News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Tiberium on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:16AM (#48687660)
Wanted to mention that Sailfish has a lot of closed-source components, especially UI-related, despite the overall marketing/"vibe" making it look very open. If anything, AOSP (Android) is more open than Sailfish. I don't think this has changed with Sailfish 5, see e.g.:

- https://forum.sailfishos.org/t/sailfish-os-clarifying-claims...

- https://docs.sailfishos.org/Develop/Open_Source/

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by mrbn100ful on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:29AM (#48687829)
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by bri3d on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:55AM (#48688124)
> It's still more open than AOSP

I don't think this is true at all? AOSP is completely open source modulo driver blobs (which Sailfish has too) and Google services.

One can make a fully functional system, modulo drivers, out of only open-source components using AOSP. It's not possible to do this using Sailfish; the compositor, UI libraries (Silica), and most of the "core" apps are still closed source.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by mrbn100ful on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:58AM (#48688153)
The compositor is open (Lipstick) : https://github.com/sailfishos/lipstick

And OSS projet based on the SFOS core exist : https://nemomobile.net/, https://github.com/nemomobile-ux

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by bri3d on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:05PM (#48688238)
Ahh, thanks for the correction, it's the window manager that's closed (lipstick-jolla-home). Regardless, I will stand by my statement that a fully open-source build of AOSP is significantly more complete and useful than a fully open-source build of Jolla.

If we're going to start counting forks, we get to count LineageOS and GrapheneOS for Android, and then the goalposts really move.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fabrice_d on Friday June 26, 2026 @01:11PM (#48689086)
A pure AOSP distribution is now lacking a lot of basic apps. Distributions like LineageOS or GrapheneOS fill the gap with their own, but pure AOSP is totally unusable.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by written-beyond on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:01PM (#48692540)
Googles been quietly chipping away at AOSP for years. There was a point where AOSP was actually decent, google made sure that wasn't the case for long.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ktosobcy on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:25PM (#48688508)
I kinda wish NemoMobile would be default UI… current SailfishUI with force gestures is (for me) highly annoying…
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by dadoum on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:57AM (#48688149)
If I remember correctly a lot of AOSP core apps have been discontinued though.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:05PM (#48688239)
I think people got too used to bundling by Apple and Google. For most of the core apps there are good and open source alternatives available.

The main point is that AOSP as a system (modulo firmware) is open source and SailfishOS is not. Also, even though Sailfish has an Android compatibility layer (though only for official devices), compatibility is most likely always going to be worse than 'real' Android.

That said, I hope that Jolla Phone becomes a success, more competition is good. Hopefully being funded better will move them to fully open source the base system.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by mrbn100ful on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:02PM (#48688198)
Yes and most people don't realize that the current "AOSP" apps are the LineageOS apps.

A true AOPS image is missing most core Apps.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by charcircuit on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:33PM (#48688610)
Because no one was using them. Everyone was replacing them and shipping other apps. AOSP is very modular and customizable letting you configure what apps get included in the OS.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by lern_too_spel on Friday June 26, 2026 @01:14PM (#48689119)
The Email app had been forked into K-9 Mail, which later became Thunderbird for Android. AOSP Browser no longer made sense to develop after Chromium was ported to Android. And so on. The barebones applications in AOSP have been succeeded by better open source apps outside the AOSP repos. It doesn't make sense to maintain them when nobody putting together an Android distribution would choose to use them over those alternatives.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by singpolyma3 on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:54AM (#48688106)
I think you mean less. Since AOSP is fully open?
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Andromxda on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:58AM (#48697481)
> It's still more open than AOSP

Uh, no? How are you getting this idea?

This is the manifest file for GrapheneOS: https://github.com/GrapheneOS/platform_manifest/blob/17/defa...

It literally contains links to all the AOSP repos or GrapheneOS forks of them. You can clone these exact repos and build the OS from source. GrapheneOS provides instructions for it: https://grapheneos.org/build

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Retr0id on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:26AM (#48687798)
Huh. I really don't see the point of this, vs something like GrapheneOS.

Edit: I'm well aware of the differences between typical Linux and Android (especially the security architecture!), and I'm willing to make some sacrifices in the name of FOSS... but only if it's actually FOSS.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ttkari on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:35AM (#48687913)
If what you want is android and you have privacy concerns, GrapheneOS is probably the best you can get.

Then again, SailfishOS is a linux with much of the usual linux stuff like userland with bash, coreutils, glibc, systemd, wayland, pulseaudio etc.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:10PM (#48688314)
And way less security, sandboxing is far more limited and the default profile looks pretty much YOLO:

https://github.com/sailfishos/sailjail-permissions/blob/mast...

Given how sensitive information most people have on their phones (banking, chats, and whatnot), it's a disaster in the making.

The typical answer is "but I'll only use open source apps that I trust". Sandboxing doesn't only protect you against rogue apps, it primarily protects you against 0-days in apps that you do trust.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by uniqueuid on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:01PM (#48689829)
It's very simple, this is about the threat model.

If you are worried about big players profiling you (hard to avoid, high likelihood of happening, low likelihood of damage), then you want Sailfish.

If you are worried about apps profiling you (easy to avoid, high likelihood of happening, moderate likelihood of damage), you want Android or iOS.

Graphene and Sailfish sit on different points on that spectrum, just like OpenBSD and Linux do.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:52AM (#48695549)
Sorry, this does not make any sense. E.g. vanilla GrapheneOS does not have Google Play services and no analytics from big players at all.

Even if you choose not to install Play Services/Play Store, you will still have access to many more apps than on SailfishOS - from many open source Android apps to proprietary apps that you can download without the Play Store. Plus, with the Linux terminal support in Pixels (note: not all Android phones support this, e.g. Snapdragons don't support privileged virtualization), you can also run Linux desktop apps.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ThatMedicIsASpy on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:56AM (#48688129)
My xperia 10 iii was 280€(+50€ OS) vs 500€++ for a pixel.

But I hate phones. All I want is navigation, sms/call, signal, steam and firefox.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:12PM (#48688334)
Ehm, a Pixel 9a is currently 349 Euro here (10a 399 Euro). Given that the OS is free, that's only a 19 Euro difference. For a much better camera, much better SoC, much better pretty much everything.

Of course, if your goal is to run SailfishOS, there is currently not much of another option.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ThatMedicIsASpy on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:19PM (#48692719)
My phone is a couple of years old at this point. A Pixel 7 was the newest i think. I don't care about cameras, I don't care about specs. All I need is listed.

My phone would have a screen time of a few mins per day. I can't stand doing anything on these tiny touch screens or browsing the web on a phone screen.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:48AM (#48695536)
The Pixel A lineup has always been affordable. Heck, the 4a was even $349 at introduction. The currently start a little higher, but are often around 350 Euro halfway the cycle.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ThatMedicIsASpy on Saturday June 27, 2026 @02:31AM (#48695734)
gOS stops supporting a device when its EOL.

A cheaper 6a would be EOL next year.

They also came later vs 6/6Pro

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DANmode on Saturday June 27, 2026 @02:35AM (#48695747)
Stops officially supporting - often still gets patches.

6a is a 2022 phone, 7a is $150 on Swappa.

Where are we going with this?

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ThatMedicIsASpy on Saturday June 27, 2026 @02:54AM (#48695830)
No idea you guys make up prices and devices when I made my choices years ago?

All I can give you is my reasoning for picking it. Not giving google my money is always a plus in my book.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DANmode on Saturday June 27, 2026 @03:37AM (#48696059)
I had no way to know it was years ago,

and I don’t consider buying used and flashing “giving Google my money”.

Although it definitely enables the market for Pixels, they definitely don’t make much (if any) money selling Pixels, due to they’re being cheap-yet-flagship devices.

It might even hurt Google for you to buy them and not capture all your data with their OS!

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:36PM (#48699648)
How are new pixels cheap?
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DANmode on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:23PM (#48700017)
Compare to comparable iPhone or Galaxy Phone hardware.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:54PM (#48700262)
Compared to iPhones yeah, they're a bit cheaper.

Compared to Samsungs, they seem to have comparable prices for less performing hardware, to me.

But what about all the other phones?

Are all Chinese manufacturers selling at a loss?

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DANmode on Saturday June 27, 2026 @05:18PM (#48701854)
No, their costs are way lower.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:32PM (#48702846)
How?

Pixels are manufactured in China, Vietnam and India.

Maybe their flash gates are made by hand, given how much more they ask for decent storage amounts...

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DANmode on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:25PM (#48703132)
But not sold there,

so not sold at the same rate.

Price goes down when you do a run of 10 million boards

vs 1 million.

(and or the facility making them is yours!)

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:13PM (#48703369)
Chinese phones are a lot cheaper everywhere, and some brand is likely to sell less than Google.

Not to mention that the Pixels were a lot more convenient years ago, when they sold a lot less.

I think you're clutching at straws here, Pixels were cheapish in the first versions, but are not anymore ;)

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by WickyNilliams on Saturday June 27, 2026 @05:47AM (#48696721)
My partner just got a 10a brand new, no contract for £250! Extremely good value.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:33PM (#48699631)
For 128gb without sd card support, you should specify that

Most people will fill that up in a glimpse without using cloud services

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsfasfd on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:00PM (#48688177)
You might be interested in the callback:

https://commodore.net/callback/

It's pretty cool looking! Very optimistic about it.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by DanOpcode on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:05PM (#48689880)
It doesn't have any web browsers. Who you are replying to wants Firefox.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by drnick1 on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:43PM (#48688751)
The Pixel 10a is on sale for $399 on Amazon right now, and it's a far better device, and it can run GrapheneOS.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by WickyNilliams on Saturday June 27, 2026 @05:48AM (#48696727)
You can find it cheaper if you keep an eye out. My partner just got one for £250 unlocked, no contract
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ux266478 on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:50AM (#48688070)
/etc configuration instead of the insanely bad system properties crap, glibc instead of bionic (which has even worse POSIX compliance than Windows), ld instead of linker, FHS, not having a batshit insane No-Sockets rule, not needing to port software that already compiles and runs on GNU/Linux, X11/Wayland/Arcan, system services aren't entangled with Java, normal IPC mechanisms instead whatever the fuck binder is. The list goes on.

Android (and by extension GrapheneOS) uses Linux as a kernel, but it lives in its own world and is completely unrecognizable. I'd say it's even more alien than macOS. For most users, the differences don't matter. If you're a programmer or a sysadmin with reasonable expectations, you feel like a fish out of water very fast. And I cannot honestly the changes are for the better.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by drnick1 on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:01PM (#48688187)
> /etc configuration instead of the insanely bad system properties crap, glibc instead of bionic [...]

The practical downside, however, is that this phone does not natively run Android apps, while GrapheneOS runs all Android apps bar those that require Play Integrity. Desktop GNU/Linux programs are either unusable or a terrible experience on a mobile device with a small screen and no mouse.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:14PM (#48688358)
Also Play Integrity (if you run sandboxed Google Play Services), but it only passes at the basic level, which is enough for most apps that use Play Integrity.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ux266478 on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:23PM (#48688481)
That's true, but is contingent on you running those Android apps for it to be meaningful. I have a very small number of interactive things I do with my phone. For me what matters is that writing software isn't a pain in the ass, my usual expectations on storage (eg remote filesystems) works and works well, maintaining my system works, my non-interactive system scripts work, etc. Almost all of this is broken on Android, and it doesn't really make up for it by breaking it to make it better. I find much of the design choices of the operating system to be completely tasteless.

If you say, rely on google maps, banking apps, apps for your IoT appliances, etc. it's certainly relevant. I don't have any of that though.

For me the most and truest pressing issue is that cell modems are very, very tightly coupled with Android. It's still true for the Jolla Phone that it simply is a worse phone because the modem drivers are buggy. This is a complicated issue that isn't getting better, and is mostly to do with legislation legally mandating the tivoization of cell modems, a weird line in the sand on what responsibilities fall to the hardware or to what software, as well as the modem manufacturers themselves not really caring.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:04PM (#48689862)
For me the most and truest pressing issue is that cell modems are very, very tightly coupled with Android. It's still true for the Jolla Phone that it simply is a worse phone because the modem drivers are buggy.

My impression (also for Ubuntu Touch, etc.) is that all these systems use the upstream vendors' Linux kernels trees and firmware blobs for Android.

Unfortunately, since we are not talking about Samsung or Google, but just some random Chinese ODMs, it's usually years old Linux versions and ancient firmware blobs full of known holes (e.g. the C2 is running a Linux tree from October 2022). It's only thanks to the tireless work of postmarketOS etc. that some devices boot on modern kernels.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by seba_dos1 on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:28PM (#48688551)
> Desktop GNU/Linux programs are either unusable or a terrible experience on a mobile device with a small screen and no mouse.

Is this an assumption or coming from your experience? Because I'm typing this on a GNU/Linux phone in a desktop browser and use a bunch of desktop applications daily and haven't noticed.

Of course if you run GIMP or something like that it won't fit unless you plug an external screen and a mouse in, but all the applications I use daily are perfectly usable. There's a lot of Kirigami and libadwaita programs these days that just work well on a phone, and if I need to launch my bank's application there's always Waydroid.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by gf000 on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:19PM (#48690790)
Well, can you take a picture that looks better than what I made 20 years ago on a flip phone?

I have a pinephone and try it out year after year.. Well, let's just say that there is so many areas of improvement to make "GNU/linux" run on a mobile device (that sorta includes laptops as well, even though I have done so for years) that we might as well start over from statch.

For example one can't just let everything run whenever it wants, wasting battery life. Android's "more complicated" system and binder was criticized in this thread, but that's exactly what ties together the whole thing to be able to run on a device that fits in your hand, with centrally managed "let's pause this app now" etc

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by megous on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:00PM (#48692537)
OV5640 will not get better just by aging. You should adjust your expectations.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by seba_dos1 on Friday June 26, 2026 @07:41PM (#48693467)
I'm pretty sure these look significantly better than what 2006 flip phones were capable of, even after scaling down by Mastodon: https://social.librem.one/@dos/tagged/shotonlibrem5

Also, I'm perfectly capable of deciding whether I need an application to be running at a given moment myself, I don't need the OS to make dubious decisions for me.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by VortexLain on Friday June 26, 2026 @01:41PM (#48689532)
Could you please elaborate, which software is usable on mobile Linux except for Firefox? I've seen multiple people using mobile Linux, and they were using Firefox and webapps for everything, no exceptions.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by seba_dos1 on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:17PM (#48690773)
Checking Flathub should give you some idea: https://flathub.org/en/apps/collection/mobile/1

There are more, not every application that works fine has metadata filled up (and not everything is on Flathub either).

I do use some webapps, but with Epiphany rather than Firefox.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsflover on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:25PM (#48690133)
I can use most native GNU/Linux apps on my Librem 5 like gnome-calculator, gnome-calender, gnome-weather etc. I can run Android apps via Waydroid. F-Droid works fine, too. Its default app store (https://software.pureos.net/categories) provides things like music players, OTP app, and games. Flatpak works, too.

See also: https://linuxphoneapps.org/

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by megous on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:12PM (#48692649)
To add to others. You can tell Kimi or whatever these days to write you a GTK4 mobile apps for a lot of pet use cases and it will. The result will also be a few C files and a meson build file, that will build on the phone itself with just gcc/binutils (I run arch linux, so no separate dev packages for deps like gtk, etc. that I need to install). You can install opencode or whatnot on the phone itself, and tell the phone to build you an app, and it will. If you need it changed, you can just ask for the changes on the phone itself and agent will update the app's code and re-build it on the phone itself. It will not need the 30+ GiB monstrosity of whatever Adroid needs to just build a hello world app and a separate computer.

The app will also build and run on your desktop without any/many changes, if you need that.

I got a fairly nice linphone GTK4 phone frontend app this way. So it's not just for toy apps. FOSS/Linux phones are well positioned for this self-building/self-updating prompt based software development, because you don't need separate computer and shitton of SDKs to build the apps, and while phone UI is shit for manual programming, it's not at all shit for writing prompts.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by 1718627440 on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @10:11AM (#48732996)
> Because I'm typing this on a GNU/Linux phone

Which are you using, can you recommend it?

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by WhyNotHugo on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:22PM (#48690090)
SailfishOS (from Jolla) runs Android applications via Alien Dalvik.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by IshKebab on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:54AM (#48688102)
I think he was asking about advantages, not "how is it similar to a Unix system from the 80s?"
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ux266478 on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:38PM (#48688684)
The irony you fail to realize, the differences listed in fact would be typical of a random Unix system in the 80s, where it's just a mountain of bad and random opinions stapled on top of a Unix system. Some random and half-baked libc? You got it! Some bizarre and overly convoluted greenfield filesystem structure? It's right there! Completely different and frustrating custom linker behavior? Yep!

Everything I listed was an advantage. Now see, I don't think Unix is the be-all end-all of operating systems design. I don't particularly care for Linux, the BSDs, macOS, etc. But Android is a definite regression in the strongest terms. Give me a PIMOS or Genera or Squeak phone that works well. I'll be happier than I would with a Linux phone.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by gf000 on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:22PM (#48690838)
Which system has better security from an end-user perspective?

Only iOS comes anywhere close.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsflover on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:59AM (#48698372)
(Not on mobile but) Qubes OS does.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by dengolius on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:31AM (#48687869)
I read somewhere that the owners have ties to russia, but the most important thing is that they’re marketing very aggressively through posts that slander GraphenOS.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ndiddy on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:20PM (#48688437)
IIRC the company tried to become a major mobile operating system in the BRICS countries, which led to Rostelecom, the Russian state telecom operator, purchasing a majority state in the company in the mid-2010s. After Russia invaded Ukraine, the company's management started a new company and moved all their employees and IP over to it to escape the Russian ownership.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:29PM (#48690916)
Oh, thanks for sharing. everything russia related is a hard pass until they repent
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ttkari on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:40AM (#48687954)
> they’re marketing very aggressively through posts that slander GraphenOS

I would really appreciate it if you could give some references - any at all - to back this claim.

All I have seen is GrapheneOS folks (or probably just a certain individual affiliated with the GrapheneOS org) accusing them of doing this.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by dijit on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:38AM (#48687940)
Jesus christ, what is this FUD?

I know the people behind SailfishOS, they’re not like, friends or anything: just ex-Nokia developers who got fucked by Microsoft (like I did, btw, which is how I know of them).

I feel like the big tech smartphone duopoly would have a reason to spread such rubbish, but its so patently obvious that I doubt they are so stupid.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by etdznots on Friday June 26, 2026 @11:47AM (#48688029)
It’s a sensitive topic for the US because it is an an EU-backed and funded project to help move away from US tech, which undermines US power and interests globally. which is why you might see some unusually intense anger/vitriol hurled their way and Goebbels-level fabrications
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by TiredOfLife on Friday June 26, 2026 @01:45PM (#48689583)
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jolla

"It acquired new investors in 2016, among them the Russian company Votron. In March 2018 they were joined by Rostelecom (which is state owned) as investor, which took over Votron and OMP."

Note that was after 2014 russian invasion into Ukraine.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:44PM (#48691093)
The word to describe this is /законтачений/ . Some people are to be avoided even if they maintain the outward appearance of normalcy and not even realize themselves what the problem even is. Trust bit permanently burned, nothing to see here.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:04PM (#48688222)
You mean that GrapheneOS has ties to Russia? https://ised-isde.canada.ca/cc/lgcy/fdrlCrpDtls.html?p=0&cor...

(I actually couldn't find information on their nationality, they might be e.g. Ukrainian or second-generation Russian immigrants; Micay is somewhat Russian-sounding too, btw, although I think he's known to have been born in Canada).

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Friday June 26, 2026 @12:17PM (#48688396)
No, Jolla. They worked with the Russian government. But they cut ties even before the 2022 invasion:

https://forum.sailfishos.org/t/plea-for-official-statement-f...

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:46PM (#48691119)
Cutting ties is a matter of protecting ones investment, while working with certain parties is a moral choice.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by iamnothere on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:02PM (#48690596)
GrapheneOS also does, as does iOS (Jobs visited the USSR on July 4th of all days) and Android (Sergey Brin is of Russian descent). The FSB is likely reading over your shoulder as we speak. Also, have you checked your closets lately?
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @03:51PM (#48691180)
You are trying to be funny, while russian drones fly above my mom's house, so it isn't as good of an answer to give as you may image
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by iamnothere on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:18PM (#48691466)
I get frustrated when people draw imaginary Russian connections into projects/products that I like. It often happens with anything “hackerish” or non-mainstream (particularly privacy adjacent things) and has become quite annoying.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @07:45PM (#48693500)
being owned by the russian government is more than a trace amount of "imaginary" connection, but since you like it, it doesn't matter. I mean, okay, reality and your vibes not being in agreement is a legit reason to be frustrated. this being done by other people is even rude, I would say
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by iamnothere on Friday June 26, 2026 @07:59PM (#48693586)
Jolla restructured after the invasion of Ukraine and the founders hold a majority share, minority owners include employees and a Finnish investor. It’s a Finnish company. Hopefully you don’t have a problem with Finns?

GrapheneOS is owned by a Canadian nonprofit foundation. One of the three board members is a Ukrainian national (currently conscripted but still on the board).

Flipper Devices is a Delaware corporation, it indeed started in Russia, but it moved out after the Ukraine war. Ukrainian nationals are on the team. It does not export to Russia.

Just to clear up some common misconceptions.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Muromec on Friday June 26, 2026 @09:28PM (#48694258)
>Jolla restructured after the invasion of Ukraine

that can mean a whole range of different things both in perception and in intention, but even at best it's "russian government currently doesn't control the company". if we speak about the /connection/, it can mean different things.

but the question worth asking -- are the people who took money from the russian government in past are the people I want to give my money to?

>Flipper Devices is a Delaware corporation, it indeed started in Russia, but it moved out after the Ukraine war. Ukrainian nationals are on the team. It does not export to Russia.

believe it or not, but the same goes and I would judge those Ukrainian nationals too.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:43PM (#48692360)
Why the downvote? That's an official document, and I did say that I couldn't figure out what it means
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Itoldmyselfso on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:55PM (#48692476)
You're accusing them of ties to Russia... based on their names?
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Friday June 26, 2026 @07:32PM (#48693387)
I'm not accusing anyone, I'm wondering if they're Russian because, you know, those seem Russian names....
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Andromxda on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:48AM (#48697421)
Straight up conspiracy theories you're spreading here. Daniel Micay is Canadian, Dmytro Mukhomor is Ukrainian (he was literally conscripted into the Ukrainian army last year), and Khalykbek Yelshibekov is from Kazakhstan.

> Micay is somewhat Russian-sounding too

Sorry what?

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:10PM (#48699447)
I said "I actually couldn't find information on their nationality". Thank you for clarifying it.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:15PM (#48699480)
Any source for that, though?
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Andromxda on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:42PM (#48700165)
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by g-b-r on Saturday June 27, 2026 @04:17PM (#48701352)
Thanks, it's a bit weird how hard it is to find that information
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by VortexLain on Friday June 26, 2026 @01:52PM (#48689686)
Russian Aurora OS was an official Sailfish OS offspring, focused on MDM devices, but Sailfish cut ties with Aurora in 2022, after the Russia-Ukraine war has emerged. It's now developed independently of Sailfish, although they share the same code since the codebase was unified before the split.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by lproven on Saturday June 27, 2026 @02:38PM (#48700602)
> posts that slander GraphenOS.

FWIW, as someone who is not in the phone OS development world at all but has been reviewing phones with alternative OSes for about the last 4 years...

My impression is that everyone else in the phone-OS and deGoogled-Android world hates the GrapheneOS folks, and it's mutual. They seem to be borderline impossible to work with, very arrogant and protectionist, and the project's own support lifetime is "when Google no longer supports your phone, we don't either."

Personally, I'd choose something else. Anything else, in fact.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by microtonal on Sunday June 28, 2026 @04:58AM (#48705597)
My impression is that everyone else in the phone-OS and deGoogled-Android world hates the GrapheneOS folks, and it's mutual.

I don't think that is true. Team members regularly speak positively of iPhone security. E.g.:

https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/113874795519341571

They also do not post much on LineageOS and when they do it usually articulates the difference between both (with LineageOS focusing more on customizability, while being much less secure).

I think the strongest disagreement is with /e/OS, which is not surprising, because their founder goes around to various widely-viewed/read media insinuating that security hardening/GrapheneOS is only for pedophiles and spies.

They seem to be borderline impossible to work with, very arrogant and protectionist,

As a user, they seem to be responsive to bug reports and actively helping out people in their forums. Not sure what else I need.

and the project's own support lifetime is "when Google no longer supports your phone, we don't either."

But that makes sense, right? One of the main foci of GrapheneOS is security. If Google stops supporting a Pixel model, there will be no more updates of firmware bundles, etc. Most firmware has monthly CVEs, pretending that it doesn't would go counter one of the main goals of GrapheneOS. If you want to maintain such a phone as an insecure device after Google's update period, there are other options you could switch to.

I am also not sure how much this matters. Even Pixel budget devices (a-series) have 7 years of security updates now. It's not only one of the longest in the industry, it's probably beyond how long 95% of the population uses a phone.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by abc42 on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @01:44AM (#48728893)
They did. This was an unfortunate reality for Finnish telecom companies before the Ukraine war. Russia was an obvious market and a company looking for profit would be practically forced to try to work there.

As for Jolla, this is about the timeline:

2014 Russia attacks Crimea, temporarily occupies it

2016 Jolla grants Sailfish license to a private Open Mobile Platform LLC in Russia

2018 Rostelecom (state-owned Russian company) buys Open Mobile Platform

2020 Sailfish license to Rostelecom ends

2021 Jolla ceases all business in Russia -- at this point Rostelecom owns 32% of Jolla either directly or via subsidiaries

2022 Russia attacks rest of Ukraine in February

2022 Jolla starts dislodging from Russian ownership. Negotations with russian owners unsuccessful.

2023 Jollyboys Oy is formed, business restructuring of Jolla starts to move assets there

2024 Jolla files for bankruptcy to get finally rid of rest of the problematic ownership

So the current company around the new Jolla phone is technically a new company and has none of the previous baggage, but retains most of the non-russian owners and staff of Jolla.

The time between 2014-2022 was of course kind of problematic, but that was the reality in Europe. We still widely and naively gave Russia the benefit of the doubt back then. It seems to me that after Russia started the war in 2022, Jolla started immediately moving away from there.

Sources:

https://www.is.fi/taloussanomat/art-2000010451277.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jolla

https://suomimobiili.fi/jollyboys-oy-ostaa-sailfish-os-kaytt...

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by tormeh on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:41PM (#48690351)
If it has the "security" architecture of Linux (it's really more of a multi-tenant architecture) then that's a complete deal breaker. Wouldn't want it if it was 1000x faster/betterer than Android.

Our desktop OSes are just incompatible with running untrusted software, and you're gonna want to do that.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by ginko on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:53PM (#48692462)
>Our desktop OSes are just incompatible with running untrusted software, and you're gonna want to do that.

So you're saying people should only use walled garden closed source OSes? Sounds like tyranny to me.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Retr0id on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:58PM (#48692508)
No? AOSP is open source.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsflover on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:03AM (#48698406)
AOSP doesn't run on any phone without a ton of proprietary blobs.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by Andromxda on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:42AM (#48697392)
1) No one is saying that. As another commenter mentioned, Android is open source.

2) The point still stands, desktop operating systems like Windows and desktop Linux distributions are much less secure than Android or iOS. Read https://privsec.dev/posts/linux/linux-insecurities/

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsflover on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:04AM (#48698412)
> Our desktop OSes are just incompatible with running untrusted software

You should have a look at https://qubes-os.org

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by port11 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:28AM (#48697308)
Maybe the point is to have more than 2 players in the mobile OS arena, especially if the American duopoly continues to force everyone’s hand.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by 1718627440 on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @10:08AM (#48732960)
> differences between typical Linux and Android

I know how this looks like, but I really wish a more precise term, like e.g. GNU/Linux would have catched on...

The kernel is necessary for the OS, but for the user freedom kind of not that important, as can be seen by Google/Linux aka. Android.

Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by bossyTeacher on Thursday July 02, 2026 @07:40AM (#48759860)
Jolla depends on the AOSP. Graphene depends on the AOSP and Google Pixel phones. If Google Pixel phones ever got their bootloader locked, Graphene would die immediately. If AOSP ever went private, both would die. The risk space is bigger for Graphene.
Re:Jolla Phone, Over 13 500 units sold by fsflover on Friday June 26, 2026 @02:03PM (#48689842)
If the openness is important to you, you may want to have a look at other GNU/Linux phones, Librem 5 and Pinephone. The former runs an FSF-endorsed Debian derivative.