People were illegally parking but because they had a city agency issued placard on their dashboard, it was a get out of jail free card.
Similar loophole was states like NJ having a temporary tag issuance fraud issue, such that people were driving around NYC with paper tags from out of state continuously.
And hopefully that will keep those people nice and busy because they're a pox upon any subject they direct their attention at.
Nope, it doesn't hold, because it's not a principle but a proof under very specific conditions.
> It seems to be impossible to write a law without loopholes, without leaning on “I know it when I see it”, which is another kind of loophole.
That's not a loophole, that's what legislators are for, "when we see it" they're supposed to close it. Most importantly, closing a loophole with another statue is always possible, so in a properly working systems all loopholes will be closed as experience accumulates.
Another major mistake of yours is to go from "I doubt all loopholes can be closed" to "forget about loopholes". It's like, if you get robbed one day, you go like, robbery is impossible to deal with, so let it proliferate without restraint or even concern.
> And each example or definition you add to what a law should and shouldn’t cover adds two more edge cases (“does this bizarre situation meet that criteria? Does this common situation somehow not meet it?”).
That's like saying "the law is worthless" because you can make the same argument for every statue. However, legislation can be written in a clean way unless you give up on it - you shouldn't be so quick to do that.
There is widespread usage of language which draws a very significant difference between being guilty of a crime and being punished for it. Attempts to establish the notion that legal means whatever you can get away with are just going to be met with confusion.
Well, this is a mischaracterization of my statement.
My statement is more “legal is whatever you will not get charged with”, e.g. possessing marijuana, using sex toys, practicing sodomy, etc.
Evading arrest was not covered under my statement, despite your framing.
These are the limitations of language, indeed.
I asked the manager, do you need me to call the fire department for you? He said "you can make a call if you want, but we don't know who it is. I told the receipt checker to let me know when they come out so I can talk to them."
I called the fire department, they said they don't dispatch for this and to call the police. I called the police, they said since Costco parking lot is private property they won't come out unless it's a handicapped violation. I said even though they're blocking the fire lane? They said yes, the proper thing would be for Costco to call a tow truck and it would be at the owner's expense.
So I guess the guy was right, rules are only for those who have shame, if you're shameless you get special privileges like parking in the fire lane because you're huge truck is hard to find a parking spot for, and there's no consequences.
I've also seen on a near weekly basis now people bringing a dog that is clearly not a service animal (from its behavior) into the grocery store.
I'm reminded of George Costanza saying "We live in a SOCIETY!" or the entire Curb Your Enthusiasm show.
What to do? Accept the fact that terrible people get special privileges now that normal people don't, and just live with it? Become a bad person myself so I get the privileges? I can't decide, but I really don't like this timeline we're in. For some reason, very very ugly people have decided they don't have to be ashamed about their terrible behavior anymore. And I guess it's too much trouble for Costco OR THE POLICE to even do anything about. I know there are terrible people everywhere but the lack of consideration for others here in the USA is really reaching new heights all the time. It sucks.
Anyone got any suggestions? I don't want to become a bad person myself, but these events are starting to happen so often I feel like a sucker for not taking advantage. :(
For me, I think of them like mosquitos. Even in beautiful places that are otherwise divine, you occasionally have to deal with an annoying mosquito. For me, the big annoying mosquitos are private equity, cars in general (with hugeass trucks being a particularly annoying subset), one political party in particular, and social media/AI/the internet.
But it is important to keep in mind that if you go to a beautiful place, don't just think about the mosquitos. Extending the analogy, don't just think about mosquitos especially when there are people dying of malaria out there.
You could have probably called their tow company and told them you're with Costco and want the truck towed (hey, you're a costco member, a real loophole).
Then told Costco staff that a tow company had been called on their behalf.
Truck would've probably been towed.
It’s not a great loophole per se but it’s a flawless example of what I might call “loophole thinking” which is kind of a transition from individualism to selfishness that has been happening for a long time (maybe there was never much of a difference)?
Where do conformity and a shared set of behaviours split? Don't we conform to norms so that we can achieve maxima greater than the individual? Is it just the negative connotations of that word? What if we replace "conformity" with "consistency"?
So yes, the word has a negative connotation to me. Bending yourself, to conform with something you do not want. I seldom heard it as "conform with basic human rights" for instance.
The kind of conformity that’s unthinking or mindless can be at odds with empathy and generosity and virtue, sure. The “computer says no” school of blindly following the rules all the way to a perverse outcome.
In the same way, though, unthinking or mindless iconoclasm-for-its-own-sake tends to lead to perverse results.
Whereas unselfishness can often lead people to considered conformity with mildly annoying expectations—like leaving the disabled parking spot free even if there’s no disabled person currently using it—to solve coordination problems cooperatively.
Not a virtue, more of a tactic—but social norms can provide an awfully low-cost, high-signal means of coordinating and operationalizing virtuous intentions, no?
The counterpoint being, I think, that conformity can offer a decent default course to people when they’re new to any given nuanced social problem, or with limited vantage on the full consequences.
I don’t know, or want to know, why they don’t want a vehicle parked in this particular place between 7 and 11 AM on a Thursday. I could inquire further, and learn either that something legit happens then, or that it is in fact a pointless/outdated rule that I could reasonably ignore.
But if I don’t care—and I don’t—I can go with the default and be reasonably confident I’m not accidentally being an asshole.
It's pretty common though, that there's a disconnect between the laws and the government, and the government does not actually enforce the laws evenly.
Extreme levels of conformity (or non-conformity) is pretty obnoxious. That said, conformity is the oil that makes a whole lot of society function.
For example, conforming to social norms around queueing at a store checkout prevents a lot of friction between yourself and other customers, and that allows cashiers to proceed smoothly
I dunno. I'd argue that some amount of conformity is absolutely a virtue. No one wants to deal with the assholes on transit who bring a wireless speaker to blast their music
Quite similarly to the anecdote at start of link, there was a guy in my condo parking directly in front of the building for a while collecting tickets. Even if he got caught every time, the tickets are same prices as paying for a garage.. and he probably only got caught 1/4 of the time. Plus, parking directly at your front door is maximal convenience compared to some garage down the block.
Why doesn't everyone just do the same - well theres 200 residents and 1 front door. And the car illegally parked blocks the street sweepers, leaving the block you live on dirtier. Tragedy of the commons stuff.
Just one small infraction in a sea of bad behavior that accumulates & makes people feel like stupid chumps for actually following the laws. Very "this is how you get a low trust society" coded.
Doesn't that mean the penalty (ticket) is too cheap or the garage is too expensive?
Like corporations paying fines as the cost of doing business.
For example, if you park badly, civil parking enforcement officers patrol the streets.
...but if you park directly on a _pedestrian crossing_, in some jurisdictions that's now a criminal offence, so only the police can prosecute it, not the civil parking enforcers. But the police have better things to do than enforce parking. So you raise the stakes significantly but you're also more likely to get away with it. Double or quits. It goes without saying that you're being an enormous arsehole.
The crux of the problem (aside from arseholes existing), is the inverse correlation - the worse an infraction is, the less it gets punished, because of the increased scrutiny and limits on who can prosecute as the severity of infraction increases.
I've heard "fudged the numbers" for when it's not a big deal (as opposed to "cooked the books" for when it is). But that's only for financial matters.
That is an example of the extra-legal punishment I mentioned. I was suggesting it could apply to any extra-legal result, not just punishment. (my income tax example),