News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by sillysaurusx on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:05PM (#49380882)
He wasn’t prosecuted for scraping. He trespassed into a room with a router, plugged his laptop into it, downloaded papers as quickly as possible, and then rotated his MAC address to dodge the bans that the admin was trying to place on him. That’s very different from downloading a webpage on the open internet.

I’m not saying he should or shouldn’t have been prosecuted, but there’s some kind of rose tinted glasses filter around what happened with Aaron, like he just was browsing the web and was suddenly prosecuted. He repeatedly broke in to a physical room and kept changing his MAC address to dodge bans. At least report it with its full context.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by greyface- on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:59PM (#49381928)
> trespassed into a room

A room with an unlocked and unmarked door, off of a hallway that was open to the general public. An INCREDIBLY tame act compared to other unprosecuted trespasses normalized and celebrated at https://hacks.mit.edu/.

> rotated his MAC address

Not a crime; in fact now a widespread and default practice for consumer Wi-Fi/Bluetooth devices.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:08PM (#49381977)
Were those hackers MIT students? Was Aaron?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by greyface- on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:18PM (#49382070)
Both Aaron and "those hackers" were MIT community members.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:10PM (#49382448)
That's an interesting spin that means precisely nothing. I'm not authorized to enter facilities or building maintenance spaces in buildings in my town because I'm a "community member".
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by greyface- on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:19PM (#49382497)
The general public was authorized to enter the facilities 24/7. The exterior doors were unlocked and it was considered an "open campus". The access controls you see today have only existed since COVID. Whether he was a student at the time also means "precisely nothing".
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by FireBeyond on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:12AM (#49383699)
Really? The expectation was that they could go into facilities closets and plug into the core networking equipment?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by stonedivot on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:26AM (#49383779)
Don't waste your time arguing with people like this. They can't admit the nuance of the situation: what Aaron did was blatantly wrong, and what the government did in response was disproportionate. They will only focus on the latter, and make endless irrational justifications for the former.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by harshreality on Friday August 21, 2026 @04:43AM (#49385450)
The expectation is that MIT doesn't go to the police when someone plugs a computer into a switch in an effectively unlocked data closet.

The expectation is that such individual and laptop doing "unauthorized" scraping doesn't trigger a criminal investigation when the host university, and the target business, didn't implement any meaningful access controls or even rate limiting for any other person on campus.

The expectation is that after an investigation of scraping at 11 req/s (450,000 over 11 hours according to the report), a further 8,000 requests (before JSTOR blocked MIT's /8) two weeks later would not have the effect that "Half the servers in one data center failed, and JSTOR engineers feared that the entire service might go down worldwide." The expectation based on that claim by JSTOR is that JSTOR was incompetent or lying.

The expectation is that when MIT was able and willing to implement access control for JSTOR, and JSTOR declined because they want to develop a notice to MIT visitors who might be negatively affected by ending uncredentialed access, JSTOR would not then create a tempest in a teapot over the violator returning and continuing to download papers at a reduced speed that wasn't even detected for about a month. On Dec 26, when JSTOR again noticed the "abuse", they went to significant effort to route the violator's requests to a special server and serve them garbage instead of the real PDFs, all on short notice... yet they couldn't add the general notice to MIT visitors about the credentials requirement, on a much less urgent timescale; they had told MIT in October that they needed until after Dec 18th to add such a message. The expectation is that JSTOR's claims are self-serving lies.

The expectation is that such a request pattern would not trigger a report, by the MIT libraries director, to the MIT academic council, that a "cyberattack" had been launched from MIT's network.

The expectation is that you don't get arrested for felony B&E for entering a data closet that's effectively unlocked, connecting to a switch, and scraping a paper hosting site that offers free downloads from the entire institutional network.

The expectation is that you don't get charged with larceny for downloading, in any quantity, papers that are freely available to anyone on the MIT campus or probably most other campuses in the U.S.

The expectation is that sending web requests with a url parameter indicating T&C has been agreed to, and without saving cookies, might be a basis for a civil action, but is not "accessing a computer without authorization" under the CFAA.

The entire situation, at most, should've been a minor local crime and a lawsuit by JSTOR against Swartz. Yet the state charges were dropped (feds didn't want to share required discovery material), and JSTOR settled with Swartz before the feds even indicted.

MIT was caught in an awkward position of having the ability to block unauthenticated scraping to protect their contract with and access to JSTOR, but not doing so. So they proceeded to treat someone connecting to a switch in a data closet and doing what any MIT visitor could do, as a criminal offense.

I don't believe anyone at MIT was genuinely concerned that there was some broader criminal conspiracy when the issue was downloading of papers from JSTOR. Certainly not based on some random Chinese IP pinging or scanning Swartz's laptop. When the data closet laptop was discovered in January, MIT could have left a note telling the owner that JSTOR is very upset and it would be better for everyone if the scraping stopped. Why didn't they? They could even, reasonably, have taken the laptop and external drive and noted that the data closet was insecure and please contact network staff to claim it.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by sillysaurusx on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:43PM (#49383083)
I'm not sure if this is meant as some kind of "gotcha," but the legal system doesn't work that way. He wasn't rotating his MAC address as a default practice. He changed the last byte of his MAC only when he noticed he was banned from the network.

Intent matters. Plugging your laptop into a router you normally don't have access to, with intent to download a large number of private articles, means something. And it means more than "I downloaded a lot of public files off the public internet," which is what Meta did.

All of this is in the indictment, which is worth reading: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/217117-united-states...

Personally I think it's a shame that digital crimes can result in prison time at all, except for e.g. crypto theft. But under US law, Aaron committed a crime back then, and it would still classify as a crime today.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by thomasjeff1 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:56PM (#49383179)
From your sourced link.

> JSTOR,founded in 1995, was and continued to be a United States-based, not-for-profit organization that provides an online system for archiving and providing access to academic journal.

If it was online, could any one have access to it? So why him downloading them was breaking the law?

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by sillysaurusx on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:31PM (#49383436)
It was free for MIT students but paid for everyone else, I believe. That's why he needed to jack into MIT's network.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by infinite_spin on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:41AM (#49383865)
JSTOR was free for the public as well, but had a per-day download cap, which IIRC was 3 papers.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by tzs on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:13AM (#49384397)
You are greatly underestimating what was going on.

Over the course of months they tried all kinds of blocking methods that would stop most people, but he kept evading them. It is impossible that he did not know his use of the free access was no longer authorized.

Then he put his equipment on their wired network, which he had no permission to do so and had to trespass to do that. It is irrelevant that the door was unlocked and in a hallway the public could get to. It being unmarked just makes it worse, since doors the public is supposed to use generally are marked.

He also repeatedly came back to that room to check his equipment.

He was now grabbing data at such a high rate that JSTOR cut off all MIT JSTOR access for a few days while they tried to figure out what do next.

At that point MIT research is being disrupted. MIT does a lot of government research and what was going on was indistinguishable at that point from a hostile attack, and police were called.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by josh_p on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:56PM (#49381402)
Yes, he did that. He also settled the problem with jstor, returned the files as part of a civil settlement.

This was overzealous prosecution after the affected party got their remedy.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:26PM (#49381665)
MIT was another affected party, who reached out to the government for help.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by protocolture on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:49AM (#49383914)
Please sir, we lost entire megabytes of bandwidth as someone accessed free resources on the internet, we are such an aggreieved party.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Friday August 21, 2026 @03:38AM (#49385005)
Amusing, but a long string of rogue cyber intrusions coupled with Jstor blocking MIT altogether a few times isn’t something to ignore. Hard to imagine just ignoring the risks and potential of that unknown.

MIT and Jstor had a bunch of incident response going on, and it isn’t a leap to consider Jstor would cut them off for good if the situation went unresolved.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by josh_p on Friday August 21, 2026 @09:37AM (#49387889)
Why do you seem so desperate to characterize Aaron as some amoral super-spy hacker? His ethics are well known. He took issue with Jstor's business model of gatekeeping tax-payer-funded research behind another pay wall, stole some articles, got caught, settled with jstor and MIT. Life could have gone on.

The OP's blog post is about how the law isn't applied equally in the United States. Aaron was an individual and an easy target for the overzealous prosecutor. Meta's a faceless corporation, guilty in the court of public opinion, and they don't even get a timely investigation because they have the money to tie up the broken legal system indefinitely.

Aaron was an example - if you're small enough, you will be caught, tried, and punished in whatever way we see fit to prove that the justice system "works". If you're a billionaire, do whatever you want wink wink.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by DeepSeaTortoise on Saturday August 22, 2026 @01:02PM (#49401574)
There are two entirely different issues:

1. Is the law aligned with moral and ethical expectations? Probably not.

2. Is the process reliable? At least since the Derek Chauvin trials, I'm having doubts, but it doesn't seem it had failed in this case.

Sure, cases of the former need urgent fixing (and we're not getting that), but the latter scenario falls into the "The end is nigh" category.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by voakbasda on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:23PM (#49381101)
Wasn’t Meta found to be scraping from addresses that were not immediately traceable back to them?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:05PM (#49381485)
Maybe, but the prosecution that most people would say lead to his decision to end his life was from abuse of the MIT network over months until they had him on video.

The rate of JSTOR content retrieved from MIT was a separate contract issue.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by ComplexSystems on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:46PM (#49381289)
So what crime was he guilty of that Meta isn't? "Scraping too unsophisticatedly?"
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by smt88 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:23PM (#49381641)
Physical trespassing (as far as we know), but they’ve certainly done all of the rest millions of times.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by nextaccountic on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:47PM (#49381303)
So what's the maximum penalty for trespassing? The prosecution was looking for a disproportionate sentence

About technical countermeasures to evade blocking.. you realize that everybody that does scraping at a large scale employs those, right? Including Meta

Specially nowadays where large swaths of the web is behind captchas

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by qingcharles on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:43PM (#49381820)
If it was charged as trespassing, not something higher like burglary, then the level of his trespass was probably the lowest misdemeanor. Usually trespass is a sliding scale starting with a warning not to return.

Being that it was on a campus, they can sometimes use that as an aggravating factor. I remember one case where a homeless person had a key for a vending machine and took out $30 in quarters, but since the land the vending machine was on was owned by a university he was sentenced to 12 years in prison. One of the few cases that got reversed for a constitutionally exceptional sentence.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:55PM (#49381892)
Don't think they did trespassing:

wire fraud

computer fraud

unlawfully obtaining info from a protected computer

recklessly damaging a protected computer

aiding and abetting

criminal forfeiture

https://web.archive.org/web/20130608041804/https://www.wired...

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by colordrops on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:46PM (#49381291)
Why is that fundamentally different?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 627467 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:38PM (#49381223)
> repeatedly broke in to a room

> rotated his MAC address

Do you really think these details drastically change how people should judge his actions vs those of a corporation?

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:46PM (#49381288)
Yeah, intent matters. Evading security matters. It's a big point that his actions were intentional and not passive or accidental - not that IP infringement by corporations isn't its own discussion.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by LostMyLogin on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:10PM (#49381524)
How is Meta using BitTorrent to download over 80 terabytes of copyrighted books while avoiding using corporate IP addresses not evading security?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:19PM (#49381611)
Torrents are openly accessible, even if .gov might enable infringement claims by the rights-holder. They're not hacking into networks.

Changing your IP isn't a crime, even if it has the effect of making attribution to Meta more difficult.

The thing with Aaron was that it went on for months to the point JSTOR's complaints had activated MIT's organizational antibodies, let's say, and the IS department was turned loose to investigate repeatedly. They went to the trouble of upgrading their load balancers and traffic analysis to narrow it down and installed a camera. At that point, the hook was firmly set and with digital and video evidence, the Secret Service had him red-handed abusing MIT.

Keep in mind the thing that spiraled out of control was how Aaron (mis)used MIT resources persistently and with overwhelming evidence - in the end, the civil part with JSTOR was largely irrelevant. MIT called in the big guns with the FBI and Secret Service, and they ate it up. I'm not arguing in favor of it, I'm just familiar with the zeal they bring once they get on a trail.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by LostMyLogin on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:54PM (#49382344)
> Changing your IP isn't a crime, even if it has the effect of making attribution to Meta more difficult.

To borrow your words, intent matters.

Also why are we acting as if Meta wasn’t doing this for over half a decade and that companies don’t actively take steps to try and prevent piracy?

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 63stack on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:12PM (#49381549)
Sure intent matters but I still don't see how this warrants the government going after him.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by 9x39 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:31PM (#49381708)
MIT called up the government and said there's this guy. Whether they should have is debatable, but they did.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by bigstrat2003 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:46PM (#49382282)
No, but they do drastically change how people should judge his actions vs someone who simply downloaded some documents that were served on an open web server. OP didn't say "it's ok if a corporation does that", he said that Aaron's actions were more serious than people commonly make them out to be.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by PenguinCoder on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:09PM (#49380930)
Information should be free.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by hk1337 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:17PM (#49381594)
Agreed, to an extent, but that doesn't mean you can breach any barrier someone has in place preventing access, take it, and make it publicly available.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:38PM (#49381770)
The information Swartz was downloading was scientific papers that we, the public, have already paid for with our tax dollars. The crime here is that the government allows JSTOR and other private companies to still hold those papers behind paywalls instead of releasing them into the public domain as they should have been.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by s1artibartfast on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:44PM (#49381828)
Doesn't matter if the public funded it. The public didn't mandate or pay for the publication rights or access.

The public might donate food to the poor. That doesn't give them the right to go into their house and rummage through their fridge.

Maybe there is a missed opportunity to require open access as a condition of public grant funding. That doesn't change the fact that it is not a stipulated condition.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:50PM (#49381875)
> Doesn't matter if the public funded it. The public didn't mandate or pay for the publication rights or access.

So when your tax dollars pay for a scientist to do research, you don't think the papers that document that research should be public property? If scientists want to keep their research private, they should find private funding.

Note that, as in my previous post, I said "should". If you mean there isn't explicit language to that effect in the grants, see further comments below.

> The public might donate food to the poor. That doesn't give them the right to go into their house and rummage through their fridge.

Invalid comparison. The scientific papers in question are not the personal property of the scientists.

> Maybe there is a missed opportunity to require open access as a condition of public grant funding.

IMO this should be the case, and it's an outrage that it's not, since it should be an obvious requirement for any research that our tax dollars pay for.

> That doesn't change the fact that it is not a stipulated condition.

Maybe that wasn't written into the grants explicitly, but that just means our government is (once again) failing to act in our best interests.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by s1artibartfast on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:09PM (#49381988)
It seems like you are jumping between the reality you would like with the reality that exists.

It is fine to want for something to be different, but that doesn't change the facts of how they are.

It's fine to advocate future papers be made public. I think it is antisocial and delusional to say past papers belong to the public just because that's what you would have wanted. The word for this is expostfacto recontracting, and undermines just about any system of law where is used.

Last there are lots of reasons to pay for research even if it is not made public. Free public access is often the least of those concerns. Especially so when 99% of researchers whom might make meaningful use of the publication already have access through a journal system.

To understand this better, consider private drug patents coming from Public Funding. The government might rightly calculate that it is in the public interest too help a for-profit company develop a cancer cure with grants, then have no cure at all.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:18PM (#49382487)
> It seems like you are jumping between the reality you would like and the reality that exists.

No, you did that, by responding to my post where I said "should" as though I were trying to describe how things are instead of how they ought to be.

> I think it is antisocial and delusional to say past papers belong to the public just because that's what you would have wanted.

I didn't say that. You need to work on your reading comprehension.

> The word for this is expostfacto recontracting

No, the word for what you're doing is putting words in my mouth and attacking a straw man.

> there are lots of reasons to pay for research even if it is not made public.

Can you give some?

> Especially so when 99% of researchers whom might make meaningful use of the publication already have access through a journal system.

Which they then have to pay fees to, using more of our tax dollars, because of the sweetheart deals the government has given the journals.

Not only that, but researchers nowadays share copies of papers over the Internet routinely (for example, using sites like arxiv.org), so they don't even need journals to know what other researchers are doing. So even that rationale for paying the journals is now out of date.

> consider private drug patents coming from Public Funding

A patent requires revealing the information that the invention is based on, in exchange for the exclusive right to produce the item for some period of time. So I don't see how this is an argument for keeping publicly funded research behind a paywall.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by s1artibartfast on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:36PM (#49383468)
> No, you did that, by responding to my post where I said "should" as though I were trying to describe how things are instead of how they ought to be.

I dont really want to get into a tit for tat, but for clarification, you said several times that the public had paid for the papers. Researchers were not paid to create open access papers. You even said it was criminal that they weren't.

> didn't say that. You need to work on your reading comprehension.

rude...

> Can you give some?

I gave a few. The government may want the technology in production and dont care at all about any public disclosure. all the researchers they care about will have journal access either way.

One I didn't mention is that researchers want the freedom to publish as they choose. The government is happy to trade this away as part of the grant process.

The point I was trying to illustrate is that there is no reason to think open access is a non-negotiable or top priority from the government (or public good) perspective. All things being equal, it is nice to have.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:26PM (#49392073)
> You said several times that the public had paid for the papers. Researchers were not paid to create open access papers. You even said it was criminal that they weren't.

I had assumed that readers would be able to exercise intelligence and common sense to see that I was describing how things should be, not how they are. Evidently I assumed too much in your case.

> rude...

It is to laugh: you had no problem describing me as "antisocial" and "delusional", and now you're complaining that I am being rude?

I think I'm done here.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by silver_sun on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:38PM (#49382618)
>The public might donate food to the poor. That doesn't give them the right to go into their house and rummage through their fridge.

I think a better analogy for this situation is: The public donates food, then the recipient, after being fed, sells access to (infinite cheaply replicable copies of) said food for a profit. The public in this case just wants to have said food.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by s1artibartfast on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:48AM (#49383902)
Maybe we are better off avoiding the analogies.

The public gives them cash for terms of a grant. If those dont include an open access paper, it is unreasonable to demand it after the fact. It certainly doesn't give a right to go take take their papers (or whatever they made).

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by silver_sun on Sunday August 23, 2026 @10:00PM (#49414476)
There's some common-sense understanding of this situation that I'm not sure you're wilfully overlooking or oblivious to. The claim is that it's unjust to blatantly exploit a system that was intended to fund/sustain you, for profit. It's not necessarily illegal behavior since "open access" was not in the terms, but how can it possibly be morally defensible that they have managed to find a way to legally subvert/trick the system for their own benefit? An overly pedantic view of the situation isn't helpful.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by s1artibartfast on Saturday August 29, 2026 @01:08AM (#49487052)
Its not subversion or a trick. It is reasonable and functioning as intended.

There was no deception or trick. It was 100% up front and what those involved expected.

There is no moral failing aside from those stealing and spreading outrage.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by tzs on Friday August 21, 2026 @01:37AM (#49384207)
JSTOR didn't own the copyright to any of the material, so could only serve it under the license agreements it had. Nevertheless they were able to arrange for their license to allow over 10000 schools, libraries, and other institutions to provide free access to walk-in users.

A large number of the material on JSTOR wouldn't be online at all if not for JSTOR, because they have put a lot of time and money into digitizing back issues of journals that the publishers probably would have never gotten around to.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Friday August 21, 2026 @07:25PM (#49394983)
> they were able to arrange for their license to allow over 10000 schools, libraries, and other institutions to provide free access to walk-in users.

Sure, but that still only covers a miniscule fraction of US taxpayers. Plus, you have to walk in to the school, library, or other institution, instead of just being able to use your web browser at home.

> A large number of the material on JSTOR wouldn't be online at all if not for JSTOR, because they have put a lot of time and money into digitizing back issues of journals that the publishers probably would have never gotten around to.

This is a genuine value add, but it could have been paid for by the government directly without then having the material behind a paywall.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by zymhan on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:24PM (#49382113)
Surely it depends on the specific information in question?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by MattDamonSpace on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:25PM (#49381118)
“People who generate valuable information should be uncompensated”
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by msftgreed on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:54PM (#49381387)
You say this like it's related to the parent quote. We could absolutely compensate people and not charge for information. It's not that hard to imagine that we could feed, house, care for, and provide a small stipend to authors, artists, etc. and also make their work output free to everyone who wants it.

Does that require changing some other things? Absolutely. Would it be hard to convince people to try? Probably (I'm guessing HN crowd won't like this comment, considering it unreasonable.) Has it been a suggested way to organize society for almost 200 years with a long and well argued set of principles behind it? Sure enough!

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by pdonis on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:39PM (#49381783)
The scientists who wrote the papers that Swartz downloaded were compensated, with the public's tax dollars. That should mean that we the public should now have free access to what we paid for. Unfortunately the government prefers to let private companies keep those papers behind paywalls.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by ajam1507 on Saturday August 22, 2026 @12:25PM (#49401260)
JSTOR isn't just full of publicly funded work.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by xigoi on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:40AM (#49384583)
How much money do you think the scientists who wrote the papers are getting from the access fees? (Hint: it’s the only number that stays the same when you multiply it by sometting.)
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by aeve890 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:20PM (#49381059)
What's the point of statements so broad and ambiguous that they seem to disregard any kind of context or nuance? Do you really believe that _Information_ should be free? Which one? All of it?
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by maximinus_thrax on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:30PM (#49381701)
> and then rotated his MAC address to dodge the bans that the admin was trying to place on him

And corporate scrapers never ever use proxy pools to rotate IPs to evade throttling and blacklisting. Meta is also scraping illegal content, such as pirated books. So I'm not sure what your argument is.

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by silver_sun on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:42PM (#49382649)
The difference here is that the scientific papers he downloaded weren't freely available to the public, like those scraped webpages would be. Corporate scrapers have been sued[0] in the past for scraping pages from behind a login page / paywall.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn

Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by maximinus_thrax on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:17PM (#49391943)
Neither are the pirated books Meta is using for model training.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by silver_sun on Sunday August 23, 2026 @09:52PM (#49414424)
I totally agree with you, and didn't mean to endorse that.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by Cabal on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:49PM (#49382303)
Thank you. It's absurd that we are comparing breaking into MIT and (physically) breaking into a network with scraping the web and scanning physical books.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by rib3ye on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:33AM (#49383824)
The core argument makes a lot more sense when you compare Aaron’s pirating via network closet with Meta’s pirating via BitTorrent.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by AngryData on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:48AM (#49383904)
To me his crime is the equivalent of sneaking into a public library with a photocopier and copying down books without having a library card. It is not and should not be that serious. Is it annoying? Yes. Should he have gotten in a bit of trouble? Sure. But nothing like what he was charged with or dealt with. They hammered down serious law on this guy for what should of at worse been a petty crime.
Re:Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does... by lofaszvanitt on Friday August 21, 2026 @07:39AM (#49386621)
And that warrants a 7-8 years sentence, without a plea? Maybe in a police state.