News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The real reason for pensions by 3pt14159 on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:23PM (#6864277)
A group of people collectively bargained for future payouts from an entity that was only represented by its current voters (or in some cases, shareholders).

Predictably the pensioners-to-be asked for generous pensions, paid early in life, at the least expense possible. Predictably the public purse was more generous with future payouts that didn't look like debt than it would be with present payouts. Predictably the economy shifted away from uncompetitive and unionised sectors of the economy in Detroit to Austin. Predictably the now-pensioners claim that they paid for pensions and are thus 'owed' them.

But from whom? Either they never cared to set up a fund or did and had the state backstop it, and now there is no money. Retiring after 32 years and earning "80% of your best 4 years of pay" for 40 years (remember, they keep paying out when you die because your wife still needs to eat, so we have to handle the statistics to handle the average case) turned out not to be affordable on the tiny percent they put away.

What else was ever going to happen?

Re:The real reason for pensions by lsc on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:40PM (#6864359)
>Predictably the now-pensioners claim that they paid for pensions and are thus 'owed' them.

Do you think employees are 'owed' a paycheck after they do their month of work?

Some jobs, instead of paying you all that money up-front, instead give you a pension. Just because it's deferred 30 years rather than just 30 days doesn't mean it's any less your pay than your paycheck.

I mean, you can argue that it isn't sustainable, or even that it's stupid to expect a company to deliver on a promise 30 years from now, but when you are paid in a promise of future pay... you are certainly owed that money.

Re:The real reason for pensions by 3pt14159 on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:50PM (#6864624)
I put it in quotes because the group of people demanding it weren't honest enough for me to feel that they have a moral claim to it.

Companies and cities go bankrupt. This isn't news. This has been happening since before the Aztec empire started. If you are going to design a pension for thousands of people you should take care to design it for the worst case scenario. I would rather take a pension that had a 99% chance of paying out $500 per month, than one that had a 95% chance of paying out $650 per month, because the retired should be risk adverse.

Instead the employees were greedy, thought they could double dip by being part of the huge baby boomer group (thus not paying in a fair share, considering what they would get out) and retiring handsomely.

Well you can't change reality. At the very bottom of economics is actual real resources, and if you don't create enough value or save enough value and there there isn't enough other people to feed from then you must downwardly adjust your standard of living. Remember Freedom 55? I actually know people that worked for only 30 years at a government job and are being paid 80% of their best 4 years (adjusted for inflation of course) for the rest of their life. This is unsustainable.

Re:The real reason for pensions by lsc on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:10PM (#6864698)
>Instead the employees were greedy, thought they could double dip by being part of the huge baby boomer group (thus not paying in a fair share, considering what they would get out) and retiring handsomely.

The big thing you are missing is that when the boomer pension contracts were created? you could expect a reasonable return, over and above inflation, on your T bills. Because safe investments that paid out reasonably existed, defined benefit pensions were a reasonable thing.

The economic reality is very different now, and the very idea that someone could make good on a defined-benefit pension is kinda laughable. My point is that the economic realities were different in the 80s. The big danger in the 80s wasn't that the value of your investment wouldn't go up, it was that inflation would go up even faster, making your 'defined benefit' worth much less in real dollars.

Re:The real reason for pensions by lsc on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:06PM (#6864679)
>Well you can't change reality. At the very bottom of economics is actual real resources, and if you don't create enough value or save enough value and there there isn't enough other people to feed from then you must downwardly adjust your standard of living. Remember Freedom 55? I actually know people that worked for only 30 years at a government job and are being paid 80% of their best 4 years (adjusted for inflation of course) for the rest of their life. This is unsustainable.

And? I've had jobs where I got paid $200/hr. I mean, that's not a "sustainable" rate- I'm just not bringing that much value.

But the boss agreed to the rate; I still expect them to pay up for the hours I work, and I think that expectation is legitimate.

Re:The real reason for pensions by rayiner on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:54PM (#6864414)
Sure, under normal circumstances, but e.g. in bankruptcy employees can be left with unpaid wages. That's the context here.
Re:The real reason for pensions by lsc on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:57PM (#6864427)
I was responding to the previous poster saying

>>Predictably the now-pensioners claim that they paid for pensions and are thus 'owed' them.

I read the quotes as implying that the poster thought that the pensioners were acting entitled because they thought they were owed their wages.

Of course, if someone that owes you money declares bankruptcy, sometimes those debts are reduced or expunged. But that doesn't make the original debt any less legitimate.

Re:The real reason for pensions by Retric on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:11PM (#6864482)
Sure, but there first in line in-front of all other creditors. So first Detroit would have to completely default on all loans as in everyone get's 0$ before they could go after pensioners. In this case the Judge basically said, bankers are just as important than you despite whatever the state law said.
Re:The real reason for pensions by mathattack on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:31PM (#6864318)
Ponzi schemes can keep going if you can keep growing. They only die when growth stops. Detroit shows us the truth here. When the companies get strangled, people leave, and Detroit follows suit.
Re:The real reason for pensions by drcube on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:22PM (#6864273)
Pensions are a foolish idea and I seriously hope no one under the age of 50 takes a job with a pension, expecting it to actually materialize. But the workers of the past didn't have our benefit of hindsight, and we should do what we can to keep our promises to them.

But seriously, guys, don't offer your employees a pension, and if a potential employer offers you one, laugh in their face. Let us manage our own retirements.

Re:The real reason for pensions by jgreen10 on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:50PM (#6864392)
It's easy for me to say, since I'm from a country with an excellent pension system (the Netherlands), but completely managing your own pension would be foolish at best. You cannot predict how long you will live compared to others. To spread the risk, you should always be part of a bigger pension scheme.
Re:The real reason for pensions by aquark on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:10PM (#6864478)
That is an interesting point. You can of course always buy an annuity to benefit from the risk spreading whilst retaining control over your pension funds up to that point.

Are there products that let you do this pre-retirement as opposed to at retirement? If so they certainly don't seem as popular as the traditional save-to-65-then-buy-one approach.

Re:The real reason for pensions by mathattack on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:30PM (#6864306)
Once could argue the same thing about Social Security. :-)

In my view, there are 2 kinds of pensions. One is Defined Benefit, which is crazy to count on. On the other hand, companies can offer Defined Contribution, which is fine. If a company offers a 401K, and makes a 10K contribution, I'm happy. It's 10K more income that will probably get taxed at a lower bracket when I retire.

Re:The real reason for pensions by _delirium on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:38PM (#6864351)
Defined contribution is kind of a poor match to future needs on the recipient's side, though, since people do not live fixed and predictable periods of time. You could fix this individually by converting the lump sum to an annuity, but few people seem to do so (it doesn't help that the annuity market is a bit confusing). The end result is that people who live significantly longer than expected run out of money. And they do so at the least convenient time: many people early in retirement could probably go back to work if needed, but a typical 100-year-old, who retired 30+ years ago and now ran out of money, is not in a condition to reenter the workforce.

In most countries the backstop is to have a small defined-benefit state pension, so they won't end up literally penniless (in the U.S. this is Social Security, which pays a minimum of ~$9,500/yr). Other countries have tried to move more people into essentially buying annuities to mitigate the varying-lifespan risk. For example most defined-contribution private-sector pensions in Denmark now pay into pension funds (third-party, non-profit organizations) that by default are essentially the purchase of an annuity. You can cash it out as a lump sum upon retirement, but if you do nothing, the default is a traditional monthly pension for life, with the amount dependent on your contribution.

Re:The real reason for pensions by mathattack on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:00PM (#6865072)
The problem with defined benefit is there are always unknown risks. You can say that the government, or an insurance company will pick up the tab, but what if they fail? If the amount of the benefit is large enough (retirement savings for a generation) it's impossible to guarantee. Small #s yes, large, no. Many intelligent people don't believe a small system like Social Security will hold.
Re:The real reason for pensions by bradleyjg on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:08PM (#6864469)
Defined contribution can be transformed into defined benefit if the contribution is a deferred annuity.

The reason pension obligations can be discharged in bankruptcy and 401k contributions can't+, is because the former is a contractual obligation to a future stream of payments, while the latter is a transfer of vested property.

Neither employers nor unions like this idea however because they both like to use pensions as a slush fund. Some workers also might not like it because annuities don't have great returns.

+There is the unlikely possibility of a clawback of 2 years at most.

Re:The real reason for pensions by gnaritas on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:37PM (#6864345)
> Let us manage our own retirements.

We already know from pre-social security times that approach doesn't work; most people end up destitute.

Re:The real reason for pensions by drcube on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:52PM (#6864406)
I'm not talking about social security, I'm talking about pensions. To which a 401k or IRA is infinitely preferable. But SS has the same problem as pensions: there's nothing to stop future politicians from eliminating it at any time to free up some headroom in the budget.

Perhaps a mandatory 401k everyone must have, contribute to and refrain from using until age 65 would be the best of both worlds?

Re:The real reason for pensions by dragonwriter on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:12PM (#6864706)
> I'm not talking about social security, I'm talking about pensions.

Social security is a pension.

> To which a 401k or IRA is infinitely preferable.

I dunno, the people who have had 401k's wiped out in various economic collapses might disagree on whether such plans are "infinitely preferable" to defined-benefit pensions.

> But SS has the same problem as pensions: there's nothing to stop future politicians from eliminating it at any time to free up some headroom in the budget.

Well, except voters, which have stopped politicians on several occasions who wanted to make much smaller changes -- which would not even affect current beneficiaries -- to Social Security than eliminating it.

> Perhaps a mandatory 401k everyone must have, contribute to and refrain from using until age 65 would be the best of both worlds?

Well, certainly, it would be one of the best (of the very many!) public subsidies the financial services industry has received. Not sure it would be good for anything beyond that, though.

Re:The real reason for pensions by rpedela on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:12PM (#6864489)
While I generally agree with your view on pensions. 401K is currently not a good solution because many of them have higher fees and perform worse than an index fund. Over a 30+ year period, those higher fees often result in a 2-5% loss in income which can easily be tens of thousands of dollars or more. What happens if you are unlucky to retire right when a crash occurs? There is an upside though: tax-free income.

There are some 401K plans (not many) that allow you to have index funds as your core which is definitely good. But not sure how to handle the market crash problem.

Re:The real reason for pensions by coldtea on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:57PM (#6864425)
>But SS has the same problem as pensions: there's nothing to stop future politicians from eliminating it at any time to free up some headroom in the budget.

The same goes for salaries. There's nothing to stop them from offering them and enforcing slavery.

Except, you know, the people that would be affected.

Re:The real reason for pensions by drcube on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:15PM (#6864501)
No, if they stop paying your salary, you can stop working for them. If you work your entire career, you don't really have a recourse if they then refuse to pay the pension you were promised. You can't go back in time and choose another career.
Re:The real reason for pensions by dragonwriter on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:13PM (#6864711)
> If you work your entire career, you don't really have a recourse if they then refuse to pay the pension you were promised.

Society needs to find some way to make promises of future money in exchange for present goods and services enforceable. If only there was some mechanism for that...

Re:The real reason for pensions by gnaritas on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:43PM (#6864606)
> I'm not talking about social security

I didn't say you were, I merely pointed out that we already know people can't in general handle their own retirements.

Re:The real reason for pensions by coldtea on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:55PM (#6864419)
>But seriously, guys, don't offer your employees a pension, and if a potential employer offers you one, laugh in their face. Let us manage our own retirements.

Yes, let's see how that turns out, when 80% of the population over 65 is destitute or working at Walmart/McDonalds well into its seventies...

Re:The real reason for pensions by Shivetya on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:07PM (#6864467)
I am always shocked by the number of professionals I work with who either do not fund their 401k, or only to matching, instead of going for max. Yes I understand hitting your maximum can be difficult, but it should come before frivolous expenditures. You are investing in yourself and if you have family, them.

Yet while the excuses are legion the majority of these same people have no issue with car notes(s), cell phone contract(s), and buying breakfast/daily.

Fortunately my company offered a pension when I joined, they have since converted to 401k and frozen pensions at the end of the year. Yet it is there and one more safety for me.

Re:The real reason for pensions by dmm on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:20PM (#6864519)
What kind of politicians and policies will of these retired, former professionals vote for? Maybe it will be something like "Tax the idiots stupid enough to save and give it to the newly poor".
Re:The real reason for pensions by mynewwork on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:51PM (#6864631)
This is a serious concern of mine. There already exist countries in Europe which tax savings. It wouldn't shock me if after 40 years of living below my means and saving diligently, that an act of congress makes my IRA/401k be taxed at a higher rate to give money to my non-saving contemporaries. I'm sure there are some on the far-left that could rationalize redistributing savings accounts.
Re:The real reason for pensions by gaius on Saturday December 07, 2013 @03:19AM (#6865920)
Already happening. In 1997, then-chancellor Gordon Brown raided the private pension funds. Seeking an alternate asset class to save for retirement, the middle classes piled into property causing a bubble.

It will take decades to undo this mans legacy.

Re:The real reason for pensions by dingaling on Saturday December 07, 2013 @03:10AM (#6865899)
In the UK, we can never directly access our capital upon retirement ( even for a private, self-managed pension ).

The best we can do is withdraw 25% as a lump sum and then buy an annuity with the remainder ( or draw-down a Government-controlled small % each year ).

Not much of a safety net.

So naturally people decide to use a different savings vehicle, one in which they can decide how to use the capital. Hence the headline 'underfunding' of our personal pensions.

Re:The real reason for pensions by bradleyjg on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:15PM (#6864502)
Depending on your alternative tax advantaged investment options, you may not want to max your 401k contribution. For various tawdry reasons most 401k plans have terrible investment options. You certainly want to take the free money (i.e. up to match) but if you have alternative tax advantaged options (e.g. IRA, HSA) with better fund options you may want to max those first before the 401k.
Re:The real reason for pensions by nilkn on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:14PM (#6864495)
In the oil & gas industry, it's common for companies to offer both 401(k) plans with matching and traditional pension plans.
Re:The real reason for pensions by hapless on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:07PM (#6864170)
This article proposes that we close the barn door after the horse is left.

If my employer offered me a pension I'd laugh in his face. In 2013, a pension benefit's market value is $0. Who actually believes the money will be there when the time comes?

After 30 years of private sector firms refusing to fund pensions and passing them off to the PBGC, the public sector is finally getting into the game. No one should surprised.

Re:The real reason for pensions by msandford on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:04PM (#6864145)
Which is worse? Taking money from the young (who already have bad prospects) and giving it to the elderly? Or "taking" money from the elderly and "giving" it to the young? I say "taking" in quotes because a pension is a contractual obligation, not a god-given right.

Ultimately neither solution is a good one. This is class warfare at its finest.

Personally I think the social contract of the US is starting to break down, as is societal cohesion. We're all super civilized when we all have good prospects and everyone's life is improving. As the prospects deteriorate so do people's willingness to participate.

Re:The real reason for pensions by gohrt on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:06PM (#6864165)
Generally speaking, life gets massively better from one generation to the next. There are exceptions, of course, for nations collapsing in war, and there's pollution and whatnot posing a lurking threat, but overall:

If you had the choice, and had to pay for your decision, how much would you pay to live in the 2000s instead living in the 1900s?

The elderly deserve their pensions. The young get Modern Progress.

Re:The real reason for pensions by christkv on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:11PM (#6864198)
The problem with pensions is that they need a pyramid age distributions. That's to say lots of young people to pay the taxes to fund the top of the pyramid. That scheme is broken in the west so the whole system will creak on until the younger generations cuts the funds.

The excessive entitlements granted over the last 2 generations is unsustainable. In Spain many baby-boomers have 2X-3X the pension income of a full-time employee. How is that sustainable ??

Re:The real reason for pensions by gohrt on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:15PM (#6864218)
> The problem with pensions is that they need a pyramid age distributions

No, they don't, necessarily. There is a balance to be struck with regard to magnitude and length of pension payments.

2-3x the pension income of a full-timer seems excessive at a glance. That doesn't disprove the existence of a reasonable pension scheme.

Re:The real reason for pensions by adventured on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:40PM (#6864361)
None of it is sustainable, not even remotely.

Falling populations alone force a requirement for ever higher taxes due to a downward spiral equation on taxes / people / savings / standard of living. The next generation always has to pay more for the last (greater population in the past each cycle), while having less savings and a lower standard of living.

Re:The real reason for pensions by christkv on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:50PM (#6864394)
Actually for this generations the squeeze are two way. One is higher pensions the other is higher housing costs. A growth in house equity value is a transfer between generations as the older generations came into the property value at the bottom. Norway right now is an extreme example of this as the high prices of property squeeze out the young from the market and transfers money to the older generations.
Re:The real reason for pensions by revelation on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:18PM (#6864239)
It's not exactly a tradeoff. You can get Modern Progress and not pay some old dudes lush pension.
Re:The real reason for pensions by adventured on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:36PM (#6864335)
It's also worth noting that the premise of life getting massively better one generation to the next, is a freak occurrence - and as it applies to the broad planet it's a recent one - over the course of human history. It has been the extremely rare event, for there to be a big leap one generation to the next, if you're tracking the total span of the species.

Why do I point that out? Because there's no rule that human life has to get massively better. There is no guarantee. It does not have to happen at all, and I would argue entropy + certain aspects of human nature are constantly acting to undermine the potential for progress to occur.

It's not just that there have been exceptions. Life getting massively better one gen to the next is the extraordinarily rare exception. We definitely shouldn't take it for granted.

Re:The real reason for pensions by msandford on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:54PM (#6864641)
Oh I agree completely. The problem is that life got massively better for a while. That's stopped as the industrial revolution has slowed down. I don't mean that the world is getting worse, just that it's getting awesome at a much slower rate.

BUT the pensions and social security and whatever are premised on the world getting more bitchin' at a high rate. That high rate is gone, but the programs put into place while it was around are still around, and they haven't been adjusted.

I don't mind that we've returned to slow growth instead of rapid, so long as it happens to everyone. That does not seem to be the case re: social security, the housing market, etc and those are largely dictated by government. The Fed (a quasi-government agency) sets the interest rate and thus has a lot of control over housing prices. The Federal Government enacted Social Security and refuses to reform it in any meaningful way.

As a result I'm not optimistic that social cohesion will continue. We're graduating people who can't buy houses or cars or start families at a substantial rate. Loss aversion is a REALLY strong emotionally motivating force for humans as we're wired to avoid losses much more aggressively than pursue gains. But if you don't have much to lose any possibility of gain appealing and that's how you have a revolution.

Re:The real reason for pensions by gohrt on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:49PM (#6864839)
> That's stopped as the industrial revolution has slowed down.

It's just not true: http://gapminder.org , http://www.gapminder.org/world/

Re:The real reason for pensions by msandford on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:20AM (#6869046)
That's all fine and dandy if you think the BLS CPI isn't gamed. I happen to think that they change it enough that it's nearly meaningless to talk about "growth" for the last 20-40 years. When the inflation rate and the growth rate as as close to one another as they are all you need is a small error calculating CPI and suddenly mild increase turns into mild decrease.
Re:The real reason for pensions by gohrt on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:46PM (#6864831)
> entropy

"The Earth's not a closed system, it's powered by the Sun." -- M C Hawking

Re:The real reason for pensions by rayiner on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:51PM (#6864397)
This is the really interesting part of the article:

> On Tuesday, a federal judge said Detroit could legally cut the pensions it has already promised to workers as part of its bankruptcy plan. Many state constitutions, including that of Michigan, hold that the government can’t go back on pension promises, and, because of this, cities have generally assumed that they could not touch existing pensions even in cases of bankruptcy. (Instead, many have been cutting pensions for newly hired workers.) But federal law supersedes state law, and, according to Judge Steve W. Rhodes, pension cuts are just fine under federal law. “Pension benefits are a contractual right and are not entitled to any heightened protection in a municipal bankruptcy,” he said.

Takeaway: Bankruptcy courts > state constitutions. It's a straightforward result of the Supremacy Clause, but is practically very significant.

Re:The real reason for pensions by GVIrish on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:41PM (#6864362)
Maybe pensions are a bad idea after all, but the bigger implication of this is that it will be yet another thing that dissuades people from public service. Some may say that's a good thing, but if you keep removing benefits of public service, it is only going to reduce the quality of people working for our government.

People talk about how bad government incompetence is now, but it can get far worse in the future. Not saying that pensions need to stay, or that they should never be cut. Just saying that if the good reasons to go into public service keep getting removed government is only going to get worse.

Re:The real reason for pensions by 001sky on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:01PM (#6864443)
it will be yet another thing that dissuades people from public service

Lets face it, greed and easy-money is absolutely the wrong reason to be in "public service".

Re:The real reason for pensions by GVIrish on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:03PM (#6864671)
I don't think it's greed at all, if you're going into public service a lot of times you are paid less as a result but it's made up for in the benefits package. If the benefits package gets drastically reduced, then you're left with less pay, and less benefits than the private sector.

So maybe some people will still go govvie out of a sense of duty, but for more than a few people it'll make it a raw deal. Especially considering how government workers now have to deal with furloughs and shutdowns. Sure, many people in other fields have to deal with a lot of uncertainty too, but one of the pluses of gov't work used to be stability. Without stability, it makes the job even less attractive.

Re:The real reason for pensions by gaius on Saturday December 07, 2013 @03:25AM (#6865931)
Except in the UK public sector salaries are higher than private sector, plus the gold plated pension, job for life, etc. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-14028848
Re:The real reason for pensions by dmm on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:25PM (#6864547)
Asking to be paid what you are promised is "greed"?
Re:The real reason for pensions by 001sky on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:38PM (#6864578)
Ha ha you should write one liners for [insert special interest here].

The parent is espousing "greed" as a primary means of recruitment. The method of payment my point. People motivated by "greed" is not the type of people one wants in government. Especially If we have to pay them with a form of remuneration is at once both opaque and easily manipulated.

In otherwords, if these people (say teachers) are valuable, pay them proper salaries. Don't pay them poor salaries and then promise them a $2 or $5 million dollar pension pot if the "stick around" for 20-30 years. Just pay them fair and square a proper wage from the get-go. The poor pay + gold plated pension thing is just a form of dis-honest pay, where special interests manipulate the system for their own advantage.

So, don't negotiate cut-rate payment plans for cut-rate people. Seems simple enough. If you want good people, pay them properly and transparently.

Re:The real reason for pensions by GVIrish on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:07PM (#6864684)
I'd be all for just paying proper salaries up front. Chances are it would be very politically difficult to lobby for raising salaries for government workers, even if pensions were eliminated but it's a good idea IMO.

As I said though, it's not "greedy" of people to choose a job that pays less in the short term because it makes up for it with a deferred benefit. It's no different than getting a smaller salary in return for equity or a lower salary in return for more leave. It's just another thing that goes into the equation when people are evaluating their options.

Re:The real reason for pensions by 001sky on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:27PM (#6864753)
I don't disagree with anything as you've stated it here.

The word "greed" (typically) goes beyond "rational foresight"to include opportunistic self-enrichment (esp. in the absence of transparency, effective oversight or control). But doing a DCF of a career trajectory vs. a simple Salary comparison is legitimate math any employee, IMHO.

Re:The real reason for pensions by Adrock on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:08PM (#6864471)
Related: I recently was chatting with a retired 401k salesperson who explained to me the real reason for employer-matched contributions. The highest compensated employees, typically executive management, are subject to deferral limits that are based on the contribution rates of the regular employees.

> Why is it important for companies to encourage their employees to save? Aside from “it’s the right thing to do,” there are actually compliance reasons why this is necessary. “It helps with nondiscrimination tests,” says Robert Richter, vice president of SunGard’s wealth & retirement administration business in Jacksonville, Florida. He adds, “Highly compensated employees are subject to deferral limits that are based on non-highly compensated employee contribution rates. If non-highly compensated employees defer at low rates, then it will limit the amount that the highly compensated employees can defer. Safe harbor plans are a way to eliminate that test, but in order to use the safe harbor provisions the employer is required to contribute to the non-highly compensated employees either a minimum matching contribution or an across-the-board contribution, even for those who do not defer.”

- http://fiduciarynews.com/2013/11/are-401k-plan-sponsors-pois...

Re:The real reason for pensions by OneOneOneOne on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:51PM (#6864064)
I think that a pension is a promise to the employee that should be held.

I also think it was silly to offer pensions in the first place since it is not possible to predict the future. People working for cities and other organizations offering pensions should be very concerned by recent events.

Re:The real reason for pensions by ef4 on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:07PM (#6864173)
Every debt is a promise that should be held. But in a bankruptcy that's not possible, so it only becomes a question of which promises will be broken and by how much.
Re:The real reason for pensions by bradleyjg on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:02PM (#6864135)
A contract is how we formalize promises.

Every contract is formed in the shadow of its governing law.

Municipal bankruptcies have been a part of the law of the United States since 1937.

∴ no promises are being broken in a meaningful sense.

Re:The real reason for pensions by GVIrish on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:36PM (#6864336)
It is difficult to predict the future but when it comes down to it, most of the time when these pensions go belly up, it is due to significant mismanagement and incompetence.

I think a big failing of government pension funds (and Social Security) is that there is always a tremendous temptation for politicans to borrow against them, and leave the repayment to someone who will be elected after they're long gone. The next person kicks the can down the road, and sooner or later you're Detroit.

With sane and responsible management I'm sure some pensions would fail anyway because there's always the chance of catastrophe. But I've seen enough pension problems that were the result of risky investing, poor forecasting, and irresponsible borrowing that I feel like most of the time the pension needn't have failed or gotten cut.

Re:The real reason for pensions by cma on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:55PM (#6864096)
Make commitments, launder out the money through dividends, renege. (not applicable to cities, etc.)
Re:The real reason for pensions by redwood on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:59PM (#6864437)
What I thought was missing from this article, but insinuated: that Caeser knew: give 'em something so they don't overthrow you.

Well the modern economy is reaching such inequality levels that we're going to have to do something or else it'll be forced, and potentially volatile.

Guaranteed income seems the best plan.

Re:The real reason for pensions by noclip on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:58PM (#6864432)
Re:The real reason for pensions by protomyth on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:44PM (#6864371)
Isn't the problem not so much with the pension, but the amount being paid into the pension fund vs what is scheduled to payout? Underfunding the plan and unreasonable expectations of the amount the fund will earn are commonly sited problems.
Re:The real reason for pensions by dangerboysteve on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:40PM (#6864357)
Re:The real reason for pensions by AndrewDucker on Saturday December 07, 2013 @06:26AM (#6866171)
I am very glad that in the UK all Defined-Benefits pensions have to be insured, so that if the company goes bust people aren't abandoned.