>While Supreme Court justices question the role of racial consideration as a factor in the college admissions, Stanford remains committed to upholding affirmative action, arguing that the policy helps to ensure a diverse student body. One Stanford professor has submitted a brief to the Supreme Court defending the practice.
http://www.stanforddaily.com/2012/10/16/stanford-administrat...
It's not a perfect control, though, because of Caltech's focus on STEM. Caltech does actually offer non-STEM courses (and majors). In fact, it requires students to take about 1/4 of their coursework in humanities and social sciences, which is similar to what a science major at a good liberal arts school would take. Nevertheless, no one chooses Caltech for the humanities or social sciences, whereas people DO choose Harvard for them.
Although undergraduates are generally not admitted on a department by department basis, surely the schools have to try to get some idea from the application what fields the student is interested in majoring in, and they have to take that into account in making their decisions. If you have facilities for 50 new chemistry majors a year and 50 new English Literature majors a yer, and you get 500 applicants from people whose application suggests they might go into chemistry and only 60 applicants who appear likely to go into English Lit, you are going to reject a lot of those potential chemistry majors, even if their applications look better (grades, tests, and so on) than those of many of the people you accept from the group that looks interested in English Lit.
Since many high achieving Asians are driven by pressure from their parents, and parents push their kids toward STEM a lot more often than they push toward English Literature, it is possible that Asians could be getting effectively discriminated against as a side effect of them concentrating in STEM.
[1] http://findlawimages.com/efile/supreme/briefs/02-241/02-241....
What language in that brief makes you conclude that MIT and Stanford both use race as a "significant" factor (at least as compared with Caltech)? All three schools put race in the "considered" category of their CDS submissions.
MIT considers all aspects of each candidate's background,including racial and ethnic factors..
Stanford is strongly of the view that race and national origin should no more be entirely ignore..
http://studentsforfairadmissions.org/wp-content/uploads/2014...
FWIW, this line from the article is wrong, according to CalTech's CDS statements over the last decade or so: http://finance.caltech.edu/Resources/cds (see section C7 in the filings).
(this is assuming that "racial preferences" is being used to mean "racial/ethnic consideration" or "affirmative action")
The numbers apparently conflate Asian-Americans with Asian foreign students. A breakdown of the two groups would be more useful to work from given the huge numbers of wealthy Chinese fighting tooth and nail to send their kids to the most prestigious American schools.
The numbers are also skewed by simple geography. The West coast has more Asian-Americans and would be more desirable for foreign students in terms of quicker and cheaper travel between home and school. California schools can't be equitably compared to the East coast.
It is an interesting choice to compare Harvard's racial admissions with that of CalTech. I would think that Harvard vs. MIT or Stanford would create a more convincing argument. So, here are the numbers:
Stanford class of 2018: 22.6% Asian [1]
MIT class of 2018: 30% Asian [2]
Harvard class of 2018: 20% Asian [3]
It looks like the writer of the article chose the school with the highest percentage Asian population to make this comparison (excluding Hawaii). [4]
[1] http://facts.stanford.edu/academics/undergraduate-profile
[2] http://mitadmissions.org/apply/process/profile
[3] https://college.harvard.edu/admissions/admissions-statistics
[4] http://www.collegexpress.com/lists/list/colleges-with-the-hi...