News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by dredmorbius on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:44AM (#7296388)
Note that the 1907 panic and the present Bitcoin situation are fundamentally different in nature. BTC exchanges operate as, well, exchanges and stores -- more akin to a security deposit box with the ability to trade with other boxholders -- not lending institutions.

The other piece of the puzzle is that stock exchanges would allow trading on margin, often as much as 10:1 margin or more (an error repeated in the lead-up to the 1929 crash). Because of transactions, local banks were further implicated.

The trust lost wasn't in the exchanges' and banks' fiduciary responsibility but in their creditworthiness, and what Morgan accomplished was to say "don't trust their credit, trust ours". Not a foolproof gamble, but one which worked. The Federal Reserve takes this one step further by being a lender of last resort: if you're a bank and you need a loan, you can always go to the Federal Reserve's lending window to get more cash (though the FDIC may end up owning you). Stockholders can be wiped out (bank stockholders), but depositors are insured (subject to limitations).

The problem with Mt. Gox is, apparently, one of fiduciary trust or negligence -- it's not clear who's made off with the coin, but it's not creditworthiness that's in question.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by judk on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @04:10AM (#7303790)
Why would a depositor care about the difference between trustworthiness and creditworthiness?