News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:52PM (#49987929)
I put "loophole" in quotes for a reason.

The person in question was arrested and charged with tax evasion and filing a false sales tax return. What he is alleged to have done is illegal.

The state was under no obligation to alert him to the fact that they believed he had committed tax evasion and filing a false sales tax return before they arrested him and charged him with a crime.

What he seems to have expected was an opportunity to pay to settle a criminal charge before it landed him in cuffs. This I should be able to pay to make it go away attitude seems especially prevalent in American society today.

This Montana car registration scheme is, I believe, often referred to as "loophole" not because it's legal but because so many people have been able to get away with it without consequence that it is seen by many as relatively low-risk.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by NDlurker on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:56PM (#49987954)
How about we go after Delaware and South Dakota registered corporations before we go after a few people registering their cars with Montana LLCs?
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:05AM (#49988025)
Huh? There is nothing illegal about setting up a corporation in Delaware or South Dakota.

If you have a Delaware corporation doing business in, say, California, and you refuse to register as a foreign corporation in California and follow the laws applicable to businesses in California, that is a different matter.

The Delaware corporation is perfectly legal; the failing to follow California's laws when your company is doing business there isn't.

Over half the Fortune 500 is incorporated in Delaware. Countless private companies are incorporated in Delaware and other states, with their owners properly registering as foreign corporations and paying applicable taxes and fees in second states where they do business.

The person in question wasn't arrested for buying and registering a car in Montana. He was arrested for not paying the tax he owed on it under Tennessee law after he brought it into Tennessee. The law there states that sales or use tax is owed on a vehicle if the vehicle is primarily housed and operated in the state.

Under Tennessee law, you are also required to change an out-of-state vehicle's registration to Tennessee if it's brought into the state and operated there for more than 30 days.

So, in summary, you can buy a car in Montana and pay no sales tax and it's not a crime. It becomes a crime when you use the Montana purchase to evade paying taxes in another state where you actually use and house the car.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by dozerly on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:47AM (#49988318)
Just in case you’re not aware, people have problems with Delaware LLCs because:

A) They can be used relatively easily (compared to other states) as shell companies because you do not have to identify yourself publicly when minting the company. B) The legal process corporations can choose to go through in Delaware are extremely advantageous to corporations (look up The Court of Chancery)

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by refurb on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:17AM (#49989798)
What do you mean “shell companies”? Most Delaware corporations don’t hide their identities.

And yes, the legal process is advantageous in DE because the courts have a massive body of prior law. Decisions are made quickly. It doesn’t mean the courts routinely rule for corporations.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:31AM (#49988644)
Are US companies, including Delaware LLCs, used as shells for dubious purposes? Yes. That the US is one of the better places to set up a shell company is a not-so-secret secret.

But it's not clear what use case you have in mind, and I think your comment deserves some qualification:

1. Even if disclosure of your name and personal details isn't required to set up a Delaware LLC, almost everyone is going to be identified anyway: through the registered agent, the EIN you obtain from the IRS, your bank. Sure, if you have a team of lawyers and layers of layers of shell companies across multiple jurisdictions, it's trivially easy to keep your ownership pretty effectively hidden but the minute you have any assets in or moving through the US, it's trivially easy for the authorities to figure out who you are once they have a reason to.

2. The legal "advantages" of Delaware basically aren't relevant to single-member/closely-held companies because you're not going to have any disputes with yourself over the corporate structure. If your Delaware entity is doing business in other states, you are exposed to the laws of those states as far as your business operations are concerned.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by kristjansson on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:04AM (#49988445)
Delaware law is not so much favorable as it is well-trodden. Of all places here we should understand the value of the network effect.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by dozerly on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:32AM (#49988655)
Idk, I just have zero faith that corporations are not dumping money on the law decision makers for favorable outcomes.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by iamnothere on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:26AM (#49991235)
It’s not so much a problem anymore. Delaware is mainly used for consistency and ease of acquisition. It’s Western states like Nevada and Wyoming that are becoming more advantageous for owners, but this isn’t always a good thing if you intend to sell the company or seek funding.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by hvb2 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:58AM (#49988406)
Which is why they're all registered there. And the state of Delaware gets a fortune as a result from all the activity it creates.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by dozerly on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:00AM (#49988424)
Yes, the fact that states can race to the bottom of requirements to promote themselves as LLC havens is a broken system not an intentional one.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by notpushkin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:36AM (#49989526)
The purpose of the system is what it does.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by hvb2 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:36AM (#49989924)
You can't have 'power to the states' and not have them compete

Does that mean a race to the bottom? Yes.

Bit dont worry, the real bottom is when they would actually start bidding against each other with tax incentives. Oh wait...

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by dozerly on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:11PM (#49998154)
If a race to the bottom is incentivized then federal oversight needs to maintain some standards… if a states policy consisted of being able to murder someone from another state, we have federal policy to keep that in check. States rights does not mean unchecked states rights.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by antonvs on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:53AM (#49990038)
> …not an intentional one.

Why do you believe that?

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by atoav on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:11AM (#49988492)
Idk, where I live companies need to be tied to real people, so Delaware LLCs sound as shady as it gets to me.

But I was also never a fan of using one problem to justify not going after another. We ought to be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.

Someone who does not pay their taxes, be it a legal or illegal loophole, does not pay their fair share within the society they live in. It is not us people against the state, it is us people who are the state.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by consensus1 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:25AM (#49989857)
Delaware LLCs are tied to real people
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by BLKNSLVR on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:17AM (#49988997)
> Over half the Fortune 500 is incorporated in Delaware

If that's not the reddest of red flags, I don't know what is.

It is, however, off-topic for this thread.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by miki123211 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:05AM (#49989336)
THe problem is what "doing business" means (and what it should mean) for internet companies.

If you're an American company selling your stuff to German users, are you doing business in Germany? What if you don't have a German translation of your site, don't accept Germany-specific payment methods and don't advertise in Germany-specific channels, but still ship there? What if your products are delivered electronically, and you don't apply any IP blocks? What if you IP block Germany, but don't block VPN use? What if you do block VPN use, but still process personal data of German citizens (even without giving them access to your systems)? What if you do everything in your power to stop German users from using your site, but the site is free and VPN detection isn't 100% reliable, so some users do slip through?

Just to be clear, there are no good answers here, and the law (and international law in particular) is wholly unprepared for the realities of the internet.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by xxs on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:17AM (#49989796)
> stuff to German users, are you doing business in Germany

Yes, and the VAT must be paid. You'd need to have some EU member state registration to do so (and still pay the correct VAT-rate, it's different per country). If it's business-to-business it'd be somewhat different.

>but still ship there

The local folks will have to customs-clear it themselves, pay the import tax AND the VAT. It's doable but very consumer unfriendly and likely won't be doing much business at all.

With the regards to topic - the tax is still very much paid.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by piva00 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:50AM (#49989620)
> What if you don't have a German translation of your site, don't accept Germany-specific payment methods and don't advertise in Germany-specific channels, but still ship there?

Shipping there demonstrates willingness, that is the sales contract (shipping to the customer address), advertising or localisation don't matter since those aren't a "contract" but the final sale with shipment is. It's quite clear-cut.

> What if you do everything in your power to stop German users from using your site, but the site is free and VPN detection isn't 100% reliable, so some users do slip through?

If you can demonstrate that you had active safeguards to not allow someone in Germany to use your product, and these users had to find workarounds to access it, you are protected.

There are good answers: if you willingly delivery a service or a product to a resident of a country you are subject to its laws.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:18AM (#49989424)
The law is not as unprepared as you seem to think.

The law in most countries, including Germany, is very clear: if you're going to sell your products or services to individuals and businesses in those countries, you become subject to the laws applicable to that type of transaction in those countries.

If you don't want to be subject to German law, don't sell products or services to people in Germany.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by notpushkin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:34AM (#49989511)
Yep, the law is ruthless. However, for compliance reasons just checking the IP and the payment method is probably enough (definitely check that with a lawyer and a tax advisor; IANAL).
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by Propelloni on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:56AM (#49990061)
Why so complicated? Ask yourself how you find out if someone is living in country foo. By looking at the postal address, of course. If the shipping or billing address is in country foo, e.g. Germany, the shipment is subject to country foo's law. Just block potential customers from addresses in countries you don't want to deal with. It's really easy.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by notpushkin on Thursday October 08, 2026 @04:45AM (#50003376)
This works for physical goods. For SaaS stuff, if you look at the billing address only, you’ll just get a ton of users from 67 Keysmash Lane, Anytown, 10000 CA, US. (Yeah that’s not a real zipcode for CA, but don’t tell me you’re validating those and don’t even look at the IP addresses :-)

This could give you plausible deniability perhaps, if you do want users from Germany, but don’t want to deal with German laws, and are willing to argue in the German court that you didn’t know these users are from Germany because they’ve said “I’m not from Germany, pinky promise”. (Or if you have no intention of ever being in Germany and are sure that Germany can’t get to your bank accounts to fine you.)

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by Propelloni on Friday October 09, 2026 @05:27AM (#50018123)
No, I'd look at IP addresses before validating zipcodes, true ;) What I'm thinking is, if someone wants to deceive a service provider about her billing address, that's a social problem. Social problems are insanely hard to fix with technology, if at all.

So what is reasonable to request from the service provider here? Checking billing address and IP is reasonable, but beyond that? Maybe bank account? But in Europe a German can have a bank account in France, it is not even a big deal. Maybe taxation should follow bank accounts? I have an account in Luxembourg, so I'm set ;)

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by BLKNSLVR on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:15AM (#49988979)
Absolutely.

But make it illegal first. Make sure it's a "loophole" as opposed to what it currently appears to be: a specifically crafted loophole that over half the Fortune 500 can fit through.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:44AM (#49989181)
> ...a specifically crafted loophole that over half the Fortune 500 can fit through.

There is no "loophole".

It is perfectly legitimate for a company to be incorporated in Delaware and to register as a foreign corporation in other states where it has a presence/does business. You can pick any random Fortune 500 company and look up its registrations in the states where it does business.

This is not remotely similar to setting up a shell LLC in Montana, purchasing a vehicle through it in Montana to avoid sales tax in another state, registering it in Montana and then physically moving it to another state without changing the registration and paying the use tax as required by law in that state.

The crime here is not about setting up a Montana LLC. Nothing about the Montana LLC made this car tax evasion scheme even arguably legal.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by collabs on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:31AM (#49990819)
I feel like the law should differentiate a rich person doing this with many luxury cars versus me with one car who maybe in a few years needs to move across states.

For example, if I own a 2014 Nissan Versa and I register it in Colorado in January 2020 and then I need to move to Texas in August, I won't get Texas plates immediately when I get to Texas. I've "paid up" in Colorado for as long as my tags are good. I shouldn't have to get a Texas license plate until my existing one expires. However, I will eventually get Texas tags, just a few months too late.

Also I don't mind people going to Montana and buying luxury cars there if the cars actually stay in Montana. However, there should be scrutiny on these expensive toys more than regular cars we need to live because we don't have a decent transit story.

I feel like intent and magnitude should play a big role in legislation.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ben_w on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:33AM (#49990831)
> It is perfectly legitimate for a company to be incorporated in Delaware and to register as a foreign corporation in other states where it has a presence/does business. You can pick any random Fortune 500 company and look up its registrations in the states where it does business.

It may be legal, but it's rather more questionable if it's legitimate: the latter is a value statement in casual language, even if legal jargon would be more precise.

If I do business with people in all states of the USA*, there should not be any particular state which attracts a majority of big (and everything bigger than "small") business registrations: other than network effects (e.g. everyone else does it so the corporate lawyers are all right there), anything pushing so many businesses to choose one specific state, be that for taxation or for a court system that presumes more in favour of businesses than elsewhere, this creates an uneven playing field for other states and who gets what powers of enforcement for business (/consumer) laws they pass.

Like, people here argue the EU is "anti-business": well, the American-registered factories (Tesla) and American-owned IT company offices (Apple, Microsoft, Google, etc.) are still here, and the shares are publicly traded so even us Europeans can own them, but they count as "American" because of where they (/their parent companies) are registered. Even Google Deep Mind (HQ: London) gets called "American" due to the ownership structure.

* A similar argument applies to the EU

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:22AM (#49991764)
I don't have time to go into a long-winded explanation of why so many corporations are set up in Delaware (there's plenty of information online about this) but I want to address this point:

> this creates an uneven playing field for other states and who gets what powers of enforcement for business (/consumer) laws they pass.

Setting up your company in Delaware does not mean that you are exempt from the business and consumer protection laws in other states.

If you're a Delaware company and you violate consumer protection laws in California, violate environmental protection laws in Colorado, defraud investors in Maryland, etc., the relevant authorities/powers in those states will all be able to exercise jurisdiction over you.

Being incorporated in Delaware does not mean you have free reign to do whatever you want in any other state and have disputes over your actions adjudicated in Delaware.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by antonvs on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:49AM (#49990002)
> This I should be able to pay to make it go away attitude seems especially prevalent in American society today.

It works for the billionaire class, why shouldn’t it work for everyone else?

This is what’s ultimately going to kill what’s happening in the US today: when people in power decide that the rule of law is just a suggestion, they’re going to find that there are people willing to use that against them in ways that they’re not going to like.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:17AM (#49991716)
> It works for the billionaire class, why shouldn’t it work for everyone else?

As George Carlin said, "It's a big club...and you ain't in it!"

When it comes to financial crime, billionaires get benefits, plebs get prison.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by a5seo on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:53AM (#49990035)
Creating a LLC or other entity with no purpose except [checks notes] tax avoidance is not legal. That’s about as fundamental of a tax law as there is.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:43AM (#49990405)
Setting up the LLC is not illegal. On its own, this is not tax evasion.

The tax evasion comes in when you fail to pay the use tax due and make false declarations or intentionally omit information when you make representations to the government (i.e. in tax filings).

The individual in question could have set up a Montana LLC, purchased a vehicle through it, paid the use tax due when he moved it to Tennessee and changed the registration within the 30 day limit.

Of course, there is no benefit of going out of your way to buy a car in Montana if you don't intend to drive it there, but the charges against this person relate to his failure to pay tax, not the mere fact that he set up an LLC.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by lesuorac on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:29AM (#49991259)
Whats the penalty though?

If its just a monetary fine then there’s little reason to arrest somebody to immediately release them when you could’ve just told the accountant he needs to pay a fine or he’s going to be arrested.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by ElProlactin on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:15AM (#49991692)
Generally-speaking, this type of tax evasion is not treated the same as, say, making a mistake on a tax return that results in you owing a bunch of money to the state.

It's akin to intentionally defrauding the state.

A quick Google search indicates that willful tax evasion is a Class E felony in Tennessee, with a potential prison term of 1-6 years.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:57AM (#49991510)
You could say that about a lot of crimes, but that's not how it works.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by iamnothere on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:19AM (#49991184)
In current terminology, tax avoidance is legal, tax evasion is not.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by throwaway_compa on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:38AM (#49990382)
"Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury; there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes."

Gregory v. Helvering, decided by the US Supreme Court in 1935.

Edit: So if it's a legal arrangement that reduces taxes, then yes, it's legal.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by cowlevel on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:35AM (#49994317)
There's probably a law that makes this arrangement illegal.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by cranky908canuck on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:33PM (#50000206)
At least in some jurisdictions, arrangements solely for the purpose of avoiding taxes (barring explicit carve-outs) are not permitted.

https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/programs/about-canad...

TLDR: if the only reason for a transaction is tax avoidance, it may not be "illegal", but it may be disallowed (and presumably incorporated in subsequent legislation).

Similar is "wash sale" legislation: for example, selling a security for a tax loss and

- buying it back within 30 days

- buying a call option on that security.

I will guess that the former might get you just a reassessment (the first time). The latter... well, you're smart enough to know about options and tax-loss sale, now you need to demonstrate that you didn't do it for tax avoidance.

Not sure what US law (federal and gazillion states) has on this.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by quietbritishjim on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @09:44AM (#49992806)
Sounds sensible but I don't think that's actually a law. If doing something via a business legally reduces your tax bill then it is, by definition, legal.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by anon84873628 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:33AM (#49994285)
As mentioned in the article, the exception is intended for when the majority of the business is conducted in the other state. If in fact you don't do any business in the other state at all, then you are lying and evading taxes. The law is not about how you set things up on Day 1, it's about whether your ongoing behavior is actually consistent with the requirements of the law.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by quietbritishjim on Friday October 09, 2026 @04:10AM (#50017525)
Fair enough, but that just proves my point: that's a specific law about when you're allowed to do this.

The parent commenter seemed to be saying that if you could reduce your tax burden by putting something through a business then that's illegal even if you've not broken any specific laws.

Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole by scoofy on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:31PM (#49996024)
I think that could be actually illegal. The fact that you can do it, and also avoid taxes is different than doing specifically to avoid taxes.