News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by valesco on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:43AM (#50083875)
I would make the hypothesis that racism outbursts are tied to worsening life conditions.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by multjoy on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:44AM (#50084370)
I would make the hypothesis that racism outbursts are driven by Farage, Tommy Ten-Names, Putin and the right wing engagement mill that is Twitter.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by pjc50 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:45AM (#50084386)
Nah, they're directly driven by social media radicalization. And in some cases fairly obviously traceable foreign actors.

It's just an immense right wing noise machine which makes it impossible to actually focus on finding solutions. We're back to people who want to improve electricity per capita by decapitating people.

People hate electricity prices, but they hate electricity infrastructure as well. They hate pylons, they hate renewables, they hate nuclear. People hate pollution and hate anti-pollution measures (see the LEZ insanity). Every solution will encounter angry blockers, often angry about things that aren't even real (anti-5G lunatics). And they want to blame everything on foreigners. Absolutely childish behavior of our """elite""", the dead hand of which sits on our media and most of our parties.

I think everything that needs to be said in this thread probably already has been by someone. Re-litigating the same issues.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by amiga386 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:39AM (#50084860)
> hate anti-pollution measures (see the LEZ insanity)

Try this out. Have the government mandate that everyone buy a certain type of car/van. Tell them it's good for the environment and give them tax incentives to do it. Then, years after everyone's invested in that type of car/van, have the government ban that type of car/van in major urban centres. Tell them to throw the car/van away and buy another one.

And tell them that if they don't do that, you'll fine them every day, when they drive to the place they've been driving to all their adult lives for work, etc.

Announce that this applies to everyone at the same time, so there's near-zero resale value in the old type of car/van, and there's massive demand pushing the price up for the new type of car/van.

Most people don't have a spare £20,000 kicking about, and if they did, they wouldn't choose to spend it on that. Throwing away their existing car/van and buying another doesn't give them £20,000 of value. It gives them £0 of value. They already had a car/van. It might give some kids' lungs value, but not them.

Honestly, try it. Try forcing millions of people into spending a lot of money all at once, and see how popular you are. Bonus: now try blaming social media or some other fifth column for your unpopularity!

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by pjc50 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:49AM (#50084938)
This is, of course, not what happened. It's not even all that unpopular. Only about half of Londoners even have a car in the first place.

When I say radicalized, I mean this guy: https://www.cps.gov.uk/national-news/news/updated-sentence-m...

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by manarth on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:39AM (#50085433)
There's also this:

    > "The ULEZ camera had already been cut down"
The camera was already useless. Detonating an IED served no purposeful protest, and endangered property and lives.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:10AM (#50085776)
There's also a huge racial undertone to the whole London anti-ULEZ 'debate' as Sadiq Khan is a muslim

Those opposing ULEZ conveniently ignore the Conservative government led by Boris Johnson (ex mayor of London) made ULEZ implementation a key requirement for supporting TfL funding during the pandemic

Despite anti-ULEZ folk claiming it's hugely unpopular Kahn convincing won the next mayoral election including some boroughs that were affected by the ULEZ zone expansion

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by amiga386 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:20AM (#50085893)
> huge

I think you overstate this. While there are wingnuts on Twitter who hate Khan for who he is, massively more people hate him - any politician, not just him - for dipping into their pocket and taking their money. "For the greater good".

Even the most beloved politican on the planet will become the most hated as soon as the propose increasing taxes, or increasing household costs. Which is why they're always looking for the sneakiest way to do it.

> Those opposing ULEZ conveniently ignore the Conservative government led by Boris Johnson (ex mayor of London) made ULEZ implementation a key requirement for supporting TfL funding during the pandemic

Alternatively, the central authority with all the money (Johnson's government) tells the devolved authority (Mayor of London) it doesn't like handing out free money, so what if our lockdown has decimated your cashbox income... so in exchange for money now to keep the lights on during this pandemic, I demand you make more of your own money in future, by fining people and by driving up public transport usage in your area. Also, I know how unpopular it is, which is why I delayed it when I was Mayor of London, so good luck at the polls ha ha!

> some

"some" indeed.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:20PM (#50094527)
> “some” indeed

Well he flipped one of them from Conservative and didn’t lose any of the ones that had previously voted for him and his vote was up overall

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by amiga386 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:35PM (#50096457)
On the other hand, the Uxbridge and Ruislip by-election. Should've been a shoo-in for Labour, given it was disgraced Partygate BoJo stepping down. Labour won another by-election on the same day. But not this one. Reason? Most likely local anger over ULEZ expansion, even though that's the responsibility of the (Labour) Mayor, not the Labour Party generally.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Uxbridge_and_South_Ruisli...

> Both Labour's leader, Keir Starmer, and deputy leader, Angela Rayner, blamed opposition to ULEZ, with Starmer suggesting the Labour London Mayor Sadiq Khan should rethink the policy. Khan defended the policy and Starmer soon sought to heal the rift. The defeated Labour candidate, Beales, also criticised the ULEZ policy.

So someone paid the electoral price for Khan's policy, it just wasn't him.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:10PM (#50110295)
Labour increased their vote in the 2023 Uxbridge and South Ruislip by election but not by enough to win… they then won it a year later

Yes, in 2023 ULEZ was a campaign issue but so was it when Khan was reelected mayor and Labour won a general election

ULEZ is fundamentally a good thing whether you like it or not

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:35AM (#50085398)
Reduced fuel duty for diesel came in in 2001 (25yrs ago) and was removed following the scandal of manufacturers cheating the emissions tests in 2015 (11 yrs ago)

We've known diesel emissions are bad for health for a long time and ULEZ schemes improve people's health, particularly children https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1l1r1zne1ro

But some selfish people still think it's their right to drive highly polluting vehicles and let everyone else bear the cost

ULEZ / LEZ zones are a good thing

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by mitxela on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:55AM (#50084978)
What kind of car/van was it? Since you said car/van and not car or van, I assume there's more than one?
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by amiga386 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:35AM (#50085393)
Diesel cars/vans. In 2001, the government cut yearly road tax to £20 for cars/vans emitting less than 110g/km of CO2. Many car/van diesel engines can meet this but few petrol engines can. The road tax normally costs £180-£300, so a £160+ saving every year.

So a lot of people moved to diesel cars/vans from 2001 onward.

Then in 2019, the Ultra Low Emission Zone was set around central London, which issued daily fines to:

- petrol cars/vans that didn't meet Euro 4 standards (most vehicles pre-2006)

- diesel cars/vans that didn't meet Euro 6 standards (most vehicles pre-2015)

This didn't bother that many people, because central London already has a daily congestion charge, so anyone taking a vehicle in there already had business to justify it. Most people get around central London by train/tube/bus/taxi, it's the best served city in the UK for public transport. There was also a scrappage scheme offering up to £9500 for replacing the vehicle.

What bothered a LOT of people, though, is the widening of the ULEZ area, first to the inner London orbital in 2021 and then to the whole of Greater London (9 million people) in 2023, regardless of whether they went to central London or not. The outer boroughs, aren't as well served by public transport as central London is, and car/van ownership and use is much higher than central London. And of course, the scrappage scheme was cut down to a maximum of £2000, which is not a lot.

You can perhaps see why there was so much opprobrium.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:57AM (#50087017)
There wasn't 'much opprobrium', there were a bunch of radicalised mainly white men opposing it who made a lot of noise backed by right wing newspapers who want to criticise Kahn for Tory government policy

Kahn won the next election including outer boroughs that were affected by the ULEZ expansion

https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/04/map-reveals-london-mayor-elec...

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by amiga386 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:26PM (#50096349)
I don't know why you want to bring race into this. The split is along car ownership/non-ownership, or city-oriented vs countryside-oriented. The outer boroughs more often need to use cars, and work/visit outside the M25, than the people in inner boroughs. Uxbridge is 85% white, so you can expect an issue facing everyone there to be "mainly white".

What the election map on your article shows is a bunch of outer boroughs ("some"?) choosing the Tory candidate over the Labour one, there just weren't enough of them overall. Elections aren't usually single-issue, and there's probably enough value in reelecting Kahn (or his opponents are odious enough), that forcing a large number of people to set their money on fire didn't entirely wreck his chances.

But you'll note that lessons have been learned. Back in 2019, the IEA were demanding the complete ban of gas boilers by 2026. The government never adopted such a policy, it's only too well aware at how much needless cost and effort it'd put the entire country through by making 80% of households throw out their heating system and buy another one, for the sake of the planet. So that's why the closest the government got to that was proposing in 2020/2021 maybe banning them by 2035. And now? The government is reassuring people that it won't ban gas boilers; not in 2026, not in 2035, not in 2050, not ever. It saw what banning cars in London kicked off. It doesn't want that for itself.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by youngtaff on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:11PM (#50110305)
I didn’t bring race into it… all the right wingers who’ve talked about Kahn being a Muslim and his heritage did!
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by manarth on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:32AM (#50085360)
They're referring to LEZ (Low Emission Zone) legislation where a fee is charged for vehicles which exceed a defined emission threshold.

In general, diesel vehicles are more likely to exceed the emission threshold.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by mr_toad on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:28AM (#50085971)
> Nah, they're directly driven by social media radicalization.

It’s much easier to radicalise someone who is already disaffected.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by mitxela on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:54AM (#50084971)
Social media is a catalyst that only works because material conditions are bad. If everyone is happy, and social media tells them there's a Muslim invasion, they just laugh it off. If everyone is angry, and social media tells them there's a Muslim invasion, they burn down a mosque.

It's a pattern that's been repeated several times before in history, most famously in Germany: whenever capitalism creates bad times, society chooses one of two ways out: either socialism or fascism. Right now several countries are seeing surges in popularity of the far left and the far right, which is this exact pattern playing out in real time before our eyeballs. While the established capitalist politicians always promise nothing except more of the same decline, and thus become unpopular when everyone is feeling the decline and inequality, socialist candidates promise to directly fix the cause of the inequality, and fascism is propped up by the causes of the inequality to divert attention away from themselves. Again, this pattern has already played out many times and is pretty hard to refute at this point.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by pjc50 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:09AM (#50085122)
Considering the number of people involved in the hotel arson attacks who have "previous", including domestic violence convictions, I think you can say that they themselves are unhappy, but that's not quite the same thing.

> fascism is propped up by the causes of the inequality to divert attention away from themselves

I think we can agree on this. It's not that the UK is in any way a poor country in total, but it is an unequal one. And open to the negative effects of inequality from the outside - see the involvement of UAE oligarchs in Man City fraud, for example.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by watwut on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:51AM (#50086944)
Meh, economic excuse is jist that - excuse so that the perpetrators sound better.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by zahlman on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:00PM (#50096013)
> And in some cases fairly obviously traceable foreign actors.

If they are "fairly obviously traceable" then surely you can name some and provide reasonable evidence?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by ilikerashers on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:21AM (#50085256)
Very true.

The establishment view is that riots and racism are right wing agitators and foreign power influenced. The people look to rival immigrants and conspiracies, united by anxiety and fear.

They are both looking for scapegoats. This has unfortunately lead to so many atrocities in history.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by user43928 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:57AM (#50085637)
I question to what degree people are riled up over economic difficulty being scapegoated onto immigrants like the comment chains below seem to claim.

This explanation seems to ignore much more obvious motivations. Most of the recent violent protests were triggered by concerns about immigrants committing violent crime and sexual offenses or harassment, often following concrete incidents.

Public safety seems like the clear primary motivation here.

One could make an argument in the direction that this is fueled by elites trying to distract from other issues.

However, I think that glossing over the primary concern to claim that the outrage is essentially engineered or purely driven by economic factors and living standard, will not convince the public. At least that's my opinion.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by zahlman on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:59PM (#50096001)
> One could make an argument in the direction that this is fueled by elites trying to distract from other issues.

Which elites, possibly? The anti-immigrant views are represented by fringe parties (albeit ones that are getting more votes than many would be comfortable with) and all sorts of mainstream political leaders are constantly condemning them. Social media is the only reason the stories spread, practically speaking; international news barely even cares about things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Ceuta_migrant_crisis (where the number of people involved approximately matched the population of Ceuta itself).

At any rate, I can't say I particularly hear these protesters, or their representatives, talking about economic factors all that much. Certainly it comes up, but only with explicit reference to biased government policy and not as just some natural pie-sharing effect.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by user43928 on Thursday October 15, 2026 @04:51AM (#50101014)
I'm also not sure, but I heard arguments that politicians and eg. Musk are trying to use immigration to distract the public from wealth inequality for example.

Or that politicians are not trying to solve immigration issues in order to stay in power.

Really I've heard all kinds of theories used to discount the actual issues or the motivations of those who make politics about immigration.

Most of them are likely nonsense with maybe a kernel of truth here and there, but that's just how politics are, right?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by modo_mario on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:12AM (#50085794)
Because some of the worsening life conditions are caused by migration. On other fronts it may provide a benefit but people need to get their head out of their ass if they don't think some qualms are legitimate.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:43AM (#50086825)
To what degree? I'm sure migration is statistically responsible for some percentage of worsening life conditions, but I doubt it's the biggest cause for anything specific getting worse. The far bigger cause is the ever-increasing inequality and subsequent extraction by the powerful.

If migration is responsible for 5% of an issue, and other causes are responsible for 95%, it's far too easy to make the population imagine the numbers are swapped.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by nothercastle on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:37AM (#50088408)
Migrants are always an issue when the pie shrinks. You bring them in when the pie is growing but during contraction it goes the other way.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @11:16AM (#50088940)
Since migrants aren't a major cause of the shrinking pie, this doesn't really help. It can actually hurt, since the pie can start shrinking faster.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by tsss on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:09PM (#50093275)
20% of the whole population are immigrants. In the big cities, where problems are worst, it is far higher than that.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:54PM (#50095065)
I can't respond to your point about problems in big cities, since you don't specify what they are, but rural areas have a whole host of problems that cities don't face, so I'm gonna need more than a vague assertion.

Though it still won't help your argument, because 1) correlation != causation, and 2) there are literally thousands of comparable correlations, so why is it immigrants, and not any of the others?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by tsss on Friday October 16, 2026 @09:24AM (#50118110)
Because there is a VERY clear causal relationship between population increase and increased competition for housing and jobs. You'd have to be blind and deaf not to see that.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by zahlman on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:34PM (#50095666)
"Inequality" cannot reasonably be blamed for Rotherham or any other similar situations; it cannot be blamed for the findings of Lowe's report; it cannot be blamed for any of the video evidence recently surfacing of clear two-tier policing.

Rounding things off to "migration" is ignoring the state's role in all of this, deliberately, in order to present complainants as racist.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:58PM (#50095985)
But you can be reasonably blamed for relentlessly bringing up anecdotes, without engaging with the words of others.

If you feel attacked by the word "migration", take it up with modo_mario.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by modo_mario on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:55AM (#50101426)
Over here in Belgium the majority of our prison population, ludicrous unemployment/innactivity statistics, rising land/house prices (non linear), etc, etc
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by panick21_ on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:50AM (#50086921)
Except that most evidence points against that. The people who don't live next to immigrants are generally much more angry then those that do. And the general places where people are angry about living conditions are former industrial economic heartland that have de-industrialized for reasons that have literally zero to do immigration.

Even in Japan people claim immigrants are the problem even if they are a group that barley exists at all.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @11:20AM (#50089017)
>> The people who don't live next to immigrants are generally much more angry then those that do.

Lol. Ask people in Crowborough and Piddington if that's true.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by panick21_ on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:14PM (#50090042)
Using individual example instead of overall statistics is an indication that you are not actually seriously engaging with the topic.

Individual examples are results of specific circumstances and not indication of a universal trend.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @01:55PM (#50091977)
They very much are.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:14PM (#50095410)
There are literally millions of examples against your position.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Thursday October 15, 2026 @04:28AM (#50100852)
Yes, that's why Reform, Restore, Conservatives are surging in popularity.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by defrost on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:37AM (#50101313)
Through fear and little actual contact with "the others" though.

> Lol. Ask people in Crowborough and Piddington

Awww, you guys have stopped citing Luton then?

‘I feel perfectly safe’: white Lutonians on the town’s supposed no-go zones - https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/08/luton-white-...

that's the way, just move onto another UK backwater and claim that as the new hotbed of brown people plotting against the King.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Thursday October 15, 2026 @06:16AM (#50101594)
>>Through fear and little actual contact with "the others" though.

I have a rape gang enquiry report you should read.

>>Awww, you guys have stopped citing Luton then?

Not sure what "guys" you are referring to. I'm referring to the fact that dropping 1,250 male asylum seekers from countries with a completely different culture (such that need to be given brochures saying women need to consent to sex) next to a village with a population of 350 is one of the most appalling ideas ever.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:31AM (#50101268)
It's funny how you can jump around between ideas, without ever letting the same standards be applied by anyone else. What are you trying to gain out of these discussions?

Because to me, it sure looks like you're only here to spread your agenda, and not to have any meaningful conversations.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Thursday October 15, 2026 @06:18AM (#50101607)
It's not "an agenda", it's a policy position.

I'm not sure why you think I'm jumping around between ideas.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Thursday October 15, 2026 @06:28AM (#50101690)
Because as soon as someone applies your standards equally, you don't engage with their response, and instead jump to another idea. I don't know how you don't see this, maybe spend some time reading your own comments?

> It's not "an agenda", it's a policy position.

No, it's not a policy position, it's an agenda you push. And it's one I've been seeing you push for months, if not years. You never really engage with critical responses, you just keep jumping to the next idea so you can keep pushing your agenda.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Thursday October 15, 2026 @06:47AM (#50101845)
>>Because as soon as someone applies your standards equally, you don't engage with their response, and instead jump to another idea. I don't know how you don't see this, maybe spend some time reading your own comments?

Yeah, ok bro.

>>No, it's not a policy position, it's an agenda you push.

I'm not sure how you define the difference. Is it an agenda if you disagree with it?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Thursday October 15, 2026 @07:23AM (#50102126)
It is an agenda when you show zero interest in actually discussing the arguments for your policy position. You just jump to the next argument, because you're here to advertise your policy position.

Doubly so when every argument you regurgitate boils down to the exact same talking points being disseminated through far-right media outlets. What can anyone learn from your comments, that they couldn't get by e.g. opening Breitbart?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by dgroshev on Thursday October 15, 2026 @08:27AM (#50102668)
Just so you don't feel shouting into the void: I completely agree with your assessment.

It's also notable that there are several accounts in this thread doing the exact same thing.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by Timon3 on Thursday October 15, 2026 @09:00AM (#50103033)
Thank you! :)
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by zahlman on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:30PM (#50095614)
How come you get to argue by assertion but your opponents don't?
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by panick21_ on Thursday October 15, 2026 @04:57AM (#50101050)
Because its a well known pattern that anybody who spends 5min looking at the data knows. Most immigrants live in cities that mostly vote left. The places that vote right are rural places that barley have immigrants.

Hence you have places like Fox news run coverage about cities all the time, telling you how they are lawless places full of crime. Scaring rural people about what all these immigrants will do once they final start to move to bum-fuck nowhere.

You seem the same pattern in most democracies.

There is no correlation between contact with immigrants and anti-immigrant voting.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by gadders on Thursday October 15, 2026 @06:13AM (#50101575)
>>There is no correlation between contact with immigrants and anti-immigrant voting.

There is anti-immigration voting, not anti-immigrant voting. But if an area is predominantly immigrant-populated, where are you expecting the right wing votes in that area to come from?

You don't think since the Boris Wave there has been a surge in politicians taking anti-immigration positions?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by panick21_ on Thursday October 15, 2026 @10:53AM (#50104572)
Most places are not primarily immigrant, unless you believe that everybody that isn't voting Reform is an immigrant.

> You don't think since the Boris Wave there has been a surge in politicians taking anti-immigration positions?

That's not what we are arguing about. No question that the avg. level of opposition to immigration has gone up.

But interestingly again this is not actually correlated with how many immigrants are arriving, and the popularity of these politicians isn't actually correlated with how good they actually did on immigration.

Boris himself being in power while there was a lot of immigration but he remained popular with the base.

Because most people don't have any actual understanding of immigration issues or look at any kind of data.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by modo_mario on Friday October 16, 2026 @05:22AM (#50116100)
>Boris himself being in power while there was a lot of immigration but he remained popular with the base.

He actively caused a large part of that migration of the boris wave with policies which were recommended against by at least 2 reports which they had requested and fellow front line politician such as suella. This after running on a partially anti migration mandate. He gets plenty of shit for it and lost popularity with anyone that cares about the matter.

>Because most people don't have any actual understanding of immigration issues or look at any kind of data.

By which metrics that they should all care about has it been doing well for people of the existing nations in europe? I listed some examples of ones that aren't so great in an earlier comment in this comment tree.

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by panick21_ on Tuesday October 20, 2026 @09:35AM (#50166181)
> He gets plenty of shit for it and lost popularity with anyone that cares about the matter.

Maybe among well-informed people who closely follow immigration policy, but not necessarily among the broader Conservative base.

This illustrates my point: much of the political debate about immigration is driven by perceptions rather than actual policy outcomes. Johnson talked about restricting immigration, which was popular with his base, but many voters had little understanding of what his government was actually doing. Literally just anti-immigration vibes.

And the political scandals that ultimately brought him down were largely unrelated to immigration. And he would have been the best for the Tories to have a chance in the election.

> By which metrics that they should all care about has it been doing well for people of the existing nations in europe?

Nice attempt at shifting the goalposts while not so subtly implying that immigration is responsible for all these other issues.

That wasn't the argument. The argument was about whether anti-immigration sentiment and political support for anti-immigration politicians actually correlate with immigration levels and policy outcomes.

> I listed some examples of ones that aren't so great in an earlier comment in this comment tree.

You mean the racist rants based on completely made up stuff or serious misinterpretation of a few data-points while completely ignoring the much more important much more actual relevant issues?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by modo_mario on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:53AM (#50101412)
This gets pointed at here in Belgium as well....except the share that is a migrant, has it as a background, in a relationship with, etc more than accounts for difference in opposition to more endless migration. It's also like people are not mobile nowadays. I've worked and lived in Brussels and the like where I'm now a small minority.

It turns out if they have mind boggling unemployment and inactivity numbers (majroity non eu working age women are housewives), make up the majority of prisoners, cost a load of money and put pressure on certain groups of wages, housing/land prices, alongside a host of other issues then what's the point?

Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by squidbeak on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:46AM (#50086879)
Contrary to that hypothesis racists are just as racist when the going's good.
Re:The United Kingdom Generates Less Electricity per Person ... by 6031769 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:50AM (#50088572)
True. But they aren't as rioty.