News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by tzs on Sunday November 23, 2014 @01:33AM (#8648014)
MIT and Stanford both use race as a significant factor in making admission decisions. They have explicitly stated this [1]. Caltech much less so (I believe it can be used as a tie breaker). Hence, Caltech is a better control than Stanford or MIT to compare against when you are trying to see what things should look like if race were not a factor.

It's not a perfect control, though, because of Caltech's focus on STEM. Caltech does actually offer non-STEM courses (and majors). In fact, it requires students to take about 1/4 of their coursework in humanities and social sciences, which is similar to what a science major at a good liberal arts school would take. Nevertheless, no one chooses Caltech for the humanities or social sciences, whereas people DO choose Harvard for them.

Although undergraduates are generally not admitted on a department by department basis, surely the schools have to try to get some idea from the application what fields the student is interested in majoring in, and they have to take that into account in making their decisions. If you have facilities for 50 new chemistry majors a year and 50 new English Literature majors a yer, and you get 500 applicants from people whose application suggests they might go into chemistry and only 60 applicants who appear likely to go into English Lit, you are going to reject a lot of those potential chemistry majors, even if their applications look better (grades, tests, and so on) than those of many of the people you accept from the group that looks interested in English Lit.

Since many high achieving Asians are driven by pressure from their parents, and parents push their kids toward STEM a lot more often than they push toward English Literature, it is possible that Asians could be getting effectively discriminated against as a side effect of them concentrating in STEM.

[1] http://findlawimages.com/efile/supreme/briefs/02-241/02-241....

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:44AM (#8648104)
MIT and Stanford both use race as a significant factor in making admission decisions.

What language in that brief makes you conclude that MIT and Stanford both use race as a "significant" factor (at least as compared with Caltech)? All three schools put race in the "considered" category of their CDS submissions.

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @10:24AM (#8648971)
The brief does not mention Caltech.But for the other two:

MIT considers all aspects of each candidate's background,including racial and ethnic factors..

Stanford is strongly of the view that race and national origin should no more be entirely ignore..

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @11:43AM (#8649159)
Yes, but that is true of Caltech as well.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:00PM (#8649521)
For example,the California Institute of Technology(Caltech) is a private school that selects its students by strict academic standards and chooses not to consider race.

http://studentsforfairadmissions.org/wp-content/uploads/2014...

Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:16PM (#8649572)
I don't know what to tell you - there is no cite for that claim in the filing, and Caltech's own CDS filings say that they do consider race. Is there any statement from Caltech that says they do not consider race in admissions?
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by ekm2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:30PM (#8649613)
The link i have provided you is the filing and it says Caltech does not consider race.
Re:Harvard’s Asian Problem by Anechoic on Sunday November 23, 2014 @02:49PM (#8649665)
It's a filing from a plaintiff that is not Caltech. That plaintiff ("Students For Fair Admissions, Inc") is making an assertion without a citation. Given that sentence contradicts a filing made by Caltech (their annual Common Data Set filings), I'd like to see something more direct from Caltech before I give any weight to SfFA's statement.