What is a much bigger opportunity is a way that easily lets groups share music and movies. This cannot be solved by a centralized service like Dropbox for legal reasons. This is what would concern me if I was Dropbox; BTSync's killer feature is off limits to Dropbox without a complete change in architecture (and some soul searching about if they want to risk ending up like Kim Dotcom).
Automation of Google's algorithm thought he was a hacker, they fixed it and he got his account back.
You should have read the whole story ;-)
They only fixed it because he pulled teeth, tapped friends on staff at google and generally had to scream and shout.
In no way was the trek he had to go through to fix an automation problem a good example of "Don't worry about it"
Plus the fact that if it happens to you and you don't have the inside contacts you have no guarantee of getting it fixed.
Just like many people have had their hotmail, paypal, facebook, itunes developer account etc. suspended for automatic detection of breach of TOS, and they've appealed and had their access returned.
This is not so much a google problem, as a reliance on 3rd parties to store your important documents, when everyone is warned (in tiny print) as to what may happen when they sign up.
I'm not excusing google's behavior, it's as bad as the rest of them, but they are playing by the rules we all agree to when we use their services.
Where's the relevance? I asked why is Google, the entity, looking inside of private files?
> a probability of breaking the TOS
And my question was, if the files are private, why should their content be against the TOS?
Also, locking somebody out of their account because of a probability generated by a script, without manual confirmation by a human?
OMG. Some people can lose their jobs or money because of such flukes.
They probably don't want to allow the services to be used to aid illegal activity. Say what you want about how technology should be completely agnostic to matters of culture and legality, but that isn't at all the case.
Rubbish. Dropbox already has people's photos. It's easier and better to tap the screen a few times and share them there.
I have a use case that is pretty common among my peer group and BT Sync has been the best solution I've been able to find. In a nutshell, I need to sync large datasets across multiple computers.
Dropbox: expensive
AeroFS: buggy, used too much bandwidth, and slow
Sparkleshare: uses git which chokes on large files
Git Annex Assistant: didn't work reliably on mac
rsync/duplicity/unison: needs extra logic for detecting file changes
I also think the "Dropbox replacement" idea is a strawman created by the TorrentFreak article. I've never had the impression that BT Sync is trying to replace Dropbox. It is just trying to do p2p sync with a great interface and some nice features such as read-only and one-time secrets.
The biggest problem I personally have with Dropbbox et. al, is that none of the commercial solutions sync symbolic links opaquely. ("Opaque" syncing of symlinks means to sync the links themselves and not what the symlinks link to.) I use symlinks heavily and so I absolutely require this feature. Most of the commercial solutions just ignore symlinks, but Dropbox does the worst thing possible and treats symlinks transparently. This is utterly wrong and, in fact, downright dangerous!
Another feature that I need for telecommuting software development is to be able to exclude artifacts from what is synced. Eclipse, for instance, constantly churns out artifacts, and I certainly don't want or need those artifacts to be synced.
Two problems with my roll-your-own little syncing system remain: (1) The large file issue that you mentioned. (Sparkleshare is much worse in this regard than my system, last I tried.) (2) I know of no way to have the Git instance that I use for syncing not pay attention to the .gitignore files that are used by the Git instance that I use for version control. Annoying!
In any case, I'm very glad to hear that BitTorrent seems to be coming up with a solution that will address all my issues, and I won't have to roll my own anymore.
It is kinda lame that other services, e.g. Google Drive, just skip symlinks, but that isn't as dangerous. The hierarchical structure of a directory tree is often effectively part of an application's data, and Dropbox silently corrupts that data. This can cause crashes, or multiple conflicting copies of not-easily-merged data to be strewn about in different places.
It's also hard to initially notice how broken it is, since symlinks work on the first machine where Dropbox encounters them, but then on all subsequent client devices that Dropbox sees are replaced with some version of whatever data they point to.
What's even worse, is that no matter how hard I try, I am not able to convince most people of how wrong this is--even those who claim to be and should be computer savy. E.g., on support forums for other sync services, users are typically clamoring for Dropbox-style syncing of symlinks, and they will not be convinced otherwise, in spite of all reason. And despite 30 years of hard-earned experience with symlinks that irrefutably demonstrates that transparent syncing of symlinks is nothing but badness.
But thank goodness that BitTorrent got it right!
This correct solution is precisely what BitTorrent Sync provides. So that's all the more reason to be thankful that a seemingly excellent sync solution has finally arrived.
http://help.cubby.com/forums/169907-general/suggestions/3529...
What if you treat DropBox as a raw, strict hierarchical store and never use it directly, but only link into it from elsewhere? Move all the links outside of it.
ln ~/Dropbox/photos ~/Photos
ln ~/Dropbox/family/baby/cute-movies ~/Photos/baby-cute-movies
etc.(2) Your suggestion is extremely difficult or impossible to do in the general case.
(3) I have better things to do with my life than rearrange my entire filesystem to suit the ill-conceived whims of a product that does the wrong thing.
(4) I would like to sync parts of my filesystem as they currently are.
(5) I have my own syncing solution that works better for my needs, and it only took me a couple of hours to throw together.
(6) I'm going to use BitTorrent Sync in the future for most of my syncing needs (as long as it turns out to be reliable) since it does syncing properly in the face of symlinks.
(7) I'll still use Dropbox for simple sharing of files with friends and getting files onto my iPad. Apparently, Dropbox just doesn't care about the needs of more sophisticated users, as that isn't a very large market.
The tradeoff is to have all your stuff in one place, with is not a good thing most of the time IMO. A frequent problem I stumble on: there is a work folder where everything is already on svn/git, but I'd want to temporarily sync a few folders to dropbox only when needed, and get them out of dropbox when finished. As dropbox works now, to do this without using symlinks would be a PITA (I'd have to put all my files in the dropbox folder by default, and then play with the selective sync ? I am not even sure there is a way to do it without moving files around).
If dropbox had support for arbitrary multiple folder selection (but the the complexity would go way up?) I'd agree with your stance on symlink, but now this is more of a necessary evil.
I think you already answered your own objection on the right way to handle this need. Other syncing services, including BitTorrent Sync handle your need in precisely this manner. I.e., the right way. Dangerous, frustrating, and incorrect abuse of symlinks is NOT the right way to do this.
I was curious about this myself, but I never tried it, as I feared that this was precisely the badness that would occur.
Dropbox is so good in so many respects, I just can't understand how they could have made such an utterly terrible and wrong decision on this particular issue.
Is it so difficult to add a one line configuration item to your inotify cron daemon (incrond) ?
/home/my/directory IN_CLOSE_WRITE,IN_CREATE,IN_DELETE /my/unison/sync/script.sh
It works.
Why is this a problem with Flickr? I am generally shooting high res full frame, and post to Flickr. I have about a terabyte of images. There's no 100GB storage limit, just an annual flat fee.
Family can download full resolution images for printing. My grandmother can have my Flickr Photo Stream as a screensaver in her TV. I also enjoy fantastic two way integration with photo management tools, with tagging syncing back.
I can't see why I'd pay Dropbox considerably more for less features.
(What's more, if Flickr doesn't like a public photo's content, the worst that will happen is getting marked "not in public search areas", with an easy redress to get reinstated. It's unclear to me what Dropbox will do. Meanwhile, if Google doesn't like a public photo, I can lose my Google Account, as photogs have found to their chagrin.)
Which photo management tools do you use? I currently have around 45k photos (~200GB) and Picasa is sometimes just too slow. I am planning to get a DSLR soon, so total size is going to be expanding rapidly. What kind of tools would you suggest? I am on Windows mainly, so Mac-only is not an option. Thanks!
Some detail for you:
I use Aperture for most photos. I use Lightroom for slides. On the PC side, you should use Lightroom. It's just gone into beta for version 5, try it now for free.
I strongly prefer the Aperture workflow, but for slides Aperture won't recognize my 64 bit .DNG files with infrared channel as being part of a JPEG/RAW pair, while Lightroom will.
I manage photos on the latest Mac Mini with the Fusion Drive, but the photo libraries are actually stored on Western Digital MyBook Velociraptor Duo Thunderbolt drives[1] which are insanely fast in RAID0 mode. With Thunderbolt I can attach that to a laptop or the Mac Mini and Aperture is licensed for 5 computers. I had been using the built in Fusion drive for my latest project triage, but the Velociraptor drives in RAID0 are so fast it's not worth the hassle of splitting that out.
I use a nightly rsync to replicate the libraries onto a LaCie 4big via Firewire 800. I never have less than two copies of photos on two devices, because I use a Nexto DI[2] to import the photos from flash while on the go, then I import from that into my libraries, leaving copies on it until I need space. Or, for things like iPhone imports, I import to the LaCie RAID, then import into Aperture's RAID0 library for speed, and again, only delete from the RAIDs when I need space and after I know Aperture's backed up. I also have a Backblaze[5] job backing up everything offsite for their flat fee.
I have three libraries, one for 2000-2010, one for the current decade, and one for international travel. While travel is less frequent, a trip generates more photos, so my domestic and international libraries tend to be similar in size. Each is 50K to 150K photos, and in the 350GB - 750GB range.
I use Aperture's library in the fully imported mode, where photos are stored in the library. This way I'll never accidentally move or delete a photo I want to keep. Of course, the library is just a package folder, you can CTRL-Click it to open it up and get at any of your import sessions original or raw files. Even if the DB is completely destroyed, the photos are safe.
I use the incredible Nik Collection of plugins. They were worth it at $750, and so much more worth it at Google's new price of $149[3]. These plugins work with Lightroom or Photoshop as well.
With over a decade of DSLR photos under management, I recommend you use a folder and image naming scheme like this:
yyyy
yyyy-mm-dd event descriptor
Event Descriptor (nnn).ext
If I'm using generic file system tools rather than a true photo management app, I name the file in a way that lets me search, sort, and reconstruct the original file, regardless of file system capabilities: yyyy-mm-dd hh.mm.ss event descriptor nnn (ORIGINAL-FILENAME).ext
Moving images around across file systems will likely eventually lose the date, with this you can use a simple shell script to put back the create time. Or use ExifTool to get the data back from inside the file[4].---
Links referenced:
1. http://www.storagereview.com/western_digital_my_book_velocir...
2. http://www.amazon.com/Nexto-Digital-Photo-Storage-ND2730/dp/...
3. http://www.niksoftware.com/
http://ipont.jubilo.ca/ip/flickstackr/
http://connectedflow.com/flickrexport/
I like Everpix too, fun to see what it comes up with for its "moments". Cool idea.
I am a musician and want to sync my tracks with a few producers. Bt sync is a good solution.
I am a political activist and want to ensure my data will be available to my affinity group even if Dropbox is threatened with a state security letter. Bt sync is an excellent solution.
I think it will need more cute cats before you can make that call.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cute_cat_theory_of_digital_acti...
If they gained access to the sync group with full permissions they could destroy it and get IP addresses, etc. And the format itself might not lend itself to all the needs of a political activist group. But I don't see how the cute cat theory holds any water here.
Many ISPs, schools, cafes and corporate networks do this today already. They only allow HTTP (which goes through monitoring) and HTTPS which is decrypted by a MITM proxy (you have to allow their CA cert on your machine, uncompromised HTTPS is blocked).
In many countries this type of shenanigans are forbidden by law (friendly governments exist too).
I wasn't trying to argue that it was technically infeasible for an Orwellian government to stop it, just that it would be near impossible to stop where this type of traffic isn't already blocked.
It has to work before it can work well. Thus, while PGP technically works great, I haven't heard a lot of Egyptions, Syrians, etc, lauding Phil Zimmerman. Instead, they seem happier with Facebook.
If one member of your affinity group gets arrested, the police would have access to all of your files plus all of the IP addresses of everyone in your affinity group
IP addresses = VPN
Files = Truecrypted
Business scenarios make this good for us, but for consumers this isn't a Dropbox alternative.
a) I use my picassa photo albums for big dumps of regular photos I take when out and about, the storage is big enough I don't have to pay anything (yet) and I have thousands upon thousands of photos there
b) I use my flickr account (paid so unlimited) to put up photos I've curated and cleaned up and processed and stuck on a map someplace and given a detailed description of...basically I use it as a detailed travelog of places I've been. I'm about 4 years behind on it to be honest, but the flickr uploadr let's me bulk upload and getting things into the account currently isn't the bottleneck in my proces
Dropbox for privacy minded people if you will.
Cloud sync leads to storage limits (which don't make sense as a consumer for file sync, but are necessary for large scale cloud sync) and centralisation (desirable for vast access, not so much for some situations).
BT sync isn't a Dropbox replacement, it's a file sync replacement that's superior in some ways, but lacks the benefits of being combined with cloud sync.
BT sync sounds like a complete replacement for dropbox for people with the skills and willingness to set it up.
Also, I often share individual files by using the "Get a public link" feature in Dropbox, and it's comforting to know they can just access those files whenever they want no matter what devices are attached and syncing.
Personally, I use cloud sync for a lot of backup stuff. Granted, it's mostly Git to BitBucket, but in school I used to push documents to Dropbox or Box just to have a backup. I wasn't interested in having my essays synced to my phone, just that if my other versions died I could download my work again to another device.
If you're referring to companies though, no I doubt they'd want a seamless and perfect system in somebody else's data center. That said, a data center and a perfect seamless cloud backup solution is a considerable cost, especially for a startup.
But yep, I agree, BT sync would be perfect if you didn't want/need Dropbox remote backups or web services.
Additionally, I wouldn't be able to get access to my files when I was at my parents without my laptop - which I can do with Dropbox.
Uhm... how about the 200 GB plan? Or the 400 GB plan. Or 1 TB for $49.99/month? Or you could contact sales about Google Cloud Storage: https://cloud.google.com/pricing/cloud-storage Or you could just buy S3 storage.
Actually, there are literally dozens (to maybe even hundreds) of alternatives for hosting static content for less money for more bandwidth.
Google+ does that too now, but this is in fact a killer feature which has been adopted well by the average folks out there. So yes, Dropbox is not just about file sharing anymore.
Though, I believe the use case GP is describing might be a bit different, depending on whether or not a dedicated camera is being used and how large the image files are...
I agree with you that this is a very important consideration: Sync services (even Dropbox) are not backup services and shouldn't be treated like they are. You are in an even worse predicament if you are using it to sync everything locally.
I particularly like BT Sync that it doesn't require "account" to use.
On the other side of the argument, I bet BitTorrent Sync will become as friendly as Dropbox, and perhaps third-party backup services will offer what Dropbox does. At that point, rsync's only advantage would be an open-source license.
It seems to overcome NAT and dynamic addressing very well. All you need is to distribute the small shared secret once (for example, offline via USB, paper, or via the first letter of every headline in consecutive college newspaper publications), and you have the ability to transfer files (and do anything that can be boiled down to that; ex: chat, perform backups, publish videos of cats among your friends, distribute mostly static data between front-facing servers, etc...) without further coordination (for example, constantly renewing a DNS record, overcoming NAT, and keeping SSH or FTP permissions in order). Sure it may not be the best experience for all use-cases from a UX standpoint, but it is very general and, being serverless, it is better from other perspectives. I'm not boxing with you, only responding to your "?" and advocating for more such software.
That'd cost you $9.50/month just for the storage, bandwidth and transfer costs are a bit hard to predict - storing your mostly-write-only archives are different from your mostly-read-only mp3 collection or your pirate-bay-sourced movie collection collection.
I'm quite excited by this - I've been planning-but-not-doing-anything-about a cluster of inexpensive processors (probably RaspberryPi's or TPLink WR703-Ns) running Tahoe/LAFS. If this busts through NATed internet connections like I suspect it will, I'll probably give up on that plan and just install a bunch of copies of this in various places.
I need a solution for on the order of 40,000... for which Flickr is perfect, since there is no storage limit, just a very small flat fee.
I have approx' 40k photos (not including the .raw files) over about 180GB (including the .raw files).
For example, a micro instance, with 500GB of EBS storage, with allowance for 1% data growth per daily snapshot (S3 backed), and 50GB of transfer per month will apparently cost $175.68.
The 500GB plan from Dropbox will cost you $499 .
I'm thinking, with enough data, Bittorrent Sync wins the pricing war, and I've been doing some testing on the client and it seems really resilient to data changing while syncing etc.
It's nice to be able to rollback/undelete files. Plus everyone is forgetting that Dropbox snagged Audiogalaxy a while back, so I'm expecting to be able to stream music back to myself from my Dropbox at some point as a service.
I just moved a bunch of stuff to btsync to mess with it but I still need to find a place offsite to keep it in addition if I want it to replace Dropbox. I'll likely use both tools in combination.
I guess the marketing is to provide them with a nice level of deniability. It's not a Dropbox competitor, it's just encrypted folder sharing.
This service would mostly be used by us who are wary about trusting Google/Microsoft/Dropbox and the judgement of their automated decision systems with our life . Yesterday there was a HN story about a guy who got kicked off Google Docs because an automated program was trolling/mining through their users files and its judgement was not to be questioned by mere mortals.
What if I put a picture of me and my kid playing in the swimming pool -- what is to prevent Dropbox/Google/Skydrive from tagging it as offensive and setting an overzealous DA or social-worker upon my family ? People have been arrested/detained at border crossings for perfectly innocuous pictures like these.
Therefore if you think privacy is only important for people stealing stuff, your are being naive.
> Yesterday there was a HN story about a guy who got
> kicked off Google Docs because an automated program was
> trolling/mining through their users files and its
> judgement was not to be questioned by mere mortals.
Wasn't that the user who was using a Docs form/spreadsheet to collect passwords from his customers? Google has stated that such forms are reviewed manually after being reported (for example, http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/docs/7pKj6aXBK...), which means there must have been at least two humans involved.IMO the risk with cloud storage isn't in getting suspended by some daemon run amok, it's in data being too easy to leak. Files stored in Google Drive or Dropbox are just one accidental "share" click away from becoming public.
The link you submitted was a genuine scammer issue which was reported by users and dealt with correctly by Google.
The link in my post is just a citation as evidence that account suspension is a manual process.
I created the file.. added a few forum links with user/pass combos.. and within about 48 hours, the file was nuked and I had an email from google stating a document I had put on google docs broke their terms of service.
I went through the terms of service and couldn't find anything regarding passwords, but it did say that anything I put in google docs was owned by google and publishable by google, so I guessed that was the reason (they can't publish passwords?)
edit: I didn't get kicked off of google docs altogether though, just the one file got nuked
http://wmpoweruser.com/watch-what-you-store-on-skydriveyou-m...
[1] http://tonyonsecurity.com/2012/08/05/securing-your-data-on-d...
The bike is made by a gent named Robin Mather who lives in the South West of England. His website is unfortunately a poor one, but he's got coverage elsewhere: http://apracticalguide.wordpress.com/ http://www.bespoked2012.co.uk/BespokedBristol/Robin_Mather.h... http://www.headsetpress.co.uk/features/robin-mather-building...
The stem is a fully bespoke (the whole bike is) ahead stem. It uses a barrel with a 6mm allen bolt through it. The barrel is split in two and the bolt squeezes the two halves to give a large contact area with the stem. It's worked well, no complaints.
One of the goals of that bike was to design it such that it looked aesthetically clean of bolts, fixings and braze-ons.
An example of that is the rear rack... remove the rack and mudguard and there is clearance for cyclocross tyres, and there are no braze-ons that give even a hint that the frame can take racks.
I was going for a single multi-purpose frame (touring, cyclocross, urban-fixed) by simply changing wheelsets and basic things... any change should be a 10 minute job. But yet, even with multiple uses I did not want to compromise the looks to achieve it.
The photos show the bike in the most complex configuration, the Rohloff hub, the dynamo front hub, the racks, the mudguards, the flat handlebars with Rohloff shifter. But basically you can strip it to a fixed gear bike with belt drive and just a front brake in 10 minutes, and then shove it in a suitcase (S&S couplers) and go travelling with it.
And even with all of that... the bike may be custom, but I kept everything compatible with standard parts so it's easy to get a long life from the bike as parts will be available. That stem... well, any stem can go on there.
Robin's a cool guy too. Which helps when you go this crazy on spec'ing a bike.
Good to know Dropbox can host some of the steamiest bike porn I've ever seen.
It still looks like an interesting product, mind you...
One example: I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. I moved from Flickr to Picasa as it could cope with the directories full of photos and I didn't have to manually upload them and Google's storage space was cheaper. Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where next?
Hello Dropbox: https://www.dropbox.com/sc/um5zf95urdk3zmg/2SaSCUIQd8
And I've told a few photographers about this, and a few weeks later a friend of a friend of a friend excitedly told me on a forum how you can photo share in Dropbox.
And what I'm basically seeing is that the problem of "file sync" is being considered as solved by lay consumers, who really aren't prioritising encryption, and the problems that they now have is "share this directory of photos", and "share that directory of videos", and "sync this music privately, but let me play it back".
Dropbox isn't just file sync anymore.
What it is, is a serious threat to Flickr, Picasa, YouTube, Amazon MP3 Locker, Google Play Music, iTunes, etc.
And consumers are not thinking in terms of encrypted sync, they're just thinking in terms of "I just want to do X, why is it so hard", and so I can't see this (very nice) solution really solving the problems that consumers have, that will make them prioritise security.