Everyone with a brain knew Gox was dying a month ago. In relation to the panic you quote, this isn't a panic over the price falling - it is equivalent to one stock exchange back then stealing your money and going insolvent. Functionally, it is a private company failing, with the collateral that anyone stupid enough to have given them money is pretty much sure to lose it.
But that just means that the business failed, and it doesn't reflect much on the overall bitcoin economy at all. Hell, I was into bitcoin 2 years ago and knew right away MtGox was an incompetent lot that were bound to crash and burn. I also always kept my coins in local wallets and only had USD on an exchange long enough to wire it out or buy BTC that I could then move to my own wallets.
But clearly others trusted MtGox. I haven't traded a bitcoin since 2011 so I don't know much about the community past what I'd absorb about anything that's on HN daily. But isn't the claim that MtGox lost like 6% of all BTC in existence? If you think this is going to sail by without impacting the larger community, I think the foresight that led you away from MtGox is failing you now.
People are now $500+ million dollars poorer than they thought they were. That has ripples. That will erode confidence. And my bet is that it will erode confidence.
If so, then that would further imply that MtGox has lost ~3.5% of all BTC that will ever exist.
PS: Don't forget holding bit-coins does not get you a vote it's the miners that decide how things evolve.
The impending cap on bitcoin production would dry up the already recession-like liquidity, making it worse than gold as a currency.
If your bitcoin economy is full of nerds who really understand the subjective value of money than that's fine. But if you were to start having lots of normal people using Bitcoin and denominating prices and contracts in Bbitcoin than deflation would be a huge problem. As long as most of the surrounding economy isn't using Bitcoin it still wouldn't have the positive feedback loops that caused the Great Depression under the gold standard, though.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sticky_prices
That is 1.4 * 10^90 (atomic units of bitcoin) for everyone on earth. There are only around 1.2 * 10^12 actual US dollar coins and notes in the world, and only 1.2 * 10^13 dollars if you count all of M2 money supply.
Say what? They've fallen 10-15% over the last hour or so (depending on whether you look at Coindesk ot bitCoinTicket) and they're still going down.
The challenge here is that the Bitcoin system is built on faith. If enough faith disappears, so does the value of Bitcoin. In this manner, it is similar to a bank run.
The other piece of the puzzle is that stock exchanges would allow trading on margin, often as much as 10:1 margin or more (an error repeated in the lead-up to the 1929 crash). Because of transactions, local banks were further implicated.
The trust lost wasn't in the exchanges' and banks' fiduciary responsibility but in their creditworthiness, and what Morgan accomplished was to say "don't trust their credit, trust ours". Not a foolproof gamble, but one which worked. The Federal Reserve takes this one step further by being a lender of last resort: if you're a bank and you need a loan, you can always go to the Federal Reserve's lending window to get more cash (though the FDIC may end up owning you). Stockholders can be wiped out (bank stockholders), but depositors are insured (subject to limitations).
The problem with Mt. Gox is, apparently, one of fiduciary trust or negligence -- it's not clear who's made off with the coin, but it's not creditworthiness that's in question.
Quantitative easing is buying financial assets at marginally above-market price with printed money in order to boost inflation and lower real wages. It's a useful policy (assuming you believe in Keynesian stimulus) because the distributional effect is close to nil, unlike fiscal stimulus or mailing money to specified individuals.
The distributional effect is small because the bank buys a bond worth $9,000 for $9,003 or so. This puts $9,003 in circulation but the person receiving $9,003 in cash receives only $3 of profit. So you've increased the money supply by $9003 but you've given the beneficiaries of QE only $3.
QE is a far more efficient way to increase inflation than fiscal stimulus since fiscal stimulus nearly always results in malinvestment/malconsumption (e.g., building bridges to nowhere, etc) and usually has highly non-stimulative side effects (raising nominal wages of government workers).
A bailout is highly targeted. Inflation is a side effect. The people receiving the money trade nothing of value in return for the money. It's totally not the same policy.
Except that we don't really see QE causing the hyperinflation many feared or the lowering of real wages. If it is intended to do these things, it is a miserable failure.
The fact is that when you dump a whole lot of money into what Steve Keen called "the slowest part of the system" it isn't going to actually have much effect. Velocity in money matters if you want the money to actually circulate.
...we are in effect getting a test of the market monetarist view right now, with the Fed having adopted more expansionary policies even as fiscal policy tightens.
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/28/monetarism-falls...
The results are in:
http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/01/the_parrot_is_s....
By the criteria laid out by QE's detractors, it worked.
patio11: that is not how the Bitcoin protocol works.
Even if 99% of the Bitcoin miners agree, they cannot create extra bitcoin; it is simply impossible because that is not something that miners control. Every full node (client) on the Bitcoin network verifies the validity of each block. A block that created more bitcoins than allowed by the protocol would be rejected by the clients (and the miners who follow the original rules). The "extra" bitcoins would be on a hard fork and thus invalid to anyone on the main (original) blockchain.
More info: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Weaknesses#Attacker_has_a_lot_of_...
If the most common bitcoin clients are updated to allow this "bonus", and at least 51% of the network installs this update, their blockchain will become the authoritative one. Older or other clients will have to accept it if they still want to participate in the chain.
A transaction that conjures Bitcoin out of nothing is certainly invalid. Patio11 got this wrong.
Transactions that make up bitcoin out of nothing are already used as rewards for mining a block.
If 51% of miners start using an inflationary version of Bitcoin "Bitcoin-QE", but the clients (exchanges, merchants, wallet providers, etc) don't approve, they won't update the client and use the partition of the network that is secured by the remaining 49% of miners. People wouldn't want to accept the Bitcoin-QE mined on the inflationary branch and the investment wouldn't pay off.
Of course Bitcoin-QE miners could start an attack on Bitcoin in other ways, but that also woudn't be necessarily economical.
It's very hard to tell what 51% will do, but it is clear that you don't have full control of the currency.
I already remarked once that Bitcoin is remarkable democratic in a way; perhaps this is a good time to leverage that...
Gaining 51% can allow you to double spend your own transactions, but you can't spend other peoples money or make more coin, because the clients will reject those transactions even if 100% of the miners put it through. The nodes verify what the miners do. Even 100% control does not give you God power. The best you can really do is deny all transactions and thus destroy Bitcoin.
It'll be interesting to see how many of them can provide such a proof... I'm guessing most of them can (but only time will tell)
If they successfully provide this proof, there's no reason to expect a bank run.
http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/12/20/255839292/episode-...
You can't do this with BTC, because there is no credit market at this point.
Everything in BTC is full-reserve, all the time; there is no fractional reserve banking of BTC - it is in your wallet, or it is in my wallet.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1907
What is (so far) missing in the world of Bitcoin is a single actor powerful enough to play the organizing role that Morgan played during that previous crash:
"Morgan summoned the presidents of the city's banks to his office. They started to arrive at 2 p.m.; Morgan informed them that as many as 50 stock exchange houses would fail unless $25 million was raised in 10 minutes. By 2:16 p.m., 14 bank presidents had pledged $23.6 million to keep the stock exchange afloat. The money reached the market at 2:30 p.m., in time to finish the day's trading, and by the 3 o'clock market close, $19 million had been loaned out. Disaster was averted. Morgan usually eschewed the press, but as he left his offices that night he made a statement to reporters: "If people will keep their money in the banks, everything will be all right""