Re:The real reason for pensions
by mathattack on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:00PM
(#6865072)
The problem with defined benefit is there are always unknown risks. You can say that the government, or an insurance company will pick up the tab, but what if they fail? If the amount of the benefit is large enough (retirement savings for a generation) it's impossible to guarantee. Small #s yes, large, no. Many intelligent people don't believe a small system like Social Security will hold.
In most countries the backstop is to have a small defined-benefit state pension, so they won't end up literally penniless (in the U.S. this is Social Security, which pays a minimum of ~$9,500/yr). Other countries have tried to move more people into essentially buying annuities to mitigate the varying-lifespan risk. For example most defined-contribution private-sector pensions in Denmark now pay into pension funds (third-party, non-profit organizations) that by default are essentially the purchase of an annuity. You can cash it out as a lump sum upon retirement, but if you do nothing, the default is a traditional monthly pension for life, with the amount dependent on your contribution.