News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by jrmg on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:53PM (#47581532)
I’m surprised to see no comments on this yet:

[The White House app] ships with 3 embedded trackers including Huawei Mobile Services Core (yes, the Chinese company the US government sanctioned, shipping tracking infrastructure inside the sitting president's official app)

The executive branch has decided this company is so dangerous I can’t buy a monitor made by them - but it’s embedding its SDK in its official app?!

I realize the decision makers probably don’t even know it’s there - it was just added by whatever contractor built the app, but that’s arguably even worse.

And I have absolutely no doubt that if it was discovered in a political opponent’s app, and the administration wanted to harm them, there would be no compunction about using that fact against them.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by e40 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:58PM (#47582250)
Incompetence is the forte of this administration.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by N_Lens on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:07PM (#47582304)
Followed closely by malice
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Terr_ on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:11AM (#47583787)
Recycling an old post:

> We had the first 4+ years to learn that "malice or incompetence" is not the right question. There's been more than enough pathological input to show it becomes a denial-of-service attack on observers.

> The correct answer is both, until and unless the perpetrators wish to come forward and defend themselves as just malicious or just incompetent.

One might also view it as a kind politically-flavored nerd-sniping. [0] Sometimes the only winning move is not to play.

[0] https://xkcd.com/356/

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by bregma on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:25AM (#47585214)
Malicious incompetence. The inbred kissing cousin of malicious compliance.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by gpderetta on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:01AM (#47586744)
IMHO incompetent malice is as much likely.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dandanua on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:33AM (#47583109)
The current administration has created a narrative that everything they do is good, while anything their opponents do is bad. Facts or meaning do not matter any more. I honestly don't understand how the USA has become this. This won't end well.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by yard2010 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:51AM (#47584037)
Tbf living throughout the past 20 years never have I ever get this feeling that the US is gonna "end well"
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:04AM (#47585029)
It'll end well, just not for the working class, if such a thing still exists at that time
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:42AM (#47583170)
The apps have nothing to do with the current administration. All these permissions were already in place before the current administration. It’s easy to verify this by looking at previous versions of the apps. HN has created a narrative that everything the current administration does is bad.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by wodenokoto on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:58AM (#47583281)
> HN has created a narrative that everything the current administration does is bad.

In all fairness, that narrative has been helped quite a bit by the current administration!

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:59AM (#47586724)
No. That narrative is driven by mass media, which shapes the perception of opinions posted on HN.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by vanviegen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:24AM (#47588737)
Ah.. I'm glad it's just a narrative then, and that there are in fact just as many good things to report and that America is not rapidly becoming an authoritarian state.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Itoldmyselfso on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:21AM (#47586979)
Fox news, the biggest mass media in US by far, doesn't seem to drive this narrative
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:38AM (#47587207)
Fox News is not popular on HN.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by glitchdout on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @03:08AM (#47597806)
For a good reason, don’t you think?
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by alsetmusic on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:54PM (#47655237)
You're completely out of touch. If one thing the admin does is good for anyone but they and their cronies, even if only by accident, it is a total coincidence.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by herbst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:00AM (#47583706)
To be fair that's the exact narrative European media seems to draw. Not sure how you could see anything else in this shitshow
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by VorpalWay on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:23AM (#47583864)
As an European, the political situation in US has never seemed reasonable to me, and been on a mostly downhill slope for a long time. It has certainly gotten way way worse with the current administration though.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:10AM (#47585088)
My relatives in Malaysia say it went from a slight downhill slope to a cliff and now we're in free fall.

The bottom has to be somewhere...

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dandanua on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @02:10AM (#47583358)
As I've said, facts or meaning no longer matter. There are numerous cases where Trump blamed Democrats for something he did during his first term or took credit for something positive that the Biden administration did. HN does not create a narrative, people are free to post their opinions here.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:07AM (#47585065)
When a coworker leaves the company and I inherit their work, I am given a little bit of time to acclimate and understand the projects they were working on.

If it turns out a secret was exposed in production, or we're exposing PII in logs, or storing CCs or passwords in plain text, there's a certain time frame in which the blame shifts from my coworker for introducing it, to me for not catching it.

That time frame is a lot less than one year.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:55AM (#47586680)
So where was that outrage before the current administration? The comments in this submission mostly blame the administration. I verified older versions of the apps and found that the wide permissions were there prior to Trump, and now suddenly it’s "hey, but he did not fix it!" This is hilarious, don't you think?
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:32AM (#47587121)
"but Biden didn't fix it" isn't the defense you think it is.

Is there a double standard? Yes. This administration earned it through their, willful or not, incompetence and malice.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:37AM (#47587198)
Where in my comments did I say “but Biden didn't fix it”? What I say is the majority of commenters are wrong blaming the administration.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:25AM (#47587861)
> I verified older versions of the apps and found that the wide permissions were there prior to Trump

This pretty much insinuates Biden (and Trump v1, and Obama, and Bush) didn't fix it.

And the commenter aren't wrong when they blame the administration. They wouldn't be wrong to blame previous administrations either. But the previous administrations aren't in power right now.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:40PM (#47590023)
> And the commenter aren't wrong when they blame the administration. They wouldn't be wrong to blame previous administrations either. But the previous administrations aren't in power right now

They are wrong. The current administration did not make a call to widen the permissions or make it intentionally overly broad.

> This pretty much insinuates Biden (and Trump v1, and Obama, and Bush) didn't fix it.

Why do you believe the president is responsible? Could be just a lazy contractor.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:37PM (#47590865)
> The current administration did not make a call to widen the permissions or make it intentionally overly broad.

Maybe not. But are they not responsible for an app that literally markets itself as the official federal govt app? If Meta sold FB to me am I not responsible for the algorithms that I now own, that perpetuates misinformation?

> Why do you believe the president is responsible? Could be just a lazy contractor.

Obviously the president is not deploying code. But doesn't mean the president gets a free pass. If I did shitty work for my employer and deployed a rootkit to production, I get fired but my employer is still responsible. If they want to be absolved of responsibility, they can always unpublish it while they get stuff fixed and acknowledge the issue.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by jrmg on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:10AM (#47586850)
“The White House” app seems to be new, first published three days ago.

It’s easy to verify this by looking at the App Store listing for the app. And reading news coverage.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by andreygrehov on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:46AM (#47587347)
Given that all other apps follow the same pattern, I insist that it has nothing to do with any sitting administration.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by DoingFedTime on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @11:16AM (#47602048)
An app published March 27th has no prior-administration version history. The other 7 apps in the piece span back to Obama the article treats this as a bipartisan failure.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by LoganDark on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:27AM (#47584280)
The USA became this through Trump being elected.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by bregma on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:32AM (#47585284)
It started with Richard Nixon and his cynical manoevering.

It was reinforced with Ronald Reagan. Remember how he spun the Iranian revolution and the bad economy on his opposition? Remember how he rode the Moral Majority wave?

It was taken up a notch by G. W. Bush and his band of trigger-happy self-serving country club elitists.

No one in between those points tried to roll back the progress. They're just as guilty. It's been a monotonic increasing function towards the current apex (nadir?).

Fear what comes next. If there is a next.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:00AM (#47587534)
Yeah the democrats are at fault here too. Clinton had eight years to rollback any damage from Nixon and Reagan. Obama had eight years to rollback any damage from them + Bush. Biden had four years to rollback any damage from them + Trump.

One could argue that the courts or congress/senate may not have been favorable during their time, but that wasn't true during the entire combined 20 years they had.

(siddnote - I think "nadir" was the answer to a crossword clue I was stumped on. I'd never heard it before that. And I thought I'd never hear it again. Interesting coincidence!)

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by yetihehe on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:40AM (#47584853)
I think Trump being elected is a result of anti-thought, feudalism-seeking part of society coming to power, not a cause. Enough people were fed up with thinking elites stealing from them, so they elected thought-averse elites to steal from them because they naively thought that the stealing is because of intelligence.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:03AM (#47585022)
What? Trump is just a symptom. The US didn't suddenly become what it is now because of a vote. Like it or not (and I certainly don't), the people voted for this, twice. Whether they voted for it because they actually wanted it vs they voted for it because politicians convinced them they wanted it, it is what we wanted.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by LoganDark on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:12AM (#47585114)
I don't deny that Republicans existed before Trump, but Trump being elected certainly fast-tracked this skyrocketing fascist disaster.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:28AM (#47585234)
Sure, absolutely. But again, the people voted for fascism. At his pre-election rallies he'd say shit like "I'm gonna be a dictator for a day!" and get cheers.

An America that didn't like fascism would have never even let this man win the primary.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by SmirkingRevenge on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @07:43AM (#47585907)
I think it's like that old saying about bankruptcy - it happens very slowly, then all at once

The rise of right-wing propaganda mass media has been simmering brains for 3 decades in a populist, grievance and resentment stew and positioned things perfectly for right-wing propaganda to explode in the internet age - once social media came around, it was a renaissance for the paranoid-style radical right-wing demagogues, and they exploded in numbers and reach. In turn, that tilled the soil for a Trump figure to come along to disrupt things.

Trump basically took all the recurring themes of grievance from right-wing media to the extreme to turbo-charge the anxiety and fear of the right, including most things that were generally considered wrong for politicians to say/do.

It's almost hard to remember the before-times, but Trump was the first modern presidential ticket that outright attacks the media (calling them the enemy of the people, fake news, etc) to de-legitimize them - it used to be a point of pride in this country that politicians didn't do stuff like this, because it's a feature of authoritarian regimes, not democracies. Right-wing audiences were very used to hearing that sort of thing though, because it was a common feature of the right-wing propaganda media they had been boiling in for years.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:54AM (#47587436)
When I was in high school (or maybe even junior high), I remember learning the bill of rights and the freedom of speech and press and assembly. Our curricula and case studies always focused on freedom of speech because I guess it was absurd to think that the govt would ever attack the press. That was a thing "other" countries did.

I can look past some of the stupid shit he says. He gets freedom of speech too, even if it is stupid speech. But attacking the press is insane.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by thfuran on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:00AM (#47588328)
>I can look past some of the stupid shit he says. He gets freedom of speech too

That just means it’s legally permissible, not reasonable, respectable, or conscionable. Do not look past the things he says.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by abustamam on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:39AM (#47589000)
No I mean the actual stupid shit he says, not the stupid policies he enacts. Like randomly getting up during a cabinet meeting to admire a ballroom that doesn't exist yet. That's stupid but harmless.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by xnx on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:43PM (#47595380)
> everything they do is good, while anything their opponents do is bad.

Even when it's the same thing! (e.g. "canceling" someone)

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by kdheiwns on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:46AM (#47584883)
> I realize the decision makers probably don’t even know it’s there

Assuming incompetence gives the administration a cover to get away with anything. I'm not quite sure they're as stupid as they all act. Someone is surely using the facade of incompetence to rot things from the inside out.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by justonceokay on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:14AM (#47586205)
I read a comment on Reddit that changed my perspective on 90% of recent political commentary:

“Y'all are mad about the dog whistle but you forgot about the dog”

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by MisterTea on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:56AM (#47588270)
Dogs bite so I'll assume most people want to forget.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by inopinatus on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:58AM (#47586720)
The term for this is weaponised incompetence.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by TiredOfLife on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @07:33AM (#47585826)
> The executive branch has decided this company is so dangerous I can’t buy a monitor made by them

Huawei was sanctioned because they did business with a sanctioned country

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by jrmg on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:16AM (#47586918)
That’s true - this was the reason for the original action in 2019 - but is not the whole story. The current rationale depends mostly on national security concerns: https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R47012

…but it also doesn’t really matter here. Either they were sanctioned for a good reason and the Executive Branch is doing business with them anyway, or they were sanctioned for a bad reason and I’m not allowed to do business with them even though the Executive Branch does.

It’s the hypocrisy I’m pointing out.