No? AOSP is open source.
AOSP doesn't run on any phone without a ton of proprietary blobs.
1) No one is saying that. As another commenter mentioned, Android is open source.
2) The point still stands, desktop operating systems like Windows and desktop Linux distributions are much less secure than Android or iOS. Read https://privsec.dev/posts/linux/linux-insecurities/
So you're saying people should only use walled garden closed source OSes? Sounds like tyranny to me.