News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:22AM (#49964531)
> half that money goes to taxes

That is a misguided simplification. Please correct this, before anyone starts to believe it for real.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by alberto-m on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:40AM (#49964769)
More precisely, given a salary of 85'000€, about 17'500 (20.5%) goes into income tax and about 16'800 (19.7%) goes into social contributions, though one can reduce the latter by taking a private health insurance*. The remaining 60% (Nettolohn) can be used to purchase things, usually paying 19% of VAT on them (though rent is exempt and food has a lower tax).

So, “half goes away in taxes” is an exaggeration, but I can totally sympathize with the feeling. Especially since the quality of healthcare is declining and the pay-as-you-go pension system is only built to benefit the current generation of pensioners.

* note that, if one is earning less than 77'000€ today or less than 84'150€ in 2027, one is prohibited to switch to a private insurance. One of the most regressive precepts of the German system.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sva_ on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:51AM (#49964924)
I think you should also mention the ~17k Euro social contributions that your employer pays on top, which could otherwise be part of your salary. Then it is actually pretty much 50%
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by KellyCriterion on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:15AM (#49965189)
There are two terms in German salary:

"visible" and "invisble" Brutto. The one is without "contributions from employer", which is a lie anyway since an employer makes a total comp perspective and he for sure includes his "contribution" into that

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by alberto-m on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:03AM (#49965055)
Correct: if one takes as basis not the Bruttolohn but the total cost for the company, the sum of taxes and mandatory social contribution can very well reach the half of the income. The method of splitting employer-side and employee-side deductions seems just there to hide this fact.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:25AM (#49965331)
Most taxes are deducted when money is transferred between two parties. The view that one party pays it all (Brutto-Netto and VAT) seems wrong to me.

I anyway doubt that the wages would be at the same standard if there wouldn't be any deductions (from the beginning). Wages in expensive cities are higher because the cost of living must be matched. Similarly salary negotiations account for deductions. Nobody wants a job that doesn't pay the bills.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by vel0city on Monday October 05, 2026 @12:46PM (#49967249)
US also has federal employer-paid payroll taxes the employee usually doesn't see or think about.

For a $110k salary the federal employer paid payroll taxes would be almost $8,500, or ~7.69%. They would also pay some amount to unemployment insurance, but that rate depends a lot state by state.

I realize that's less than the Euro taxes, just wanted to share so everyone is aware of these often forgotten US taxes when compared.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ethbr1 on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:48PM (#49970490)
A US employer also generally provides health insurance and retirement, of which they pay a large piece.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by Kirby64 on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:49PM (#49971870)
> A US employer also generally provides health insurance and retirement, of which they pay a large piece.

Health insurance yes, retirement… no, not really. They may offer a 401k plan and some might even offer a match, but most companies offer at most a 4% salary match (dollar for dollar, or sometimes 50c per dollar).

So, it’s a vehicle to invest retirement funds with some tax advantages, but it’s not really “providing” it like you would subsidized healthcare.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by vel0city on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:41PM (#49971238)
For a role like that, they'd likely cover a decent chunk of the premium cost. Its not always the full cost though, FWIW. People earning such a wage paying for the rest of their family often still spend hundreds of dollars a month for their premiums, along with also needing to stash a few hundred dollars a month towards healthcare savings whether in an HSA or an FSA.

I do agree though, such a thing should also be considered when thinking about total cost of the compensation. Things definitely start getting a bit fuzzier though. You then also get stuff like HSA matching, 401k matching, etc.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ethbr1 on Monday October 05, 2026 @07:16PM (#49972078)
US employer health care is typically ~65% employer paid, 35% employee paid. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ebs2.t04.htm
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by preg_match on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:34PM (#49973085)
To be fair this is the case in the US, too. Your employer has to pay a bunch of taxes on your behalf.

People think the US has a low tax burden, it does not. Even in "low tax" states like Texas. And even more so when you consider "unofficial" taxes.

My health insurance surely costs my employer ~1500 dollars a month. That's quite a big chunk of paycheck that I don't get to see. But that's how it works in the US. And that's just my employers part. I, of course, have a deductible, copays, premiums and all.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by overfeed on Monday October 05, 2026 @11:17PM (#49973748)
> Even in "low tax" states like Texas. And even more so when you consider "unofficial" taxes.

"Low tax" states just shift their tax base from income to something else - usually property or energy.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:18AM (#49965237)
Thank you.

I think it is important to be (at least a bit) precise in this debate.

I dislike the wording "social contribution", as these are (mandatory) insurances that benefit the insured person in case of sickness, retirement, loss of employment, etc. Discussion about the cost efficiency and fairness of the system are warranted, of course. Anyway, the current generation of retirees benefit greatly from it, so for them at least it was worth paying.

Since you are accounting all those taxes, including the VAT on the citizen's side, companies only pay the Arbeitgeberanteil (you didn't mention) and the taxes on profit?

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:57AM (#49975980)
> I dislike the wording "social contribution", as these are (mandatory) insurances that benefit the insured person in case of sickness, retirement, loss of employment, etc.

They benefit some insured persons. If everyone benefited equally insurance would not be needed as you could just take the money and pay the doctor directly. But even the expected benefit if you average out unpredictable health issues is far from equal as what you pay doesn't depend on your risk factors. That's what makes it a social contribution. And since you are forced to pay it it's a tax.

> Anyway, the current generation of retirees benefit greatly from it, so for them at least it was worth paying.

You mean the last generation of retirees. The current generatin of "retirees" is forced to slave away the remainder of their lives in the super market checkout and other demeaning jobs. Absolutely despicable outcome considering how much money the state sucks up.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by kuerbel on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:59AM (#49965007)
>One of the most regressive precepts of the German system.

If you mean the existence of two-tier private/public insurance, yes. The two-tier system was abolished in most of Europe for good reason. Either they abolished substitutive private insurance, restricted it, or transformed private insurers into regulated providers of universal basic coverage, e.g. very recently in the Netherlands.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:56AM (#49964965)
Don’t forget the mandatory radio broadcast fee every household has to pay even if you don’t read or watch any of those propaganda channels
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by f1shy on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:43AM (#49965545)
And if we are comparing USA vs Germany, taxes to gas (car fuel) which is much more expensive in the EU, because of taxes.
[dead]
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:38PM (#49970363)
Unfortunately, the price of almost every consumer good is decided based on the price of petrol/diesel even when one doesn't even own a car.
[dead]
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:12PM (#49970835)
for some locally produced goods yes, but still the costs adds up in manufacturing because it's not like all the items/ingredients needed to manufacture one particular thing comes from one small region. Also the petroleum products includes gas used to generate energy in some manufacturing facilities and that again adds up-to the cost.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by encom on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:57AM (#49965713)
Same in Denmark, and it really boils my piss. DR (Danmarks Radio) is 80% trash. If I was dictator in Denmark I would abolish it on the spot. I won't deny that DR produces things that are not trash or only mildly trash, but I have no interest in it. People who want it can fund it themselves. State financed reality TV is an abomination.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @03:24PM (#49969273)
It doesn't seem to be the same then as in Germany. German public broadcast is arguably fine, when compared to private TV and radio broadcasters, many private newspapers and probably all social media platforms.

I don't know how bad it is in Denmark, but keep in mind that journalism that is not subject to profit seeking and independent on whatever billionaire owns the outlet, is not only valuable because you personally consume it, but also because it shapes the public discourse and thus indirectly may have influence on political decisions.

[dead]
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ethbr1 on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:55PM (#49970580)
I mean, AfD doesn't seem to be overly fond of Jews or immigrants...
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:01PM (#49970677)
You must be living in a parallel universe because in the current one we're living in there has never been a AfD rally/protest for pro-palestine ever.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by em-bee on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:03PM (#49971493)
i agree that the private TV is no better, and the public TV has some good stuff. but what confuses me every time is that the law in germany expressly forbids the public funding of printed newspapers because it could be used as a propaganda tool but the same law does allow the funding of radio and TV and internet publications (the last is now really weird of you consider that printed newspapers are now online too)
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by encom on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:26AM (#49974176)
But a state financed news outlet is no better, because it invariably ends up being government propaganda, since that's the hand that feeds it.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:42AM (#49975045)
There is no perfect world, and so it isn't perfect, but the separation between financing and content selection is there.

IMO it doesn't need to be perfectly neutral and independent to be valuable for the population and the democracy. I'd love for it to be without the flaws the system has, I just think it is hard to install the perfect system, given the incentives of the involved decision-makers.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:48AM (#49975922)
So then you can choose to pay for it but don't force those of us who vehemently disagree to pay as well.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:11PM (#49980576)
That is such a lame demand. Everybody being forced to pay for public broadcast is just the same as for every tax and the mandatory social security. People not reading books pay taxes that go to public libraries. People rich enough to send their children to private schools still have to pay taxes that go to public schools. People very much opposed to nuclear energy have payed taxes that went into nuclear power plants. People much opposed to the closure of the nuclear power plants payed taxes that were used to close down those power plants. That's how the system works, for better or worse.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:41AM (#49989565)
No, it is specifically totally-not-a-tax because a tax for propaganda would be unconstitutional. Nor would the salaries it pays as well as the money it pumps into further private companies be even remotely acceptable for public institutions.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:46AM (#49975907)
No the ÖRR are not fine. Making students pay so talkshow millionaires can live luxurious lifestyles is not fine. Forcing people to fincance propagande against their own interests is not fine. Giving completely one sided reporting such a special platform is not fine.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @03:24PM (#49969284)
Is there any news source you wouldn't call propaganda?
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:12PM (#49970007)
Not really, there are certain very well researched and written articles which present the facts as they are and letting the audience to use their own judgment and form an opinion in few news outlets. But most of the time every news outlet is just pushing their own political, cultural or doomsday agenda.

The German public broadcasters, especially the Tagesschau, are the worst.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ethbr1 on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:52PM (#49970543)
The solution to this is making sure to watch news from opposing viewpoints, not avoiding news though.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:05PM (#49970722)
I watched the first minutes of the video, but the narration is pretty cringe, I couldn't bear it. It didn't say anything about subtle propaganda, seemed to be mostly Schadenfreude.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by em-bee on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:56PM (#49971412)
the key criticism seems to be that they interviewed people on the street that turned out to be either known political activists or their own employees or contractors. in other words instead of asking random people they picked people they knew.

one criticism i didn't get towards the end is that one particular politician would always give the same response to the same question. that confused me because why wouldn't she? why is that poor? doesn't make any sense to me. but that's unrelated to the criticism of the TV reporting.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by sajithdilshan on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:16PM (#49970897)
Check the timestamp from 4:00-5:10 and 5:50-6:30. One would actually think that those were just random people on the street and their opinion, but they were strategically placed insiders.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:42AM (#49975865)
Yes, one I could choose to not financially support when its clearly acting against my interests.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:40AM (#49975854)
A horrible regressive tax that should be abolished, as should be the "news" and entertainment it pays for, but it's not very relevant cost for someone one who makes close to 100k.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by usewik on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:29AM (#49964621)
Having worked in another EU country, I can attest that I paid as much as 56% in taxes, so I believe a guy who says that he works in Germany and pays half in taxes. If you have other data, you are welcome to present it.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:36AM (#49964713)
If you make 90k in Germany, you pay around 36k to mandatory (varying degrees) insurance/pension plus taxes if you're single. About 19.5k of that are actual taxes. If you're married/have children that total can drop to ~30k and will include health insurance for your entire family unit.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by criddell on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:01AM (#49965031)
If these people are to be believed, tax freedom day (the day you stop paying taxes and start paying yourself) in Germany is July 11 so just over 50%.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Freedom_Day

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:39AM (#49965496)
I just gave you the actual numbers. The same numbers you will quickly get by using any of the many available net income calculators for Germany[0].

If you have a different idea, feel free to break the 90k down yourself. Don't lazily push the work on other people, asking them to puzzle together where some neglected Wikipedia articles' table of magic numbers actually comes from. Hint: It's a number made up by an interest group called the "German Taxpayers Federation", representing mostly entrepreneurs and wealthy taxpayers. The number being opaque is intentional, because its purpose is to mislead and support their advocacy for tax cuts.

But by all means, don't let me stand in the way of your right to blindly believe whatever someone else wants you to. God forbid we input a five digit number into a calculator.

What will it take? A notarially certified copy of tax returns mailed to your address?

[0] First Google result: https://www.brutto-netto-rechner.info/gehalt/gross_net_calcu...

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by criddell on Monday October 05, 2026 @11:19AM (#49965996)
You have to add in all the other taxes as well. For example VAT, gasoline, and property taxes are significant. That's generally what tax freedom day is meant to mean - when an average citizen is done paying all taxes.

Edit: I was curious what the answer might be and couldn't find much. One source calculates the tax burden to be about 53% of income.

https://www.steuerzahler.de/belastungs-check/?L=0

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @11:38AM (#49966287)
> https://www.steuerzahler.de/belastungs-check/?L=0

The link you provided is the web page of the interest group I mentioned. They will literally try any trick in the book to get that number up, including adding a bunch of things that aren't even taxes, a boatload of things they call "quasi-taxes" with numbers presumably pulled from their ass, and adding expenses your employer incurs only to subtract them again immediately. Anything to get that percentage number up.

But even they don't even call the resulting number "tax burden" - that'd be transparently stupid. They more generally call it a "burden ratio" (Belastungsquote).

Just to give you an idea of how ridiculous their calculations are: If my wages are 90k in Germany, they do their calculations as if I earned ~105k just so they can immediately subtract the entire 15k again and call it a burden (for expenses my employer pays on my behalf). Does this still sound like something you can easily compare one country to the next and draw useful conclusions from? Of course not. In the next country it might come from an interest group with a different goal, a government calculation, or a Fox News writer.

> You have to add in all the other taxes as well. For example VAT, gasoline, and property taxes are significant. That's generally what tax freedom day is meant to mean - when an average citizen is done paying all taxes.

What you're trying to get at - hopefully because the alternative is a nonsense number with no purpose other than being a fun fact supporting a discussion about degrees of individual autonomy in modern societies - is called discretionary income, and it's only meaningful when adjusted for cost of living and compared across similar living situations.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by kakacik on Monday October 05, 2026 @12:15PM (#49966821)
> If my wages are 90k in Germany, they do their calculations as if I earned ~105k just so they can immediately subtract the entire 15k again and call it a burden (for expenses my employer pays on my behalf).

Aren't you talking about social contributions that your employer is forced by law to pay on your behalf? You realize that if this was not in place, those money would go directly to you since your salary is whole sum your employer is paying towards your employment? Doesn't seem you grok it fully from your words.

I am not claiming if its good or bad (dramatic global financial changes will test viability of all these systems rather well in upcoming years, I'd expect many people will be unhappy when their naive views hit reality of numbers). I am outside of such system, in mostly private social system in Switzerland (aka I save for myself, mostly) and wouldn't want it any other way.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @12:23PM (#49966920)
If that's the real wage, it should be used when comparing wages internationally. It's however not used as such, because trying to figure out what should and shouldn't be included in that number for each country will result in an even bigger headache. Do we add the average cost of employer-provided health insurance to US wages to keep the number comparable? What about those who self-insure?

In any case, the resulting individual "burden" is meaningless if you don't also quantify individual benefit. As an extreme example, imagine a country in which your income taxes pay for things such as transportation credits usable on gas, public transport and roads, while the neighboring country has mostly private toll roads and low taxes. Another example is health insurance. In Germany it is pretty nearly mandatory with most having some form of insurance, and total spending per citizen is around $9,000. In the US more than 90% are insured and spending is higher, but within the same ballpark.

What does the raw tax/burden tell you here in an international comparison? Fuck all. It's at best usable as a prompt for a philosophical discussion about autonomy, but often merely used for masturbation or making dishonest arguments designed to go over well in establishments specializing in alcoholic beverages - like those of a certain interest group.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by fc417fc802 on Monday October 05, 2026 @03:57PM (#49969801)
> Do we add the average cost of employer-provided health insurance to US wages to keep the number comparable? What about those who self-insure?

Obviously yes, and obviously no. Just as we don't add the price of groceries or rent to wages unless the employer subsidizes those in which case obviously yes we must.

> What does the raw tax/burden tell you here in an international comparison?

It tells you how expensive it is to live there, relatively speaking. Obviously (as you note) that's only half of the discussion just as an expensive appliance might or might not be worth the premium to any particular individual. But you're wrong to dismiss it out of hand as you do. Just as it's disingenuous to dismiss the benefits of (for example) universal healthcare it is also disingenuous to attempt to derail discussion that focuses directly on total cost or effective tax burden or what have you.

What you are dismissing as a "nonsense number" of an "interest group" I would consider one of the most accurate and easily understood quantifications of total cost.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ethbr1 on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:06PM (#49970745)
Imho, parent's point about attempting to quantify costs without balancing them against benefits is valid.

It's meaningless to say "Germans pay X, Americans pay Y" if the two receive completely different benefits in exchange for those rates.

Furthermore, the point that the German system would be paying to individuals if not to the government is somewhat disingenuous. There are a few options.

   1. The government doesn't do it, so private options do at some cost
   2. There's some government-private hybrid
   3. It's not done at all
An example would be parental leave. In the US, it largely doesn't exist to the European extent. Employers don't offer it. You can't buy insurance for it. It just doesn't exist. That's something Germans are getting for existing in the German system.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by fc417fc802 on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:25PM (#49971021)
Yes, as I acknowledged it is only half of the story. Certainly you need more information to make an informed decision about anything. But that doesn't make it meaningless. And generally where people level such dismissals there is conversational context being conveniently ignored (such as happened earlier in this thread).

I'm not sure what point you were trying to make with parental leave as an example. I completely agree with what you wrote but don't see it being at odds with anything said previously.

I think we all know that Germans enjoy substantially more free at point of service public services than those in the US let alone those living in a developing country. Obviously that costs something. Yet when someone brings up the price tag you get a bunch of partisan screeching about how prices are meaningless.

Prices _aren't_ meaningless. The US military (for example) is absurdly expensive. There are lots of things received as a result of that expenditure. Regardless, the relative cost is high and that's not meaningless to point out given that everyone involved in the discussion has at least some conception that there are important differences in the downstream impact.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ajmurmann on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:03AM (#49965056)
Don't forget VAT
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:31AM (#49965397)
I can spend that in whichever tax jurisdiction I want and the VAT rate might be whatever depending on what one buys. If you want to go that route you'd then also have to adjust for cost/quality of living to stay intellectually honest, which means you'd then have to come up with some statistical consumer basket. It's a stupid idea to even start down that route in what fits into HN comments.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by kakacik on Monday October 05, 2026 @12:01PM (#49966644)
Do you pay VAT on almost anything? It affects how much your actual disposable income is and thus literally how much you can purchase.

Nobody said its going to be trivial to calculate, reality doesn't care about that.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by rowanG077 on Monday October 05, 2026 @07:09PM (#49972023)
You always have to cost/quality of living if you go that route. Because that's literally what taxes are for. Anyway I don't think it's fair to not include VAT. For every euro you want to utilize(modulo some exceptions) you have to pay it.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:14AM (#49976091)
3€ fee on every line item for imports says no you cant'.

Yes the exact cost will differ depending on what you buy but that doesn't remove the cost, it just obscures it - which is the point of having so many different taxes.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by ajmurmann on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @10:54AM (#49993711)
It's called PPP and yes, it makes Europe look sightly better but it's still behind the US and that's for median household income not tech income.

I've managed staff all over the US and in Europe and have had access to large corporate pay scales across zones. The difference is so significant that CoL is a total rounding error for software developers.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:16PM (#49980641)
Don't forget that rent is VAT-free
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by chmod775 on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:29AM (#49964626)
You however have to admire getting things that wrong in the same paragraph that tells one to not trust what one sees in Google searches. Though I suppose HN comments would show in Google searches... maybe their humor just went over my head.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by bbmatryoshka on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:49AM (#49964904)
49% of that money goes to taxes
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by pembrook on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:07AM (#49965092)
Sorry, you’re the one who is misguided here.

Government spending as a % of GDP in Germany is exactly 50%. So definitionally half of all money goes to taxes.

Are you counting in VAT on everything OP spends that money on? Are you counting capital gains taxes OP pays when investing that money? Are you counting the taxes paid by the employer for his role (which defacto come out of his pay, just before he gets it)? The property taxes he pays to live?

The employer doesn’t look at the employees salary as the only cost. Employers look at things rationally, using the all-in cost to employ someone (the combined total of all salary and government mandated taxes and benefits contributions). In many European countries this is 2X the persons salary or more.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:31PM (#49980799)
> Are you counting in VAT on everything OP spends that money on? ...

No, I just assumed he spends all his money on rent, which is VAT-free ;-). I also didn't account for his Kindergeld and Elterngeld, Rente, Invalidenrente, Witwenrente, Pension and whatever else that person could have. He didn't share all that information.

> Are you counting the taxes paid by the employer for his role (which defacto come out of his pay, just before he gets it)?

You may have to decide whether the payer or the payee pays the taxes, otherwise you are double-counting it.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by pembrook on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:51PM (#49983932)
I hire people remotely throughout Europe. When we budget for a hire we look at the all-in labor expense, not the persons salary. If the German government didn’t charge us before we even pay the employee, we would just pay it all to the employee.

So it’s a tax he pays whether you want to “brand” it that way or not. Who gets the money changes nothing about our budget for the role.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:52PM (#49995433)
Imagine you want to buy a house. You have a budget for the house. The government takes taxes on the price, which you need to consider in your budget. Does the seller pay the taxes, or do you?
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by pembrook on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:14PM (#49999501)
The seller does, because if the government removed that specific tax, it changes nothing about the market value of the home (competing buyers would also not have to pay that tax, buyer capacity to pay doesn't change either way).

Absent the tax, the seller would simply recoup more of the value of their property.

I think the confusion here is that there exists an economic truth, and then a separate and conflicting language/branding around this economic truth to make it more palatable to people having their money taken from them at gunpoint by the state.

I'm bringing up economic reality, you're rebutting this with the government marketing language.

Yes, I know 'employer contributions' is a clever trick to make people believe they aren't paying as much to government as they are, but in economic reality they are paying for this.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Thursday October 08, 2026 @10:49AM (#50006487)
It is in general the same though for wages, as usually companies are not hiring remotely all over Europe and can choose where the tax is paid, so it is the same for every employee.

I feel like "having their money taken from them at gunpoint" is rage bait language.

Have you ever considered that you benefit from public spending? Infrastructure, etc.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by pembrook on Friday October 09, 2026 @06:03AM (#50018378)
This is not intended as rage bait, I am again just distilling marketing language to reality.

If you don't pay the money your government decides you owe them, they will arrest you and put you in prison if you do not comply in virtually all countries. This is fact, not emotional language.

And yes, I fully acknowledge that authoritarian centralization can achieve the most efficient outcomes in certain areas (like infrastructure, military, utilities, etc).

But let's not lie to ourselves and pretend the government is not a giant monopoly that forces you to buy its products at gunpoint whether they are good or not. Allowing too much % of the GDP be captured by this monopoly, always ends in declining living standards, runaway debts, exit controls and ultimately collapse...every single time it has been tried.

HN doesn't need more pro-government voices, as it is already a a left-leaning audience. It needs the opposite, which I'm happy to calmly provide even if constantly being downvoted.

[dead]
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:27PM (#49980750)
Yeah, but social security insurance isn't the same as taxes. A few years ago I was unemployed for a few month and got money from the insurance. My parents are retired and get their pension. When I go to the doctor the insurance pays for it (in most cases). I am sure, I paid more than I got out, but that is true for all my other insurances as well.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by greenavocado on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:10PM (#49981315)
I was unemployed a few years ago, and when I applied to the state for unemployment I was denied because I earned too much. So it is effectively a tax I will never get anything out of it as long as the prior year's Form 1040 shows above a certain level.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:34PM (#49996067)
Interesting.

> So it is effectively a tax

If you desperately want to call it a tax, go ahead.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by 60pfennig on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:08AM (#49975620)
Just want to add that you also just can't compare the netto value on your bank account. In Germany the state takes responsibility for much more things like education (Kindergarten, School, University), public transport, cultural events ... . They are heavily subsidiced and give value back where you don't have to pay extra.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:03AM (#49976013)
> education (Kindergarten, School, University)

Other governments including US also pays a lot for these.

> public transport

Which is so famously reliable that Switzerland no longer allows their trains on their tracks to avoid messing up their schedule as well. And of course its run as private companies so execs can pocket large portions of those state subsidies.

> cultural events

No thanks, I don't want my government deciding what culture should be supported.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by 60pfennig on Thursday October 08, 2026 @09:57AM (#50005861)
> education average tutition US / year: private: 46,973, public (out of state): 26,034, in-state: 11.747 [1]

Germany: 100 - 400 per semester (*2 per year) including public transport [2]

[1]https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/paying-for-co... [2]https://www.studying-in-germany.org/what-does-it-cost-to-stu...

> public transport dont want to deny that it runs unrealiably but in Germany you have a really dense train network (>33,000km)which connects many small villages with good schedules. Also lots of goods are transported by train. Thats holding huge potential if the government will invest more (not less) so trains arriving realiably

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_transport_in_Germany

> cultural events valid argument. in theory all cultural events which are aligned with democratic values should be able to get funded. but if they really get funded is a political decision. i really like the affordable prices in museums, free outdoor art events... but i can see that this could seen differently. I think cultural events and art are an essential part of our culture and society and should not follow market logic that is has to make money to exist and only is affordable to some.

Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by account42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:35AM (#49975819)
It is more than real if you include all taxes.
Re:Europe's new robotics unicorn: Germany's RobCo hits $1B v... by aktenlage on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#49980666)
Not for me. But feel free to show your calculations.