News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by derektank on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:01PM (#50227531)
For what it's worth, I thought the rest of your comment was a very accurate description of how labor and capital are reallocated within an industry. The question is simply whether it's a bad thing that Hollywood studios have decamped for Atlanta and Toronto. For the people working in LA that don't want to move, I'm sure the answer is yes. But on net, I think it's probably meant more and better work for more people in general.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by jparishy on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:17PM (#50227634)
I really appreciate your perspective. Mine is definitely malleable on these topics; they're complicated and I'm not an economist.

re: regular people and their money, I will say, something about the bigger picture just feels off. I look at the graphs you linked to, and do not see it reflected in the people around me. I don't mean to be dismissive of the data, more that I feel like I am missing something, or it is, if that makes sense?

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:37PM (#50227747)
Since the 1980s, the wealthy have done fantastic while the rest have not done nearly as well. The argument from CATO and others is that we should be content with the majority of households taking home a shrinking share of an increasing pie so long as their absolute purchasing power isn’t decreasing, but that argument feels wrong in part because it’s human nature to measure status relative to others rather than in absolute terms.

Furthermore, wealth applies more pressure against certain costs like housing[1] than against others like food or durable goods. Cheap toasters only go so far in making people feel like they aren’t falling behind.

[1] https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/home-prices-surge-five-tim...

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:24PM (#50227980)
This seems to be a common argument essentially “If a rich guy get $1000 and as a result I get $10, then I shouldn’t complain because I got $10” but this glosses over the fact that money is a proxy for power. The rich guy got more power over resources from this deal. Over the years this leads to more power inequality which is bad because now the rich guy can start doing other things to me and I have no recourse.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:56PM (#50228173)
I agree, but I don't think many wealthy people are open to that perspective. Many seem to credit themselves with having created an environment where everyone's lot is improving in absolute terms, and don't see anything wrong with accumulating outsized relative power for themselves.

The reluctance to give up resources also an understandable aspect of human nature, but power concentration in the hands of the few is always problematic. I'm very much a capitalist but the last few decades have persuaded me that wealth taxes are a necessary and moral correction to capitalism's unfortunate spiraling acceleration of inequality.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:21AM (#50228291)
It’s a difficult conversation to have because critiquing the wealth accumulation tends to get you shouted down as a communist. I’m a believer in capitalism as well but our current system has produced people that are so wealthy they are effectively above the law. Some limit on wealth accumulation really needs to happen.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by rectang on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:34AM (#50228360)
To escape the "communist" critique, I think it's worthwhile to grapple with opposing all concentration of power, whether private or public, governmental or corporate.

For instance: marketplace competition requires some regulation, but recognizing that regulation is a necessary evil with many opportunities for abuse (e.g. regulatory capture) helps inoculate against socialism's worst excesses.

Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by orangecat on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:01PM (#50234917)
If the rich guy loses $1000 and you lose $10, is that good?
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by yoyohello13 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:36PM (#50235809)
Well, these days when the rich guy loses $1000, the government takes my $10 and gives it to him.
Re:America Has Lost 200k of Jobs in Media, Film and the Arts... by treis on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:36AM (#50231442)
At least in Atlanta it seems like a lot of production bounced to even cheaper locales as tax subsidies became a bit less generous. We're at like half our 2022 peak dollar wise.