News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by derektank on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:23PM (#50227276)
>Regular people do not have more more money or time

Of course they do. Median real weekly wages[1] have been rising for decades all while the average number of hours worked per worker have fallen[2].

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/les1252881600Q

[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/avhwpeusa065nrug

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by darth_avocado on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:28PM (#50227315)
Meanwhile household basics increased faster than wages. In other words people don’t have more money.

https://www.unitedforalice.org/essentials-index

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by manlymuppet on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:50PM (#50227458)
This is research from a labor advocacy group, with the explicit aim of the organization to advocate for this sort of thing. This doesn't mean the research is is automatically invalid, but it is bias worth mentioning.

Looking at an article from the CATO institute, over the last 30 years wages have climbed 169 percent, while food prices 111 percent.

But an even better measure is PCE, or personal consumption index. Rather than CPI, or any other "household basics" measure, which subjectively categorize goods and then tracks those, PCE measures the total dollar amount spent by the entire U.S. consumer sector on goods and services. This is what is used by the FRED database referenced in the reply above.

https://www.cato.org/commentary/why-dire-pronouncements-abou...

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by vlovich123 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:01PM (#50227529)
I feel like people complain about “food” but it’s a stand-in and that the cumulative increase in rent, transportation and food probably rose faster than wages. So Cato reply “but food hasn’t grown as fast as wages” is a myopic retort (admittedly one they acknowledge) that tries to fight the narrow factual argument ignoring the broader one where the emotional narrative probably remains true.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:39PM (#50227756)
Also we can probably simplify this bucket even more and just talk about the elephant in the room which is rent/mortgage.

It’s 30 to 50% of most peoples paycheck, it’s really the piece that matters and the one that is most complicated to solve.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by socalgal2 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:17AM (#50228276)
That’s another bad metric without more nuance. if I used to pay 30% and now pay 50% but the remaining 50% buys 2x what it used to then overall I’m still doing better

I’m not saying that’s the case. I’m only saying the metric “housing cost as percent of wages” isn’t enough to judge if people are doing worse or better

To take just one example: a 65inch tv costs just $700 compared to $4k just a few years ago

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by ethersteeds on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:31AM (#50228618)
You are right, I'll just eat a 65 inch TV and live in the box.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by infinite_spin on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:04PM (#50227884)
a friend showed me their budget recently, and about 45 hours of their wages go to rent each month (for a single room in a house with roommates). That seems very high to me, and their rent is considered "low" in their area (a small suburb)
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by zdragnar on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:55PM (#50228156)
Assuming they work full time, that is pretty average. The old "30%" rule is that you should spend no more than 30% of your pre-tax wages on rent. Your friend is spending just over a quarter post-taxes.
[dead]
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Barbing on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:19AM (#50228560)
Hobbies can help avoid thinking about religion when it’s not on anyone’s mind!
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by infinite_spin on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:15PM (#50234374)
Something about this still seems to be imbalanced.. and 45/160 is 28%, just below this threshold you've referenced. My intuition says something is wrong here.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by zdragnar on Monday October 26, 2026 @12:51AM (#50239275)
Either I missed or was added in an edit the bit about having roommates. That's definitely absurd. I was paying that amount for an entire house in a nice suburb maybe 8 or 9 years ago. Even with only one roommate paying the same amount, they are together paying way more than my mortgage for a house in the country with 5 acres of land and waterfront along one entire side.

I imagine they're in a high cost of living area, where tons of other people want to live. If that's the case, it probably shouldn't be any surprise that in a supply restricted market, the prices are also very high.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by infinite_spin on Monday October 26, 2026 @05:31PM (#50251298)
yeah, I honestly just feel bad for him. I have it easier, but he's going to school, working, holding down a leadership position in an engineering club. He's living his best life, so I can't feel too bad, but he deserves a break from the cost of living.

*edit: they're not in a _high_ cost living area, but it's not cheap either.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by SirMaster on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:25AM (#50228857)
That seems high. 14 hours of my salary (pretax) goes to my rent.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by WalterBright on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:40PM (#50228072)
The government heavily interferes in the housing industry. Hence, the higher costs. It's the same for everything the government interferes with - such as education and health care.

For examples:

1. there are 57,000 unoccupied apartments in NYC because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out.

2. the glacial pace of issuing building permits for burned out homes in LA.

3. the sudden influx of many millions of immigrants pushes up the demand for housing, resulting in higher prices

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Timon3 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:56PM (#50228170)
I genuinely cannot understand how anyone with basic knowledge of economics could believe that government intervention is responsible for all unoccupied apartments in a market.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by WalterBright on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:14AM (#50228263)
That's because you inserted the word "all" which was quite absent from what I wrote.

Please try again.

P.S. google "how many unoccupied apartments in nyc"

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:05AM (#50228207)
> all unoccupied apartments in a market

Which market are you thinking of?

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Timon3 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:16AM (#50228267)
Let's assume I'm talking about the same market as the person I responded to.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:38AM (#50228378)
> the same market as the person I responded to

Los Angeles? Where the homeowner vacancy rate is 0.7% and rental vacancy 4%?

If you literally weren't thinking of anywhere when your responded, where did you get the notion from?

[1] https://api.census.gov/data/missing_key.html +/- one percent

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by socalgal2 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:25AM (#50228309)
I genuinely can not understand how anyone with basic knowledge of economics could believe that government intervention is not responsible for the majority of rent price increases

The market, left to its own, will keep building because someone will see the prices people are willing to pay and think “I want in on that” but then the government comes in and blocks them from building. No building = supply lower than demand which always equals higher costs

Further, It would only have taken you one 5 second search to see the ways government regulations can cause unoccupied apartments

https://www.google.com/search?q=in+what+ways+can+government+...

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by 0c3ca83 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:08AM (#50228784)
> there are 57,000 unoccupied apartments in NYC

That's about 2.4% of the total number of rented apartments, and about 1.5% of the total housing stock.

How long do you think those apartments are unoccupied, on average?

What portion of the stock do you think would normally be healthy to have on the market?

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by WalterBright on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:39AM (#50228918)
google prompt: "how many unoccupied apartments in nyc"

Scroll down a bit and read the section: "Key Causes of Vacancies"

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by 0c3ca83 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @10:04AM (#50231714)
Google tells me that this number includes units on the market between tenants. I would quite like there to be a nonzero number of units available for rent if I move.

What's a healthy vacancy rate in your opinion, and what do you make of NYC having a lower rate than the average American city?

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by cucumber3732842 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @07:05PM (#50236927)
Prices are set at the margin.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by throwaway2037 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:37AM (#50228910)

    > 1. there are 57,000 unoccupied apartments in NYC because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out.
The correct quote should be:

    > According to state data, approximately 57,421 rent-stabilized apartments were vacant across New York City
The key term here is "rent-stabilized". And the reasons why they are vacant is much more complex "because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out". That is simply one category of rent-stabilized apartments that are vacant.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:29AM (#50229172)
> And the reasons why they are vacant is much more complex "because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out".

Is it actually more complex than that? If the regulation that makes it unprofitable to rent them out is rent control, that's still an accurate statement of why they're not being rented out.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by laughing_man on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:06AM (#50229921)
I don't think it's much more complicated than that. If you own a "rent-stabilized" apartment there's going to be a very low limit to the amount of money you're willing to spend to keep it habitable. If it needs a lot of money to make it legal to rent out, you're just going to leave it vacant. You don't really have a choice.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by WalterBright on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:15PM (#50233774)
"rent-stabilized" is just another word for "rent control", which is the government setting the prices.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by SyzygyRhythm on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:53PM (#50228149)
It's not very complicated; it's just that the solutions are deeply unpopular. Making housing affordable by definition means driving down prices. But existing homeowners don't like to see their home prices go down! And about 2/3 of the US public lives in a house owned by a resident.

I'm semi-convinced that the reason why we see so many bad ideas in housing is because the good ideas negatively affect too much of the voting public. Or, they perceive the ideas as negatively affecting them.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by nradov on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:00AM (#50228189)
You're mistaken about the reasons why solutions are unpopular. Have you actually talked to the most active NIMBYs who oppose new housing development? Most of them are barely aware of affordability and home prices. They have lived in the same neighborhood for decades and intend so stay there until they die so prices don't impact them at all. Instead they are concerned about quality of life issues: traffic, parking, noise, petty crime.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Geezus_42 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @10:26AM (#50231940)
Or just straight up bigotry. They love to claim apartments increase crime, but then act like row houses are somehow different.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by SyzygyRhythm on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:42PM (#50236340)
My point isn't about the most active NIMBYs; it's about the central mass of the voting public. Yes, the NIMBYs have disproportionate influence, but politicians still have to keep their voters happy.

Perhaps my view is too California-brained, but homeowners here like high prices because it gives more flexibility to downsell, they can get large home equity loans, and Prop 13 ensures they won't be paying full property tax (at least if they've been living there for a while). Even for those planning on living there until they die, their children would still like to inherit a valuable place.

At any rate, I didn't intend to limit the reasons to just price. The solution is to build more housing, but building housing is unpopular, and it isn't hard to see why. So we end up with bad policy like rent control instead.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by win311fwg on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:22AM (#50228574)
> But existing homeowners don't like to see their home prices go down!

As a homeowner I don't want to see my home price go down relative to all other homes as that leaves me in a precious position if I need to move, but if all homes fall in price together then that actually makes the prospect of moving less risky as, if I have to move into a house that is a step-up from the one I have, the cost to do so is lower. That would be an improvement over the status quo. High housing prices are a problem even for those with significant equity in a home.

But who doesn't want to see their wage go down is those who build houses. This is the bottleneck. The vast majority of people cannot afford a new house, which means they're stuck in their used houses, which means there is no inventory opening up for those with no houses.

> it's just that the solutions are deeply unpopular.

Is it? The solution in motion is to use AI to push software developers out of software development so that they have to become construction workers, thereby increasing the supply of construction workers, pushing construction wages down. It doesn't seem that unpopular (at least not outside of HN, but even on HN many welcome it with open arms). Maybe it will become unpopular once the motions are complete? That's a tad bit late, though.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:01AM (#50228757)
“Making housing affordable by definition means driving down prices.”

This is not true.

Not that it matters as I don’t think this is what motivates NIMBY’s but for anyone reading that believes so, this is incorrect.

The old single family home next to the new apartment building gains land value. And this shows up county after county [1]. Building more housing is a valuation win-win, the pie just grows.

[1] https://gardner.utah.edu/news/recent-apartment-construction-...

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by harvey9 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:26AM (#50229409)
But unless you intend to sell up then what you now have is a more crowded neighborhood and in some cases higher property taxes.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by germinalphrase on Sunday October 25, 2026 @10:40AM (#50232059)
Density supports local businesses though. An apartment building was built a block from my home about a decade ago. I was promised congestion, parking issues, and petty crime - but what I got was a brewery, a cafe, and a restaurant that survived COVID. Feels like a win for me.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by harvey9 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:41PM (#50234015)
You objectively have a more crowded neighborhood though, regardless of you being happy with the end result.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by lhopki01 on Monday October 26, 2026 @06:47PM (#50252235)
Probably not even objectively. My neighborhood has less than half the population of had 30 years ago because it's all retired people in single family homes where 30 years ago it was all families. They've even closed down the school because of it.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pessimizer on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:16PM (#50233167)
> The old single family home next to the new apartment building gains land value.

And this is why large property owners fund YIMBY organizations. I have no idea how they've managed to convince people of normal intelligence that relaxing restrictions on zoning lowers property values, and that's why the selfish senior citizens who stubbornly continute to live in the homes they've lived in for decades are against it. It doesn't make any mathematical sense at all. They just are willing to believe anything that promises to give them what they want, which is other people's homes who don't want to sell and who don't want to live next to 900 people on a tiny lot with no parking.

The most insulting part is when they pretend that this is racism, while YIMBYs have been gentrifying black people from the neighborhoods they've been in for centuries, into the woods. The reason they're so frustrated about senior citizens in San Francisco or wherever is because they can defend themselves, while black people can't. Black people are being annihilated from urban neighborhoods; you're seeing them replaced by rent-stressed immigrants who don't have families or connections in the country to retreat to.

> Building more housing is a valuation win-win, the pie just grows.

No, it's a win for people who sell. It's not a win for people who want to keep their homes, and their communities. It's a win for alienation and cultural destruction, pushed by people who either have no roots, or who keep their roots safely protected a thousand miles away.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:00PM (#50233648)
Gentrification doesn't cause displacement, a lack of housing options does. The part that tenant activists have not accepted is: The "gentrifiers" are coming whether you build housing or not, the question is are we going to build enough housing to keep the existing community in place or not.

Community is still community in a condo.

>>"pushed by people who either have no roots, or who keep their roots safely protected a thousand miles away"

Imperceptibly different from the argument JD Vance makes against immigrants. Maybe rethink that tack.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by inglor_cz on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:18AM (#50229373)
IDK if things are fundamentally different in Czechia, but I talked to a lot of Czech NIMBYs and they almost never mention home prices. What they usually obsess about is change in a neighborhood that they are used to and want to keep intact. The resentment against new people and new buildings is just palpable, even if the newcomers would be solid middle class.

Noise and dust from construction are often mentioned as well. Construction means heavy trucks entering places where they usually don't intrude.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by adaml_623 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:12AM (#50229631)
Saying, "2/3 of the US public lives in a house owned by a resident" sounds like a phrase talking around the problem that young people can't afford to move out of the family home. A true fact but with a story behind it.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by SyzygyRhythm on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:23PM (#50236185)
I admit it's awkward phrasing. I try to be accurate.

About half of US adults own their home. It goes up to ~2/3 if you include adult children, grandparents, etc. that live in the house but don't own it.

I wasn't trying to dance around this fact; my point is that a large fraction of the voting public has their interests aligned with keeping home prices high (presuming that these non-owning residents share interests with the people that do own the home).

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by mancerayder on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:45PM (#50234051)
California bias.

Go to Manhattan and tell me that housing isn't built because of NIMBYism. It's: RTO (very important!), cost of land (land isn't increasing in volume), end of tax subsidies (programs that gave developers tax breaks), zoning (hey let's demolish all the jazz clubs in Greenwich Village and replace it with affordable housing - is that what you consider the correct line?), jobs (the economics of people moving to a place) and many many many more factors.

About once a week someone with a singular conception of the world of housing comes and you need to open their minds up a bit.

You want to lower housing costs? Maybe increase public transportation, give workers rights to work from home, and invest in expanding the suburbs by making them more dense. But don't do that until AFTER you've established the infrastructure piece. Not everyone wants to live in LA or Austin and spend hours in cars.

If you don't do these things then people all want to live in the same place, which is far more impactful than this "NIMBYism" thing, not everything is your local HOA or little town's regulations.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:05PM (#50234257)
The is flagrant gish gallop. Most of this is very well handled by most other countries. Example:

“hey let's demolish all the jazz clubs in Greenwich Village and replace it with affordable housing”

Or just rebuild them in the commercial space under the new taller condos, so more than just the nepo trust fund babies or lottery rent control people can live in them. These are all non-issues once you get over people’s aesthetic preferences.

This is not just a California issue, the space between downtown and midtown is severely under-built when compared to the economic output of those spaces.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by mancerayder on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:14PM (#50234366)
What are you talking about? Where do you see Paris being demolished?

How would Greenwich Village look if you turned it all into towers of rental apartments?

France uses expansion of the suburbs to make housing more available, and that includes trams, buses and yes, Metro expansion. You don't need to demolish the fucking bistros and parks to replace them with towers.

In NYC it could be done with NJ Transit being replaced, and better transportation. Then the border areas would become more dense because the investment returns would support it. People would want to move there to work in Manhattan.

Please don't turn world class cities into your LA or Houston Hellscapes of cars and highways. I'd rather pay a million dollars for a tiny one bedroom apartment in a real city than half the price in those soulless, cultureless places where you spend all day behind the wheel of a vehicle.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:32PM (#50234570)
“What are you talking about? Where do you see Paris being demolished?”

Back in the 1800’s when the more dense haussmanian architecture was put in. I’m sure their equivalent of pretty jazz clubs then were mowed down too. But over a 100 years the more housing made space for more people and better culturally richer city.

New York is a newer city, it’s time to densify is now.

I’m literally trying to densify, so that’s the anti-highway move. Tear down all of FDR and put in more NJ transit for all I care, I Love the Path.

We can do both, put more transit it and densify the low density sections of Manhattan. So more people have more choices.

Blocking this on aesthetic and legacy preferences is morally wrong.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by mancerayder on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:03PM (#50234934)
>Back in the 1800’s when the more dense haussmanian architecture was put in. I’m sure their equivalent of pretty jazz clubs then were mowed down too. But over a 100 years the more housing made space for more people and better culturally richer city.

Absolutely wrong. Haussmann's restructuring of the city was intended to REDUCE overcrowding and darkness due to the narrow alleyways, not to mention illness from the overcrowding. He lowered density, built parks, and then Paris expanded a lot when they absorbed the suburbs in the 1860's. Today Paris is extremely high density, and they're again expanding into the suburbs - look up Grand Paris projects. But the 6 story buildings aren't being demolished to make 30 story buildings like you seem to be suggesting is the thing to t do.

As much as I rail against a soulless place like Houston (with no housing restrictions like in NYC or Cali), I also don't want to turn our cities into Shanghai or New Delhi.

And by the way, what makes you think building more makes housing cheaper? It's not like making widgets in a factory. Gentrification makes things more, not less expensive - have you seen the history of Williamsburg, Brooklyn? Rezoning it turned it into a lux neighborhood with an Apple store, and attracted people from around the world.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:11PM (#50235589)
You’re just laying out engineering problems with very good solutions. Densification doesn’t mean overcrowding or a lack of parks, it just requires creativity. The neighborhood will look very different though.

There’s no point fighting against known norms in economics now. Induced demand in housing is hogwash: there are a certain number of people who dream of moving to east village and that number doesn’t magically grow if you build more housing. After decades of underbuilding, yes the demand is high, but it’s not infinite. Build out the suburbs too, build good transit, split the difference and the housing prices stabilize.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by smelendez on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:05PM (#50236056)
I don’t really understand what the issue is in Houston and why it feels so culturally bereft. Part of the issue is sprawl, sure, but it feels like there’s just less going on than other sprawling cities like LA and Atlanta.

I was there a few years ago in the summer, and figured I’d go see live music at night, and there just was literally not any to see besides at the megavenues. And surprisingly few bookstores for a city that size. I think it’s possible there are more independent bookstores in New Orleans than in Houston, a much larger and wealthier city.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:11AM (#50228522)
The share of income people spend on housing has been very stable over 40 years: https://economistwritingeveryday.com/2023/04/26/spending-on-...

The problem isn't so much that housing has gotten expensive. It's that many of the existing places have moved up-market compared to what they were 30-40 years ago. 75 years ago, Scarsdale NY or parts of Long Island were expensive. But Palo Alto was a drab middle class suburb. As the tech economy has boomed, that has driven prices up in Palo Alto for the same reason they were already high in Scarsdale. And now you have to move to Gilroy.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:25AM (#50229146)
> The share of income people spend on housing has been very stable over 40 years

That's a misleading metric for two reasons. First, "people" includes all the people who bought a house decades ago before the prices went up, and correspondingly paid the old prices instead of the current prices. And second, it assumes that if housing becomes more expensive what people all do is pay more for housing rather than being unable to afford it and then having to take a longer commute to access housing they can afford, live with their parents, become homeless, etc., which negatively impact the amount or type of housing they get instead of the amount they pay for it.

Meanwhile between 1984 and today median income increased by ~290% while median new home prices increased by ~425%:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEHOINUSA646N

And that's with the gap having reduced a bit in the last couple of years, since home prices have declined slightly since the peak in 2022 while median income continued its usual trend.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by matwood on Sunday October 25, 2026 @08:19AM (#50230784)
This is a good point. Also, anytime there is a discussion about inflation, there should be a timeline included.

Both inflation and wages have not gone up uniformly since they started being tracked. We all know the Trump/Biden covid inflation was bad, but by the end of Biden's term wages had mostly caught back up. The second Trump administration's policies reversed that trend.

Housing in particular cratered in some areas during the GFC, but then went wild especially around the covid.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:46AM (#50231540)
Those are fair points. But I think it’s also misleading to look at prices in a fixed location over time, which ignores that places can become relatively more desirable and move upmarket. Yeah, your parents bought a house in Mountain View for cheap. But they were moving to escape high housing prices in the New York or Chicago suburbs where they grew up.

> Meanwhile between 1984 and today median income increased by ~290% while median new home prices increased by ~425%

The average FHA mortgage rate in 1984 was 13.2%. Today’s it’s 6.8%. The more expensive house with a cheaper mortgage costs $482 per month less and $173,000 less over the lifetime of the loan.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 26, 2026 @11:56AM (#50245918)
> But I think it’s also misleading to look at prices in a fixed location over time, which ignores that places can become relatively more desirable and move upmarket.

That's fine if there is then some other place with equivalent housing prices and job opportunities to what the parents had at the time.

> The average FHA mortgage rate in 1984 was 13.2%. Today’s it’s 6.8%. The more expensive house with a cheaper mortgage costs $482 per month less and $173,000 less over the lifetime of the loan.

Mostly because 1984 (the oldest date the graph had for median income) was a period with historically high interest rates:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/mortgage30us

They were more like 8% in the 1970s and basically where they are now in the 1990s.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pj_mukh on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:49AM (#50228713)
Fighter planes coming back with holes must mean the parts with the holes are the ones that need reinforcing.gif

People are moving out of opportunity zones (and you know…losing opportunity) or moving in with roommates to keep the average percentage low.

Feels like such a basic factor to miss for what is supposedly an economists blog. That metric means nothing.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:27AM (#50229155)
That stability claim is an average for all American households, gathering together high-income households and long-tenure homeowners along with poor renters. But in a K-shaped economy where the wealthy do well and the rest do worse, averaging the two forks of the K hides the hardship of those on the lower fork.

From https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/rental-housing-unaffordabi...

> The net effect of this longer history is that renters today spend much more of their incomes on rent than they did in previous generations. The median renter household in 1960 spent less than a fifth of their income on rent. By 2022, housing costs consumed 31 percent of the median renter’s income. And in inflation-adjusted terms, the median rent is up 75 percent over these six decades while the median renter income has risen by just under 15 percent.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by laughing_man on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:09AM (#50229938)
That's not dispositive, though, since it may be that people spend more on rent because they can, i.e. other things have become relatively less expensive.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:48AM (#50231556)
When real income goes up 15% but rent goes up 75%, people are absorbing a cost, not flaunting their wealth.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:48PM (#50235929)
The average house is double the size of what it was when the boomers were young.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by astura on Sunday October 25, 2026 @10:55AM (#50232202)
A lot of people spend more on housing because standards have greatly increased. The average square footage of living space per person has doubled since the 1970s and tripled since the 1950s. A modest home in 2020s was a luxury house in the 50s. Families have gotten smaller and houses have ballooned.

Even when I was a kid in the 1980s I didn't know a single person whose household had multiple bathrooms, a dishwasher, or air conditioning. Not a single one.

Part of the reason why standards have increased is because incomes have increased.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:50PM (#50235941)
Our 1960s house in one of the richest suburbs in the country (Mclean, VA) was 1,800 square feet. The average new house today is over 2,200.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by astura on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @01:25PM (#50277261)
Average household size in 1960s: 3.7

Average household size in 2020s: 2.6

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by darth_avocado on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:05PM (#50227888)
1. PCE tracks spending by and on behalf of households, including employer-paid health insurance and government-funded medical programs like Medicare. Arguably this does not reflect out-of-pocket costs or the immediate cash-flow reality experienced by a regular household.

2. Shelter accounts for roughly 34% of the CPI, whereas it makes up only about 16% to 17% of the PCE which underplays the pressures of housing people face. Housing arguably is one of the most basic necessity and people will spend on it. For majority of the people in the country housing as a % of income is the biggest expense, so weighing it at 16% sounds almost ridiculous.

3. PCE also famously isn’t based on household surveys like CPI which means it doesn’t accurately represent the actual inflation either.

4. PCE also doesn’t accurately represent lifestyle downgrades even though it tracks them. PCE will capture if you swap chicken for beef (like people are doing right now) but the conclusion you’ll come to is that people have the same amount of spending power as before.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jparishy on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:03PM (#50227540)
Hey thanks for posting this perspective w/ the link. Fun rabbit hole to go down stuck in a hotel tonight. I wonder if you think something explanatory is missing in _all_ of these different indices, in the "where there's smoke, there's fire" sense of economic anxiety on display today
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:25AM (#50228591)
The sense of economic anxiety is due to increasing economic efficiency and sorting. It's not that the cost of living somewhere has gone up as much as people think. It's that the market is efficiently allocating housing in the place you grew up, near your parents, family, and friends, to Google and Facebook engineers. But you can still get a house twice as big as what your parents had at your age in a new subdivision in Tennessee.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by HWR_14 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @08:45AM (#50230978)
Yes, you can afford a very nice house in Tennessee if you can work remotely with a Silicon Valley salary.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by pessimizer on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:33PM (#50233377)
> But you can still get a house twice as big as what your parents had at your age in a new subdivision in Tennessee.

Tennessee suburbs are eyewateringly expensive. Your parents made a living wage at a job that doesn't exist in the US anymore, and definitely isn't located in Tennessee anymore. The mean homebuyer is older than your parents.

You can get a cheap house in the middle of nowhere where all the industry was destroyed for imports, services destroyed for outsourcing and the retail was destroyed for the internet and big box chains, if you are a wealthy person who works remotely or at one of the local health insurance conglomerates.

If you are not a wealthy person who works remotely, you can't live there anymore; it is not cheap for you. In fact, all of your family (who has lived here, near each other, for generations) has to figure out where in the country they will have the best chance to feed themselves (or whether they should leave the country) and move there. Now, they're trying to get by without the support of each other, making them more alienated, isolated and dependent on corporations and the state.

There are natural limits to this sort of evil. People won't starve to death quietly.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by cucumber3732842 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @07:07PM (#50236944)
>You can get a cheap house in the middle of nowhere where all the industry was destroyed for imports

By the people your parents voted in to do just that no less.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by openasocket on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:36PM (#50227740)
I’m not necessarily disputing your point, but it’s very odd to downplay one source for potential bias, and then follow up with a study from the CATO Institute. Like, the CATO institute is openly a libertarian think tank founded by one of the Koch brothers.

I also think it’s unfair to look at just food prices. Housing and healthcare have bloomed massively.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by manlymuppet on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:09PM (#50227912)
Of course you’re right. Food isn’t the whole picture, and no think tank is perfect.

We should evaluate research by the research itself, rather than by the author’s subjectivity credibility alone. The is the point I was trying to make by providing alternative research and adding a little bit of nuance to the reply, but perhaps I should’ve been more forthright in addressing my own bias as well.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by solomonb on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:07AM (#50229049)
> We should evaluate research by the research itself

Why is this the argument when someone challenges your source, but when it comes to someone else's source your argument is:

> This is research from a labor advocacy group, with the explicit aim of the organization to advocate for this sort of thing. This doesn't mean the research is is automatically invalid, but it is bias worth mentioning.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @07:21AM (#50241961)
Oh that is easy. He is not discussing in good faith.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by intended on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:37AM (#50228375)
Yeah, CATO is … not what I would reach for to make a point on neutrality.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rayiner on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:22AM (#50228573)
Who is neutral in your opinion?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by intended on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:23AM (#50228848)
On this topic? I would have to check. R/badeconomics ? R1 means that its impenetrable to average pontification. The Fed data is neutral.

Using CATO as a neutral source though, is sketch no matter what.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rpcope1 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:49PM (#50227810)
> calls a labor advocacy group biased

> Links the fucking CATO institute

Pot, meet kettle

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by derektank on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:34PM (#50227361)
The term “real” means the values are adjusted for inflation
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by smallmancontrov on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:45PM (#50227433)
...which is notorious for using a dogshit basket and basket-update methodology to make the number look good.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Avicebron on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:53PM (#50227478)
Yup. The St. Louis Fed is a joke. Inflation of owners' equivalent rent alone blows the whole argument up..
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by vconnor on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:45AM (#50228954)
I love that any time there’s a discussion about inflation, someone posts that link.

“If you would please look at the chart…” when it is known that inflation is a politically-charged figure that is indirectly manipulated to show much lower figures than the price increases the average person with average expenses (rent, car, fuel, food, etc.) experiences.

Let alone doing comparison of inflation over longer timespans. Garbage model in, garbage numbers out.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by littlecranky67 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:56AM (#50229275)
It is not necessarily politically influence. You simply cannot measure inflation properly. See my siblin comment about technology - it is just impossible to compare the life of a 1920s person to a 2020s person based on tomatos, butter and rent. Because the access to products that didn't exist at the given quality level in 2020 is impossible to price in.

You can think of it with a thought experiment: A smartphone (with hypothetical internet) in 1920 would be worth almost all the money in the world. If you simply had one smartphone in 1920, the richest billionares would offer most of their wealth to have one. Hence in 1920, a smartphone would be worth at least $10M in todays money. Yet you can buy one for $500 today - so you are twenty-thousand times richer than 1920. The same applies for flatscreen TVs, antibiotics (really valueable when you need it), polio vacination etc.

You can't measure this with CPI, yet people complain about the CPI is fake. It is just a statistical average, no more no less. It always was irrelevant. It is the arguments people do with that number, that are bullshit. Basic statistics teach you never use an average to come to conclusions about the individual.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @07:25AM (#50241986)
What are you talking about, a billionaire would not offer most of his money for a cellphone in 1920. There is no way you actually believe that.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by littlecranky67 on Monday October 26, 2026 @10:12AM (#50244062)
Of course they would, it would be the most valueable item on the planet (asuming there is an internet surrounding it). You could charge millions for todays 65" OLED TVs in 1980. The price for polio vaccine in 1920? Well, no billionaire would risk any of their offspring to suffer from polio.

We literally have billionaires flying to space and longing for other planets today - way more useless than a smartphone.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @12:27PM (#50246526)
Why would an internet that only the billionaire is on be worth anything?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by littlecranky67 on Monday October 26, 2026 @01:27PM (#50247535)
It is a hypothetical that you chose to not want to understand. Replace phone or flatscreen TV with something more available, such as a modern midrange car - gasoline/diesel and streets were widely available in 1920.

Or the option to cross the atlantic in a day instead of 3 weeks. Etc.

The whole point is, basically everything that is widely available to the broad population today wasn't even available to the ultra wealthy back then, let alone the broad population. People just take this stuff for granted nowadays.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @07:06PM (#50252442)
Right which is fine. Where it veers of into absurdity is when people try and claim we are better off then the ultra wealthy of yesteryear because we have access to cellphones or transatlantic flights.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by littlecranky67 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:48AM (#50229248)
The basket is dogshit, but not for the reason you probably think. Our lives improved tremendously by technology: internet, smartphone, videogames, netflix & co, medical progress, online shopping of any goods you can possible imagine, ability to travel the world for cheap.

The problem with the CPI basket is, it needs to be constant of products to be comparable, so NO technological advancement is considered in that basket. Instead, they use the price of butter and tomatoes. Well, a fictious 1950s person wouldn't care that is can buy more butter or tomatoes than we can, but would want smartphone and a plane ticket to thailand.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by cicko on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:39AM (#50229475)
I'm sorry but videogames and Netflix have done exactly nothing for my quality of life. In fact, I wish there were less of both, and multiple other things you listed. I think we have a significantly different understanding of quality.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by littlecranky67 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:00AM (#50229586)
It is just an example, but you come to the base of my argument: CPI basket is an average - and you cannot use it to make statements about individuals. If Netflix is nothing to you, then look at houses: My granparents (born even after 1920s) had an outhouse. That means, every time you need to use the bathroom, you left your house through the garden - come wind and weather. That meant in the winter, you were walking through the snow and do your business in a small, smelly outhouse without no access to running water whatsover at sub-zero degrees. Yet there are people running around saying that our grandparents could afford houses, while we can't anymore.

The quality of the house your grandparents (for 1920 probably your grand-gran parents) is vastly different. Those houses cannot be compared at all, when I take my dump in the heated warmth in a nicely smelling place listening to some music over my airpods.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by versteegen on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:19AM (#50230005)
Getting offtopic... for my father growing up in the Netherlands, the early 50's was still as you describe: an outhouse with a bucket, no running water, an uninsulated house with a roof that let in snow; he caught every illness. They had electricity but no appliances (except a radio?). By the time he was 18, they had a heater, fridge, freezer, washing machine, he had a (rusty) Mercedes and they got a TV soon after. So progress has been very uneven and if you only go back 40 years goods are far more comparable.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by astura on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:40PM (#50233433)
In a video Ann Reardon, a popular Australian YouTuber, tested a vintage hand-cranked stand mixer invented in Australia. She explained the context of a hand cranked stand mixer - that rural homes in Australia didn't have electricity until well into the 1960s.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday October 25, 2026 @07:39AM (#50230553)
If your grandparents were born in the 1920s they'd have been adult in the 50s, and outhouses were already rare except in rural areas. The 40s/50 building boom built suburbia, not shacks with outhouses.

Let's look at some real numbers instead of a folksy parable about grandma. Here are recent stats about rent arrears:

https://www.baselane.com/resources/unpaid-rent-debt-statisti...

And rental affordability:

In 2026, a full-time worker needs to earn $34.73 per hour to afford a modest two-bedroom rental home in the U.S. and $29.19 to afford a modest one-bedroom rental.

https://nlihc.org/oor/about

And mortgage affordability:

https://www.visualcapitalist.com/median-house-prices-vs-inco...

None of these are heading in the right direction.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jodrellblank on Sunday October 25, 2026 @08:19AM (#50230787)
My grandparents’ house’s purchase price, inflation-adjusts to 3x the current average salary in the UK.

That house trades at 13x now.

There is no house of any size for 3x in most areas of the UK.

You can’t handwave that away by saying “central heating”. The cost of part-of-a-house is far less than the total - not 10x more on top.

Part of the issue is population doubled since then but house building didn’t. Part is cheap debt in the 2000s turned everyone and their dog into buy-to-let landlords then AirBnB hosts.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by goodmythical on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:54AM (#50231633)
Here in the US there are tons of homes available for 3x median income.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jodrellblank on Monday October 26, 2026 @12:38AM (#50239189)
... and?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by cedilla on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:36AM (#50229749)
You might as well complain about that the basket contains tomatoes because you don't like tomatoes.

It's a statistical tool concerning populations, not a sampling of what hacker news user cicko in their wisdom thinks increases quality of life.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bartnp on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:00AM (#50229891)
Funny, for me it seems terrible exactly for the opposite reason. These kinds of baskets are too heavily weighted by things that go relatively down in costs like technology and airplane tickets.

The monetary reason is that the reason those things go down is because of technology advances and not because of changes in the value of the currency. Inflation should be about the currency, and less about what cool advances people are doing to make cheaper TVs and better websites

The practical reason is that if the basics like rent and food go up relative to wages, then a lot of people end up crushed by the basics alone and have no disposable income left for the cool stuff. The baskets are often too biased towards spending patterns of those who live the good life and for whom luxuries actually matter

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by gruez on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:20AM (#50231283)
>Funny, for me it seems terrible exactly for the opposite reason. These kinds of baskets are too heavily weighted by things that go relatively down in costs like technology and airplane tickets.

Have you looked at the actual weights?

https://www.bls.gov/news.release/archives/cpi_10142026.htm

Airline fares make up a whopping 1.04% of the CPI basket. "Information technology commodities" makes up a whopping 0.752%. Meanwhile the weights of essentials are: Food (13.507%), Energy (7.418%), Shelter (35.323%), Medical care services (6.834)

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by smallmancontrov on Sunday October 25, 2026 @08:18PM (#50237406)
The American Dream is not to Owner's Equivalent Rent a house.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bmitc on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:25AM (#50230047)
> Our lives improved tremendously by technology

Aside from technological and scientific progress in the medical field, it's generally been shown that people's lives have gotten worse.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by smallmancontrov on Sunday October 25, 2026 @08:18PM (#50237399)
Not only is CPI calculated with Hedonic Adjustments (the term they use when doing the thing you said they didn't do), those are one of the most controversial parts of the CPI calculation, because they allow CPU GHz to offset wildly inflating health care, housing, and education costs, which is obvious bullshit.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by mschuster91 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:13AM (#50229959)
> The term “real” means the values are adjusted for inflation

And that is the cause behind so much distrust in politics these days!

The problem is, sure, inflation as a whole using the official metrics may "only" be 3% YoY.

But WHAT THE FUCK does that have to do with the reality of the 99%, who see their grocery bill, their gas bill, their rents increasing far, far more than "official inflation" says?

The inflation basket includes way too much stuff people buy like, what, once every two decades like new kitchen appliances. It is of no use for me if that price stagnates.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @08:04AM (#50242296)
It is done that way on purpose. The numbers are not supposed to reflect reality, they are supposed to pacify the masses.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bmitc on Sunday October 25, 2026 @06:30AM (#50230076)
How does inflation explain $5/gallon gas or $3,000 single bedroom apartment rent or $300 grocery bills for a few grocery bags or $50 to ship small packages or any other ridiculous cost increases we experience?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by gruez on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:13AM (#50231213)
Because "inflation" is a weighted average, and there's no law that says that every good/service in an economy must increase in price by the same amount?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bmitc on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:52PM (#50234107)
Okay. If it's an accurate weighted average, what is decreasing in cost so much and weighted enough that it keeps the inflation percentage as low as it is normally presented?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by gruez on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:22PM (#50234460)
You really couldn't do that yourself? I linked the data tables with all the information you need. I get you might be lazy but that's hardly an excuse now that we have AI. Anyways I asked AI, here's what it calculated:

    Owners' equivalent rent of primary residence (sub6): score=-9.9748, rel_imp=24.937, yoy=3.3
    Health insurance (sub4): score=-10.3886, rel_imp=0.818, yoy=-9.0
    New vehicles (sub4): score=-11.6188, rel_imp=3.748, yoy=0.6
    Used cars and trucks (sub4): score=-13.9776, rel_imp=2.688, yoy=-1.5
    Motor vehicle insurance (sub4): score=-22.0197, rel_imp=2.531, yoy=-5.0
OER seems to be there not because it's dropping, but because its weight is huge, so if it grew even slightly slower than overall inflation it would be a significant drag. All the vehicle related stuff are probably related to the car market being crazy during the pandemic and then normalizing. No idea what's going on with health or even car insurance. Of course this is all 1 year's worth of data so oddities like this are expected You'd probably want to redo this with 5, 10, or 20 year data.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bmitc on Sunday October 25, 2026 @11:23PM (#50238702)
Well, I'm just waiting for these numbers to somehow reflect the reality everyone is feeling.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by bluecheese452 on Monday October 26, 2026 @08:01AM (#50242277)
I kid you not, ipads. That is what the rich out of touch fed officials tried to claim to a chorus of boos.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by roenxi on Sunday October 25, 2026 @07:41AM (#50230565)
darth_avocado is implying that he'd rather use a different index to measure inflation. Which is reasonable, this game where "real" doesn't mean real is not helpful. I've been seeing "real" growth in my gold holdings for years but mysteriously enough the weight hasn't changed. And while I'm ranting it drives me mad that we're supposed to pretend exponentially increasing prices are "stable", that is about as unstable as prices can get without starting a mathematics degree.

I doubt there is a compelling argument why people should have to use CPI as the comparison index. I'd consider any investment that only matched CPI to be losing value for example; they should be tracking something one of the monetary aggregates.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by chorsestudios on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:53PM (#50227481)
They do have more money, less spending power.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:04AM (#50228205)
> Meanwhile household basics increased faster than wages

Not what real means!

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by Gibbon1 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:26PM (#50227996)
I first saw the claim everything is hunky dory because workers are working fewer hours from a economist probably ten years ago. The idea is workers are choosing to work fewer hours and instead enjoy more leisure.

So to point out how inanely out of touch economists are.

The problem with that is the worker economic base unit is a family not one person. Now compare 1960-70s where one person in the household works 40 hours a week. Compare with a modern family where both parents are working a combined 70-80 hours a week.

So yeah workers are working slightly less hours and families as a unit substantially more.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by vkou on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:37AM (#50229199)
People lack money, but a Netflix (or some other streaming) subscription is a very cheap way to buy a lot of entertainment, and just about everyone has at least one.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by HWR_14 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:11AM (#50231191)
About 25% of Americans have a Netflix account.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by vkou on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:28PM (#50233313)
How many have cable? Paramount? Disney plus?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:30PM (#50233331)
This is tricky. Household basics have not remained constant in the sense of being the same product. Out of household basics, like healthcare, also show similar transformations.

But these transformations are not complete, and thus comparing "what people are getting for their money" now vs. then is challenging, complex and subject to a lot of debate and disagreement.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by constant_flux on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:52PM (#50227470)
I don't find either of these charts dispositive by themselves. The cost of healthcare, education, housing, transportation, and insurance have easily outpaced any growth in wages. Another facet of this debate is that cheaper goods aren't necessarily of equal or better quality.

> Of course they do.

That level of certainty is not justified.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jparishy on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:37PM (#50227380)
Upvote for bringing data, since I did not. That said, that quote was in reference to AI, so referred to the past 3-4 years. And of course, our money today is not worth as much as it was 20+ years ago. Also many important goods and services increased in price at a higher rate than inflation or wage increases. It might be interesting to look at such industries for a history of consolidation or PE-involvement.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by derektank on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:01PM (#50227531)
For what it's worth, I thought the rest of your comment was a very accurate description of how labor and capital are reallocated within an industry. The question is simply whether it's a bad thing that Hollywood studios have decamped for Atlanta and Toronto. For the people working in LA that don't want to move, I'm sure the answer is yes. But on net, I think it's probably meant more and better work for more people in general.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jparishy on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:17PM (#50227634)
I really appreciate your perspective. Mine is definitely malleable on these topics; they're complicated and I'm not an economist.

re: regular people and their money, I will say, something about the bigger picture just feels off. I look at the graphs you linked to, and do not see it reflected in the people around me. I don't mean to be dismissive of the data, more that I feel like I am missing something, or it is, if that makes sense?

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:37PM (#50227747)
Since the 1980s, the wealthy have done fantastic while the rest have not done nearly as well. The argument from CATO and others is that we should be content with the majority of households taking home a shrinking share of an increasing pie so long as their absolute purchasing power isn’t decreasing, but that argument feels wrong in part because it’s human nature to measure status relative to others rather than in absolute terms.

Furthermore, wealth applies more pressure against certain costs like housing[1] than against others like food or durable goods. Cheap toasters only go so far in making people feel like they aren’t falling behind.

[1] https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/home-prices-surge-five-tim...

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:24PM (#50227980)
This seems to be a common argument essentially “If a rich guy get $1000 and as a result I get $10, then I shouldn’t complain because I got $10” but this glosses over the fact that money is a proxy for power. The rich guy got more power over resources from this deal. Over the years this leads to more power inequality which is bad because now the rich guy can start doing other things to me and I have no recourse.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:56PM (#50228173)
I agree, but I don't think many wealthy people are open to that perspective. Many seem to credit themselves with having created an environment where everyone's lot is improving in absolute terms, and don't see anything wrong with accumulating outsized relative power for themselves.

The reluctance to give up resources also an understandable aspect of human nature, but power concentration in the hands of the few is always problematic. I'm very much a capitalist but the last few decades have persuaded me that wealth taxes are a necessary and moral correction to capitalism's unfortunate spiraling acceleration of inequality.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:21AM (#50228291)
It’s a difficult conversation to have because critiquing the wealth accumulation tends to get you shouted down as a communist. I’m a believer in capitalism as well but our current system has produced people that are so wealthy they are effectively above the law. Some limit on wealth accumulation really needs to happen.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:34AM (#50228360)
To escape the "communist" critique, I think it's worthwhile to grapple with opposing all concentration of power, whether private or public, governmental or corporate.

For instance: marketplace competition requires some regulation, but recognizing that regulation is a necessary evil with many opportunities for abuse (e.g. regulatory capture) helps inoculate against socialism's worst excesses.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by orangecat on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:01PM (#50234917)
If the rich guy loses $1000 and you lose $10, is that good?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:36PM (#50235809)
Well, these days when the rich guy loses $1000, the government takes my $10 and gives it to him.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by treis on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:36AM (#50231442)
At least in Atlanta it seems like a lot of production bounced to even cheaper locales as tax subsidies became a bit less generous. We're at like half our 2022 peak dollar wise.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by manlymuppet on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:53PM (#50227483)
The data by the Fed linked above is inflation adjusted.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jparishy on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:56PM (#50227504)
I realized after, yeah, thanks for calling out though.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by manlymuppet on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:18PM (#50227953)
You are welcome. Though seeing your overwhelming openness and good nature in the rest of this thread, I now feel some regret in how I replied to you here.

I addressed but one of your points here and ignored essentially the rest of your reply. A rather myopic one sentence reply to a more nuanced comment.

Sorry to sink to the lowest common denominator, friend. Thank you for making me see this.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:40PM (#50227409)
> the average number of hours worked per worker have fallen

Hooray for just-in-time scheduling where workers have to be available full time but rarely get scheduled full time. It’s an innovation that has been great for capital and terrible for labor.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by matt_heimer on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:37PM (#50227748)
Yep, keep everyone part-time so they don't get benefits.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by groundzeros2015 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:41PM (#50227770)
which is in unintended but predictable side effect of requiring those benefits for full-time employees.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by kraken_cult on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:09PM (#50227913)
shakes fist at sky "if only we didn't have to pay those pesky benefits then we wouldn't be forced to make the roles abusive contractor/part-time roles...Wild people even try to take this stance.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by groundzeros2015 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:25PM (#50227991)
I'm baffled. Do you not see the normative vs descriptive claim here?

The reality is that requiring benefits imposes a cost, and employers manage that cost by limiting who qualifies. So yes, this hurt many workers - and disproportionately impacted disadvantaged people who didn't make the full-time cliff.

Ignoring increntives is actually shaking your fist at the sky.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:40PM (#50228081)
Then can we agree on a government funded safety net for the sake of labor mobility? ;)

Typically the real disagreement here is over whether workers should get benefits at all.

EDIT: can we get another `vouch` or two for groundzeros2015's currently [dead] reply? It's well-argued and an olive branch and deserves to be visible.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by charlie90 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:15PM (#50235622)
who needs healthcare anyways
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:02PM (#50227879)
The CPI has gone up far faster than real wages.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL

People are earning about 12% more and working about 5% less since 1980, but everything costs roughly 3x what it did in 1980 relative to wages, and that's where most people are pinched.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by QuesnayJr on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:36AM (#50228643)
It doesn't make sense to compare CPI to real wages. Real wages are wages divided by CPI or another inflation index.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jacobolus on Sunday October 25, 2026 @01:39AM (#50228666)
Real wages are inflation adjusted. So if everything costs 336% of what it did in 1980, and the real ages are 112% of what they were, then that means nominal wages are 376% of what they were.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by stonogo on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:27PM (#50227311)
Nicely sliced. Weekly wages for full time workers have been rising for decades while fewer workers work full time. I don't think this data backs your assertion.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by derektank on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:50PM (#50227459)
The number of full time workers as a percent of the total employees has gone from roughly 84% (rounding up) in 1979 to roughly 82% (rounding down) today. There was a spike in people working part time in the wake of the GFC, but we've returned to trend.

Also, I chose weekly wages because annual wages are complicated by time off, which was the other item in question.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by manlymuppet on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:29PM (#50227325)
Something like 80% of workers are full time.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by scotty79 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:43PM (#50227418)
25% increase in half a century? We ahd like 3 technological revolutions since then and economy grew massively.

Compare that to how much wealth appreciated, like a price of gold or real estate.

Median real wages increased by the narrowest possible meaning of this word.

Trickle down economy is literally a trickle.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by steele on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:12PM (#50227930)
Boomers gonna boom