News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by muppetman on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:09AM (#46550605)
I feel like I'm the only person on this site that doesn't use AI for coding. I guess there's probably a lot of other people that haven't commented on this story who don't use it either. But when I read about how much hype and all that sort of stuff there is in the AI industry, and then I see the amount of posts and commentary and deep technical discussion about how this feature has affected people, I'm not so sure. Everyone I know hates AI and how it's been shoved into every corner of our lives, but I look here and it's insanely popular. Anyway, sorry this was a very off topic comment. It's just very interesting to me that the hype isn't all just hype.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by isodev on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:19AM (#46550656)
I also don’t use AI for coding. I tried, I explored, I learned how it works.

At the end, “maybe-sometimes works” and “sends a copy of all your code to some server in the US” are just incompatible with the kind of software I create.

Regarding the post, I think it’s telling that Anthropic is trying to force people into using their per-usage billing more than the subscription. My take is that the subscription offers a lot as a way of hooking developers into it and is not sustainable for Anthropic if people end up actually maxing their usage.

Given how much money is wasted into the LLM craze, I can imagine there will be more “tightening of the belt” from the AI corps going forward.

For the five coders out there, maybe it’s time to use your tokens to get back control of your codebases … you may have to “meat code” them soon.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by luckilydiscrete on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:22AM (#46550678)
I'll say "maybe-sometimes works" is a misunderstanding.

It feels like that initially, but that's no different from any new tool you adopt. A jackhammer also "maybe-sometimes works" as a hammer replacement.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by cocoto on Friday January 09, 2026 @02:43AM (#46551064)
Not true, most tools are deterministic. For instance my programming language LSP just works 100% of the time with no failure. It doesn’t hallucinate any types, methods or variables.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by wiseowise on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:06AM (#46551647)
Your LSP also can’t do complex reasoning across the purpose of your whole codebase.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by lomase on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:31AM (#46551830)
Neither LLM can reason about anything.

Reasoning is an human trait.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by wiseowise on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:32AM (#46551834)
Whatever you say lol.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by isodev on Friday January 09, 2026 @05:13AM (#46552157)
The usage of the word "reasoning" in the context of LLMs, just like the "I" in "AI", that's more marketing than a technical reality. I know it can be confusing.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by hu3 on Friday January 09, 2026 @06:16AM (#46552650)
Regardless of semanthics, LLMs + tooling can do impressive things.

For example I can tell LLMs to scan my database schema and compare to code to detect drift or inconsistencies.

And while doing that it has enough condensed world knowledge to point to me that the code is probably right when declaring person.name a non-nullable string despite the database column being nullable.

And it can infer that date_of_birth column is correct in being nullable on the database schema and wrong in code where the type is a non-nullable date because, in my system, it knows date_of_birth is an optional field.

This is a simple example that can be solved by non-LLMs tooling also. In practice it can do much more advanced reasoning with regards to business rules.

We can argue semanthics all day but this is reason enough to be useful for me.

There are many examples I could give. But to the skeptics I recommend trying to use LLMs for understanding large systems. But take your time to give it read only access to data base schema.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by wiseowise on Friday January 09, 2026 @07:48AM (#46553298)
Sure, sure.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by xpe on Friday January 09, 2026 @08:52AM (#46553828)
> Neither LLM can reason about anything.

> Reasoning is an human trait.

Note: this is not directed at the commenter or any person in particular. It is directed at various patterns I've noticed.

I often notice claims like the following:

- human intelligence is the "truest" form of intelligence;

- machines can't reason (without very clearly stating what you mean by reasoning);

- [such and such] can only be done by a human (without clearly stating that you mean at the present time with present technology that you know of);

Such claims are in my view, rather unhelpful framings – or worse, tropes or thought-terminated clichés. We would be wise to ask ourselves how such things persist.

How do these ideas lodge in our brains? There are various shaky premises (including cognitive missteps) that lead to them. So I want to make some general comments that often lead to the above kind of thinking.

It is more important than ever for people to grow their understanding and appreciation. I suggest considering the following.

1. ... recognize that one probably can't offer a definition of {reasoning, intelligence, &c} that is widely agreed upon. Probably the best you can hope for is to clarify the sense of which you mean. There are often fairly clear 'camps' that can easily be referenced.

2. Recognition that implicitly hiding a definition in your claims -- or worse, forcing a definition on people -- doesn't do much good.

3. Awareness that one's language may be often interpreted in various ways by reasonable people.

4. Internalize dictionaries are catalogs of various usage that evolve over time. Dictionaries are not intended to be commandments of correctness, though some still think dictionary-as-bludgeon is somehow appropriate.

3. Acknowledge confusing terminology in AI/LLM in particular. For example, reasonable people can recognize that "reasoning" in this context is a fraught term.

5. Recognition that humanity is only getting started when it comes to making sense of how "intelligence" decomposes, how our brains work, the many nuanced differences between machine intelligence and human intelligence.

6. Recognize one's participation in a social context. Strive to not provide fuel for the fires of misunderstanding. If you use a fraught term, be extra careful to say what you mean.

7. Hopefully obvious: sweeping generalizations and blanket black-or-white statements are unlikely to be true unless you are talking about formal systems like logic and mathematics. Just don't do it. Don't let your thinking fall into that trap. And don't spew it -- that insults the intelligence of one's audience.

8. Generally speaking, people would be wise† to think about upping their epistemic game. If one says things that are obviously inaccurate, you are wasting your intelligence refined over millions of years by evolution and culture. To do so is self-destructive, for it makes oneself less valuable relative to LLMs who (although they blunder) are often more reliable than people who speak carelessly.

† Because it benefits the person directly and it helps culture, civilization, progress, &c

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by isodev on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:25AM (#46550696)
Every prompt is a run of probability - It’s at the core of the technology to be unable to give reproducible responses and even after a while, Claude is just as likely to sneak-in crimes in every snippet it outputs.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by jatora on Friday January 09, 2026 @02:31AM (#46551014)
like the other commenter said. you need to learn to use new tools. and your take clearly indicates you haven't.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by lomase on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:32AM (#46551838)
Your take clearly indicates you need to learn how to code.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by xpe on Friday January 09, 2026 @09:24AM (#46554152)
Please don't snipe at others, even if someone else started it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by dang on Sunday January 11, 2026 @02:15PM (#46578835)
We've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines and ignoring our requests to stop.

Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. It will eventually get your main account banned as well.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by xpe on Friday January 09, 2026 @09:30AM (#46554229)
> Every prompt is a run of probability - It’s at the core of the technology to be unable to give reproducible responses and even after a while, Claude is just as likely to sneak-in crimes in every snippet it outputs.

Some readers might interpret "a run of probability" to mean "we can't say anything about the statistical distribution". I don't think the commenter means that, but still, communicating statistics is hard, so I suggest being careful.

For example, writing "even after a while, just as likely to sneak-in crimes in every snippet it outputs" is pretty attention-getting and even provoking. What does the commenter mean by it? What kind of 'crimes' do they mean? Does the commenter really mean 'just as likely'? Just as likely as what? I would think most readers would form very different takes.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by teaearlgraycold on Friday January 09, 2026 @09:57PM (#46562304)
Completely depends on your domain. TypeScript web dev? Very good experience for a lot of tasks. Minecraft mod development? Don’t waste your time.

I only have a few experiences to pull from so if anyone else has good data points give them.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by dannersy on Friday January 09, 2026 @03:40AM (#46551436)
I share your experience. Additionally, I am surprised anyone on this site did not see this progression coming. Between costs, the race to be THE provider, and anyone who has an awareness of how the tech industry has been operating the last 15 years, this move by Anthropic was so laughably predictable that the discourse in this thread is pretty disappointing.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by BrouteMinou on Friday January 09, 2026 @03:53AM (#46551538)
All those people are on the drug they got on the cheap during the fun party nights.

They are, or soon will be, surprised that the price is going to increase, and they are the only losers in that great story of theirs...

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by defrost on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:47AM (#46551951)
Was it the drug that killed River Phoenix, or the one that Edmund Hillary had in his veins ascending Everest?

Greek philosophers pondered that question: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ijx_tT5lCDY

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by muppetman on Friday January 09, 2026 @07:43PM (#46561408)
OMG I got this reference before I even clicked. Bravo. (we're old)
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by daliusd on Friday January 09, 2026 @02:23AM (#46550974)
It will be shoved into your life anyway. You might like it or not, but the only safe choice is to learn and understand it IMHO.

About usage: it looks like web development gets benefits here, but other areas are not that successful somehow. While I use it successfully for Neovim Lua plugins development, CLI apps (in JS) and shell development (WezTerm Lua + fish shell). So I don't know if:

a) it simply has clicked for me and it will click for everyone who invests into it;

b) it is not for everybody because of tech;

c) is it not for everybody because of mindset;

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by luckilydiscrete on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:18AM (#46550653)
AI is indeed just hype in a lot of cases, but also has revolutionary value in a other cases. Trying it is the only way you'll be able to differentiate the latter from the former.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by LorenzoGood on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:25AM (#46550699)
I feel the same. I don't want to hear about it all the time (although I welcome discussion). I wish this site would go back to talking about other tech things.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by mgfist on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:10AM (#46550613)
I hate how AI is being shoved in most things, but I do love AI in a few of those places (ai coding and google search replacement)
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by iamkonstantin on Friday January 09, 2026 @01:22AM (#46550683)
Have you noticed how Google search summaries have taken the shape of those annoying blogposts that take you through several “What is a computer program” explainers before answering the question?
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by globular-toast on Friday January 09, 2026 @02:07AM (#46550902)
I use it sparingly. I do still have to produce boilerplate and don't have the time/will to engineer a better solution. But any actual logic etc I do myself. Why would I take a chance on an LLM doing it wrong when I know exactly how I want it and am perfectly capable of doing it myself. Also, what the hell am I going to do in the minutes it takes to generate, just sit there and watch it? No thanks.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by solumunus on Saturday January 10, 2026 @07:13AM (#46565069)
Because if the LLM does it wrong you simply correct it, you will still get to the end result quicker than DIY. People like this stuff because they’re getting their work done faster, or getting more work done. Personally while waiting I’m either creating plans for other tasks, or I do chores, exercise, watch TV, have a shower, etc.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by globular-toast on Saturday January 10, 2026 @04:30PM (#46570114)
> Because if the LLM does it wrong you simply correct it, you will still get to the end result quicker than DIY.

No you don't.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by solumunus on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:17AM (#46576994)
No you don’t. Yes I do.
Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by tkgally on Friday January 09, 2026 @06:28AM (#46552733)
> I feel like I'm the only person on this site that doesn't use AI for coding.

I’m surprised by that. One reason I follow discussions here about AI and coding is that strong opinions are expressed by professionals both for and against. It seems that every thread that starts out with someone saying how AI has increased their productivity invites responses from people casting doubt on that claim, and that every post about the flaws in AI coding gets pushback from people who claim to use it to great effect.

I’m not a programmer myself, but I have been using Claude Code to vibe-code various hobby projects and I find it enormously useful and fun. In that respect, I suppose, I stand on the side of AI hype. But I also appeciate reading the many reports from skeptics here who explain how AI has failed them in more serious coding scenarios than what I do.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by schiem on Friday January 09, 2026 @09:50AM (#46554459)
I don't use it at all for a variety of reasons, but I rarely bother to get into discussions on HackerNews.

Looking at how new it is, and how quickly things are changing, it seems likely that I could adopt it into my workflow in a month or two if it turns out that that's necessary.

On the other hand, I've spent the last 2 decades building skills as a developer. I'm far more worried that becoming a glorified code reviewer will atrophy those skills than I am about falling behind. Maybe it will turn out that those skills are now obsolete, but that feels unlikely to me.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by Izkata on Friday January 09, 2026 @11:18AM (#46555435)
> I'm far more worried that becoming a glorified code reviewer will atrophy those skills

A co-worker who went all-in around a year ago admitted a few months ago he's noticed this in himself, and was trying to stop using the code-generating functionality of any of these tools. Emphasis on "try": apparently the times it does work amazingly makes it addictive like gambling, and it's far too easy to reach for.

Re:Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscript... by spicyusername on Monday January 12, 2026 @12:34AM (#46584481)

    I don't use AI for coding
It's a very powerful tool now, and it's going to continue to get more powerful and more popular.

The world turns around us. you can choose not to turn with it, but it turns all the same.