News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Wowfunhappy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @10:54AM (#48346152)
...in the age of AI, does anyone have an actual solution for keeping out bots while preserving the privacy of humans?

Obviously this is terrible, but I think there's a possibility it's the least terrible option? Another option is IP reputation, which I think is worse. Or scanning a code with a non-rooted phone, which I think is even worse than that!

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by fidotron on Sunday May 31, 2026 @10:57AM (#48346179)
> ...in the age of AI, does anyone have an actual solution for keeping out bots while preserving the privacy of humans?

There isn't one, and pretending otherwise is nonsense because humans will always provide their credentials to something to act on their behalf.

In the limit you end up with Chinese phone farms.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by tardedmeme on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:06AM (#48346271)
Right. Botnet operators love cloudflare because they make so much money renting out compromised machines to pass their tests.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by thisislife2 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:21AM (#48346421)
The only solution is regulation. If all content created by anyone has a copyright, how does an implicit opt-in (which is what happens if you don't create a robots.txt file for your website) for scraping make any sense? Moreover, even if you have a robots.txt, AI (or whatever) bots often don't respect it (or use workarounds - they outsource scraping of such "restricted" sites to unethical third-parties to get the data; Meta has even resorted to piracy, openly!). So clearly, the logic and the "honour system" has failed.

Cloudflare, Google Captcha, HCaptcha etc. are all shitty technical solutions because, as we are all discovering, it comes at the cost of our privacy (i.e. our personal data may monetise these services) and / or our computing resource and time. If current copyright laws aren't sufficient to prevent this, we have to acknowledge the system is broken. The answer could be enhancing it with some kind of Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) -like laws, but in favour of the creators against BigTech or rogue actors.

- Web-scraping and copyright law - https://www.neudata.co/blog/web-scraping-and-copyright-law

- Why DMCA Claims Against Web Scrapers Face Long Odds - https://capstonedc.com/insights/why-dmca-claims-against-web-...

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by oceanplexian on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:48AM (#48346680)
Or you could let information be free, at least the stuff that’s on the public net.

As for issues like bots overloading websites or using too many resources scaling laws will take care of it quickly, it’s not like you can’t serve thousands of RPS from a Raspberry Pi these days.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by ImPostingOnHN on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:29AM (#48346503)
I don't think regulation will stop web scraping, not least of which because it can be done from locations outside the jurisdiction of the regulations.

> we have to acknowledge the system is broken

The system is broken. It probably takes, what, 10 seconds or less to use a residential or foreign proxy, 6+ months to internationally track and prosecute a single offender? So like a million times more effort going the regulatory route.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by thisislife2 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:36AM (#48346554)
Just as criminal laws don't end all crimes, copyright laws and anti-scraping regulation won't end all scraping. But it will greatly reduce it and limit it to rogue actors. Two examples I can cite here are the laws against email spams and laws against unsolicited marketing calls - they had a definite impact in reducing both (even in India, from where I am, where implementation of laws are often lax).
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by JoshTriplett on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:40AM (#48346606)
Exactly. Bot activity is a problem of volume, not all-or-nothing. Solving 95% of it would be a win.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Wowfunhappy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @09:02PM (#48351510)
I basically agree that the idea should be to reduce, not eliminate, bots.

However, a big difference with crimes involving the internet is that they can be launched from anywhere. In the real world, I can't steal from someone unless I'm physically present in the same country as my victim. On the internet, the US could outlaw scraping and Russia would keep doing it.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by account42 on Monday June 01, 2026 @07:02AM (#48355214)
We already have ways to deal with badly behaving countries.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by HappMacDonald on Tuesday June 02, 2026 @12:45AM (#48366179)
One thing I want to know is how porn spam (that is, spam containing pornographic image attachments) vanished so suddenly in the early 2000s. It used to be a huge segment of spam, and then one day it all just vanished.

So.. what made it go away, and how could learning about that help us make all the rest of it go away too?

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by brandonwindson on Tuesday June 02, 2026 @02:27AM (#48366748)
Visa, Mastercard, and PayPal stopped processing payments for adult sites that used deceptive marketing. Hosting providers terminated accounts that sent image-based spam because the legal risk was too high. The same approach would work for other spam types. Target the payment processors, the hosting providers and make spam financially unsustainable.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by mschuster91 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @03:13PM (#48348718)
> The only solution is regulation.

The thing why Cloudflare got invented isn't AI scrapers. These are just the latest development... the original reason why Cloudflare got created and why it experienced such a meteoric growth is DDoS and botnets.

Yes. We need regulation in the AI space. But it will be useless as long as bad actors aren't held accountable - and a lot of the bad actors aren't in our jurisdictions. You got hacked devices all over the world in giant botnets, controlled by Russia, Chinese, Iranian and North Korean actors. You got Chinese AI scraper bots as China is heavily investing into training their own models. You got Indian, Filipino and Myanmar-based scammers.

And frankly I have no idea how to get all of that under control. As much as I'd like to see sanctions against both domestic and foreign enablers of abuse (which includes residential ISPs) - it's going to be one giant ass whack-a-mole game.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by HappMacDonald on Tuesday June 02, 2026 @12:47AM (#48366184)
I just wish that DDoS wasn't such a huge racketeering game.

Who profits the most from it?

The services charging you to defend against it, that's who.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by arbol on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:04PM (#48349226)
Or the regulated agents standard that cloudflare is conveniently going to steward alongside Google...
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by 0x59 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:22PM (#48349372)
I mean, you could just turn on WebGL or use an approved, secure, agent to access the web. If you have nothing to hide, then you have nothing to fear.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by cr125rider on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:05AM (#48346270)
And identifying a bot that is acting on my behalf. Claude go search this topic is basically the same as Googling something and clicking on the results. Human driven AI searching needs to be in a different box than AI scraping for training data.

Which sounds extremely difficult to differentiate

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by JoshTriplett on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:32AM (#48346528)
Hopefully it stays that way; "a bot acting on my behalf" is still a bot. At least it's often a well-behaved bot and uses a user-agent that can be detected and blocked.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Gander5739 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:19AM (#48346408)
You don't need a non-rooted phone to pass captcha checks, I have a rooted phone and can pass the captchas that ask you to scan a qr code. But I doubt phones without google services would manage.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by HWR_14 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:44PM (#48347800)
How does scanning a QR code prove any kind of captcha?
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Gander5739 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:50PM (#48347880)
https://support.google.com/recaptcha/answer/16609652 - it just launches the verification service.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by spacedoutman on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:13AM (#48346346)
Private invite only internets
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by arbol on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:05PM (#48349233)
LAN parties?!
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by csomar on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:08AM (#48346301)
They are not a problem unless you "believe" it is a problem. I estimate around 20-25K hits to my website from bots per day and I have all cloudflare protections disabled. Any decently optimized server should be able to easily handle that. (it's roughly 1 request every 3 seconds).
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by specialp on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:22AM (#48346426)
Yes and that is just the bot background radiation of the internet. I run a primary source of information site and these botnets are aggressive to a DDOS level. All to do some sort of scraping. Because they have sophisticated enough tactics to DDOS us if they wanted to. However I am not sure their objective as they have wasted enough of our resources to have scraped all our content 1000s of times over. That 25k traffic is a couple of minutes for us. And that adds up. 80-90pct of our traffic is this
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by thisislife2 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:24AM (#48346446)
True. But it still wastes your server resources, right? And it's sad that you have to accept that as part of the "cost" of hosting a site ...
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by ndriscoll on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:46AM (#48346657)
What resources are you concerned about? An n100 minipc should be capable of serving something like a blog at 20k+ requests/second (or saturating its network).
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by thisislife2 on Monday June 01, 2026 @02:45AM (#48353387)
Sure. But 25,000 (bot hits / day) x 50kB (static webpage) = 1.25 GB / day / page x 30 (days) = 37.5 GB of data transfer / month / page. And that's assuming a static resource - if any of the resource is dynamically generated by the server, there's a CPU and memory cost too. Overall, even if you treat the impact on the server as "negligible", it's still an unnecessary waste of resource was the point I was trying to convey.

Here's a more real-world projection of the cost and server impact - The Bandwidth Cost of AI Crawlers: What Scraping Really Costs Publishers - https://aipaypercrawl.com/articles/ai-crawler-bandwidth-cost

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by HWR_14 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:45PM (#48347809)
Assuming that the bots aren't repackaging your content and preventing users from seeing your blog by serving that content to them first.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by doctorpangloss on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:08AM (#48346291)
web environment integrity
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Wowfunhappy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @07:04PM (#48350637)
But that is so clearly worse than WebGL fingerprinting!
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by malka1986 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @10:58AM (#48346185)
> keeping out bot

You can forget about it. It is not possible. Simple as that.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Wowfunhappy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:01AM (#48346219)
Let's say I'm selling concert tickets. How do I prevent bots from buying up all the tickets and scalping them?
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by ranguna on Sunday May 31, 2026 @12:18PM (#48346943)
Do it like plane tickets do, tie a ticket to an identity + buyback up to a week or so before the concert in case someone wants to cancel (or authorize the transfer and capture only a week before). Ask for ID and ticket at the entrance.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by ndriscoll on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:52AM (#48346709)
Sell them via a Dutch auction. Eliminate the arbitrage opportunity for scalpers and make more money in the process.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by dcrazy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:06PM (#48347394)
That’s how you wind up with only kids of millionaires at your Taylor Swift concert.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by queenkjuul on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:59PM (#48347973)
So a Taylor Swift concert
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by MyMemoryfails on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:12AM (#48346329)
I'd simply check filling speed, even with browser's autocomplete humans are slow due needing click submit.

Then when it's "processing", do them in bulk and prioritize slower users. There's huge opportunity do bot checks after checkout without affecting user experience.

Also on product launches you could add unique field which requires user to input, for example that way bots can't prepare for launches.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by fragmede on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:39AM (#48346596)
huh. no wonder my password manager's auto submit triggers bot detection (it's a fairly popular one).
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by arbol on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:09PM (#48349263)
Yeah, this doesn't even begin to cut it
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by luckylion on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:03AM (#48346242)
Tie them to the buyer's identity, offer at-value buy-backs until X weeks before event, disallow resale.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by arbol on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:08PM (#48349259)
- behavioural fingerprinting - ja4 - IP rep - queue mechanism - card country to IP country checks - app attestation - custom metrics based on knowledge of past scalpers

It's hard but it's not impossible. You can make it very inconvenient for scalpers. They need to poll at volume so their behaviour is very much detectable. A hard stance is required on IP rep, especially for more in demand concerts.

Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by Wowfunhappy on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:31PM (#48350379)
I don't now, a lot of this seems just as invasive as WebGL fingerprinting, if not more invasive.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by arbol on Monday June 01, 2026 @03:13AM (#48353553)
It's either that or you tie tickets to government ID like in France. If the arbitrage opportunity is more than the cost of automation then someone will exploit it.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by jeroenhd on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:07PM (#48347395)
Remote attestation should still be possible with a rooted phone if phone manufacturers weren't so shit. If the attestation happens at hardware level, it doesn't matter what programs or kernels you're running.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by ravenstine on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:20PM (#48347521)
Or maybe we can actually start paying for all the things we use on the Web, making it prohibitively expensive to deploy fleets of bots.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by HappMacDonald on Tuesday June 02, 2026 @12:48AM (#48366189)
Feel free to work out a frictionless micropayment method though.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by onel on Monday June 01, 2026 @05:28AM (#48354509)
Unfortunately, I think the solution will be invite only services, communities, etc. Someone needs to invite you to have access to it. If you host your own blog then that might be okay to have public access, you would want everyone and everything to read it. But if you're hosting your own photos, we might need tailscale like services to only allow certain people to access that.
Re:Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL by neop1x on Monday June 01, 2026 @10:10AM (#48357071)
Just implement caches, add indices to your DBs, use CDNs. Servers are very fast nowadays, have quite a lot of RAM and can handle huge amount of clients. No need to implement this anti-bot bullshit, it is mainly marketing, providing solutions to a problem which doesn't exist for most websites.