News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cmilton on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:16PM (#47683540)
It all sounds great. Which government? Is it a different regime? If not, why would the US concede?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by marricks on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:20PM (#47683570)
> why would the US concede?

Because it has no way of achieving its objectives.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cmilton on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:28PM (#47683638)
I don't think that has stopped anything so far, but I appreciate your optimism.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by derektank on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:01PM (#47683946)
More accurate to say that the US is not willing to pay the price to achieve its objectives I think (depending on who/when you’re asking what exactly the objectives are of course).
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by firesteelrain on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:33PM (#47683692)
It did achieve its objectives. Iran is of little threat.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by SideQuark on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:10PM (#47684040)
Iran was little threat to the US before the US attacked. Now the US likely has earned itself more decades of terrorists, while simultaneously losing its military and political support from other countries.

If the US objective was self destruction or massive face plant, it is certainly getting closer to its objective.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by firesteelrain on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:03PM (#47684517)
I’ve had no spam calls. Mission Accomplished.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:35PM (#47684261)
This ignores the possibility that we have set their nuclear program back to starting from scratch.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by SideQuark on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:46PM (#47684369)
It ignores we already had that, in 2016, with experts from all over the world doing inspections and agreeing it worked. Then Trump blew up the deal against the wishes of the rest of the free world, claiming he’d make a better deal, which he got zero from. Advisors, both hand picked and military, told him this would be the outcome, which he ignored.

We have not set their program to zero. They now have, and will continue to have, people trained in the knowledge of how to rebuild it. They now have massively more incentive to do so. Countries in the region now have more reason to help. Countries the world over have more incentive to contain US idiocy, as yet again we screw their economies for made up reasons.

As do their allies, and the raft of allies the US has lost over this idiocy will hurt US for decades, likely never to be repaired.

This is why Iran has won. The US has so destroyed brand US that it’ll never regain trust anywhere, economically, militarily, or morally.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:20AM (#47685184)
> It ignores we already had that, in 2016, with experts from all over the world doing inspections and agreeing it worked. Then Trump blew up the deal against the wishes of the rest of the free world, claiming he’d make a better deal, which he got zero from. Advisors, both hand picked and military, told him this would be the outcome, which he ignored.

1) JCPOA was in effect for barely more than two years. Iran's nuclear work prior started way back circa 2000. It was killed before we can say anything about its effectiveness.

2) IIRC, JCPOA didn't prevent Iran from developing nuclear tech. It only limited capacity. They were free to do all the R&D they wanted.

3) Iran was doing weaponization work prior to the deal which they didn't disclose. So taking them at their word on the subject is probably not a good idea.

Trump pulling out from the deal was dumb, because it probably was slowing weaponization down, but the idea that the deal was stopping Iran from developing weaponization tech is not supported by the aims of the deal itself.

> We have not set their program to zero. They now have, and will continue to have, people trained in the knowledge of how to rebuild it.

Very close to it. Lots of facilities were destroyed, and I believe a majority of their scientists were killed.

> They now have massively more incentive to do so.

Debatable. I can see it going either way.

> Countries in the region now have more reason to help. Countries the world over have more incentive to contain US idiocy, as yet again we screw their economies for made up reasons.

Nearly all the countries in the region want Iran gone. They are a destabilizing force for all their neighbors.

> As do their allies

Iran has pretty much 0 official allies. Their only allies come in the form of "we hate the US too, so we will help you be a thorn in their side"

> This is why Iran has won

Won what? If that's winning, then I'll take losing.

> The US has so destroyed brand US that it’ll never regain trust anywhere, economically, militarily, or morally.

This remains to be seen I think. Honestly, if Europe kicks us out I'll be happy personally. I look forward to the day the US isn't running the oceans as a toll road for the globe and everyone handles their own backyards. I think we are far enough past WW2 that the world no longer needs a nanny.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by Hikikomori on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:31AM (#47686632)
4 years as an provisional deal was done earlier. All us intelligence agencies agreed and testified to congress that Iran was not working towards a bomb as Trump ripped up the agreement. They were all wrong or what?

>This remains to be seen I think. Honestly, if Europe kicks us out I'll be happy personally. I look forward to the day the US isn't running the oceans as a toll road for the globe and everyone handles their own backyards. I think we are far enough past WW2 that the world no longer needs a nanny.

Pretty rich to day this given what US is doing now.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @05:24AM (#47687563)
You are ignoring the fundamental difference between the JCPOA's goals and the argument here. JCPOA was not a denuclearization agreement, it wasn't even a "no atomic bombs" agreement. All it did was limit centrifuge count, and enrichment density. Iran complying with those was mostly useless for the goal for the goal of preventing them getting an atomic bomb. It was effectively a stalling maneuver, one that would have partially expired last year.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by Hikikomori on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:54AM (#47688401)
Or it was working, as intel agencies seems to agree on, and set the stage for future agreements and getting Iran on a path of normalization.

Instead Trump ripped it up and then got involved in yet another useless zionist middle eastern war that only seems to have made Iran stronger and further destroying US reputation.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:19AM (#47688662)
"It was working"

I'm trying to discuss what that means, because I think that's where we are disagreeing.

What does that mean to you?

To me (and it's crafters) the JCPOA "working" meant slowing Iran down temporarily.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by Hikikomori on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:35AM (#47688772)
Comparing their progress towards building a bomb under and after the agreement? We know they followed the agreement with minor discrepancies, and when sanctions started they started breaking it. With no diplomatic agreement and sanctions in place what should Iran be doing? Might as well build a bomb then.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:24PM (#47695026)
> Comparing their progress towards building a bomb under and after the agreement?

Well yeah, like I said, it was a stalling maneuver. It slowed things down.

> We know they followed the agreement with minor discrepancies, and when sanctions started they started breaking it. With no diplomatic agreement and sanctions in place what should Iran be doing? Might as well build a bomb then.

Well yeah, they were doing that before and during the JCPOA. Why wouldn't they do it after?

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cosmicgadget on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:49AM (#47685856)
Weird, just a few days ago he said we needed two more weeks of war to destroy their nuclear program.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by BobbyJo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:45AM (#47688289)
Maybe the US military is aiming for a greater level of confidence in order to say "definitely destroyed" than some random guy online needs in order to say "possibly destroyed"?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by acjohnson55 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:48PM (#47683813)
All those ships stuck on either side of the Strait of Hormuz and their insurers would beg to differ.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by majormajor on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:30PM (#47684759)
The most deadly attack on US soil from the Middle East didn't come from nukes.

How sure are you that we're reducing net total future threats in the Middle East under Trump?

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by feb012025 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:49PM (#47683829)
For the sake of peace... yes ;)
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by PierceJoy on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:42PM (#47683764)
To whom, and to what? A military threat to the continental US, sure. To US allies in the region, and to the global economy, it appears Iran is a much bigger threat than we were lead to believe, and still are. If anything, they're justifiably more emboldened now than ever.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by throwaway173738 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:30PM (#47684758)
If you keep picking fights with someone don’t be surprised if they learn how to fight. There’s literally a line in Sayings of Spartans about teaching your enemy to fight by making war with them.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by goatlover on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:07PM (#47684012)
Then why was Trump threatening their annihilation prior to accepting the ceasefire around their proposal?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by alfiedotwtf on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:47PM (#47683810)
You must not be paying attention…

So far, Trump said that the Straight of Hormuz closed is cutting off China’s oil supply and isn’t important to the US, the US doesn’t need allies, but after Trump got zero help from Europe he then proceeded to ask China of all countries to help in the straight?!

Knowing people travelling near and through the Straight, Iran has all the cards. “Iran is of little threat” doesn’t hold water when the US can’t even send ships though to protect container ships

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by firesteelrain on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:05PM (#47684531)
I don’t think the US signed up to protect Chinese or Indian ships through the Strait. Also, it’s not blocked.

https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/strait-of-hormuz-a-citrini...

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by bluGill on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @09:55AM (#47690279)
The US has mostly achieved their objectives (as best as I can tell - the strategy isn't exactly coherent) - Iran has much less missiles, and much less ability to produce them.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by marricks on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:04PM (#47693040)
If there was any outside visible thread of reasoning for this war it was "Iran seems like it could have regime change" and I haven't heard anything saying they're more likely to have a different form of government.

I doubt the revolutionaries sympathizers within Iran liked their children being murdered or infrastructure getting destroyed. All the US has done is a repeat of the same thing they've done for half a century: start a war and immediately get more enemies within the middle east. Perhaps the only change is now the US's allies are distancing themselves faster and further than ever before.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by bluGill on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:35PM (#47693552)
There was a lot more - since mid last summer the US and Iran have been talking. There was some progress on nuclear issues. However Iran refused to discuss their ballistic missile program or funding for the likes of Hezbollah. Just based on that alone it is no surprise that the US got fed up. However you have to pay a little more attention to see that even though it is public.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:47PM (#47697636)
Sometimes you want someone to do something, but you don't have authority to order them around, and you are bad at persuasion and dealmaking, so you don't get what you want.

If you're not ok with walking away at that point, maybe put a better offer on the table?

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by bluGill on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @09:10PM (#47698184)
I fail to see a better offer. Support for those trying to kill jews is not something I can accept. I don't like any option for dealing with it, but walking away is still evil.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday April 09, 2026 @08:30AM (#47702832)
I can't speak for you, but for me, as a jew, killing innocent people just to get what you want is bad, even if they aren't jewish. Support for genocidal wars of conquest (like russia's and israel's) isn't something I can accept.

Additionally: supporting the killing of innocents, war crimes, genocide, etc, just because the perpetrators are jewish, is eviler still. Israel's actions make all jews (like myself) look bad, and puts us at risk around the world.

Maybe try diplomacy instead? And no, diplomacy doesn't mean "take our offer with no changes or we will kill you all". It means recognizing that israel isn't better than other countries, it means treating others as equals, it means you don't get to boss around co-equal countries, and it means giving first if you want to receive.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by lumost on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:20PM (#47683571)
Because it doesn’t have a choice. There is no path to winning this war, just ways of making larger and more complex versions of the Iraq occupation.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by acjohnson55 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:50PM (#47683834)
Depends on what you mean by "win". It would be possible to go in, topple the regime and secure the nuclear material. But only at astronomical cost and years of blowback
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by lumost on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:07PM (#47684015)
"Regime Change" has become a modern term for vassalization. We should not be surprised that countries with no reason to be a US vassal, and no long-term ties to the US refuse to remain vassals.

So then what would we achieve? nuclear material is cheap (10s of billions) relative to a multi-decade occupation (single digit trillions). It's undoubtedly true that Iran would revert to it's preferred form of government, geopolitical orientation, and nuclear capability once the US left.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by SideQuark on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:12PM (#47684056)
How’d that plan work out in Iraq or Afghanistan, both much smaller, less armed countries? Decades and trillions spent, and what exactly did the US “win”?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by amluto on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:29AM (#47685257)
The US won the removal of a regime in Iraq that strongly opposed Iran. </sarcasm>
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by jltsiren on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:19PM (#47684120)
Winning a war means achieving your political goals while preventing the enemy from achieving theirs. Most of the time, you've won the war when the enemy effectively admits they lost.

The lack of will to use sufficient force to win a war is fundamentally no different from not having that force in the first place. Both are equally real constraints on your ability to win the war.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by wrs on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:33PM (#47683683)
Why would the US start this in the first place? Be assured that however this comes out, a “Truth” will be posted assessing it as the Greatest Deal Ever and a Total Win, end of story.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by 8note on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:49PM (#47684937)
a major reason would be that they didnt think iran could selectively close the strait, and the intelligence about how not liking the current government is not the same as supporting the US
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by sosomoxie on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:46PM (#47683798)
It’s been repeatedly stated by officials that we fought this war for Israel. We had nothing to gain and much to lose, and lose we did. Thankfully Israel also lost and I think this was their last chance at using the US as their attack dog.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by mupuff1234 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:04PM (#47684525)
People are looking for conspiracy theories when the truth is simple - trump did it because he thought it would be an easy quick win that will put him in the history books.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by sosomoxie on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:48AM (#47685390)
It’s not a conspiracy theory if Trump and all parties involved explicitly state this was for Israel. The simplest explanation is that they are telling the truth, which makes sense since the US had nothing to gain from this.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by rsynnott on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @04:17AM (#47687000)
Netanyahu has wanted to do this for decades. If you rob a bank, you don't get to say "oh, well, my crazy friend down the pub has been saying we should rob a bank for ages, and I suddenly decided he was right"; you do have some personal responsibility.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by rsynnott on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @11:49AM (#47691861)
Sidenote; there's this weird thing that people sometimes do wrt to Trump (and I think it's both his supporters and detractors to an extent) where they kind of treat him as if he's without agency, and stuff is just happening to him. I think it might be a kind of subconscious response to him being old and coming across as a bit senile, but it is nonsensical.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by kraken_cult on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:06PM (#47684010)
We will see if this is all the chips that Epstein bought
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by tw04 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:53PM (#47683848)
> If not, why would the US concede?

Because Trump is already facing a bloodbath in the midterms and his next step is either a ground war or dropping a nuke, and both of those will ensure he not only loses the midterms but has a legitimate shot at seeing the inside of a prison cell.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by goatlover on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:04PM (#47683976)
Because the escalation Trump was talking about would have wrecked the ME with Iran's retaliation on desalination plants, oil infrastructure, power plants, etc. Which would have been a massive shock to the global economy, along with a large humanitarian crisis inside of Iran and it's neighbors.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by jojobas on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:19PM (#47683566)
The old government is largely dead. The new one has a carrot and a stick in front of them.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by ceejayoz on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:34PM (#47683697)
The new government is led by the Ayatollah Khamenei. The son of the last one, younger and out for revenge.

Knocking off Saddam gave us ISIS. These things have a way of going sideways.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:07PM (#47684546)
> new government is led by the Ayatollah Khamenei

Let's see. It may be a military dictatorship using Khamenei, who may or may not even be in Iran, as a figurehead.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by int_19h on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:42AM (#47685346)
Not the military, the IRGC. Which is a religiously indoctrinated military.

So it would still be a theocracy, same as before, but now also run by people who are conditioned to believe that more violence is always a solution to any problem.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @09:21AM (#47689882)
Unfortunately, it's now theocrat vs. theocrat.

https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3miybj6ff622f

> Hegseth: "God deserves all the glory. Tens of thousands of sorties, refuelings, and strikes, carried out under the protection of divine providence. A massive effort with miraculous protection."

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by alfiedotwtf on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:50PM (#47683833)
Knocking off the Taliban gave us the check notes the Taliban
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by derektank on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:05PM (#47683991)
The IRGC is probably more analogous to the Ba’ath party than the Taliban if we’re limiting ourself to regional comparisons
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by jojobas on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:43PM (#47683770)
This son is reportedly in coma and in no position to rule.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by ceejayoz on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:45PM (#47683793)
Yay! We cut off two of the hydra’s heads! That always ends well.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by alfiedotwtf on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:53PM (#47683849)
So who has the authority to claim that Iran has agreed to a ceasefire?!
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by sosomoxie on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:46PM (#47683802)
Reported by whom?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by SideQuark on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:16PM (#47684093)
The old govt was about to be toppled by people sick of it. The US attack unified those people behind the leaders son, someone they’d not have taken before, and entrenched a new generation against the US. So far the carrot and stick has them openly mocking Trump and the US as Trump makes threat, draws line, folds yet again, repeats.