If you had the choice, and had to pay for your decision, how much would you pay to live in the 2000s instead living in the 1900s?
The elderly deserve their pensions. The young get Modern Progress.
The excessive entitlements granted over the last 2 generations is unsustainable. In Spain many baby-boomers have 2X-3X the pension income of a full-time employee. How is that sustainable ??
No, they don't, necessarily. There is a balance to be struck with regard to magnitude and length of pension payments.
2-3x the pension income of a full-timer seems excessive at a glance. That doesn't disprove the existence of a reasonable pension scheme.
Falling populations alone force a requirement for ever higher taxes due to a downward spiral equation on taxes / people / savings / standard of living. The next generation always has to pay more for the last (greater population in the past each cycle), while having less savings and a lower standard of living.
Why do I point that out? Because there's no rule that human life has to get massively better. There is no guarantee. It does not have to happen at all, and I would argue entropy + certain aspects of human nature are constantly acting to undermine the potential for progress to occur.
It's not just that there have been exceptions. Life getting massively better one gen to the next is the extraordinarily rare exception. We definitely shouldn't take it for granted.
BUT the pensions and social security and whatever are premised on the world getting more bitchin' at a high rate. That high rate is gone, but the programs put into place while it was around are still around, and they haven't been adjusted.
I don't mind that we've returned to slow growth instead of rapid, so long as it happens to everyone. That does not seem to be the case re: social security, the housing market, etc and those are largely dictated by government. The Fed (a quasi-government agency) sets the interest rate and thus has a lot of control over housing prices. The Federal Government enacted Social Security and refuses to reform it in any meaningful way.
As a result I'm not optimistic that social cohesion will continue. We're graduating people who can't buy houses or cars or start families at a substantial rate. Loss aversion is a REALLY strong emotionally motivating force for humans as we're wired to avoid losses much more aggressively than pursue gains. But if you don't have much to lose any possibility of gain appealing and that's how you have a revolution.
It's just not true: http://gapminder.org , http://www.gapminder.org/world/
Ultimately neither solution is a good one. This is class warfare at its finest.
Personally I think the social contract of the US is starting to break down, as is societal cohesion. We're all super civilized when we all have good prospects and everyone's life is improving. As the prospects deteriorate so do people's willingness to participate.