News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by jandrewrogers on Monday October 12, 2026 @02:43PM (#50060891)
People underestimate just how much effort goes into minimizing food waste and shortages in these types of industrial systems. The entire supply chain coordinates using these embedded sensors and control systems to make sure you always have safe food available at the lowest possible cost.

Connectivity in these environments is often challenging, it isn't like connecting a consumer fridge to wifi. Sometimes you are bridging weird networks that multiple parties need access to. It should be secure but that isn't as straightforward as one might assume. Many of these systems have very long lives, so there are many limitations that reflect the technology that existed when they were built.

All of this is invisible to the average person but it is what makes the world work.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by natdavidson on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:32PM (#50061724)
No, this “user story” does not mean the customer actually wants or uses the feature. You do not need remote command and control to tell if your truck chiller is working.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by 9x39 on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:58PM (#50062117)
But you’re going to adopt a platform that meets the needs across your enterprise, so the capability is often there even if one situation may only call for monitoring.

Further, once you have hundreds or thousands of devices, “just call someone to turn it up/down/off” doesn’t scale.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by reaperducer on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:39PM (#50062725)
Further, once you have hundreds or thousands of devices, “just call someone to turn it up/down/off” doesn’t scale.

And yet, somehow it did scale just fine for a hundred years before we hooked everything up to the internet.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by echoangle on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:51PM (#50064655)
Yeah, and people sewed clothes per hand for hundreds of years until someone automated it with a machine.

You need to save labor somewhere to free it up for other jobs that give you technological progress. If everyone would still be occupied plowing fields with oxen, we wouldn’t have cars and computers now.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by dalyons on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:01PM (#50063668)
And yet, progress marches forward and people want great efficiency and flexibility.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by account42 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:08AM (#50070391)
If you measure progess by reports of equipment that was needlessly connected to the internet getting hackedn then sure, those are way up.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by accrual on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:57PM (#50062097)
What am I missing? Of course the user cares if their food has been stored at the proper temperature from production to transit to the shelf. They don't care that this specific implementation clearly had a security vulnerability, they just want to check out and get back to their lives (and not get sick), but there's no way this whole setup was completely unnecessary to produce that desired outcome, flawed or not.

Maybe we throw it all away and go to 1990s-style grocery chain management, hire a bunch of people, and costs go up while reliability and monitoring shifts to humans. But that doesn't mesh with consumer expectations on price, which is probably how the whole system originated.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by dalyons on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:00PM (#50062146)
And you know what the customer needs? Or is this just a personal feeling. There’s multiple people from the industry chiming in on these threads as to why this is needed.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by Johnny555 on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:42PM (#50061896)
You don't need remote command and control to tell you if your single truck chiller is working, you can just go look at the thermostat. But a company needs it to confirm that the chillers are working and at a safe temperature across all 1,000 trucks in their fleet.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by jakeydus on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:57PM (#50063624)
That's remote monitoring, though, not remote operation. Very different threat vector.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by Johnny555 on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:50PM (#50064647)
Along with remote monitoring comes automatic remediation. "Your reefer is set to 40F degrees, but your cargo manifest says that you're hauling frozen chicken, we set it to 0F."

Or "Your reefer is set to 35 degrees but you're hauling chilled beer, we set it to 40 degrees to save fuel"

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by socializer on Monday October 12, 2026 @02:52PM (#50061044)
And yet, supermarkets existed in the year 2000, selling products at comparable or lower inflation-adjusted prices, without any of this connectivity.

Yes, a lot of it exists to squeeze a bit more of a margin out of the business, but come on. The alternative isn't going back to the Middle Ages, it's shaving 0.1% off the profit margin. It's OK to wonder if the risk is worth it.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by volkl48 on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:51PM (#50062015)
Grocery stores infamously have some of the lowest margins in all of retail and typically hover in the 1-3% range. As a sector they have about zero room for inefficiency and have to be this aggressive about chasing operating cost reductions.

The increased profits that have occurred in recent decades have landed with the big food companies, not with the retail chains selling their products at very little margin.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by Barbing on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:35PM (#50063368)
Wonder the margins on those $9 boxes of Cheerios at major California grocers.

They did promise to increase the cost of breakfast a couple years ago.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by to11mtm on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:33PM (#50064014)
Well, for whatever it's worth, I think the closest manufacturing facility for those would be in Iowa. They had a plant in California but it closed in 2015.

AKA, the decade where everyone bought way too much into the 'Just do JIT supply chain for the manufacturing location to warehouse tail and pretend we are Amazon' bullshit.

I put it that way because it is short-sighted to not consider that transportation costs will always increase over time (i.e. fuel prices, wages of drivers) and shipping a final product over that long of a distance (i.e. at least half of the country, and instead of shipping grain to process it is finished boxes which is less efficient for volume) and yet they made that choice.

Where it got nasty is that when the average consumer base decided it was fine to pay dealer markups on cars because of the parts issues that industry saw from their JIT shortsights, everyone saw dollar signs instead of a problem to fix.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by Barbing on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:14PM (#50064875)
Wonder the max price a company would be charged to ship a trailer of the largest boxes of Cheerios from say Maine to San Diego. Maybe fifty cents a box? You got me curious about the breakdown of the $9.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by to11mtm on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:28PM (#50079811)
I'll admit I'm curious about the cost breakdown myself.

I did go ahead and do a query against gemini, and the estimate is 25 cents a box after considering long tail expenses (i.e. fuel, CARB premiums, etc.)

So, Less than you thought and way less than even I initially expected.

Mea culpa on my end, I wonder where the other parts of the price are coming from.

I do have other thoughts, but don't know California labor laws and the like enough to guess.

e.x. I know one big factor in the 'slowing' of inflation of grocery prices in my state over the last 20 years, has been the erosion of pay/benefits for workers. If California is still guaranteeing that for the workers (decent health care, at least a couple weeks of vacation time, etc.) and it's built into the cost... makes sense and TBH I wouldn't hate paying extra for that. Grocers here have with only a few exceptions gotten terrible.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by account42 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:59AM (#50070282)
A lot of supermarkets here own their own "budget" food brands and for many items they are not that far off from the competition in price.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by __MatrixMan__ on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:21PM (#50062443)
Yeah, I worked at one during that time. The amount of food we threw away on a regular basis was incredible.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by account42 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:01AM (#50070310)
Seems like these days stores just keep it on the shelves instead of throwing it away. The produce quality in even the more expensive stores here is abysmal.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:59PM (#50062122)
That's the work that goes into hiding the "other half" of the inflation (i.e. the 2x diff between reported inflation and what you can actually see in your life).
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by karahime on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:11PM (#50061332)
Except that in this case, the possibility of something like this probably is worth it, because system vulnerabilities are solvable problems, while ignoring the ability to improve system efficiency is a static stance. A lot of things have driven up the price of groceries since that time. You mention "comparable or lower inflation adjusted prices", but this hides the fact that the inflation adjusted basket of groceries in the US is near inflation (105% vs a baseline of 94%), while the input costs to that supply chain (like labor, and diesel) have gone up faster. The efficiency isn't doing nothing, grocery prices would almost definitely be higher without it.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by EQYV on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:31PM (#50061711)
> because system vulnerabilities are solvable problems

If only…

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by karahime on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:42PM (#50061900)
That's why I spoke of them in the plural. Obviously the possibility of a system hack (presumably) won't ever completely go away, but individual vulnerabilities as they appear in specific systems are usually tractable problems, especially if you narrow it to things that one wants solved rather than all possible vulnerabilities regardless of severity or accessibility.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by DemocracyFTW2 on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:25PM (#50061604)
> system vulnerabilities are solvable problems

Which apparently why after >2000yrs of effort from both sides we now, finally!, have locks that no lockpicker can compromise.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:02PM (#50062173)
That's not what "vulnerabilities are solvable problems" means, except maybe for cybersecurity maximalists who believe that, "bro, add passkeys, and just one more thing, attestation, and W^X, and ..., and there will never be vulnerabilities".

Vulnerabilities will always exist. Systems will always be hackable. You solve the problem by patching what you can, and cleaning up after what gets exploited, if and when it gets exploited.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by pessimizer on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:21PM (#50061535)
> the inflation adjusted basket of groceries in the US is near inflation

You must not mean what you have said here. If so, you are double-dipping.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by petesergeant on Monday October 12, 2026 @02:57PM (#50061113)
How would you stay in business if your competitor was offering 20% off your prices because they had better logistics and tracking? Ask consumers to eat the cost due to their latent demand for, uh, inefficient delivery and food spoilage?
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by socializer on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:09PM (#50061295)
Are you saying that stores in the 2000s were throwing away 20% more of their total revenue than they are today? That sounds crazy, especially given that the prices - again - seem pretty much the same or higher if you correct for inflation.

But more to the point, there's plenty of grocery stores that ask 20% more than their competitors and are doing just fine; in fact, constant price changes and promotions make it impossible for consumers to really compare if Safeway is cheaper than Whole Foods, so people usually go to the place that's physically closer, has better selection, or better vibes. I can't even know if a 12-pack of Coca-Cola is going to be $6.99 or $9.99 today.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by petesergeant on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:59PM (#50062133)
Choose your own number, but it has to be large enough that supermarkets decided the CapEx was worth it, and also large enough that once one did it, the rest followed suit.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by PunchyHamster on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:47PM (#50062837)
It's not even significant cost. The main cost is still the hardware, not electronics driving it, and especially not a tiny module that talks with electronics to send/receive commands/metrics
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by seb1204 on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:48PM (#50063512)
Coca cola is a bad example as it does not require refrigeration during transport and does not spoil fast (at all?).
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by asdff on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:02PM (#50061184)
This is already the case in the grocery market. There are various leaner and more efficient operators offering the same goods for lower prices, sometimes a lot lower than just 20%. However most people don't think to shop at the various Grocery Outlet's or Food4Less's. Working class is wise to it but not really further up the class ladder. They don't think much at all and reflexively go to their ralphs, which plays the opposite game where they have higher prices such that they might occasionally mark them lower and make you think you are getting a deal. Some people are even going to erewhon.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by hcs on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:00PM (#50061145)
There are numbers between 0.1% and 20%
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by user43928 on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:06PM (#50063081)
I think it's an interesting question.

I would be interested to know what the damage caused by this attack is compared to savings over a system where thermostats need to be adjusted on-site.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by jltsiren on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:50PM (#50064177)
It looks more like they set a target level for shortages and then try to minimize waste without exceeding that level. Almost every time I go to Safeway, they have run out of some items I intended to buy. Trader Joe's is more reliable, probably because they have fewer items in stock.
Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by titzer on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:50PM (#50064648)
> The entire supply chain coordinates using these embedded sensors and control systems to make sure you always have safe food available at the lowest possible cost.

I think the entire supply chain is making sure it has maximum profits extractable by law and any other emergent phenomena you observe is serendipitous and probably temporary, damaged or dropped as soon as the regulatory environment or marketplace changes to allow another dime of profit.

Re:Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European su... by djaro on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @12:21PM (#50074235)
and the law says food must be safe, and to attract buyers costs must be similar or lower than the competition.

Of course in a cynical view companies only try to "generate profit" but usually generating profit is tied to providing some sort of service or product, and people like to buy good products