News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by noosphr on Monday February 02, 2026 @03:35PM (#46861135)
Whenever people say that MIT or GPL licenses are a good idea I point out projects like this.

Only humans should have freedom zero. Corporations and robots must pay.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by wmf on Monday February 02, 2026 @03:57PM (#46861444)
You can demand payment but it doesn't mean you'll get paid. These days companies will clone your work instead of paying.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by zhengyi13 on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:06PM (#46861536)
As covered literally just a few days ago (IIRC), you absolutely can demand payment: https://github.com/LGUG2Z/komorebi actively works to detect MDM, and if found, demand payment.

Not open source, but an interesting counterpoint, I think.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by bsnnkv on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:39PM (#46861992)
Relevant articles are here

- https://lgug2z.com/articles/normalize-identifying-corporate-...

- https://lgug2z.com/articles/i-started-identifying-corporate-...

The post-open source space is indeed a very exciting space in 2026

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by alt187 on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:24PM (#46865597)
That's not post open-source. That's dual licensing, an use-case FOSS has enabled and supported forever.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by bsnnkv on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:36PM (#46865710)
> any time someone says something is post-$thing it means what they are doing is in dialogue with and in response to $thing. “we were doing that before $thing” no, you can’t be in dialogue with something that hasn’t happened yet.

> this is like saying “what do you mean post-modernist architecture, architecture predates modernism”.

https://lobste.rs/s/kaftkn/i_started_identifying_corporate_d...

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by Aurornis on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @09:23AM (#46871336)
Releasing open source software and then “demanding payment” goes against everything about open source.

If someone expects to be paid for the use of their software, releasing it as open source is not what they want.

If a maintainer of a software project starts trying to demand payment or threatening to change license terms, it’s a reasonable response for a company to fork it or build their own solution.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by bsnnkv on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @11:14AM (#46872903)
And this is why all new projects by independent developers should seriously consider using a post-open source license before defaulting to corporate-friendly/corporate-first OSI licenses
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by AlexeyBelov on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @05:14AM (#46883940)
I think they should expect payment from the job they're working, not opensource or "post-opensource" work.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by bsnnkv on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @03:31PM (#46891266)
Yep, this kind of attitude is even more reason to reject the broken status quo.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by groby_b on Monday February 02, 2026 @03:48PM (#46861306)
That's a nice slogan, but how does it work?

Say, I clone sudo. Clearly, a human applying freedom zero. I use it in my projects. Probably still freedom zero. I use it in my CI pipeline for the stuff that makes me money... corporation or human? If it's corporation, what if I sponsor a not-for-profit that provides that piece of CI infra?

The problem is that "corporation or not" has more shades than you can reasonably account for. And, worse, the cost of accounting for it is more than any volunteer wants to shoulder.

Even if this were a hard and legally enforceable rule, what individual maintainer wants to sue a company with a legal department?

What could work is a large collective that licenses free software with the explicit goal of extracting money from corporate users and distributing it to authors. Maybe.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by conception on Monday February 02, 2026 @03:57PM (#46861428)
Not for commercial use without buying a license is a pretty standard licensing scheme. This has been worked out for decades.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by mulmen on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:38PM (#46861975)
What happens when the code is abandoned? Can I make my own changes whenever I want?

The problem with commercial software is the lock in.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by groby_b on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:39PM (#46861998)
And the shades in between account for the large number of new licensing schemes sprouting, with different restrictions on what is and isn't possible. (Not to mention the large number of "just used it anyways" instances). And it struggles for smaller utilities, or packages of many different things.

It's "worked out" in the sense that it still doesn't really work for a lot of maintainers.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by atq2119 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:26AM (#46870160)
The challenge is that this doesn't really work for community-developed software.

Let's say somebody uses this scheme for software they wrote. Would anybody else ever contribute significantly if the original author would benefit financially but they wouldn't?

Mediating the financial benefits through a non-profit might help, but (1) there's still a trust problem: who controls the non-profit? and (2) that's a lot of overhead to set up when starting out for a piece of software that may or may not become relevant.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by saubeidl on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:26PM (#46861826)
The GPL is a good idea. It's our socieconomic system that isn't.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by PunchyHamster on Monday February 02, 2026 @06:32PM (#46863825)
GPLv3 is a bit overreaching , especially in patent clauses. The GPL as idea is great but the license needs a little more refining

The constant fear of lawyers that using some GPL lib will infest entire codebase of their project with GPL is a real problem that stops many corporations from contributing in the first place.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by aboardRat4 on Monday February 02, 2026 @07:08PM (#46864292)
GPL is a response to the copyright law, which was created for the big corporations to extract rent from ordinary people.

It's copyright law which should go away.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by JuniperMesos on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:11PM (#46864910)
Copyright law is hundreds of years old and originally was intended to prevent owner-operators of mechanical printing presses from printing and selling copies of some author's books without paying them or getting permission.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by degamad on Monday February 02, 2026 @11:50PM (#46866653)
> originally was intended to prevent owner-operators of mechanical printing presses from printing and selling copies of some author's books without paying them or getting permission.

We agree that that was its initial stated intention.

However, what we have seen in practice is that it has resulted in the owner-operators of those machines banding together to restrict access to the machines unless authors sign exploitative contracts assigning their rights to the operators (which they interpret as "getting permission").

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by JuniperMesos on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:18AM (#46867643)
The world has changed substantially since the 1710 Statue of Anne; there's a thousand things that you could call the modern-day equivalent of mechanically printing a book, with myriad capital and operating costs and availability. Many ways an independent author or artist can publish their work are extremely cheap and effective. I'm relatively anti-copyright, but that doesn't mean that everyone currently benefiting from copyright law is rent-seeking in an exploitive way.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by aboardRat4 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:38AM (#46867778)
It was created when there was a scarcity of content, so state violence was used to encourage production of content.

But now we don't live in the age of scarcity of content. On the contrary, content creators are competing for a possibility to get into consumers' attention span and push their agenda (ads). Everything has changed.

Removing all copyright restriction will not decrease the amount of content available for a person through their lifetime even a few percent.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by satvikpendem on Monday February 02, 2026 @07:44PM (#46864650)
Including the hangups people have about AI training as well.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by drnick1 on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:51PM (#46865267)
> It's copyright law which should go away.

This precisely. What started out as a way of rewarding authorship (of text, software, or other things) has mainly become a way of extracting rent -- see the music, movie, and software industries. In the digital age, when the cost of making copies of such works is approximately zero, copyright law ceases to make sense.

Note that this does not mean you cannot make money selling software or software-related services. For example, game developers could still sell keys for online play on their servers even if they couldn't copyright the binaries.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by saubeidl on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @05:36PM (#46878347)
GPL is much more than that. It is distributing the means of production to the tech workers.

rms is the Marx of the 20th Century. GPL is freedom from corporate oppression.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by aboardRat4 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @11:15PM (#46881392)
No it's not. GPL is quite the opposite. GPL means that "you own what you buy", which is the foundation of capitalism. You own what you buy, including programs, which you can buy, replicate, modify, and sell.

Due to the nature of software, especially in the 80s, it existed in both text and binary form, which made it easy to perverse the nature of selling software from selling code to selling binaries, and big companies went even further in their collusion with the government socialists by making even re-selling even your own binaries illegal.

GPL is just trying to fight this madness with its own weapon. The GPL is an attempt to go back to capitalism of small business owners and individual service providers.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by saubeidl on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @05:02AM (#46883834)
Going from the capitalism of small business owners to the market socialism of coops is a small step ;)
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by aboardRat4 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @08:53PM (#46894623)
Well, none of the implementations of Marxism in the XX century worked like this, so I dare to disagree.

Of course, you can always say that America is exceptional, and she will have "Marxism with American characteristics", just like China switched from true socialism to "socialism with Chinese characteristics", but would still recommend avoiding the word which associates with GULAG and mass starvation.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by noosphr on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:13PM (#46862573)
Everything is a good idea if you assume a world in which it works.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by fragmede on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:23PM (#46862726)
Communism has entered the chat.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by saubeidl on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:24PM (#46862743)
That, for example, would be a better system. One the GPL would work beautifully in.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by david-gpu on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:54PM (#46863272)
If you can't explain why it did not work in the past, and can't explain how & why things will be different this time, you don't have a plan. History is a harsh mistress.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by mediumsmart on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:20AM (#46867234)
It works, but you need real human staff. And we learn from history that we don’t learn which can be harsh.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by jibal on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @05:10AM (#46869013)
Communism worked in China, for some definition of "worked". Stalinism eventually failed in the USSR and elsewhere. An extensive literature explains these things, as well as explaining different forms and varieties of "communism", and things that people call "communism" but aren't.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by david-gpu on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:05PM (#46875636)
Communism worked so well in China that as soon as they adopted something resembling free markets in some regions, thanks to Deng Xiaoping, their GDP per capita rose amazingly fast for 3~4 decades. Not exactly a stellar example.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by jibal on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @02:06AM (#46882475)
China is still communist. Again communism has worked for some definition of "worked". This is an objective statement, not an endorsement of Chinese communism.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by Muromec on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:49AM (#46867420)
As a person who had a privilege to live in a commie-block half his life, no, it isn't a better system.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by jibal on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @05:12AM (#46869027)
That was Stalinism, not communism. And there are many ways to implement communism, some of which are better than others.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by Muromec on Thursday February 05, 2026 @02:51AM (#46896905)
If anything, Stalin-era commie blocks are better than the Khruschov-era commieblock I lived in. That particular brand of communism had a tendency to paperclip-optimize everything in a weird way. Like it's really the opposite of capitalism where you go from an MVP to a fully usable product, but in reverse. You would thing it's optimization, but then you regulate the temperature in winter by opening the window.

In terms of housing and speaking only from personal experience, European brand of social democracy seems to get it.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by omoikane on Monday February 02, 2026 @04:27PM (#46861838)
I am not sure sudo is licensed under MIT or GPL, looks it's like a mix of licenses[1]. The end of the first license says it's sponsored in part by DARPA.

From 2010 to February 2024, it was sponsored by Quest Software according to the history page[2].

[1] https://github.com/sudo-project/sudo/blob/main/LICENSE.md

[2] https://www.sudo.ws/about/history/

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by sixtyj on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:26PM (#46862782)
The behavior of corporations is shameful.

After all, people in these companies don't work for free and are able to spend a lot of money for other services.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by 6LLvveMx2koXfwn on Monday February 02, 2026 @11:31PM (#46866527)
Haven't you just hit the nail on the head? Corporations do not feel shame even if people within them do; hence actions . . .
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by throw0101c on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:29PM (#46862845)
> Corporations and robots must pay.

Greenpeace is a (non-profit) corporation. Unions are corporations. Municipalities. Colleges and universities.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_person

Should they have to pay?

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by llbbdd on Monday February 02, 2026 @06:32PM (#46863821)
Yes. Non-profits are more than capable of abusing the commons, the purpose of even small monetary requirements is to put a bound on that.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by isatty on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:05PM (#46864859)
Yes. Not for profit does not mean they don’t have money.

With that logic why should non profits have to pay for anything at all?

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by Muromec on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:45AM (#46867389)
For the same logic they are tax-exempt. There is a general consensus that their goal is the greater good (like developing sudo and such) and not the usual capitalistic good of generating more money.

Then again, you usual Friday outing of FANG engineers may have more money than some nonprofits too.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by noosphr on Monday February 02, 2026 @05:33PM (#46862903)
Yes.
Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by degamad on Monday February 02, 2026 @11:43PM (#46866609)
I used to volunteer for a local non-profit a few years ago.

From time to time, I would reflect on the fact that Microsoft and other commercial suppliers were getting paid for providing services to us, but I was expected to work for free.

Re:Todd C. Miller – Sudo maintainer for over 30 years by LunaSea on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @08:48AM (#46870920)
If Mozilla and Wikimedia can pay millions in salary to their CEOs, I'm sure that they can spare a few thousands for open source projects.