News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iPhone Duo by brookst on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:13PM (#49637001)
Remind me if AVP is proof that they have no creative spark or proof that they only do boring stuff that will sell 20m units?
Re:iPhone Duo by Melatonic on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:21PM (#49637067)
The AVP I thought looked like amazing hardware. It was just bizarre they didn't also go all in on making it useable for gaming.
Re:iPhone Duo by lbourdages on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:37PM (#49637210)
They failed to come up with a strong selling point. Health is the big seller for Apple Watch. But AVP, at its price point, needs something better than "well you can watch movies on a big screen or work in a café while looking silly".
Re:iPhone Duo by jandrese on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:58PM (#49637386)
It absolutely failed to justify its price point IMHO. If it were affordable people would be finding uses for it, but when it is that expensive you basically need a business justification for buying one. That means you won't have a hobbyist community finding new and interesting things to do with it.

This leaves Apple and maybe a handful of subsidized third parties as the only people making applications for it, which is pretty much a guarantee that it will remain a tiny niche industry.

Re:iPhone Duo by brookst on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:47PM (#49638165)
Agree, it’s basically the Apple Lisa all over again. Innovative, but not mass market.

But I think Apple learned some things from the Lisa, even though it barely sold.

Re:iPhone Duo by grensley on Thursday September 10, 2026 @12:42AM (#49638499)
The Apple Vision Pro is basically a developer kit.
Re:iPhone Duo by ToucanLoucan on Thursday September 10, 2026 @09:23AM (#49643318)
This, 100%. The only other headset I was aware of even remotely in AVP's price zip code was the Valve Index, priced at $999 and the AVP was three times that.

And even then I proooobably would've been able to justify it? But no external connectivity at all just sank it for me. Like if it had a DP port on it so I could hook it up to a gaming PC, I would've probably at least picked one up second-hand, possibly even new when my bonus hit but 3 large for... what? Email in my house? Movies shown in a way that makes it damn hard to eat popcorn?

Re:iPhone Duo by brookst on Thursday September 10, 2026 @09:24AM (#49643329)
As someone else said, it’s a developer kit. It was supply constrained and priced accordingly. IMO it was a mistake to not just call it a developer’s kit, abd promoting it as a consumer product was just weird.

But I guess the downside of the DK approach is it means telling developers when the “real” device will ship, which I’m not sure anyone knows.

Re:iPhone Duo by jandrese on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:04PM (#49646994)
As you note, the concept of a developer kit for a product that doesn't exist makes little sense. Why would I as a company spend the time and money developing for a product that isn't even on the roadmap?
Re:iPhone Duo by jimbokun on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:27PM (#49638037)
True. Seems like none of the VR devices have found their killer app.
Re:iPhone Duo by victorbjorklund on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:57AM (#49638979)
But remember health was a small thing when the watch was launched. Then the focus was on notifications, communications etc. Fitness was more of a ”oh and it also tracks your heart rate”
Re:iPhone Duo by user43928 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:43AM (#49640427)
I have no interest in using a headset in public or doing work on one.

Watching movies on a big screen would be interesting, but they still do not sell the device in my country in Europe, so I had no way to demo it and judge whether the quality is adequate for a home theater experience.

Re:iPhone Duo by pseingatl on Thursday September 10, 2026 @10:07AM (#49643949)
You might use such a device if you were vision-impaired and it helped you see.
Re:iPhone Duo by pseingatl on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:30AM (#49642673)
As a medical device for the vision impaired, AVP has a built-in audience that is used to paying top dollar, especially if paying means just a co-pay. It also eliminates popular disquiet about improper recording--no one will complain about a device that helps the vision impaired get around. Why neither Apple nor Meta went down this path is inexplicable.
Re:iPhone Duo by the_other on Thursday September 10, 2026 @09:28AM (#49643389)
I'm partially sighted. I've yet to see an AVP demo that made me want to try one out as an access tool. In fact, everything I've seen so far suggested it would be a hinderance. Can you suggest how it could help? What am I missing?

(I accept, I could book a demo at an Apple Store...)

Re:iPhone Duo by BobaFloutist on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:53AM (#49645844)
I think they're kind of saying that's the problem, that intuitively having a screen inches from your face displaying things that are further away in decent detail, with things like contrast and saturation and brightness color palettes being modifiable should have some obvious possibilities for people with limited vision - but Apple wasn't interested in developing for and demonstrating these options.

I'm near-sighted, so I can see how magic glasses that let me focus on everything as if it's six inches away could be nice. That being said, normal prescription glasses work very well for my particular vision impairment, and "You only have to buy glasses once more ever, but they're $3000, weigh over a pound, and need to be recharged" isn't a great value proposition for my needs, but it doesn't take much imagination to figure that being able to toggle even just dark, high contrast, or colorblind modes irl would be nice for some people. Not worth it for me, but possibly for others.

Re:iPhone Duo by alex43578 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:34PM (#49637665)
I think the lack of a AppleVision non-pro that was just some really good screens and a battery, hooked up to your iPhone/MBA/MBP for use as an immersive display was a miss. I tried the AVP but realized I didn't want/need to strap a Macbook to my face: I have a computing device, I just wanted the display.

Scrap the passthrough cameras, the LCD eyes, and all that complexity.

Re:iPhone Duo by brookst on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:48PM (#49638174)
Yikes. I can’t imagine it without passthrough. You have to take it off to move around at all?
Re:iPhone Duo by alex43578 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:15AM (#49639136)
Yeah? It's just a display for sitting on the couch or in an airplane, watching videos or viewing a huge virtual desktop. Scrapping the cameras would save a ton on size, BOM, and complexity. Basically a "Pimax Dream Air" formfactor.

I'd love the ability to have AVP immersion with my MBP on a flight, and combined with Airpods, you'd be able to block out everything. I don't need to walk around and wouldn't need to interact through it. It's like transparency for Airpods: an overengineered alternative to just taking an airpod out (or in this case, lifting the headset up).

Re:iPhone Duo by wooger on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:49AM (#49640494)
I can't imagine wanting to walk anywhere with massive clownish goggles on, and while tethered to the power box & various peripherals.

Still, a small camera is an odd thing to cut.

Re:iPhone Duo by whywhywhywhy on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:38AM (#49642772)
For “just a display” you need a computer in there anyway.
Re:iPhone Duo by alex43578 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:10PM (#49647065)
Not if you’re driving it from your iPhone or MacBook. You’ll still need chips, but certainly not a M series processor, coprocessor, tons of storage, etc.
Re:iPhone Duo by whywhywhywhy on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:44PM (#49756925)
Unless it's wired you need enough hardware Timewarp / Reprojection anyway otherwise dropped frames would cause motion sickness.

There just isn't a world where it makes sense to make this very expensive headset and not put a relatively cheap computer in it too which then opens it up to normies who don't own powerful tower computers for content consumption and light games.

Re:iPhone Duo by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:40AM (#49640405)
Apple never goes all in for gaming. They are more than happy to base most of its software revrnue on Skinner boxes, but otherwise it feels like it wants little to do with games.

Every 4-5 years they need something to show off their tech and they begrudgingly look to gaming studios to provide some demos for them. They get the demos, get some hype, then put it straight back into the box. Devs move on because they know their audience isn't there anyway. Rinse and repeat. This last time was to help show off their unified architecture with AAA games running on an IPad.

Re:iPhone Duo by wooger on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:44AM (#49640438)
Seriously, this (and pron) is the only use case that will appeal to the mass market for a single user, un-shareable, stupid looking, immersive thing like this.

For nice hardware with hardly any content, not making huge strides to get existing VR content on it was a terrible strategy. And Apple can afford to just buy one of the bigger players to get content too.

Re:iPhone Duo by comfysocks on Thursday September 10, 2026 @12:42AM (#49638496)
Here’s my theory about AVP.

Apple’s strategic position is to be the main device by which apps and AI can gain access to end users. This puts them in a nice position to charge a toll on everything that passes through their device. Now if someone were to come out with a new type of device and a new paradigm that could disrupt iPhone as the main device, Apple would be in trouble.

Not long ago, Zuck seemed really confident about metaverse/AR/VR. Apple took the disruption threat seriously and countered with AVP. Now it looks like metaverse flopped. I suspect the priority of AVP has gone down inside Apple accordingly.

Re:iPhone Duo by theodric on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:48AM (#49638924)
Hadn't the Metaverse already well and truly flopped before the AVP came out? It's a cool device, but when it was released I felt like Apple was a couple years late and 3499 dollars short.
Re:iPhone Duo by gorgoiler on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:11AM (#49640723)
Are smart glasses not the modern, practical implementation of the metaverse. I don’t think Meta were banking on games and low-poly avatars for their next generation of revenue, it was more about building (and then — hold onto your lunch please — monetizing) new forms of social connectivity. The only difference is that your permanent social camera went from being in-game to in-reality.
Re:iPhone Duo by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:50AM (#49641055)
Interesting view, but not quite. The Big Changes in computing happen when both the mode of access, the demographic, and the primary use case change. So historically computing evolved from corporate server + batch -> real time "personal" scientific and technical -> mass market commodified PC for business and gaming -> social media, entertainment, and 'personal bureaucracy' (tickets, bank statements, and such) on mobile.

At each step the tech gets smaller and more physically accessible, the use case gets more interactive and less demanding and serious, and the demographic gets wider and less technically educated.

Apple owned a huge part of the last change with the iPhone.

What's the next step in the series?

Clearly it's not a huge device you strap to your face.

But it's also not an easy question to answer. What is the next step after social media?

From a software POV it's AI, but where's the matching hardware? The next gen has to be even smaller, multimodal, but still physically interactive, likely always on.

Glasses are the closest, but not there yet.

So I think we're still in the early Nokia mobile stage. The concept exists and the current tech is beginning to be workable, but the gamechanger refinement and perfection of the concept is still a way off.

Re:iPhone Duo by minimeow on Thursday September 10, 2026 @06:29AM (#49641342)
The tech is workable. The issue is the AVP is heavy and big. So I'd say we're still at the Motorola brick phone not even the Nokia stage yet. Shrink the AVP down to glasses size and I'll agree on the Nokia analogy.
Re:iPhone Duo by naravara on Thursday September 10, 2026 @10:37AM (#49644467)
I’d argue the fact that the hardware is still big and clunky means the tech isn’t workable. If it was about as light and easy to get on and off as a chunky pair of ski-goggles I think they’d have been onto something, but big and heavy with no “killer app” or feature makes it a tough sell.

VR gaming is a niche even among hardcore gamers. There’s some value in spatial computing for just being a more ergonomic way to do computer stuff (i.e. not being in a fixed position all day, being able to walk around while you work) but it’d need to be able to hit everything a Mac can do with no compromises to be worth it at that price (and at the cost of making you look goofy). So far it seems like it’s only found real utility in some very specific industrial and scientific research contexts, which is very cool but probably isn’t the lane a mass market consumer products manufacturer wants as their play long-term.

Re:iPhone Duo by brookst on Thursday September 10, 2026 @09:21AM (#49643300)
I agree with you, but the critical thing about AVP (just like iPhone, just like iPod, just like Mac) is the user interface. The device is just hardware to deliver the UI.

Apple’s UI work on AVP is under-appreciated. It’s been improving over the years, as real usage showed the need for things like shared world anchors and coordinates, prediction for pose estimation, etc.

The hardware isn’t ready yet. At this point I half-think the UI won’t be truly real until we have BCI (brain-computer interface for the offended party above). But it may well take a decade to really land what an always-on, sometimes-invisible AR UI looks like and how it works.

Re:iPhone Duo by socalgal2 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:13AM (#49645162)
I found the AVP UI work to be bad honestly. I walked right up to a surface to touch it, you can't. Holding my eyes still so it registers what I'm looking at, not what I'm touching, was horrible and super unintuitive.
Re:iPhone Duo by Danox on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:30PM (#49647412)
Everything has to be half the size or less, 3-4 times faster use less power etc… plus an even better more integrated operating system, not just with the device itself, but with the whole family of Apple devices, ecosystems and there are no shortcuts to get there and the cost will be the cost.
Re:iPhone Duo by pazimzadeh on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:39PM (#49648410)
It’s definitely glasses. Once you try any even low res HUD glasses like the Vuzix Z100, or even the Vision Pro, you might realize how annoying it is that phones, tablets, and even books subtly force you to look downwards all day.

There’s no reason I shouldn’t be able to for example take a stroll in the park and read my email, song lyrics, etc.. without craning my neck downwards or holding my phone right in front of my face. The content should just be where my eyes are looking. Even laying on the couch to watch a movie is annoying when you have to hold your arm up and shift the balance of your iPad all the time to stop getting tired. Just put it in front of me. For input, I favor a ring you can scroll and squeeze.

I’ve thought about hanging a book-holder from the ceiling by a string for this reason. Maybe a ton of helium or a quiet drone would work too. I think thats’ the frontier..having our current setups but just floating around us.

Re:iPhone Duo by Danox on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:23PM (#49647278)
Maybe but Apple doesn’t really have to worry because Meta basically is a website company, operating systems and high end hardware are beyond them (and no you can’t buy your way in there are no shortcuts not at that level), but the Apple Vision has its own problems.

The processors have to be what? Three or four times faster and the battery life has to be at the level of a MacBook Pro with everything squeezed into a device half its current size how many years away is that 3-4 years? And don’t forget the accessory processors that Apple designed specifically for that Vision Pro.

Re:iPhone Duo by jorisw on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:15AM (#49638709)
Apple Vision Pro

Abbreviations waste people’s time

Re:iPhone Duo by swiftcoder on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:01AM (#49639024)
Here I thought we were discussing a return of the Aliens vs Predator franchise
Re:iPhone Duo by port11 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:37AM (#49645580)
I’d rather have that than a really wide phone. Do a whole series on the Predators, please.
Re:iPhone Duo by vr46 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:36AM (#49642751)
And some of them take even longer to say than the original words, e.g. WWW
Re:iPhone Duo by swiftcoder on Thursday September 10, 2026 @10:37AM (#49644484)
FB's main monorepo was named WWW, and you needed to refer to it every 5 minutes, so everyone pronounced it "dub-dub-dub". A surprisingly hard habit to break once you leave their employment
Re:iPhone Duo by jorisw on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:55AM (#49654052)
Facebook.