Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole
by cowlevel on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:35AM
(#49994317)
There's probably a law that makes this arrangement illegal.
Re:How California Closed the Montana License Plate Loophole
by cranky908canuck on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:33PM
(#50000206)
At least in some jurisdictions, arrangements solely for the purpose of avoiding taxes (barring explicit carve-outs) are not permitted.
https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/programs/about-canad...
TLDR: if the only reason for a transaction is tax avoidance, it may not be "illegal", but it may be disallowed (and presumably incorporated in subsequent legislation).
Similar is "wash sale" legislation: for example, selling a security for a tax loss and
- buying it back within 30 days
- buying a call option on that security.
I will guess that the former might get you just a reassessment (the first time). The latter... well, you're smart enough to know about options and tax-loss sale, now you need to demonstrate that you didn't do it for tax avoidance.
Not sure what US law (federal and gazillion states) has on this.
Gregory v. Helvering, decided by the US Supreme Court in 1935.
Edit: So if it's a legal arrangement that reduces taxes, then yes, it's legal.