feelings, they're still just as worthwhile outcomes to me.

That's easy to lose sight of.

Beating a placebo is an important measure when looking at drugs, because they pretty much all have potential risks and downsides (including the downside of cost). Showing provable effects is also important if considering prescribing meditation practice for psychological disorders, for example, because it could mean avoiding other treatment.

It is also worthwhile in order to learn more about the processes involved, and see what effects can be proven.

But it is largely uninteresting when considering casual meditation for someone who expects only subjective effects on mental state. In that case, what matters is mainly whether the perceived effects are sufficiently positive for someone to find it worthwhile to continue.

If it's all a trick of the mind, then fine. It still feels great.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mackwic on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:18AM (#8996603)
Great answer, and I agree with you. As a practicer it doesn't really matters as long as you get your dose of well-beingness.

I was more thinking of all the "train yourself to meditate" thing which can end with more frustration than relaxation for some, relatively of the scientific measure of this training (which is imperfect as we just saw).

On a side-note, I practice relaxation on the evening and I don't see such huge effects on my mind but "only" a greater sleep (which is already great). Could you share some of your practices ?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vidarh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:51AM (#8996748)
I only practice mindfulness meditation with varying frequency, sitting anything from about 5 minutes to 30 minutes, rarely longer.

Typically mindfulness meditation starts with basic breath meditation: Sit in a stable, comfortable position, focus on your breath and notice it going in and out. If thoughts appear, try to keep focus on the breath but don't force the thoughts away, just try to let them dissipate without continuing them.

The big difference for me with unstructured relaxation was that it was hard at first to focus on the breath. My mind produced all kinds of objections to sitting there and paying attention.

Sitting for 5 minutes like that caused my mind to practically rebel. Then I went through a period with dream-like states (one of the most memorable effects, which I've only had a few times, was like seeing a dream unfold around me, but while dreams always feel "fuzzy" and unclear for me this was as if I was standing in the middle of a theatre set, seeing everything clearly, yet knowing it was not real).

Then I had a period of what is something referred to as "monkey mind" - all kinds of distractions piled on. Then I went through a period where I would suddenly get an intensely strong belief that I'd forgotten to set my alarm and was going to be late. I knew I'd set my alarm, but the feeling would become unbearable until I looked at my (set) alarm. I had to solve that by triple check the alarm before I started, and telling myself it was set, and telling myself it didn't matter because I had lots of time free after it was set to go off, and then it stopped happening (and I don't triple check my alarm any more).

These distractions were not constant, and I could sit longer and longer before they'd set in. After a few weeks of daily practice they were weakened enough that I started feeling I was getting somewhere.

Once I'd gotten past those distractions, it changed nature very strongly. Now I slowly sink into more and more relaxed states depending on how long I sit. At about 20 minutes I will generally start feeling as if I am noticing the pulsing of blood in my eye lids and pressure on my eyes (I have no idea if those are real physical sensations or not - doesn't matter to me) and see patterns similar to what you might see if you squeeze your eyes firmly shut and feel a sense of blissful calm that makes it tempting to just stay like that.

If I sit longer and focus, those feelings dissipates as I get calmer and more concentrated and I can best describe it as if my mind is "emptying" and clearing of whatever feelings the sense of bliss brought, and it feels more steady and crisp. It's very hard to relate the sensations of it with words.

If I sit to the "bliss" state or past, I will feel an immense feeling of calm once I finish that will often last for hours afterwards.

I'd recommend the frequently recommended Mindfulness in Plain English (available for free online, or from Amazon etc.) or Introduction to Mindfulness (free podcasts) by Gil Fronsdal. Both are no-nonsense secular introductions and very simple, basic practice to try out and see if you like the effects.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by collyw on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:22AM (#8996894)
If someone is stressed (from work, relationships, etc) we accept that it can and does have negative effects on our physical being. I would have thought that meditation would easily fall into the category of doing the opposite. Seems pretty obvious to me.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dood on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:39AM (#8996311)
That meditation research has historically been inconclusive and of poor quality does not mean it doesn't do anything.

Also, meditation research has come a long way since the studies cited in your source. Something I dug up quickly: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/americanbuddhist/2014/01/the-ef...

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by failed_ideas on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:54AM (#8996363)
Follow all the articles listed back to the journal being referenced.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dood on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:32AM (#8996956)
Yes, this is the source: http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=18097...

It seems respectable and concludes:

"Clinicians should be aware that meditation programs can result in small to moderate reductions of multiple negative dimensions of psychological stress. Thus, clinicians should be prepared to talk with their patients about the role that a meditation program could have in addressing psychological stress. Stronger study designs are needed to determine the effects of meditation programs in improving the positive dimensions of mental health and stress-related behavior."

This directly contradicts the GP's claim that meditation is ineffective, and supports the OP's claim that meditation is a good way to deal with "psychological worries".

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Simp on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:05AM (#8996556)
More information to satisfy the complaints of my critics regarding the date, definitions, forms of meditation, etc:

A systematic study on the efficacy of various forms of meditation programs (inc mantra, transcendental, and mindfulness meditation), commissioned by the US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, was published in 2014.[67] After a review of 17,801 citations, the study based its conclusions on 41 randomized controlled trials with an active control, involving 2,993 participants. The assessment found "no effect or insufficient evidence of any effect of meditation programs on positive mood, attention, substance use, eating habits, sleep, and weight."

Study: http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=18097...

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dood on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:23AM (#8996909)
Amazingly, you have cherry-picked the part of your source that agrees with you.

This is the full quote, including the bits you left you:

"Mindfulness meditation programs had moderate evidence of improved anxiety... depression... and pain... and low evidence of improved stress/distress and mental health–related quality of life. We found low evidence of no effect or insufficient evidence of any effect of meditation programs on positive mood, attention, substance use, eating habits, sleep, and weight."

The same source goes on to conclude,

"Clinicians should be aware that meditation programs can result in small to moderate reductions of multiple negative dimensions of psychological stress"

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Simp on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:39PM (#9035153)
In other words, the same reductions as a placebo would give.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by stolio on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:29PM (#8998620)
You should be aware that the "CSM Mantra" (?) and "TM" meditation are very fringe forms. When most people say "start meditating" they're generally not referring to those. I personally consider TM to be neutral-to-harmful and I've never heard of this CSM Mantra until just now.

Mindfulness meditation, which is the only form tied to the 2,500 years of Buddhist meditation tradition, did ok.

Interesting is the graph of the results where you see the mindfulness meditation fared better than the "mantra" meditations pretty much across the board (even though most of it wasn't statistically significant.)

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by return0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:01AM (#8996224)
You 're quite young. i wonder if it is possible to change so fast when you're older.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by freshfey on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:25AM (#8996443)
take a look at the book "4 Hour Body" by Tim Ferriss, there in the chapter Improving Sex, sub-chapter: "Sex Machine I: Adventures in Tripling Testosterone"

I think in there the author, Tim Ferriss aged 34(?), mentions how he went from 2xx to 6xx in a very short amount of time, mainly by changing his nutrition.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by jkscm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:17AM (#8997658)
Or it could be a coincidence since the number of test subjects was 1.

I like how the examine.com article sums it up:

> Although 'natural' (non-supplemental) methods of increasing testosterone are pretty weak and unlikely to build muscle mass, they tend to be related to pro-sexual effects (particularly libido) and exerting dominance

http://examine.com/faq/how-can-i-increase-testosterone-natur...

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by LukeB_UK on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:33AM (#8996960)
TRT has now been banned in the UFC.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @03:53PM (#8999685)
Naturally? What did you do?