If the most common bitcoin clients are updated to allow this "bonus", and at least 51% of the network installs this update, their blockchain will become the authoritative one. Older or other clients will have to accept it if they still want to participate in the chain.
A transaction that conjures Bitcoin out of nothing is certainly invalid. Patio11 got this wrong.
Transactions that make up bitcoin out of nothing are already used as rewards for mining a block.
If 51% of miners start using an inflationary version of Bitcoin "Bitcoin-QE", but the clients (exchanges, merchants, wallet providers, etc) don't approve, they won't update the client and use the partition of the network that is secured by the remaining 49% of miners. People wouldn't want to accept the Bitcoin-QE mined on the inflationary branch and the investment wouldn't pay off.
Of course Bitcoin-QE miners could start an attack on Bitcoin in other ways, but that also woudn't be necessarily economical.
It's very hard to tell what 51% will do, but it is clear that you don't have full control of the currency.
patio11: that is not how the Bitcoin protocol works.
Even if 99% of the Bitcoin miners agree, they cannot create extra bitcoin; it is simply impossible because that is not something that miners control. Every full node (client) on the Bitcoin network verifies the validity of each block. A block that created more bitcoins than allowed by the protocol would be rejected by the clients (and the miners who follow the original rules). The "extra" bitcoins would be on a hard fork and thus invalid to anyone on the main (original) blockchain.
More info: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Weaknesses#Attacker_has_a_lot_of_...