News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by zanny on Monday February 24, 2014 @11:08PM (#7295434)
This news went up around 2 hours ago and market prices haven't really budged. In bitcoin, these kinds of shocks are almost always instant, and usually happen days or weeks in advance with insider knowledge trading.

Everyone with a brain knew Gox was dying a month ago. In relation to the panic you quote, this isn't a panic over the price falling - it is equivalent to one stock exchange back then stealing your money and going insolvent. Functionally, it is a private company failing, with the collateral that anyone stupid enough to have given them money is pretty much sure to lose it.

But that just means that the business failed, and it doesn't reflect much on the overall bitcoin economy at all. Hell, I was into bitcoin 2 years ago and knew right away MtGox was an incompetent lot that were bound to crash and burn. I also always kept my coins in local wallets and only had USD on an exchange long enough to wire it out or buy BTC that I could then move to my own wallets.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by encoderer on Monday February 24, 2014 @11:40PM (#7295619)
I applaud you on your foresight and you should pat yourself on the back extra good tonight.

But clearly others trusted MtGox. I haven't traded a bitcoin since 2011 so I don't know much about the community past what I'd absorb about anything that's on HN daily. But isn't the claim that MtGox lost like 6% of all BTC in existence? If you think this is going to sail by without impacting the larger community, I think the foresight that led you away from MtGox is failing you now.

People are now $500+ million dollars poorer than they thought they were. That has ripples. That will erode confidence. And my bet is that it will erode confidence.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by bunderbunder on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @12:12AM (#7295770)
But isn't the claim that MtGox lost like 6% of all BTC in existence?

If so, then that would further imply that MtGox has lost ~3.5% of all BTC that will ever exist.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by Retric on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @12:51AM (#7295913)
Perhaps, however I suspect bit-coin is going to be forced to increase the long term cap at some point in the future as they keep being destroyed. Which might not seem like an issue but it adds a lot of instability as nobody knows how many bit-coins are still in circulation.

PS: Don't forget holding bit-coins does not get you a vote it's the miners that decide how things evolve.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by intelliot on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:49AM (#7296397)
Nobody knows how many dollars are still in circulation. They have good guesses, but nobody knows about the millions in cash that was lost/burned/buried in the desert. It doesn't matter. Supply and demand doesn't rely on the total number of bitcoins in existence; only the number that are available on exchanges. And with blockchain analysis, we can have a very clear picture of bitcoin circulation - much better than with traditional currencies.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by toyg on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @04:14AM (#7296478)
With fiat money, this is not a problem, because that's only one of the available parameters to determine the relative value of a currency. Also, inflation constantly pushes fiat currency value towards zero, so your stashed 1970 dollars are now worth much less. Bitcoin, being deflationary in nature and not linked to anything, is a different ballgame.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by leoc on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @01:40AM (#7296053)
My suspicion (I am not an expert on finance) is that (if it remains successful long enough) Bitcoin is going to end up being fractionally reserved by the exchanges—I mean openly so, with the consent of the depositors. That should generate a large increase in the apparent supply of Bitcoins. I mean, gold is already heavily fractionally reserved...
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by judk on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @03:59AM (#7303767)
And as we saw with the banks, fools who hand over money to unregulated banks don't get their money back. Why would any bank not steal all the money, or get robbed, when it costs nothing to do so?
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by bduerst on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @02:55AM (#7296235)
They would absolutely have to.

The impending cap on bitcoin production would dry up the already recession-like liquidity, making it worse than gold as a currency.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by meric on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @01:12AM (#7295982)
A bitcoin can be divided into many pieces.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by bunderbunder on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @09:57AM (#7297900)
So can a dollar. Admittedly not as many pieces - only 100 of them - but the principle is exactly the same.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by michaelq on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @02:03AM (#7296122)
There's no reason to issue more bitcoin. The forces of supply and demand will keep the value stable, regardless of the exact number of bitcoins outstanding. Issuing more bitcoin would only serve to invite fears that it would be issued in shady ways, or that such issuances might become routine and inflation would take place. This would only further undermine the currency's perceived staying power.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by Symmetry on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @09:58AM (#7297903)
Unfortunately humans are famously loss averse[1] which leads to downwardly sticky nominal prices[2] in practice. In the face of deflation a lot of people just stop buying and selling and hope that prices go back up, or hold out for a nominal offer as big as what they think they "should" get even if the real value is the same.

If your bitcoin economy is full of nerds who really understand the subjective value of money than that's fine. But if you were to start having lots of normal people using Bitcoin and denominating prices and contracts in Bbitcoin than deflation would be a huge problem. As long as most of the surrounding economy isn't using Bitcoin it still wouldn't have the positive feedback loops that caused the Great Depression under the gold standard, though.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sticky_prices

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by valas on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:32AM (#7296349)
Why do you think "forces of supply and demand will keep the value stable"? Bitcoin is much more susceptible to huge valuation fluctuations than fiat currency, where central bank can step in to shift demand/supply.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by josu on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:43AM (#7297220)
I remember reading that it's only divisible by 10^100.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by mazesc on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @08:37AM (#7297479)
only
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by josu on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @09:44AM (#7305177)
I meant only, because if Bitcoin effectively becomes the leading world currency 10^100 might not be enough. However it shouldn't be hard to change that limit, or to find a way around it.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by meric on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:49AM (#7332543)
You have no idea how big 10^100 is.

That is 1.4 * 10^90 (atomic units of bitcoin) for everyone on earth. There are only around 1.2 * 10^12 actual US dollar coins and notes in the world, and only 1.2 * 10^13 dollars if you count all of M2 money supply.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by varjag on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @05:42AM (#7296788)
So can gold. It's not the question of dividing it up.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by rtkwe on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:25PM (#7300219)
And weighting, assaying, and using the tiny divisions of gold has a steep upwards cost as the amount of gold gets smaller.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by ok_craig on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:20AM (#7296316)
The funds were likely stolen, not sent into the void.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by bunderbunder on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @09:59AM (#7297913)
Right, but with the blockchain being public, there's a certain parallel between stolen BTC and stolen art.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by intelliot on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:46AM (#7296392)
Even if they were sent into the void, bitcoins are highly divisible. Just shift the decimal point over a few places and you've got convenient units once again.
Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by anigbrowl on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @12:25AM (#7295815)
market prices haven't really budged

Say what? They've fallen 10-15% over the last hour or so (depending on whether you look at Coindesk ot bitCoinTicket) and they're still going down.

Re:Joint Statement Regarding the Insolvency of Mt. Gox by mathattack on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @09:28AM (#7305058)
In relation to the panic you quote, this isn't a panic over the price falling - it is equivalent to one stock exchange back then stealing your money and going insolvent.

The challenge here is that the Bitcoin system is built on faith. If enough faith disappears, so does the value of Bitcoin. In this manner, it is similar to a bank run.