Speculation on my part, they just rolled out their SMART air traffic routing system. https://www.flyingmag.com/faa-smart-ai-now-active-at-22-artc...
Bet the increased strain on data polling from this system is the culprit for increased traffic.
It is possible that this overwhelming was caused by a software or configuration error, no doubt.
I think that if that's the case, rather than failing upwards and going for a full simultaneous upgrade with a 50B congress bill, the brakes should be stepped on a little bit, continue the partial migration as long as there are no issues. Or at least wait until the start of a 4year administration to go for a rehaul, so that you can stay around if things go fubar.
Transportation secretary Duffy says that the smart system is unrelated. That the smart system is a dashboard for displaying all the data from across the air traffic system. My questions is obviously where is the smart system getting its data from...
I suspect FAA pushed for the new AI system, didnt take into account the increased traffic demand to feed the system. Aging infra isnt sufficient to handle the increased demand. Now Duffy is trying to deflect blame unto someone else.
Should be an easy answer. We saw increased traffic from X and we've implemented Y to ensure it doesn't happen again.
Instead it was vague hand waving around old hardware and funding.
Even if they don't have all the details organized, what was done to fix the problem? How was the 12b spent thus far and what where does the additional 50b number come from?
Or maybe don't start with demanding money. What happened? How was it fixed? What is being done to ensure it doesn't happen again? Then mention this shit needs fixed and we'll be working with Congress for additional funding.
It was interesting that Mullen mention new technology contributing at one point. Sounds like someone made a mistake somewhere and this press conference was purposefully vague or they really don't understand what happened yet (doubtful).
Plenty of critical systems operate reliably on old tech as long as you work within the limitations.
This press conference had maybe 30s of actual info and the rest was this antiquated system is fucked even though it's been working for years and the only way to move forward is $50b. :shrug:
They did hurriedly mention it was "new patches" in the midst of their deranged ranting and finger-pointing (at...their own party, a point Duffy was visibly taken aback by when told by a reporter). When they vehemently insisted it was 'not SMART' one has to presume they meant that the hasty execution of their haphazard AI rollout was performed unintelligently.
> old system give us money
> probably not a cyberattack btw
> not SMART related
> we've opened the airspace but this is gonna be slow
just ended actually as i was typing this, that's pretty much it
They didn't.
I expect it to be a combination of extremely poorly funded and sidelined IT infrastructure trying to use a bloated AI system from a hype company. Which results in everything breaking and poor schmucks already at the end of their rope working to fix something they barely understand.
It doesn't take a genius to see the problem is the new AI system. Whether or it's the "AI" part of the system isn't really relevant system this new system was vibe-coded by AI and built around the "AI" features.
And the actual culprit was telecommunications related...
Highly doubt this. Unless you mean sort of like education in many areas where the system is robustly funded but the money doesn't actually reach the people doing the work on the ground.
Yeah of course I mean this, I mean the guy who had to serial connect to whatever shit show was running and was sitting there trying to parse error logs.
FAA has been doing this for decades. A single electronics box, or even a couple should not drop the system. Maybe for the time it takes to remove and replace.
After hearing the press conference "some new stuff was plugged in and the legacy system could not handle it" or alternatively 'a mistake was made that just so happens involved non today equipment, but we want more money'
Do you really need the government to solve that problem for you? Just book another flight.
It's possible this is the standard "privatize a government function and skim the profits" move but some of this stinks of union busting and trying to reduce the amount of influence air traffic controllers have whenever the organized criminals that run our government want to have a shutdown but keep their private jets flying.
Suffice it to say - there's no reason to trust any of these people when it comes to taking care of critical government functions.
Not sure if this was the the exact quote, but I see AP wrote, "introduction of some new technology into an old air traffic control system overwhelmed it." Despite that, the whole conference, on loop, they were insisting that the problem is entirely the old hardware and this is why they need billions to overhaul it and rebuild from scratch.
But my completely unfounded and more conspiratorial theory, based on zero knowledge of air traffic control systems, is that to better accommodate SMART, L3Harris was strong-armed into to rolling out a hastily written patch on a Friday, which accidentally took down the system.
The secretary also mentioned that the new system should be brought altogether, and not piece by piece. Which would lend credence to an incompatibility between both systems.
What am I missing?
As a postmortem, once the dust has settled, is the time to ask for more funding/support
Is it more likely that decades old hardware failed coincidentally or that the first rollout of a new tech went wrong within a number of hours because the test environment didn't have sufficiently scaled load testing?
https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2026-09/M...
The Senate will be in session for four more days next week before the Thanksgiving holiday, and then back for the first three weeks of December before the 119th Congress adjourns for good on Dec 18th.
So basically, after two full years with control of both branches of Congress and the WH, this bill was introduced on the very last week of the regular Congress calendar. After which the lame duck Congress would only meet for about four weeks until adjournment.
Not really stalled, more like procrastinated until days before the election, hoping that the lame duck Congress (notoriously unproductive period generally) would force it through in a rush? Doesn't seem like a great strategy if they actually wanted it to pass.
Maybe things are moving fast today and they didn't have time to understand and communicate accurately, but at some point soon I think we deserve a more in depth explanation.
It's farfetched, but if it's true, pretty sure I'm the first to posit it. If it ends up being that, feel free to write to me for more info or an interview on how I knew.
LAX hasn't restarted yet. Departures are either "Cancelled" or "Delayed".
All information about this is from PR teams. Nothing from reporters who cover airports. Nobody from airport management, airline operations, FAA operations people, or somebody who just got off shift at a control tower. People who might actually know something. There was a briefing at the White House, and it was all cabinet secretaries. "Instead of reassuring an anxious public, and providing concrete information, this briefing appears to be intended for President Trump’s approval" wrote a New York Times reporter.
FAA policy prohibits anybody but PR people talking to the public. The details of that policy are not public.[2]
[1] https://www.ops.group/blog
[2] https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/orders_notices/inde...