News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by psadauskas on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:13PM (#47579161)
Right? If I had enough money that I could make a serious dent in local or even global poverty without noticing the change in my lifestyle, and I just... chose not to, I have no idea how I could sleep at night.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by csallen on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:36PM (#47579403)
Huge numbers (billions) of people have enough money to make massive changes to the lives of those less fortunate than them, but don't, and prefer instead to make incremental upgrades to their own lives. New rugs, more savings, first-class airline tickets, eating out a few more times a month, etc.

This is just human nature.

People who are at wealth level x tend to say, "I can't believe that people at wealth level x+1 aren't more generous!" all the while ignoring their own lack of desire to give generously to people at wealth levels x-1 and below.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by conception on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:57PM (#47579614)
Aaron Swartz had a good take on this - http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/handwritingwall
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by nostrademons on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:10PM (#47580354)
I remember wrestling with this in my therapist's office when Aaron died. I had known him tangentially - we hung out in the same IRC channels, and had several mutual friends in the Cambridge/Somerville techie crowd that he would hang out in person with.

As a college student and young adult I had always envied his fame, his intelligence, his money (post-Reddit acquisition), and the strength of his convictions. And yet, in that moment in early 2013, he was dead, and I was working a good job at Google (and this was 2013 Google, when it was still a nice place to work doing things that I could generally approve of). And he'd died doing the stuff that I wanted to do but had been too chickenshit to actually carry out.

I think that this illustrates why the world is the way it is. All the true altruists are dead, killed for their altruism. It is adaptive, in a survival sense, to think of yourself and your own survival and not worry too much about other people. Ironically, this is what my therapist was trying to get me to realize.

But I think this also goes back to the GP's point. When people at wealth level x give to people at level x-1, it doesn't raise the people at x-1 up to x. It brings the person at x down to x-1. There are more people at x-1 than x, after all; you could give everything you had away and mathematically, it would lower your net worth significantly more than it would raise theirs. And of course, it doesn't do a damn thing about the people at x+1. Why can't they donate instead, where their wealth would do an order of magnitude more good?

There actually do exist people who are like that: they would rather spread their wealth around the people at wealth level x-1, joining them at that level, than raise themselves up to x+1. I've met some; most poor people are far more generous than rich people are. That is why they are poor. But then, it doesn't solve the problem of inequality, they just disappear into the masses of people at level x-1.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by gzread on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:18PM (#47582019)
Game theory is the most dangerous force in the universe.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by sfn42 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:10AM (#47584158)
There's also twitch viewers who love to give all their money to people at wealth level x + 10-100
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by phist_mcgee on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:18PM (#47580425)
RIP
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by unfitted2545 on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:58PM (#47579621)
I also think this could be a symptom of an economically unequal society (which creates a higher range of x), and is a big reason why it's important to fix it, on top of the extra money to the state.

So thats essentially communism right? Is human nature incompatible with communism or is capitalism incompatible with human nature?

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by nostrademons on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:47PM (#47580664)
Communism doesn't eliminate power relationships, it just papers them over with politics and bureaucracy instead of having them legible with prices and wages.

In the American golden age of capitalism from ~1950-1970, the top marginal tax rate was 90%, and so you didn't have CEOs get paid more than about 3x the median worker, because the government would get it all. Instead, they got perks. Private jets. Positions at the company for their kids. Debaucherous holiday parties. Casual sexual harassment of secretaries.

In Soviet communism, all production was centrally planned by government bureau run by party members. It was not uncommon for these bureaus to make mistakes, leading to severe shortages for the population. Nevertheless, these shortages never seemed to really hit the party members responsible for making the plans. Power has its perks.

And that's also why reforms attempting to reduce economic inequality need to focus on power rather than money. There have been a number of policies that do meaningfully raise standards of living for the poor: they're things like the 13th amendment to the (US) Constitution, the 1st amendment, the jury trial system, free markets, anti-monopoly statutes, bans on non-competes, etc. What they all have in common is that they preserve economic freedom and the power to make your own living against people who would seek to restrict that freedom and otherwise keep you in bondage.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by scottyah on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:36PM (#47580020)
We can also tell because anyone who can take the time to use a computer with internet to write a comment in well-formed English is already comparatively wealthy or connected enough to provide food and housing for dozens of people.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Cipater on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:49AM (#47584916)
Dirt poor people in 3rd world countries have smartphones and internet access and write comments in well-formed English.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by scottyah on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:19PM (#47592151)
All of them? Weird argument to take
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by psadauskas on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:59PM (#47582254)
I'm not talking about people with x+1, where X is a standard US middle-class amount of money. In that case, $20k or $100k or some amount that would make a tiny difference in the world is a huge amount of money to a middle-class family.

No, I'm talking about wealth level X*100. For them, the difference between $100M and $1B is basically no difference in the quality of life to that family. They'd have 1 fewer megayachts. They could give away $900M, and eliminate hunger forever in a large city or a small state. $100B is 100x that again, they could give away $99.9B, still have $100M, and solve poverty in most _countries_.

Or, if they don't want to, we institute a 90% wealth tax on everything over $10M, and solve it ourselves.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by lynx97 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:00AM (#47584535)
What you forget is, none of the x+100 people you are talking about would have ever become a x+100 person if they thought like you suggest they should. In german, we have a proverb: "Von den Reichen lernt man das sparen." (The rich teach you how to save money) And giving away huge sums without personal gain, is the contrary of saving.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by csallen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:35PM (#47594367)
Hmmm.

> For them, the difference between $100M and $1B is basically no difference in the quality of life to that family.

I think money at that level is not about family quality of life. It's usually about buying companies, launching product lines, etc.

> They could give away $900M, and eliminate hunger forever in a large city or a small state. $100B is 100x that again, they could give away $99.9B, still have $100M, and solve poverty in most _countries_.

Ehhh...

Most people who have $X billion don't really have that. They just have controlling shares in a company that's worth a lot, and media companies like Forbes enjoy making headlines by pretending that's cash. Actually turning that into cash would be impossible.

Of course, they can still turn meaningful percentages of it into cash and give it away, that's true. And I think more billionaires should.

But also, many problems aren't money problems. For example, simply flooding a state or a small city with money isn't going to "solve hunger forever." Hunger and poverty are more often an issue around distribution and logistics, infrastructure, politics, culture and conflict, and things like that. Huge cash giveaways famously tend to disappear and accomplish very little.

The single biggest force that reduces suffering and poverty in an enduring way, imo, is the creation and proliferation of technology. Vaccines that are cheaper to produce. Water filtration systems that are easier to maintain. Seeds and crops that are heartier and more durable. Healthcare that's more affordable and available. Etc. Advances like this have reduced more suffering and ended more poverty and counteracted more famine and saved more lives than any amount of charity ever has or could.

What I would like to see more of is billionaires and even super-talented non-billionaires starting more organizations that are a force for good. Or using money from profitable enterprises to fund unprofitable-yet-charitable enterprises.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Aarostotle on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:56PM (#47582578)
Safe to assume those downvoting you will not be donating their MacBooks and refrigerators.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by surgical_fire on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:43PM (#47579476)
If you had that amount of money you would also be a sociopath. It's a precondition.

Good news is that you would sleep fine at night. No matter how destructive your existence was, and how much of a net negative you were to the world, you would still think very highly of yourself.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by phatskat on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:16PM (#47579797)
Trump has largely not had that kind of money. He’s had a _lot_ of money, many many times more than most, but by all accounts except his own, those numbers are much lower than he likes to brag about. Well, they were - there’s been a troubling amount of money going out of the federal government that isn’t well-accounted for under his reign.

He had the kind of money that can hire expensive projects on trust that payment in full will be rendered, but only kept his money by often not paying out.

As with all things Trump, even up to the new ballroom not having a front door despite the massive staircase, his wealth is more in appearance, and less in actual assets…or was. Of course, someday maybe we will know the true extent or shortfall of his bank accounts

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Nursie on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:26PM (#47581359)
Don’t forget the fairly naked corruption around his crypto coins too…

He may not have been that successful as a businessman, but his whole clan are monetising the Whitehouse.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by malfist on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:34PM (#47579993)
Elon tweeted that he'd fund ending world hunger if someone presented him with an actual plan to do that. UNESCO did. Elon did not act.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dnautics on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:07PM (#47580316)
can you verify that the UNESCO plan would have ended world hunger?
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by Den_VR on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:19PM (#47580433)
It was a 6.6 billion dollar plan to alleviate famine in 43 countries for one year, so, no.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by XorNot on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:22PM (#47581322)
Also famines are political problems to start with. We have more then enough food. Getting it to people reliably is the issue - i.e. there's usually a plethora of other issues like an active war.

It also isn't an economically isolated enterprise: Ukrainian grain shipments traversing into Europe via Polish roads and not heading to Africa via their ports caused a bunch of price crashes which became political flashpoints.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by HWR_14 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:26PM (#47582057)
Which is why UNESCO's plan focused on delivering the food, not buying it.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dotancohen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:38AM (#47582811)
Why not grow it, where the hungry people are?
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by zimpenfish on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:25AM (#47584272)
> Why not grow it, where the hungry people are?

I bet no-one has ever thought of that before. You should present that idea at the UN.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dotancohen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:29AM (#47586365)
It was a serious question.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:38AM (#47586469)
Not all areas are equally good at growing food. That can be because of climate, soil quality, war or simply population density requiring housing and industry.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dotancohen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:23AM (#47587832)
Is shipping food there the correct solution? For war, an ostensibly temporary condition, by all means ship the population food. But if an area is already overcrowded beyond what the land can sustain (due to climate, soil quality, or population density) then is it productive to further bolster the population? Seems a human catastrophe in the making, supporting population growth in an area where the land can not supply enough food.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by malfist on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:40PM (#47593194)
This is literally how cities exist. Or in your world view is food not shipped into cities?
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dotancohen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:37PM (#47593795)
My worldview is based on the cities I've lived in, in which the citizens of that city have the means to purchase the food themselves. Therefore the movement of food into that city is in the economic interest of those supplying the food. Furthermore, that food _is_ grown locally, within half a tank of gas from the city itself.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dotancohen on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:14PM (#47595194)
I should note that the cities I'm familiar with, and thus my worldview, have multiple thousands of independent suppliers bringing food into the cities as profitable businesses, not a single altruistic organisation functioning off donations. Therefore there are much fewer catastrophic points of failure - an event that would prevent food from getting into the city would be a large, wide geographical catastrophe. Not the whimsical changing of political positions or sudden misfortune of donors. And in this worldview, when natural pressures such as population overdensity occur, the feedback loop stabilises at a sustainable level - those for whom food becomes too expensive move to cheaper places. I've done it myself.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by modo_mario on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:19AM (#47587778)
Maybe it's too malthusian of a view but I think a big issue to contend with is that some people should not be as populated as they are and there's no push against it from either government or the dominant economic systems.

And yes that includes the controversial poor population hotspots of africa that have grown super rapidly beyond multiples of what the land can provide

But also just the same places like arizona with comparatively rich folk growing the urban desert sprawl

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by modo_mario on Thursday April 02, 2026 @04:06AM (#47611386)
some places*
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by taylorportman on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @09:59PM (#47595867)
Good question I think. Norman Borlaug was known for transforming places with food importers into food exporters. And to ask the question again occasionally makes sense. In recent history we are exploring the idea of vertical gardening etc. I was joking to someone once that we should grow watermelons vertically so that the large heavy melons could power a carousel style escalator or water pumping mechanism.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by XorNot on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @02:39AM (#47583547)
The issue is that simply saying you're going to deliver food aid is elliding pretty much the entire problem. You cannot simply deliver food aid, because to do so you might have to fight and win an entire war against one or several insurgent groups or governments.

You could turn up reliably and distribute quite a lot of food, and yet at the end of the day find there's still a famine.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:47AM (#47586588)
Right, which is why I never said I was going to simply deliver food aid like it just required trucks and gas. It's why UN World Food Program, an organization with actual experience, designed a plan to deliver and distribute food. Please explain why they are wrong.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by XorNot on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:07AM (#47588452)
They're not but it also won't end world hunger. Because world hunger is not being caused by accidental deficits in food availability: it's caused by serious local security threats and in many cases deliberate political action.
Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by zimpenfish on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:24AM (#47584265)
On the other hand, it would have alleviated famine in 43 countries for one year and if your response to that is "but that's not ending world hunger and I will not do it", you really need a long hard look at yourself.

But then again, Musk is going to turn out to be one of the great mass killers of world history with his destruction of USAID. Why would he spoil that by helping some folks?

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dnautics on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @07:57AM (#47599648)
where do you draw the line? Suppose someone had a program that spent 6 trillion dollars that fed 10 people for one year. Would you then say "you need to take a long hard look at yourself". Not keeping people dependent on a program for just one year is exactly the point that Musk was trying to make. Solve the fucking problem, don't put a very expensive bandage on it.

> But then again, Musk is going to turn out to be one of the great mass killers of world history with his destruction of USAID. Why would he spoil that by helping some folks?

If you consider turning off an program that a group of people aren't particularly entitled to as equivalent to mass murderers who pulled the trigger on people like Stalin and Mao, maybe you need to take a long hard look at yourself. Suppose yanking USAID prompts the creation of a more efficient, more local solution that feeds more people. Will you give Musk the credit of saving people's lives?

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by zimpenfish on Thursday April 02, 2026 @05:14AM (#47611917)
> where do you draw the line?

Well before someone comes out with a ludicrous bad faith hypothetical.

> Suppose someone had [ludicrous bad faith hypothetical]

Whoops.

> Solve the fucking problem, don't put a very expensive bandage on it.

That only works for the most trivial of problems. Anything complex will need expensive bandages until a complex solution can be worked out and, more importantly, implemented correctly.

> maybe you need to take a long hard look at yourself.

I have, many times, and that's how I turned from a bad faith edge lord posting this kind of hypothetical drivel defending the indefensible for years into a slightly less problematic member of society. And I will continue to take long hard looks at myself to try and improve further.

> Suppose yanking USAID prompts the creation of a more efficient, more local solution that feeds more people.

Again a bad faith hypothetical but let's assume this does happen - great! That would be grand. It still won't take away from Musk being responsible for one of the biggest mass murders in history.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by dnautics on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:47PM (#47633863)
> It still won't take away from Musk being responsible for one of the biggest mass murders in history.

i dint particularly like musk. i would say he is shitty. your moral compass is fucked up.

Re:Fedware: Government apps that spy harder than the apps th... by keybored on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:09PM (#47580341)
I don’t get puzzled that the criminal doesn’t use his ill-gotten gains for pro-social causes. Why would a person ever use anti-social means to acquire funds for pro-social goods?[1]

This is not too disimilar from the case of the billionaire.

[1] Excepting some Galaxy Brain philosophies like Effective Altruism