News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Terr_ on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:03PM (#8647764)
What's the etiquette for registration-required (or paywalled) links?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dang on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:58PM (#8647853)
Good question. Thanks for putting it so precisely.

HN wants the most substantive article for a story, and also prefers non-paywalled links. From that we can deduce one bit of etiquette, which is that if you post a paywalled article you're implicitly promising that it's the best one, i.e. that you searched and there's nothing else as good on this story. In such a case, as long as it falls in the workaround-able category (which most paywalls do), it's ok.

That's on the submitter side. On the reader side, the etiquette might be that you should point out a non-paywalled URL if you can find one that's as good (in which case we'll be happy to switch to it), and also that you probably shouldn't post generic complaints about paywalls to the thread, which are guaranteed to be off-topic.

It's not a status quo anyone's happy with, and we'd be happy to hear suggestions of a better way, but please read https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8634076 before you do.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by vmarsy on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:32PM (#8647814)
For true pay-wall articles it would be a problem but here you can just search for the article's title on Google and see it for free
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by greglindahl on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:54PM (#8647845)
No, you can't. I opened up Google News and did a search for the article title in an incognito window and still couldn't view the article. Maybe it worked for you, but it's a lot higher paywall than the ones at NYT. HN can't continue to publish stories that people can't read.

Edit: That was using Firefox's incognito mode; in Chrome incognito it worked. I can't imagine how that could possibly be true. Maybe it's because the first time I clicked on the wsj link in FF I wasn't incognito and the WSJ recorded my IP/UA? In any case, no, it's not an easily solved paywall.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by vmarsy on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:03AM (#8647970)
This is strange, I opened it from Firefox, but without bothering going into incognito mode. I tried multiple times from the direct link I had the paywall, from Google's search everything was fine.

If it can help anyone access the article, I use the Disconnect, Adblock plus, and self destructing cookies add-ons.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by dang on Sunday November 23, 2014 @12:00AM (#8647856)
Part of the problem is that we get inconsistent reports from readers about what articles do and don't have workarounds. I just did what you described (from SF) and it worked.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by iLoch on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:30PM (#8647811)
Someone usually posts either the article in full, or the Google redirect link (WSJ doesn't paywall traffic directly from Google)