News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by icelancer on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:28AM (#8647906)
As someone who is Asian, I've just kind of accepted this kind of casual racism. The stereotype of Asian men are that we are better at math, science, and logic (sadly enough, this is where I spent most of my working career) and everyone kind of laughs about it and jokes how it's great this stereotype is so positive.

Except, of course, that it leads to these kinds of policies. Just like Jewish people are ascribed the stereotype of being good with money leads to other policies that have occurred in the past and probably still continue to this day.

To me, though, this is just another example of why higher education is becoming a parody of itself. To become personally angry about decisions that are based on the angle of my eyelids is a waste of my time; and this reaction is overwhelmingly common in the Asian community. It has been for decades since Korematsu v. United States, too. I'm not sure it's the "best" approach, but I've learned to live with it, knowing that others have it a hell of a lot worse. Is that rationalization and "giving up?" Perhaps. But I just can't bring myself to care.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by obviouslynot on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:54AM (#8647953)
The head of my (STEM) course at a university in the top 5 of most global rankings (not Harvard, though) once told me casually (I am white) that she was upset at the high percentage of Asians in her course since they were "great at tests, but really bad at leadership" and "never move beyond middle management" which looked bad on statistics and (implied) wasted seats. So, anecdotally, another example of that "casual" racism.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dengnan on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:28AM (#8648085)
As I said in another comment, this stereotype of American Asian men is partly caused by the universities admission procedure and the country's immigration policy. In short, they just like foreigners in STEM.

Another reason is probably the culture differences. Asian people are not only interested in STEM. We do have other majors in universities. However, Asian has an equally long, if not longer, history with Europe. Many fields are "stateful", i.e. they rely on the history. For example, a physicist could have a very successful career even he does not know Newton's anecdotes. However, a art-majored student probably needs to know some history in his field --- at least, he needs to remember some names and their corresponding achievements.

People majored in literature in China definitely know poets like Li Bai, Du Fu, Bai Juyi and they have devoted lots of time to learn these poets' work. The culture barrier prohibits them from studying in another country in a different language. That's probably another reason why there's little Asian students outside STEM.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by obviouslynot on Sunday November 23, 2014 @09:13AM (#8648830)
I guarantee you they do not "just like" foreigners in STEM. I currently live and work in Asia and the growth in the region (particularly China) can be orders of magnitude that of the US. Just looking at Vietnam, you went from 0.25% to 43% internet penetration between 2000 and 2014. China alone has over a billion people to the US' 0.3 and the percentage of Asians in the middle-upper class (those that both can afford, and desire an Ivy education) is rapidly rising, whilst the quality higher education supply remains constant. It's one of these cases where you have to refresh your view of the world every couple of years.

Not only are candidates more numerous, they are better prepared, some even doing a year or two in a local university to stack on the skills. In my experience, "locals" in the West don't see the sheer drive and intelligence of these students because of the language barrier (yours truly was, of course, guilty of that back then - it's been an expensive lesson). I've seen engineering undergrads with a tenuous grasp of English skip every lecture in the year and still get in the top 5% of the class (after all, grad-level maths lectures were so much more interesting) - the "Western" students were just nowhere near as prepared. There is nothing inherently special about the mythical Asian undergrad, it's just a numbers game - the top 100 Chinese candidates by IQ are equivalent, statistically, to the top 30 American ones.

The same story plays out with capital and is driving real estate prices up in major global cities. And in both cases, it is dismissed the same way that the British would dismiss the rise of the USA as a global economic power just as the Fabians put the finishing blows to prosperity at home (or, in Sydney's case, happily embraced with negative gearing and rationalized via any graspable straw). The region has issues the US did not, so the story's not written up yet.

FWIW I've seen plenty of Asians do great in non-STEM subjects (including publishing, acting and music). As a classically trained musician, I know many more Asians with a great knowledge, understanding and interest of music history and theory than Westerners, even those who studied the subject full time, even though it is theoretically the latter's "cultural baggage". I'm not a fan of Lang Lang, but hearing musicians like Yuja Wang is incredibly promising and shows that "foreigners" with not much local exposure to so called Western culture can easily master "our" arts.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by seanmcdirmid on Sunday November 23, 2014 @03:04AM (#8648133)
There are actually lots of Asians outside of STEM. Art doesn't involve that much history (art history is quite different), and especially design doesn't. Also, Asian American vs. Asian is very different.

> That's probably another reason why there's little Asian students outside STEM.

I totally read that wrong the first time.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by wumpus on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:48PM (#8647838)
Back when Harvard didn't admit (many) blacks and women, they also had an anti-Jewish quota. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numerus_clausus#Numerus_clausus...

Edit: Now that I eventually figured out how to get around the paywall (hint: Chrome makes it easier than Firefox, I wonder why), the article mentions this: "The suit compares its current racial admissions to Harvard’s quotas limiting Jewish students in an earlier era. In both cases, Harvard kept out minorities who would have been admitted based on academic merit."

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by msherry on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:28AM (#8647905)
Just read an interesting article on boingboing (I know, I know) about this. http://boingboing.net/2014/11/20/for-god-for-country-and-for...
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dengnan on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:09AM (#8647988)
When talking about Asian's stereotype, one thing is always ignored: the stereotype of Asian in the U.S. is a direct result of the education system and immigrant policy. Most 1st generation Asian immigrants are students who come to the U.S. for grad school. They (and their children) are better at STEM simply because they (or their parents) are/were grad students in that area. As an Asian, I saw lots of students who are not good at STEM and simply did not get an offer from any U.S. university. The immigration policy and universities' admission procedure are intentionally designed to select foreign students who are good in those majors.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by parennoob on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:48PM (#8647837)
As I have tried to point out before, this exact same problem is also present in efforts to bolster minority participation in tech. Asian men are often completely ignored in minority programs, because "Uh, there are a lot of Asian guys in tech", completely ignoring the strongly inferior position that they hold in American society as a whole (in my opinion, definitely one below that of white women; though this is only an opinion.)

The response I usually get when I point out this problem on HN is a glib "Hey, it's a free country. Nobody prevented you from starting up your own minority program for Asians." [1] Unfortunately, so far I haven't been able to find a proper response to this.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7524665

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by potatolicious on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:52PM (#8647842)
I read an article once that phrased it well regarding Asians: "we have a problem, and we are a problem, at the same time".

We're "represented" in tech, but not at the upper echelons where we're substantially under represented, and at the same time our presence is used as justification that other races aren't being discriminated against.

Asians are tremendously more privileged than Blacks or Hispanics in tech, but still suffer from tremendous problems ourselves. Many seem unable to comprehend this in a world view where privilege is binary.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:51AM (#8647946)
We're "represented" in tech, but not at the upper echelons where we're substantially under represented...

Do you have data on this? Anecdotally it isn't hard to think of Asians in the upper echelons (e.g. Satya Nadella). A quick glance at google's management team finds Asians to be overrepresented at 4/18 Asians (6/18 if you include middle easterners).

http://www.google.com/about/company/facts/management/

Microsoft (2/16) and Twitter (2/14) seem similar:

http://news.microsoft.com/microsoft-senior-leaders/

https://about.twitter.com/company/leadership

(0.8/16 is what would be expected based on proportional representation.)

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by potatolicious on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:05AM (#8647976)
> "Do you have data on this? Anecdotally it isn't hard to think of Asians in the upper echelons (e.g. Satya Nadella)."

In the same way Barack Obama is evidence that black people have it pretty easy around here ;) There are definitely some high-profile Asians in tech, they're not exactly rare like unicorns, but the underrepresentation is plenty real.

I dug up the original article I was reading: http://the-toast.net/2014/10/23/asian-americans-media/view-a... - btw, this is IMO the most approachable/parseable summary of where Asian-Americans fit into the greater American race relations landscape I've seen yet. It's well worth a read.

It's a more general look at Asian-Americans, but there is a section specifically addressing tech.

More concretely giving numbers to the representation deficit:

http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_23100254/glass-ceiling-asian-a...

Even in Google's own numbers Asians represent 34% of the tech workforce and 23% in leadership roles.

Facebook's a bit worse - 41% of tech workforce Asian, 19% leadership.

Yahoo is particularly egregious - 57% Asian, 17% leadership.

Even Twitter isn't particularly great: 34% Asians in tech, 24% in leadership from their own report: https://blog.twitter.com/2014/building-a-twitter-we-can-be-p...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:33AM (#8648015)
By those numbers, Asians are overrepresented in both tech and leadership. The real question is why they aren't more overrepresented in leadership. It's a valid question, but a different one than I was asking.

Apriori I would not expect the demographics of leadership to look like those of tech. My simple model (with allusions to michaelochurch) is that tech is generally not the path to leadership. I.e., if 3% of techies go into leadership vs 5% of non-techies, then leadership demographics will look more like non-tech demographics than tech demographics.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by potatolicious on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:36AM (#8648091)
The under representation exists even if we include all Asians employed at these companies - Twitter has for example a 29%/24% difference, Facebook is 24/19 when restricted to just non-tech role headcount. Yahoo comes in at 24/17 when similarly looking at just non-tech employees.

The demographics of leadership actually get worse once you leave tech: Asians represent 0.8% of C-level roles, and 2.1% of board seats - against 5% in the general population. Tech is actually a relative bright spot when it comes to Asians in leadership roles.

> "The real question is why they aren't more overrepresented in leadership."

This really isn't the question at all. You're conflating two separate problems: over-representation of Asians in tech overall, vs. under-representation of Asians in progression of tech leadership. Both can be true simultaneously.

Accepting the precondition that Asians are over-represented compared to the general population, their progression to leadership roles (from both tech and non-tech origins) suggests under-representation. i.e., based on the precondition we'd expect to see more Asian leaders in these companies.

That the precondition exists is a fairly interesting problem itself, but largely separate from the argument of leadership.

At the heart of it is the notion of equality - that two equal candidates get a fair shake at a promotion/role regardless of race. Regardless of whether or not leadership positions bias towards tech candidates or non-tech candidates, the gap exists - Asians are promoted/hired into leadership positions at a lower rate than their participation in the rest of the industry.

This is particularly visible in professions where the advancement track is less vague and more straightforward - for example in law Asian-Americans represent 6.7% of associates, but only 1.8% of sr. counsel, and 1.7% of partners.

This sort of gets at the original problem I brought up - that Asians have a problem, and are a problem. The over-representation of Asians in white collar professions is used as a bludgeon with which to attack other minorities, and used to invalidate real inequities within these professions such as whether or not they're being treated fairly when it comes to promotions and advancement. The Model Minority myth is damaging all around - to other races, to Asians themselves.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 23, 2014 @05:51AM (#8648400)
At the heart of it is the notion of equality - that two equal candidates get a fair shake at a promotion/role regardless of race.

And pointing out that Asians (or whoever) are underrepresented does NOT prove they don't get a "fair shake". It's also possible they are getting a fair shake and coming up short, or choosing not to be shaken. More evidence is needed.

The over-representation of Asians in white collar professions is used as a bludgeon with which to attack other minorities...

No one is "attacking other minorities". Asians are brought up to refute the "mirrortocracy" hypothesis: white gatekeepers in the industry will prevent entry by people different from them.

Describing that as an "attack" is silly.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by jacalata on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:14AM (#8647996)
You shouldn't be comparing the percentage of Asians in leadership positions to the overall percentage of Asians in the country, but to the demographics of the companies as a whole. By that comparison, Asians aren't overrepresented in Google's leadership team - checking out their own diversity stats, 30% of the company is Asian but only 23% of their leadership team. (http://www.google.com/diversity/at-google.html#tab=leadershi...)

This article contains numbers for a lot of companies: http://www.sfgate.com/technology/article/In-tech-even-Asians...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by morgante on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:33AM (#8648016)
> You shouldn't be comparing the percentage of Asians in leadership positions to the overall percentage of Asians in the country, but to the demographics of the companies as a whole.

Why? It's only in the context of the rest of the country that complaints about the underrepresentation of other minorities makes sense.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by jacalata on Sunday November 23, 2014 @03:31AM (#8648178)
Not really. Imagine a company where 99% of hires had graduated from Stanford and 1% from Harvard, but only 1% of people promoted to management were Stanford grads. You wouldn't say "well, the percentage of Stanford graduates in the country is statistically insignificant so it makes sense for there to be very few Stanford grads in management".
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by morgante on Sunday November 23, 2014 @04:20PM (#8649968)
This assumes that the standard path into leadership positions is via promotion from the tech department. I think that's a pretty dubious assumption.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:41AM (#8647928)
The most charitable interpretation I can come up with for "hey, it's a free country" is that a person is entitled to start an organization which discriminates racially and sexually.

If you really want the downvotes and accusations of racism that come with asking provocative philosophical questions, ask whether unpopular private organization of the week can do the same. Is it morally/ethically permissible (as opposed to legally permissible) for Uber to discriminate in favor of Asians?

Note that once folks have no glib answer, they will attack you.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by tokenizerrr on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:30PM (#8647809)
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ocb on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:43PM (#8647828)
On my Mac this doesn't work on Safari but does work on Chrome. Interesting!
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by pickle27 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:51AM (#8647945)
can you explain how this works?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by jacalata on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:04AM (#8647973)
I think that if you want google to be able to index the article text, then the article has to be accessible from the search result - you can't show different pages to google's robot than to human visitors or they'll block you. So the paywall is not allowed to kick in if you are coming directly from google. (Works for the NYT as well, probably anywhere else that is indexed on google too).
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by gizmo686 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:01AM (#8647967)
http includes a referer field that tells a webserver what page linked you to it. It is therefore possible for the server to disable the paywall for visitors who arrive through google.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by gamesbrainiac on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:18AM (#8647885)
If you can access it, just save it via the internet archive.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by greglindahl on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:34AM (#8647913)
IA has 4 copies of this page. 3 are CAPTCHA challenges, and the 4th throws an error message. Why on earth did you think this might work without testing it yourself?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by epoxyhockey on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:46AM (#8647936)
In 1992, 19.1% of Harvard’s admissions offers went to Asian applicants, compared to 25.2% who were admitted to the California Institute of Technology, a school that doesn’t use racial preferences. In 2013 Harvard made 18% of its offers to Asians, while CalTech admitted 42.5% Asian students.

It is an interesting choice to compare Harvard's racial admissions with that of CalTech. I would think that Harvard vs. MIT or Stanford would create a more convincing argument. So, here are the numbers:

Stanford class of 2018: 22.6% Asian [1]

MIT class of 2018: 30% Asian [2]

Harvard class of 2018: 20% Asian [3]

It looks like the writer of the article chose the school with the highest percentage Asian population to make this comparison (excluding Hawaii). [4]

[1] http://facts.stanford.edu/academics/undergraduate-profile

[2] http://mitadmissions.org/apply/process/profile

[3] https://college.harvard.edu/admissions/admissions-statistics

[4] http://www.collegexpress.com/lists/list/colleges-with-the-hi...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by gareim on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:53AM (#8647951)
A quick Google search found me this for Stanford. I haven't checked for MIT.

>While Supreme Court justices question the role of racial consideration as a factor in the college admissions, Stanford remains committed to upholding affirmative action, arguing that the policy helps to ensure a diverse student body. One Stanford professor has submitted a brief to the Supreme Court defending the practice.

http://www.stanforddaily.com/2012/10/16/stanford-administrat...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by tzs on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:33AM (#8648014)
MIT and Stanford both use race as a significant factor in making admission decisions. They have explicitly stated this [1]. Caltech much less so (I believe it can be used as a tie breaker). Hence, Caltech is a better control than Stanford or MIT to compare against when you are trying to see what things should look like if race were not a factor.

It's not a perfect control, though, because of Caltech's focus on STEM. Caltech does actually offer non-STEM courses (and majors). In fact, it requires students to take about 1/4 of their coursework in humanities and social sciences, which is similar to what a science major at a good liberal arts school would take. Nevertheless, no one chooses Caltech for the humanities or social sciences, whereas people DO choose Harvard for them.

Although undergraduates are generally not admitted on a department by department basis, surely the schools have to try to get some idea from the application what fields the student is interested in majoring in, and they have to take that into account in making their decisions. If you have facilities for 50 new chemistry majors a year and 50 new English Literature majors a yer, and you get 500 applicants from people whose application suggests they might go into chemistry and only 60 applicants who appear likely to go into English Lit, you are going to reject a lot of those potential chemistry majors, even if their applications look better (grades, tests, and so on) than those of many of the people you accept from the group that looks interested in English Lit.

Since many high achieving Asians are driven by pressure from their parents, and parents push their kids toward STEM a lot more often than they push toward English Literature, it is possible that Asians could be getting effectively discriminated against as a side effect of them concentrating in STEM.

[1] http://findlawimages.com/efile/supreme/briefs/02-241/02-241....

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:44AM (#8648104)
MIT and Stanford both use race as a significant factor in making admission decisions.

What language in that brief makes you conclude that MIT and Stanford both use race as a "significant" factor (at least as compared with Caltech)? All three schools put race in the "considered" category of their CDS submissions.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @10:24AM (#8648971)
The brief does not mention Caltech.But for the other two:

MIT considers all aspects of each candidate's background,including racial and ethnic factors..

Stanford is strongly of the view that race and national origin should no more be entirely ignore..

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @11:43AM (#8649159)
Yes, but that is true of Caltech as well.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:00PM (#8649521)
For example,the California Institute of Technology(Caltech) is a private school that selects its students by strict academic standards and chooses not to consider race.

http://studentsforfairadmissions.org/wp-content/uploads/2014...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:16PM (#8649572)
I don't know what to tell you - there is no cite for that claim in the filing, and Caltech's own CDS filings say that they do consider race. Is there any statement from Caltech that says they do not consider race in admissions?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:30PM (#8649613)
The link i have provided you is the filing and it says Caltech does not consider race.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:49PM (#8649665)
It's a filing from a plaintiff that is not Caltech. That plaintiff ("Students For Fair Admissions, Inc") is making an assertion without a citation. Given that sentence contradicts a filing made by Caltech (their annual Common Data Set filings), I'd like to see something more direct from Caltech before I give any weight to SfFA's statement.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:57AM (#8647958)
who were admitted to the California Institute of Technology, a school that doesn’t use racial preferences.

FWIW, this line from the article is wrong, according to CalTech's CDS statements over the last decade or so: http://finance.caltech.edu/Resources/cds (see section C7 in the filings).

(this is assuming that "racial preferences" is being used to mean "racial/ethnic consideration" or "affirmative action")

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by gareim on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:06AM (#8647981)
That's a really great find, wow. I wonder how the author concluded that Caltech didn't consider racial status then.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:55AM (#8647954)
Caltech is fairly unique in that it explicitly does not use non-merit factors in admission (no racial preferences, no legacies, no "we want someone from all 50 states").
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:01AM (#8647963)
Not true according to CalTech's CDS filing (see my other post upthread).
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by guelo on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:01AM (#8647966)
Caltech is known for having the most meritocratic admission process with no racial balancing.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:59AM (#8647959)
... damn lies and statistics... and bad journalism.

The numbers apparently conflate Asian-Americans with Asian foreign students. A breakdown of the two groups would be more useful to work from given the huge numbers of wealthy Chinese fighting tooth and nail to send their kids to the most prestigious American schools.

The numbers are also skewed by simple geography. The West coast has more Asian-Americans and would be more desirable for foreign students in terms of quicker and cheaper travel between home and school. California schools can't be equitably compared to the East coast.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by tzs on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:28AM (#8647908)
For those complaining about the paywall or for whom the usual paywall bypass tricks failed, Google "harvard asian lawsuit" or "Students for Fair Admissions" (that's the group that is suing) and filter to limit the search to article in the last week.

That will give you a few other sites that have covered the story. Some details might differ from the WSJ coverage, but it will give you enough to be able to appreciate the comments here and participate meaningfully in the discussion.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by jeffreyrogers on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:37AM (#8647923)
I noticed the article compared Harvard's admission percentage to Caltech (19% to 25%). If you're going to make that comparison it's worth noting that a significant fraction of Harvard students are athletes and the admissions criteria for athletes is different. Anecdotally, Asians seem to be under represented in athletics, so that probably explains part of the difference.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by saretired on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:01AM (#8647962)
That's 1992. "In 2013 Harvard made 18% of its offers to Asians, while CalTech admitted 42.5% Asian students." "Though the number of Asians applying for admission [to Harvard] has increased, the percentage of offers has barely budged."

Funny, what you say about Asians and sports "anecdotally" is exactly what was said to "explain" discrimination against Jews in the Ivy League.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by jeffreyrogers on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:21AM (#8648075)
Ah okay, thanks for pointing that out. I just skimmed the article. Also, I don't think that I suggested that explains all of it, and it certainly doesn't in the case where 42.5% of the students are Asian, however, it is worth noting that Caltech and Harvard admit students for different reasons, and many of Harvard's students are admitted for non-academic reasons.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:46AM (#8647938)
> If you're going to make that comparison it's worth noting that a significant fraction of Harvard students are athletes and the admissions criteria for athletes is different.

Another significant fraction are legacies.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by fabulist on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:22AM (#8647891)
Non-paywalled link:

https://archive.today/0a9a6

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Terr_ on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:03PM (#8647764)
What's the etiquette for registration-required (or paywalled) links?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dang on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:58PM (#8647853)
Good question. Thanks for putting it so precisely.

HN wants the most substantive article for a story, and also prefers non-paywalled links. From that we can deduce one bit of etiquette, which is that if you post a paywalled article you're implicitly promising that it's the best one, i.e. that you searched and there's nothing else as good on this story. In such a case, as long as it falls in the workaround-able category (which most paywalls do), it's ok.

That's on the submitter side. On the reader side, the etiquette might be that you should point out a non-paywalled URL if you can find one that's as good (in which case we'll be happy to switch to it), and also that you probably shouldn't post generic complaints about paywalls to the thread, which are guaranteed to be off-topic.

It's not a status quo anyone's happy with, and we'd be happy to hear suggestions of a better way, but please read https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8634076 before you do.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by vmarsy on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:32PM (#8647814)
For true pay-wall articles it would be a problem but here you can just search for the article's title on Google and see it for free
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by greglindahl on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:54PM (#8647845)
No, you can't. I opened up Google News and did a search for the article title in an incognito window and still couldn't view the article. Maybe it worked for you, but it's a lot higher paywall than the ones at NYT. HN can't continue to publish stories that people can't read.

Edit: That was using Firefox's incognito mode; in Chrome incognito it worked. I can't imagine how that could possibly be true. Maybe it's because the first time I clicked on the wsj link in FF I wasn't incognito and the WSJ recorded my IP/UA? In any case, no, it's not an easily solved paywall.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by vmarsy on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:03AM (#8647970)
This is strange, I opened it from Firefox, but without bothering going into incognito mode. I tried multiple times from the direct link I had the paywall, from Google's search everything was fine.

If it can help anyone access the article, I use the Disconnect, Adblock plus, and self destructing cookies add-ons.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dang on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:00AM (#8647856)
Part of the problem is that we get inconsistent reports from readers about what articles do and don't have workarounds. I just did what you described (from SF) and it worked.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by iLoch on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:30PM (#8647811)
Someone usually posts either the article in full, or the Google redirect link (WSJ doesn't paywall traffic directly from Google)
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by butwhy on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:22PM (#8647792)
I would speculate that this problem is not as big as the paywall problem.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by viggity on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:56PM (#8647848)
Search the title of the article in google, then click the link. They'll let you through if the referrer is a search engine
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by fabulist on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:05AM (#8647862)
This is usually my goto move, but it failed me here.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by mynameishere on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:39AM (#8647926)
Shrug.

The anti-European ruling class of the Western world is unintentionally hurting Asians as well. No kidding. But they really didn't want this to happen, and any Asians hurt by these policies should try to understand: You are just collateral damage--the real enemy is people of European descent. This has been going on for a long time.

I'm sure they'll straighten it out. Trial balloons on the topic are always going up.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by himynameistimli on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:07PM (#8647775)
Asians are being used as a wedge in the one lawyer's agenda against affirmative action.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by yummyfajitas on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:44PM (#8647830)
Lawyers and other people interested in rational argument will look at cases where a policies stated justification does not match up to it's actual implementation, and use that (correctly) as evidence of malfeasance.

What's your point?

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by sremani on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:29PM (#8647806)
That does not exonerate Harvard from its Asian glass ceiling, misdirection does not explain 20 years of "record".
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by forrestthewoods on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:07AM (#8647867)
You say that as if it's a bad thing.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by verroq on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:32PM (#8647817)
Are Asians as privileged as whites?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by siliconc0w on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:48AM (#8647940)
Diversity in education may be more valuable to Harvard (and, probably, the rest of us) than a few tenths of a GPA point or handful of SAT points. This seems perfectly valid. (IMO) Diversity helps creates better solutions to better problems than you're likely to get with slightly higher performing but less diverse populations.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dengnan on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:21AM (#8648005)
I would say that fairness is more important than diversity. Setting different goals for different races is a racism no matter how diverse you could get in the end.

About GPA/SAT: According to Goodhart's Law, "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." However, a measure is required and should be consistent.

Asians are not born to be good at GPA, American Asians are good at that because the universities admission system and immigrant policy are specifically designed to select students who are good at school. The first generation of Asians in the US are most grad students from foreign countries.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by glomph on Sunday November 23, 2014 @10:57AM (#8649042)
It is interesting that you argue fairness should be the goal. If diversity results in a universitiy doing better overall (which some studies suggest it can) then presumably it is akin choosing high GPA students in that it is done for the purpose of achiving their goals as an institution.

Put another way: If fairness is your goal what about the kids who don't have a high GPA score? What happened to their fair chance to go to Harvard?

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by gamesbrainiac on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:06AM (#8647982)
Agreed. But, diversity is not limited to race alone, there are many kinds of Asian people, with diverse backgrounds and different beliefs. Is that not worthy of consideration?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by smtddr on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:05AM (#8647978)
Assuming this to be true(and I generally do), you end up with a different problem - that of resentment. There are groups of people who will be upset that they couldn't get into a school because they were the "wrong" race. So you still have a racism problem at the end of the day; just a lesser-known version. This is where I prefer things like BlackGirlsCode.com to try and work on these issues "on the side"[1] to raise academic performance, so the school in the big public spotlight like Harvard don't have to take sides in the controversy and just admit people based on scores, achievements, whatever... just not the controversial stuff like gender, race, etc.

_______

1. When I say "on the side", I basically mean that probably nobody is going to be upset at BlackGirlsCode.com enough to actually file a lawsuit(and have a chance at winning) the way Harvard is getting sued now. Is this fair/right? Probably not, but I think this is the best way to navigate the shaky terrain of public opinion & racism.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by icelancer on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:59AM (#8647960)
>Diversity in education may be more valuable to Harvard

And fair to those who have no control over their genotype?