News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:23AM (#49684335)
Random people calling 911 on other people filming them is a staple of Youtube; banks, coffee store workers, hairdressers, most especially restaurant managers. I don't know why anyone would expect technicians from Flock to be different. It's worse for the technician in this case, because he really was being followed --- that's not unlawful but it's unnerving.

You'd think from the response that this was like the VP/Sales of Flock Safety. But it's just some installer dude probably making $65k/year to climb poles and fasten cameras. I guess that's praxis for you though.

I think this is just a ragebait piece.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by DrewADesign on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:42AM (#49684539)
Well, when you’re on the clock, you’re an agent of that company. And when you’re installing an indiscriminate mass-surveillance camera, calling the police on someone that’s video recording you is kind of bananas. Perhaps you don’t find that to be an interesting event, but a lot of people who are rightfully angry at the non-consensual deployment of a mass surveillance network disagree.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:34AM (#49685161)
It's not bananas. It happens all the time. The police show up, check things out, and inform the caller that the person recording has a right to do so. In this case, it's even less bananas, because the people recording him were literally following him around, which is not what generally happens in these "audit" scenarios where someone parks themselves on the street outside a restaurant or bank.

There's pretty clearly a vibe on this thread that calling 911 is itself a use of coercive force. It is not. 911 is how you're ordinarily supposed to reach the police. In my neighborhood, it's how you'd report a stolen bicycle. It's the job of the police to handle those calls appropriately, and I don't see any indication that the call was handled inappropriately here.

The story doesn't want to give you that context because their goal isn't to inform you, it's to get your blood pumping.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tanseydavid on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:58AM (#49685435)
TIL that 911 (Emergency Services) is how one should report a stolen bicycle.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:00PM (#49685456)
Happy to help. 911 is the primary "call for service" channel for most police departments.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by nullocator on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:30PM (#49686362)
I've personally never come across a police department or sherrif in the U.S. that doesn't have a non emergency number. I'd assume thats what you should call for things that aren't an emergency? They've never told me to call back and call 911.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by aleksejs on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:21PM (#49689798)
Allegheny County in Pennsylvania is one such department without a separate number. I don't think it's that uncommon.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by samspot on Monday September 14, 2026 @04:29PM (#49703462)
I've tried calling the non-emergency number for my city, and they told me to hang up and call 911.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by c0nducktr on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:44PM (#49686536)
Just want to add that myself to the list of people who can't imagine calling 911 for a non-emergency. Never in my life have I heard anyone assume it's for that purpose.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by johnnyanmac on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:00PM (#49689624)
Let's clarify things. You can call 911 for a non-emergency. That dispatch worker will then redirect the line to a non-emergency line based on the situation. They will also likely remind you of a faster way to reach the non-emergency lines in your area, because they do not want everyone clogging 911 with non-emergencies. But it is very technically a valid way to call.

I will still judge someone for doing it that way, though. Especially in a day and age where a simple search query of your non-emergency line will save the time of such dispatch agents. Or at least 411 if you're of an older generation (411 still works on more cellular lines than you'd think today).

I'll also remind people that abuse of the emergency dispatch lines are illegal (not that this is what happened here), so please do not consider pushing your luck with non-emergencies maliciously.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by taywrobel on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:46AM (#49685281)
Except that the reason that the YouTube “1A Auditors” get the attention that they do is that frequently it’s not a simple “check things out, and inform the caller that the person recording has the right to do so”, but the interactions often escalate to threats of unlawful arrest as police default to the side of the caller.

Calling the police, especially in America, can 100% be a coercive use of force. That’s why people threaten to call the cops/DHS/ICE all the time during arguments, and why things like SWATing are as big of a problem as they are. When the behavior of many policy officers is escalate first, ask questions second if at all, it does become a genuine threat.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:56AM (#49685403)
I don't know what to tell you. I watch these videos all the time (it's one of my vices, bodycam footage in particular) and what I see every time --- when it's "auditors" harassing businesses, not when it's auditors confronting police at police departments --- is business owners being told to suck it up.

I know that in Summer 2020 there was a fashion for saying any call to the police was ipso facto a deployment of coercive force, but I'm rejecting that argument out of hand while also pointing out that in many regions 911 is exactly the thing you're supposed to do when you have uncertainty. It is simply not a demand for violence; it's a demand to have a trained authority come and resolve a situation, rather than having two private citizens with no training at all in the law confront each other and hope for the best.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by weard_beard on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:23PM (#49686286)
The key point here is hypocrisy. The very evident double standard.

A person holding a camera and following you around is an emergency or at the very least a suspicious act worthy of investigation and possible arrest.

A person attaching hundreds of thousands of cameras to poles calling the police to report this act is what is noteworthy.

Its not clickbait in the normal sense of overselling a series of un-noteworthy events IMHO.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tzs on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:58PM (#49686713)
> A person attaching hundreds of thousands of cameras to poles calling the police to report this act is what is noteworthy

That's one seriously impressive person. If they started as soon as Flock was founded and spend 40 hours a week 50 weeks a year installing cameras they would have to on average have installed a camera every 6 minutes.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by DrewADesign on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:19PM (#49689778)
I’m very close with several current police dispatchers, and even have an expired state telecommunicator certification. Calling 911 can absolutely be a coercive force, and people use 911 to harass people all the time because in many instances the dispatcher has no choice but to send uniformed people over there to investigate. Police are equipped and trained to deal with certain kinds of problems, and they’re constantly looking for evidence to support a criminal charge. It’s their job. All they know walking into that situation— as human beings that aren’t immune to the power of suggestion— is that the caller, who is the complainant, says that the other person is doing something wrong. That is not a neutral action. If it was, many departments wouldn’t be adopting non-uniformed, unarmed social worker responses to non-violent situations.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ryandrake on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:16PM (#49690199)
When the police come, they bring with them a nonzero chance of violent, deadly force. Especially if the caller says me of a few magic phrases like “I fear for my life” and “I’m not sure if he has a gun but he might” and (in some areas) “Black male, six foot two.”

Calling the police on someone is like mailing them a bomb with a 0.1% chance of exploding. You have no idea if you are summoning a calm, experienced officer or a power tripping monster with an ego.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:20PM (#49690231)
When people feel threatened, it is almost always better than they call the police than that they engage and try to resolve the threat themselves.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @06:35PM (#49871503)
Seems like this was more an annoyance than a threat. So, to rephrase when people feel annoyed, its almost always better to ignore it than call the police.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by giaour on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:23AM (#49685031)
> It's worse for the technician in this case, because he really was being followed --- that's not unlawful but it's unnerving.

The technician was in public, bearing a company logo, performing an activity in which there is widespread public interest, and identified himself to law enforcement as an agent of Flock Safety. He is entitled to be unnerved but has no reasonable expectation of privacy here.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:33AM (#49685140)
Nobody disagrees, though "calling 911" is exactly what he's supposed to do if he thinks he's being followed.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by vkou on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:20PM (#49687635)
Who do I call if I think Flock is stalking me, and who will the police show up to intimidate when I do?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by akerl_ on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:22PM (#49688284)
> Who do I call if I think Flock is stalking me

Your local representative who signed a contract with Flock to install and operate the cameras?

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by vkou on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:29PM (#49688356)
So, complain to the stalker?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by hammock on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:56AM (#49684705)
> it's just some installer dude probably making $65k/year to climb poles and fasten cameras

I find it hard to be persuaded by the salary idea. A hitman who works for $100 is just as bad as one who works for $10,000.

In fact other immoral activities work the opposite, bizarrely (a whore who works for $100 is worse than one who works for $10,000)

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:00AM (#49684738)
Most jobs are imoral. If we were to do only the moral ones… we’d have probably 75% unemployment or something like that.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by dml2135 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:31AM (#49685119)
This is the kind of thing that someone knowing they are doing bad things at their job says to justify it to themselves.

It’s not true. You can go find something worthwhile to do instead.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by xboxnolifes on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:11PM (#49686163)
How would hackernews visitors support their lifestyle then?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:07PM (#49688138)
If the only job you find is working for a healthcare provider and your KPI is denying as many claims as you can, what do you tell yourself?

And probably I could find many more extreme examples and some not so extreme.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by cristoperb on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:35PM (#49686421)
"there's no ethical production under capitalism"?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by saghm on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:37AM (#49684480)
The response is stronger because your hairdressers and baristas aren't actively providing a service for surveillance as part of their work. The bar should be higher for a company that's ostensibly being trusted to provide a law enforcement tool that's prone to misuse than for providing beverages or cosmetology.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by gruez on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:46AM (#49684584)
>The response is stronger because your hairdressers and baristas aren't actively providing a service for surveillance as part of their work.

Should other law enforcement contractors also be subject to the same higher standard? For instance, should dell get extra flak if one of their contractors called 911, because they were installing PCs for a police department? If not, this just seems like a way of applying a double standard, just because you hate flock. It's fine to hate flock, but it should be actually justified reasons (eg. "they're enabling mass surveillance" or whatever), not spurious ones like "they did a bad that's vaguely common, but we're gonna admonish them extra hard for it because we hate them")

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by dylan604 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:14AM (#49684932)
I don't buy into your premise. A hairdresser, barista, Dell installer, etc are not out in the open public. These people are in places open to the public but not considered public. These people can deny your "right" to be there, and impose rules/restrictions on what you can do in their open to the public space. Go against those rules/restrictions and you are no longer welcome.

You are really trying to contort yourself into some very uninteresting twists.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by throwaway7783 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:02AM (#49684776)
Do you think Flock is in the same category of installing PCs for police departments, when it comes to public impact?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by saghm on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:02AM (#49684759)
If they called 911 because they were worried about privacy when publically installing a privacy-violating tool, then yes, they 100% should be. Having higher standards for higher impact things isn't somehow hypocritical.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by gruez on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:18AM (#49684966)
>If they called 911 because they were worried about privacy when publically installing a privacy-violating tool, then yes, they 100% should be.

Seems like the installer was calling because he thought he was being harassed?

>As Keefe began to shoot video, the installer saw him and immediately packed up his equipment and drove away, so Keefe also returned to his car and followed several cars behind, hoping to document the next stop.

>...

>“I work with Flock Safety. And I called originally because I’m getting followed,” the installer can be heard telling a dispatcher after being transferred. “I was getting harassed, pretty much. Taking videos and pictures. And now, the same vehicle that pulled over where I was working at has been following me.”

Sure, you can try to equate "flock setting up a surveillance network" to "physically following flock employees", but what's the implication here? That anyone working for flock should be fair game as a stalking target? What about someone working for NSA? Should it be fine to look through their emails?

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by saghm on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:53AM (#49685374)
The implication is "setting up public security cameras in a city should be fair game to document by journalists". If anything, the solution here seems like it would be a requirement that the date, time, and location of each camera being set up should be public information, so then no one needs to get followed to be able to document what's happening.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by Someone1234 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:00AM (#49684742)
> It's worse for the technician in this case, because he really was being followed --- that's not unlawful but it's unnerving.

Isn't that exactly what Flock are doing to tens of thousands of people a day? So why the double-standard.

I actually agree it is unnerving, I just don't agree that one should be held to a different standard than the other.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by chii on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:13AM (#49684915)
> one should be held to a different standard than the other.

harassing a worker is not the way to fix the problem. The worker has no agency to affect the changes desired by the harasser. It's an issue with the gov't, and needs civic procedures to change.

This behaviour is the same as harassing hospitality staff for bad prices. Harassers would be considered borderline committing terrorism if they go further.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ndriscoll on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:47AM (#49685292)
The worker does have agency. They did not have to take a job installing mass surveillance systems. They're directly doing the bad thing, and the "harassers" are literally doing the same thing the worker is doing, but back to the worker.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ryandrake on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:22PM (#49690248)
Contractors On The Death Star. You know you are working for the bad guys and are willingly doing the job.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ricketycricket on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:46AM (#49685273)
It legally wasn't harassment. If it was, he would have not been let go. That word means a real thing and this was not it.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by Hizonner on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:48AM (#49685304)
Filming them at work, or following them to the next job so you can film them at work, is not in any way, shape, or form "harassment".
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tzs on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:22PM (#49687005)
> Isn't that exactly what Flock are doing to tens of thousands of people a day? So why the double-standard.

It's not the same thing. Flock cameras have terrible privacy implications but at least when I pass by one of them they are also filming everyone else passing by. I'm not being singled out.

They are also sometimes used by stalkers that have access to improperly track people, so if I do acquire a stalker they might help my stalker.

If some person is following me personally around and filming me then I am clearly being singled out.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by hk1337 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:50AM (#49684633)
> technicians from Flock

Do they even have their own technicians? I believe there have been Dish Network technicians seen working on and setting up flock cameras and even those technicians are contractors of Dish network.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by kotaKat on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:19AM (#49684983)
Mix of. Large metros they'll use their own staff to install, rural Americana they'll use Dish's OnTech division. Dish realized they have an entire 'trained' workforce of cable/dish techs that they can put to other technical use, so they pushed into more managed hands tech services.

https://www.ontechsmartservices.com/

I noticed a more prominently branded "OnTech" van roaming around my rural slice of life that had a smaller Dish brand logo on it that seemed to be more of that side of the business.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by emsign on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:12AM (#49684896)
Guy is not just a technician, he's a technician working for Flock installing surveillance tech to monitor the public. Wrong life choices have consequences like being filmed being complicit in establishing a surveillance regime.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by cute_boi on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:02AM (#49684769)
Well then everyone is innocent except CEO's or management lol.

This isn't how world works.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by EgregiousCube on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:28AM (#49684398)
Especially when chances are that this camera installation was the result of local government asking and paying Flock to put it up. I'm not sure why the anger is directed at the company instead of local elected officials, and I understand the plight of the installer who's worried about being labeled as a bad guy for executing public works contracts.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by michaelt on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:39AM (#49684503)
> I understand the plight of the installer who's worried about being labeled as a bad guy for executing public works contracts.

You do unpopular things, you gotta expect to be an unpopular person.

Sophisticated, educated types might understand that parking wardens are just doing their jobs, and they didn't make the policy they're enforcing. But to 70% of the population, the person putting a ticket on their car is an asshole.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by diath on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:40AM (#49684514)
The company could have rejected the government deal if they cared about the moral aspect of spying on citizens instead of money; by accepting the deal and executing the contract they are complicit.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by xp84 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:44AM (#49684560)
What? Is that not their whole business?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by LeBit on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:34AM (#49684457)
Well, politicians are to pay for the fact they have allowed something like Flock cameras to be put up and spy to egregiously on their constituents.

But Flock itself should not be spared . They are building things that are going against widely accepted values.

Since when Americans are okay with that level of erosion of their privacy?

Same thing with Meta building pervert glasses.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by EgregiousCube on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:10PM (#49686848)
This is the disconnect. You say that politicians are allowing them - that's not right. They're directing them to be set up, they're spending citizen tax money on buying them.

The blame lies entirely with government officials who sought out and purchased surveillance tech, and we should not blame the technologists who responded rationally to the incentive that local governments provided for them.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by anigbrowl on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:38PM (#49690375)
banks, coffee store workers, hairdressers, most especially restaurant managers.

Those people are all working in private premises, and have the right to eject customers for being belligerent or just annoying. The Flock technicians are in public, and as we're always reminded by Flock advocates, have no expectation of privacy. There's no indication that the reporter was harassing him in any way.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:03PM (#49690973)
There's no indication that anything at all happened to the reporter, is there? A worker had a concern about someone following them and called it in, and that... is the end of the story?
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by anigbrowl on Monday September 14, 2026 @08:09PM (#49705999)
I was just pointing out the problem with your initial premise, but I don't think this argument holds water either. Nobody enjoys being subject to a police stop, and the reporter's journalistic undertaking (which was very clearly signaled as such) was interrupted, although certainly he was free to resume it the next time he spotted a Flock installer at work.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:07PM (#49706458)
It's not Summer 2020 and I'm just not going to entertain the idea that calling the police when you're alarmed by something is an act of violence. This is some random working schmoe hanging things on poles. It's a nonstory.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by anigbrowl on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @02:44PM (#49731225)
That's quite a straw man you've taken on there.
Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by ozgrakkurt on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:11PM (#49690600)
Sure, people working on german army in ww2 were also probably just some guy getting 10k/year salary or something like that. Person doesn’t matter if they are in uniform.

I had a situation like this against airlines recently where I am getting so obviosly screwed but unfortunately the guy that is doing the screwing is “just a guy” so I can’t go off on them.

Re:Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public came... by tptacek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:02PM (#49690969)
Totally reasonable comparison. Can't imagine why that didn't occur to me, too.