Re:The real reason for pensions
by dragonwriter on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:12PM
(#6864706)
> I'm not talking about social security, I'm talking about pensions.
Social security is a pension.
> To which a 401k or IRA is infinitely preferable.
I dunno, the people who have had 401k's wiped out in various economic collapses might disagree on whether such plans are "infinitely preferable" to defined-benefit pensions.
> But SS has the same problem as pensions: there's nothing to stop future politicians from eliminating it at any time to free up some headroom in the budget.
Well, except voters, which have stopped politicians on several occasions who wanted to make much smaller changes -- which would not even affect current beneficiaries -- to Social Security than eliminating it.
> Perhaps a mandatory 401k everyone must have, contribute to and refrain from using until age 65 would be the best of both worlds?
Well, certainly, it would be one of the best (of the very many!) public subsidies the financial services industry has received. Not sure it would be good for anything beyond that, though.
Social security is a pension.
> To which a 401k or IRA is infinitely preferable.
I dunno, the people who have had 401k's wiped out in various economic collapses might disagree on whether such plans are "infinitely preferable" to defined-benefit pensions.
> But SS has the same problem as pensions: there's nothing to stop future politicians from eliminating it at any time to free up some headroom in the budget.
Well, except voters, which have stopped politicians on several occasions who wanted to make much smaller changes -- which would not even affect current beneficiaries -- to Social Security than eliminating it.
> Perhaps a mandatory 401k everyone must have, contribute to and refrain from using until age 65 would be the best of both worlds?
Well, certainly, it would be one of the best (of the very many!) public subsidies the financial services industry has received. Not sure it would be good for anything beyond that, though.