News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pizza234 on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:14PM (#49215667)
In our team's experience, the product of agents is generally The Homer (1). It does work, but it's vastly overengineered.

When I personally want tight code, I have to spend a considerable amount of time adjusting it manually:

- It needs to be trimmed down. In my experience, at least one agent I use struggles to produce minimalist designs, and it's very frustrating

- I need to consider whether there are solutions based on higher-level assumptions, that AIs typically miss

- I need to check whether there are off-the-shelf solutions - AIs like to reinvent the wheel

IMO, software production has become a mass-produced commodity in every sense - it's much more expensive to produce software manually, but the quality is not the same.

(1) https://simpsons.fandom.com/wiki/The_Homer

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by extr on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:24PM (#49215776)
This was more true a few months ago but Fable has improved the situation considerably.

Also just remember - minimalist code looks and feels great but customers do not read your code. I have caught myself many times providing "corrections" to abstractions that were already ~fine, just not perfect. The average SWE costs $200/hr. Careful you don't burn $50 worrying about code that will likely be rewritten or can be better abstracted when that's actually needed.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by dieselgate on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:31PM (#49215851)
> The average SWE costs $200/hr

This is a pointless quibble but the hourly rate claim is not true--it's like ~$60 in the USA [0]. Maybe you meant at a specific Org but this is important context when comparing "pricing" between human and AI.

[0] https://www.salaryexpert.com/salary/job/software-developer/u...

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by extr on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:36PM (#49215922)
How is this not true? Taking a Senior SWE @ ~$200K, even just the base salary cost / 2080 working hours is $100/hr. Fully loaded employer cost + accounting for non-coding time gets you to upper 100s easily.

Even for a junior making $100K, I have a hard time believe their time is worth less than $75/hr or so.

Edit: Fine, "Senior" is not "Average". But naive salary is not the true numerator.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pdhborges on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:51PM (#49216103)

   I have a hard time believe their time is worth less than $75/hr or so.
In many places in Europe it is.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by Foobar8568 on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:21PM (#49216382)
Western Europe is mostly consultancy, and the rate paid by client is usually higher, and doesn't matter if it's eastern Europe, Portugal or even India.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by rustystump on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:35PM (#49217786)
It is. And the quality is on par with any us eng. People here forget that the big comp packages are a minority even in the US. The cost tho is much higher than just salary.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by anon73044 on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:49PM (#49216064)
Company time != Pay rate, if you're working somewhere that's publicly traded check out "revenue per employee" metrics sometime.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by jknoepfler on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:51PM (#49217190)
I hire contractors for a large enterprise in the US. The going rate is typically $85-$100/hr for a senior dev, depending on specialization. Lead-level maybe $120 for the right skill set.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by sublinear on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:21PM (#49216915)
Of course, the SWEs making that much (over 200k) are not representative of the broader field. That's the point.

Pay hits a ceiling, and that ceiling is moving lower regardless of experience. That has nothing to do with AI, but what the market will bear. Hiring counts of humans must increase no matter what. Moving some of the spend to AI reduces the risk of hiring less qualified employees they might have rejected a decade ago.

Wages at the top end are stagnating to subsidize this. That's undeniable.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by copperx on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:34PM (#49215894)
$15, where we're going.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by fragmede on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:43PM (#49217512)
Federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by russellbeattie on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:57PM (#49216165)
An MBA's rule of thumb is that a full time employee's hourly cost to a business is at least 1.5x to 2x times their salary depending on employer taxes, benefits, offices, travel, training, hardware, perks, etc.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by BobbyJo on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:40PM (#49215969)
Minimalist code is necessary to keep AI agents working well for longer than a month on a system IME. At a certain point, their own machinations overwhelm them and they both slow down, and make worse and worse decisions.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by sejje on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:57PM (#49216158)
Also, you can probably think about it like this:

"Will I benefit from this code being minimalist before [date]", where [date] is whenever you think the agent will be good enough to come back and make the corrections you would make today.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by Terr_ on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:53PM (#49218762)
I'd caution that some corrections become harder to make over time, rather than easier. A bad architecture now can become much harder to fix once other things have grown up around it.

Even as a self-contained unit, you can't step in the same river twice, and on [date] some important details may have seriously faded, both in terms of text that can be mined and also in terms of human "why did we do that" and "what was the reason we did it this way and not that way" etc.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by j-bos on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:36PM (#49215926)
> The average SWE costs $200/hr.

And this is how I find out I'm woefully underpaid.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by icedchai on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:14PM (#49216853)
That "cost" includes all the overhead provided by the company: benefits, rent for offices, utilities, equipment, etc. The average SWE is not taking home anything close to that, outside of Silicon Valley and a few other limited areas.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by jacquesm on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:18PM (#49216350)
Whatever you are making this year as SWE you'll be making less next year if the current trend in improvement of AI coding aids is going to be sustained. Think about it : programmers used to derive a lot of their value from the fact that it was a hard skill to acquire. My kids can now 'vibe code' stuff faster (and better looking) than what I could come up with as the beginnings of a design plan. And then I still need to implement it.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by alfalfasprout on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:42PM (#49216573)
There's a massive difference between your kids vibe coding something and an engineer using AI to implement something. If you're unable to discern the difference, that's something to reflect on :)
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by throw-the-towel on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:52PM (#49216660)
It doesn't matter if GP is able to discern the difference, it matters if your CEO is forced to care about the difference.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by ipaddr on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:29AM (#49218907)
CEOs will always want someone who knows to implement so we're safe from kids vibe coding their way in but in a short while it becomes AI who knows who is managing less expensive AI.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by lelanthran on Saturday August 08, 2026 @04:36AM (#49219935)
If he is unable to discern a difference, then a paying customer almost certainly won't.

We're entering a market of lemons in software. It's going to be interesting indeed.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by junto on Saturday August 08, 2026 @04:42PM (#49225717)
You might be paid $100/hr but it costs the employee $200/hr. It’s worth mentioning because cost to the company is not just your salary, but the taxes, pension and contributions on the other side, plus a variety of other things that the employee doesn’t consider.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by slopinthebag on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:31PM (#49216474)
The average SWE makes $400k a year? Are you being serious?
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by fragmede on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:50PM (#49217539)
Costs, not makes. That includes employer taxes, benefits, offices, travel, training, hardware, any perks.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by dieselgate on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:29PM (#49215832)
It took me a few seconds of deliberating if The Homer was a reference to baseball or "The Odyssey" and then realized there was a footnote

> software production has become a mass-produced commodity in every sense - it's much more expensive to produce software manually, but the quality is not the same.

Agreed.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by GoofGarage on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:32PM (#49217773)
I believe “The Homer” is a reference to Season 2, Episode 15 of The Simpsons, “Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?”

Homer reunites with his long lost brother, who runs car company Powell Motors. Homer is ultimately tasked by his brother with helping to design a car for the “average man” that ultimately bankrupts the company for being wildly overengineered and costing too much ($82,000 in 1991-money).

Here’s the car: https://simpsons.fandom.com/wiki/The_Homer

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by thejazzman on Saturday August 08, 2026 @04:36AM (#49219930)
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by frevib on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:40PM (#49215970)
No surprise, LLM companies optimize for waste. More tokens, and more prompts means more revenue. Reminds of Google’s Prabhakar Raghavan story: deliberately making search worse [1]

[1]: https://pluralistic.net/2024/04/24/naming-names/#prabhakar-r...

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by nomel on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:14PM (#49218008)
Or, more likely, it's that concise code requires a much deeper, wholistic, understanding that these models just are capable of yet.

Same with a junior dev. They don't write long form spaghetti because they're trying to write more LOC. They do it because not doing it is hard, literally above their pay grade.

I use LLM every day, but they're still completely awful at architecture. I don't think this clear lack of ability is some conspiracy.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by lilbigdoot on Saturday August 08, 2026 @01:19AM (#49219084)
Personal anecdote: I spent a few days hacking on my compiler to remove 1k lines of code (about 15% of total code) while preserving behavior

I was only able to do that after I had solved multiple related problems in different places and started introducing subtle bugs by accident / had difficulty detecting all edge cases

I've noticed whenever I use LLMs they introduce the same kind of thing but at much smaller scales than I would. They often suggest solving the wrong problem when I prompt them to diagnose specific bugs too. Usually opting for a shortcut that introduces its own issues and ironically calling the proper direction "too complex" when it's really not.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by frevib on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:33PM (#49223339)
> I don't think this clear lack of ability is some conspiracy.

Maybe currently not. But we will never be able to know, as models are undeterministic and benchmarks are kind of scams. When you cannot prove that something gets worse, rest assured companies will to it.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by nomel on Saturday August 08, 2026 @05:30PM (#49226085)
This requires something other than a free market, and for China to not exist. We're not there yet. There's plenty of competition to prevent this, for now, with AI spending being an incredibly hot issue.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by frevib on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:36AM (#49242315)
Currently the bad quality of architecture and holistic view of models is probably explained by the fact that the models just cannot do it. Free markets and China will make sure of that, kind of. In reality Claude and Codex are better and provide much better tooling, so not much competition from free markets and self-hosted models from China, I think.

Then when competition really settles to monoploy or duopoly, like it always does in bigtech, it is really difficult to prove Anthropic and OpenAI enshittify their models. Same with Opus 4.6, that suddenly was worse when 4.7 came out.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by nomel on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:10PM (#49249789)
> Currently the bad quality of architecture and holistic view of models is probably explained by the fact that the models just cannot do it. Free markets and China will make sure of that, kind of.

I'm not following. Free markets and China will make sure that models stay bad!? Why didn't these entities already stop the progression we've seen? What has been motivating them all this time that has preventing them from stopping?

Keep in mind this was all science fiction just a few years ago.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by bonoboTP on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:40PM (#49223405)
Bullshit. You can be cynical, it's fine but this is just nonsense. People have so much demand for coding that there is no need to make it waste tokens. People are eager to implement more features, do more testing, more platforms, more file formats, bla bla. There is absolutely no incentive to waste tokens. They can barely serve the demanded tokens anyway. There is in fact incentive to save tokens, so subsidized subscriptions don't consume as much.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pianopatrick on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:05PM (#49216794)
If software has become a mass-produced commodity then seems to me the software business will become a much more finance focused business

You will really have to weigh the cost of making the software against the expected revenue.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by roncesvalles on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:13PM (#49217337)
Since software is still a winner-takes-all market, the mass-production property of software doesn't really matter.

In such markets, what you produce is either worth nothing or worth millions of dollars. For as long as it's the case that well-constructed code (with or without LLM help) is more likely to be in the latter category, the economics of software don't really change.

Even before LLMs, you could've commissioned a half-assed clone of any app you wanted from a 3rd world consultancy for a few thousand dollars. LLMs are basically Bangalore-as-API.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by oblio on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:37PM (#49217472)
> Since software is still a winner-takes-all market, the mass-production property of software doesn't really matter.

Fairly sure software dev was always an iceberg. Most software and most software devs aren't working on horizontal software, but on vertical software, in cost centers. Sales for that kind of software don't scale as much.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by roncesvalles on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:42PM (#49217504)
Most vertical software is just horizontal software glued together
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by oblio on Saturday August 08, 2026 @09:23AM (#49221639)
Horizontal open source modules... And making the horizontal modules doesn't employ many people, both because of FOSS and also because you only need so many reusable modules.

When we were making brick houses we needed a few brick factories with thousands of people for million of bricklayers.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pianopatrick on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:33PM (#49217781)
I think part of the reason software was winner take most was the difficulty of making software.

I remember hearing a story that in the past movies were so technically difficult to make that any movie that got made had a good chance to be a profitable hit. But as movies got cheaper to make, more movies got made. Nowadays movie studio execs have to really calculate out the audience and expected revenue for any new movie and balance that against the budget and the cost of the studio's failed movies.

I think a similar dynamic may happen in software

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pcox on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:01AM (#49218790)
> I think part of the reason software was winner take most was the difficulty of making software.

That might be part of it, but I think it also has to do with the reality of replicating and scaling. Hardware or physical goods simply don’t scale like digital goods. There can be hundreds of knock-off physical products that have lower quality and lower cost but serve 90% of the same purpose, because physical capacity for raw materials, construction, labor, shipping, etc. have scaling limits in each market and economy. Digital goods are just so much easier to replicate and scale, so it often doesn’t make sense to buy software at lower quality and lower price if it doesn’t do most of the job. There are still limits of course, and different from physical goods, but I think this is a key reason why software is seen as winner-take-all.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by pianopatrick on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:47AM (#49218975)
Yes, but there are other digital goods, like music, movies and books which are not quite as hard to make as software. In those you have a hit driven market dynamic with lots of niches instead of winner take all.

I.e. because software was hard to make and complex to copy you would tend to have "natural monopolies" that were hard to compete with. Who wants to try to build a new desktop OS to compete with Windows? Or a web browser from scratch? Or a new search engine? Etc.

Those and other pieces of software were complex and hard to make. The cost to copy and compete was very high. So one winner took most because that winner was the company who could figure that software out.

But as we can see with Kimi Work and other such things, software is now much easier to copy. Let's say it took $1 billion to make a copycat piece of software with people but now takes $100 million or $10 million with AI. Suddenly a copy and compete tactic makes much more sense than before

For example, with AI it might make financial sense to build a Chinese Native OS instead of Windows. Similarly for Russia, Iran, the EU, and a whole bunch of other places. All of a sudden, Windows might not be the winner take most OS, we might have lots of Operating Systems, with smaller markets and lower profits, which require much more careful financial analysis to stay profitable.

This would be just like Movies, TV Shows, Books or Music. When something works, people relentlessly copy it and different regions put their own spin on the idea. After Iron Man succeeded we had so many super hero movies. Etc. So there is not really a winner take most dynamic in these other digital products. Software may be moving that way

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by xbmcuser on Saturday August 08, 2026 @08:08AM (#49221046)
I disagree the worth of software will become a lot less as LLM take hold and more people outside software devs know how to use them properly. I am the default IT manager for our small office as I am the guy most interested in tech and in the last 2-3 years I am getting llm to write python scripts for me to do work that would have cost $100s of dollars. Currently you need to pay $100-1000s for a software with 100s of features while you might actually need 1 or 2 of the features which you can get the llm to write for you.

As the LLM's keep getting better at writing software actual coding skills required will decrease which will result in a huge influx of software crashing prices. You can see this in already in open source projects in the last 6 months to a year Jellyfin had a huge influx of custom clients made by different people for fixing their own itches about the official software.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by hyperadvanced on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:02PM (#49217938)
That honestly sounds a lot healthier than “just ship what the CTO/Product team wants” with as much hand waving as is necessary to very roughly estimate ROI and then pray it hits with the market. In anything that’s not a startup operating in a new industry, the “old way” is a hard way to run a business
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by sevenzero on Saturday August 08, 2026 @07:06AM (#49220671)
>Since software is still a winner-takes-all market, the mass-production property of software doesn't really matter.

This could not be further from the truth. It might be true if the software works without supervisors in a B2C scenario where everything is self explanatory and nothing can go wrong, movie streaming services for example, and even these have tons of variants and multiple big players racking up billions in market share. So even there "winner-takes-all" does not apply. It gets even worse in B2B software, as there is SO MUCH software thats commonly used and needs tons of supervising by experienced devs. If we had a "winner-takes-all" market a lot more software would already be dead. And a lot of companies would have way less options when adopting new software for something.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by roncesvalles on Saturday August 08, 2026 @01:16PM (#49223742)
"Winner-takes-all" in the software context is never meant literally. It's more like, an oligarchy of a few winners will emerge out of hundreds of contenders.

It's not like restaurants where for example you can open a "Larry's Pizzeria" and still build a valuable business despite a Domino's nearby.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by sublinear on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:15PM (#49216861)
> software production has become a mass-produced commodity

For who?

The public? The public has never liked buying software at any price.

Businesses? Businesses need higher quality software when it's relevant to their core competencies, so they hire people instead. Buying competing SaaS or depending too much on AI is throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by eitally on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:49PM (#49217168)
As a business user, the same thing is true for non-code documents. The biggest exertion is reducing the excessive slop down to concise, clear points.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by redhale on Saturday August 08, 2026 @10:53AM (#49222418)
I largely agree, but when this point is brought up I always feel the need to go one step further:

For the vast majority of software out there, this quality gap simply doesn't matter. Not everything is big tech, needing internet scale. Most software built by developers at non-tech companies are simple line-of-business apps used by a handful to a few dozen or maybe a few hundred people to do a thing a bit better than the Excel spreadsheet that was used before.

And AI has essentially automated the development of this kind of software. Or rather, it has dramatically increased the ability of skilled developers to produce larger amounts of these kinds of systems.

Excel hardest hit.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by zobzu on Saturday August 08, 2026 @11:47AM (#49222935)
i don't think people writing this understand how computers work. there is no "Internet scale hard" problem. its reliability, safety, efficiency problems. these problems exist at any scale. ai sucks at it.
Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by redhale on Saturday August 08, 2026 @03:31PM (#49225081)
> its reliability, safety, efficiency problems. these problems exist at any scale

Respectfully, I disagree. When you have 5 users using an app sandboxed within the corporate firewall that just does some CRUD and basic workflows, these problems you're calling out really just don't matter much. Some do some of the time, but not much.

Obviously not all software falls into this category. But so, so much does. Do you know how many thousands of tiny applications are maintained by big all non-big-tech corporations? I've seen many of them up close -- the code is usually complete garbage (seriously, it's bad; and alas, most was written before the age of AI coding agents), and yet, the business continues to operate and use the software.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by myegorov on Saturday August 08, 2026 @02:00PM (#49224204)
> For the vast majority of software out there, this quality gap simply doesn't matter.

You don't mean the majority of paid for software can behave non-deterministically? That's the value add of the human in the loop.

Re:Databricks drove down AI coding spend 70% by sandworm101 on Saturday August 08, 2026 @11:56AM (#49223000)
>> In my experience, at least one agent I use struggles to produce minimalist designs, and it's very frustrating

Which ones don't?

I used to play Wing Commander II. It was 30mb. Today, the software to adjust the colored lights on my keyboard requires literally a thousand times as much memory.