News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by WarmWash on Sunday September 27, 2026 @05:48PM (#49871201)
Its also why Google Search "went to shit years ago"

Technically adept people would search using ordered keywords and phrases, which would have excellent results with Google 2006:

Dario Turkey NBA "never coming over"

But regular people agonized over this because to them a search was

What were some of the memes about Dario staying in turkey

Google put immense effort into calibrating search for regular people instead of engineers.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by HaZeust on Sunday September 27, 2026 @06:13PM (#49871376)
Christ, thank you! I’ve been saying this for years and no one I’ve spoken to, even engineers, could acknowledge the level of “chunking” that’s been engrained in them over the years for turning inquiries into keyword/phrase shorthand, and that this is NOT something most people want to do, and is the killer app of Google AI. This time around, you CAN type in an input box what you would say to a human in everyday conversation, AND expect a reasonable response. That’s invaluable to a casual user.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by Terr_ on Sunday September 27, 2026 @06:30PM (#49871460)
> this is NOT something most people want to do

I've always felt that "proper" and responsible LLM use for search [0] would be two boxes: You can describe what you want in the first, and it'll propose search terms in the second, and then those get executed normally.

Yes, the "average user" [1] might not usually care about the second box... Until they need to because the query/results are wrong.

Showing them in tandem means:

1. Users are at least capable of learning through exposure.

2. Users may realize a key term can be added which the model could never have guessed.

3. Users may recognize a term in there that doesn't make sense, allowing them to detect a translation error.

4. If good search-terms leads to a bad outcome, it is possible for someone to report and diagnose it, rather than a fully black-box mystery.

_____

[0] Not just for websites, but also things like internal business software, or SQL queries.

[1] The average that might not exist. ( https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/when-u-s-air-force-disc... ) There are some features that everybody needs, just at different times.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by tokioyoyo on Sunday September 27, 2026 @08:15PM (#49872141)
Your described thinking pattern does not apply to 95%+ users, and might add confusion leading to retention loss (e.g. 2 text boxes? Wtf, two boxes? What do i type in the second one? Whatever i’ll switch to the usual). Every project with at least 100K non-tech users I’ve worked on, has shown that sort of thinking just doesn’t translate.

And regarding “average doesn’t exist” - that’s true. But no company does a/b testing to land on average. I’d assume a good 85%-kinda pass rate for these type of experiments.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by savory_pancake on Sunday September 27, 2026 @10:15PM (#49872787)
I think A/B testing may have value in selecting a specific path preferred by 85% of users, but it seems like alienating the remaining 15% doesn't feel great.

95% of users might not want the double-textbox, but 5% might, and some might want to use it someday.

I think, make enough of these decisions, and there's bound to be mounting friction for users with different preferences navigating your app.

Ideally, the app should offer a way for the user to intuitively configure the app to their own liking.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by tokioyoyo on Sunday September 27, 2026 @10:20PM (#49872828)
When an experiment passes, you don’t really lose that 15%. Most of the time they just get used to the other behaviour. Case in point - we’ve been whining about Google’s deterioration of search queries for ages, yet we’re still using it.

Ideally, yeah maybe, but why bother with extra implementation, support, costs and etc., when people fold and use the new way anyways?

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by myaccountonhn on Monday September 28, 2026 @01:51AM (#49874122)
I mean when you're the size of Google designing a search engine, with probably around 5 billion users, ideally yeah you'd bother.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by taormina on Monday September 28, 2026 @03:36AM (#49874751)
Ideally. But when you’re Google, what are they going to do, use Bing?
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by savory_pancake on Sunday September 27, 2026 @09:56PM (#49872672)
In the words of Edsger Dijkstra, "Projects promoting programming in 'natural language' are intrinsically doomed to fail." I think for something as bespoke as a search engine, a DSL that accepts quotes, logical operators, and specific terms definitely allows for far greater specificity than natural language can (at least in an equivalent amount of text).

I think the two-tiered input-output approach you propose makes sense. Allowing users to inspect and mutate lower-level languages allows the user to make modifications as needed. I think it's very much in the spirit of free software.

But then again, for text-based search specifically (search engines, notes, etc.), I think there is some value in querying the LLM directly, as it is able to fuzzy search by inspecting its weights. This results in a lesser degree of specificity, which allows for more false positives, but can maybe capture similar words (i.e., synonyms / typos / tenses) or higher-level semantic concepts.

Maybe they're just two different search algorithms, and the user should be able to choose between them.

Thanks for linking the article, I found it very interesting.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by HaZeust on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:31PM (#49999664)
I said casual, not average.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by ikr678 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @09:43PM (#49872597)
It's not just engineers, I think it's more an age thing.

For a certain cohort (eg those currently between 35 and 45) who did any sort of grade school computer/library classes in the 90's/early2000's, 'chunking' or keyword searching was one of the main skills taught.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by xd1936 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @09:55PM (#49872662)
I mean, I'm in my mid-30s, and "keywording" and "how to use search engines" was taught in my US Midwest public school library/media center.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by ozozozd on Sunday September 27, 2026 @06:52PM (#49871625)
If you are a fast typer, maybe the longer query might just come out naturally.

If you are properly lazy, you must expect or at least attempt to get results for the shorter query. Especially on a phone.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by hiddencost on Sunday September 27, 2026 @08:24PM (#49872193)
It's not about shorter vs longer.

Many people who learned to search the Internet in early 2000s learned "boolean search queries" (terms connected with AND or OR). They're talking about the difference between boolean search queries and natural language search queries.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by helterskelter2 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @11:07PM (#49873116)
I'm not an engineer, but this is how I was taught to use digital search back in my elementary school's library in the second or third grade (it replaced the card catalogue) and it's how I've searched ever since. We had an entire class period on how to keep our search keywords to the minimum so we'd get good results.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by wpm on Monday September 28, 2026 @12:12AM (#49873548)
The problem was our parents never got this course, and sadly, neither did the generations after us. "Computer" Class for me (born early 90s) was keyboarding -> how to find information online -> how to evaluate and rate itegrity of internet sources -> Microsoft Office.

The kids who stopped getting that are probabaly old enough for a bachelors degree now. Today, the schools mostly just hand them an iPad and a Google Workspace sign-in and pretend everything is fine.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by globular-toast on Monday September 28, 2026 @01:49AM (#49874110)
They did. Our local libraries in the 90s had internet courses you could take that would teach you how to browse and search. But this stopped for everyone around 2000 when suddenly knowing how to use any piece of software was considered assumed knowledge for some reason.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by b112 on Monday September 28, 2026 @05:11AM (#49875393)
This is also why the wacko and bizarro concept that "removing options and configs from programs" aka Gnome's big purge more than a decade ago, is nonsense today.

All those studies about GUI usability were done in the early 2000s. Before phones. When most people were just learning how to use a computer. The idea of options certainly was confusing, because "clicking on things" was even confusing.

Yet today, we have a populous which, more and more, grew up with computers. And loves to personalize. And wants options. So just keep that in mind, all you frontenders, config options aren't necessarily bad. Ancient studies have little relevance 24 years later.

Sorry to hijack a bit, but felt it was relevant to courses, teaching, and the state of time in 2000 vs now.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by TonyStr on Monday September 28, 2026 @09:46AM (#49877891)
I think Gnome removing options was more about having a smaller and more manageable set of features that need to be QA tested. I'd much rather have well-designed and well-supported defaults than 500 buggy customizable components that don't work well together.

https://ometer.com/preferences.html

I'm not sure about you, but I find Gnome very easy to use, although I miss some features. Those features can be added with Gnome extensions that are maintained by third-parties. Meanwhile I find GIMP extremely hard to use, as it packs in too many features to allow their designers to figure out a good UX which doesn't break some component.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by wpm on Monday September 28, 2026 @03:15PM (#49883017)
They could; those were opt-in classes, neither of my parents took them. In my case, it was because my mom didn't care, and my dad didn't think he needed them (worked at IBM in field tech). I imagine most folks were in the same boat.

I wouldn't have taken keyboarding if I hadn't been forced to at the age of 8. I hated keyboarding classes. I am so glad I took them now. I hated doing boring research projects and looking crap up on Yahoo's Directory. I love that I have a basic understanding of how to rate and investigate a website's trustworthiness. Mfers don't even look at the "About" section anymore.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by pwdisswordfishq on Monday September 28, 2026 @03:50AM (#49874837)
> how to find information online -> how to evaluate and rate itegrity of internet sources

You were lucky to have that part. Mine, as I remember, was just Microsoft Office throughout.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by dcrazy on Monday September 28, 2026 @11:32AM (#49879643)
Yes, but is making everyone learn information retrieval techniques, re-skilling as needed for new generations of systems, really a societal optimum? Prior to the Internet, this was a dedicated job done by librarians and paralegals. LLM-augmented search has gotten us over the temporary hump of it being everyone’s job.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by zb3 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @11:12PM (#49873152)
Except sometimes I explicitly do not want to reveal what my search intent is / explain why I want to search for this. The Google 2006 method gave me some room to do this, but now it feels like I can't do that on my own and I need to talk to Gemini. Horrible experience.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by deno on Monday September 28, 2026 @04:19AM (#49875034)
You could just have a specialized model that rewrites prose questions to actual search keywords (i.e. what power users do in their heads), and even a 2nd one that does a fitting pass based on intention after querying.

Answering with AI slop is a choice.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by dluan on Monday September 28, 2026 @07:51AM (#49876569)
I used to use search commands with "quotes", triple quotes, and +exact word search, I noticed last weekish that those no longer work.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by majani on Monday September 28, 2026 @08:02AM (#49876673)
The site: operator is also hit and miss nowadays
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by Forgeties79 on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:16AM (#49878356)
We know exactly why google went to shit years ago. It's not a perception/"people used to be more techie" issue.

https://www.wheresyoured.at/the-men-who-killed-google/

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by mrguyorama on Monday September 28, 2026 @02:40PM (#49882505)
But that's so dumb. Google search didn't die in 2019.

The PageRank algorithm, and importantly, any algorithm which depends on page content and pages linking to each other and referencing each other was DoA, because it only worked in an adversary free context! The very second there was a real incentive to be at the top of Google's search results, their algorithms were going to be attacked and manipulated.

That makes "search" a neverending arms race. The very thing that launched Google as some amazing thing was doomed from the start. They've been laying hacks on top of hacks on top of hacks ever since. It's been shit basically since SEO has existed, which is what the "adversary" is.

Another good point for when google "died" was when they bought doubleclick. They were an ad company from that point on. There was never a good outcome possible after that. If ads were something that benefited you the user, you would have to pay for them.

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by Forgeties79 on Monday September 28, 2026 @02:47PM (#49882619)
Ed’s piece on this is considered pretty authoritative. There was a very specific moment where they determined, concretely, ad placement > utility of search results. Combined with years of damage from encouraging SEO tactics…well, here we are. Sure maybe this was always going to be the outcome, but we do know the major decisions that directly lead to this result as it played out.

If you haven’t read it from start to finish you should. If you have, what about it is insufficient?

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by strbean on Monday September 28, 2026 @05:16PM (#49884482)
Yeah, the history of Google search quality is cycles of good results vs. cycles of SEO spam. ~2019 tracks as the point when Google surrendered in the war on SEO.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by strbean on Monday September 28, 2026 @05:19PM (#49884526)
Super interesting read, thanks!
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by Forgeties79 on Monday September 28, 2026 @05:45PM (#49884866)
It really is a great piece. I think a lot of his stuff has suffered in quality as he’s trying to strike while the iron is hot, but this piece in particular really is excellent.
Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by rkuykendall-com on Monday September 28, 2026 @11:56AM (#49880073)
I typed this into Google because I expected you would be correct, and the LLM would return examples of the meme, and I wanted to see it.

Instead, the AI answered that it is "actually a famous example from internet culture used to describe how people use search engines. The phrase stems from discussions on tech forums like Hacker News regarding the differences between "keyword searching" and "natural language searching"".

Re:When did Google get so f-ing weird? by mijowi on Monday September 28, 2026 @01:12PM (#49881197)
Is that just from this thread/post?? Or am I out of the loop on famous examples of how people use search engines?