News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by delichon on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:31AM (#46527516)
This meme is very healthy among MAHA, and Secretary Kennedy is overseeing an overhaul of the Dietary Guidelines, recasting saturated fat as a health food. There is a lot of speculation that we will soon see a new food pyramid that is an inverted version of the last one.

https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2025/10/08/nx...

I wonder if it will keep flipping as administrations change.

Edit: The new guidelines are expected to be released today.

https://www.wfla.com/news/national/kennedy-wants-to-end-war-...

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by alphazard on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:43AM (#46527665)
> There is a lot of speculation that we will soon see a new food pyramid that is inverted.

Pretty much everyone I know understands that the food pyramid is the product of various lobbies coming together and does not represent a legitimate theory of diet or nutrition. That is independent of their politics or opinions about RFK.

I don't think a change to the food pyramid would change anyone's actions, people haven't taken it seriously for decades.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by mullingitover on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:53AM (#46527809)
The food pyramid went away over twenty years ago. It was discontinued in 2005, and the current guidelines are at https://www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/myplate which launched in 2011.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by ecshafer on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:35AM (#46528492)
Even the myplate doesn't seem right. There's probably too much fruit and too much dairy. There isn't any indication of legumes. Vegetables is too vague. There is no indication of fats, which are part of everything else.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:05AM (#46527996)
Which are crafted by individuals with strong financial ties to the meat, dairy, or egg industries, thus should be disregarded by any reasonable person.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by stevenwoo on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:17AM (#46528172)
Yes, but I have distinct memories of these nutrition facts being taught to us in school for years, and our teachers asking us to report back how well we conformed to this supposed ideal diet as homework prior to any possible expectation that we children could be informed consumers.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:09AM (#46528058)
Then I would think the meat, dairy, and egg industry didn't get their money's worth. The My Plate guidelines have protein as less than 25% of the plate, and nothing says it has to be animal based.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:21AM (#46528236)
The Court has actually ruled that the USDA violated federal law by hiding conflicts of interest in the Dietary Guidelines.

It is beyond insane that these are the official guidelines on what Americans should eat. Why would anyone defend them?

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:23AM (#46528260)
What do you find disagreeable about the My Plate that was linked?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:29AM (#46528392)
I just told you: it's made by food industry interests and is ultimately divorced from actual nutrition science.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:26PM (#46529297)
And I'm asking what would be different if you had to make a basic graphic based on nutritional science vs the My Plate graphic.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by flatline on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:16PM (#46531110)
Dairy is completely unnecessary, for one. Its prominence on the plate makes everything else immediately suspect. There are probably some axes along which a glass of milk or cup of (unsweetened) yogurt is one reasonable option but that's not what is being promoted here.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:55PM (#46531650)
I see it as more of a limit than a requirement. After all, you can technically satisfy your dietary needs with vegetables and eliminate fruits. But we aren't talking about technicalities and edge cases, rather what a balanced diet might consist of. For many people that does include dairy and fruits, even if neither are completely necessary.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by flatline on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @04:34PM (#46533252)
I would gently suggest that you may be blinded by a cultural bias here, which has partly been formed by the dairy lobby over the course of every living American’s lifetime. While it is true that we are not the only culture that drinks cow’s milk, it is predominantly a Northern European and later American phenomenon, and the number of people who are intolerant to dairy on some level is very high. I’m not saying a balanced diet cannot consist of dairy, but implying it should, as the plate diagram does, is highly misleading and outright paid for.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:49PM (#46534333)
"I’m not saying a balanced diet cannot consist of dairy, but implying it should, as the plate diagram does, is highly misleading and outright paid for."

And to exclude it would imply that it cannot be part of a balanced diet. That would be misleading based on the predominate culture.

"I would gently suggest that you may be blinded by a cultural bias here,"

I would suggest that you are not aware of the cultural background. The US was colonized by Europeans. Many cultures who immigrated also used milk, cheese, or other dairy products. It makes sense that the guidelines be based on the cultural background of the foods eaten in that country.

Also many Asian countries have nutrition guidelines that include dairy products, not to mention historical cultural foods that do include dairy.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by mapotofu on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:55PM (#46530799)
I wouldn’t reduce food to some stupid equational graphic. Instead I would work to try to regain trust by cracking the whip on these companies for once, whether it’s their prices, the quality of their products, their advertising, or all of the above. Our diets deserve more respect and that’s the reason RFK has an audience. He’s speaking to people who believe that. There can be better leaders than him, but at least he’s doing something!
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by dontlikeyoueith on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:06PM (#46559325)
How about critiquing the actual recommendation instead of the people?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by knowitnone3 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:04PM (#46529996)
I find Diary to be completely unnecessary and was paid for by the diary industry.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by platevoltage on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:31PM (#46534088)
Absolutely. The human body was not meant to process the milk of other animals.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bagels on Thursday January 08, 2026 @01:12AM (#46537778)
What was it meant to process? Why have some of us evolved tolerance for lactose?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:16AM (#46541985)
Fruits, roots and vegetables. A tolerance for lactose is not an indication of optimal human food.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by platevoltage on Thursday January 08, 2026 @02:47PM (#46545540)
I mean, some animals have evolved to thrive in post Chernobyl disaster Pripyat. No other animal consumes the milk of another species of animal.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by panja on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:17AM (#46528183)
Going through that link, it's hard to see where you came to that conclusion? It seems to have pretty reasonable dietary advice.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:38AM (#46528523)
The food pyramid also seemed like pretty reasonable dietary advice until it wasn't. The skepticism expressed by other posters about where the guidelines originated from is well founded.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:33AM (#46528451)
There is literally a consumption group for "dairy" which tells people to eat the food of another mammal's baby. This is the opposite of "reasonable" - it is actual government propaganda to support lobbied industry.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by miltonlost on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:45AM (#46528660)
> tells people to eat the food of another mammal's baby. This is the opposite of "reasonable" - it is actual government propaganda to support lobbied industry.

Oh, I was wondering where the part of your screed was gonna come out as crazy. Human consumption of dairy is thousands of years old.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by DetectDefect on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:09PM (#46529053)
Many (most?) human behaviors are thousands of years old, it does not make them reasonable. Also, refrain from hurling insults; just do not respond if you cannot materially substantiate your argument.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by wgjordan on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:00PM (#46528900)
Please follow the HN guidelines [1]:

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by resoluteteeth on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:36PM (#46530522)
> Which are crafted by individuals with strong financial ties to the meat, dairy, or egg industries, thus should be disregarded by any reasonable person.

The RFK jr version of the food pyramid now moves meat and dairy to the biggest section of the pyramid

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by CrimsonRain on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:26AM (#46539046)
It is only unreasonable to mentally ill vegans and the likes.

Full disclosure: I'm not affiliated with any meat/dairy/egg industry.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by nsxwolf on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:42AM (#46528599)
I just see one lobby, "Big Macronutrient". We all need to eat. I'll be worried when some company tries to make me eat actual plastic.

We know far less about any of this than we pretend to.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by js2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:55AM (#46528825)
> eat actual plastic.

Foreseeing such Crimes of the Future, David Cronenberg has already made that one into a movie.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lithocarpus on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:11PM (#46533822)
I mean I've seen "low calorie bread" that was basically industrial bread cut with cellulose which is analogous to very fine sawdust.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by aziaziazi on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:04AM (#46539649)
Cellulose is one of the main constituant of plants and as a fiber, great for your gut:

> In human nutrition, cellulose is a non-digestible constituent of insoluble dietary fiber, acting as a hydrophilic bulking agent for feces and potentially aiding in defecation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellulose

Workshop sawdust would be a bad idea though.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lithocarpus on Saturday January 17, 2026 @02:39PM (#46661307)
I'm dubious about the idea that the cellulose additive is no different than eating plants. The forms that are used in food are refined / modified, i.e. not the same thing that I eat when I eat plants. I know a few people who react very badly to this added cellulose but don't have issues eating plants.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by SoftTalker on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:54PM (#46529806)
But prior to that it was pushed very hard in elementary schools. I remember performing in a school play that was all about the food pyramid and nutrition, in lockstep with the government propaganda at the time.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by giantg2 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:05AM (#46528005)
"Pretty much everyone I know understands that the food pyramid is the product of various lobbies"

Maybe adults, but probably not the people who were taught the food pyramid - children.

Edit: changed the tense to acknowledge this was in the past. Thought that was obvious since the food pyramid was a thing of the past.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by NiloCK on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:11AM (#46528086)
Nit: Children haven't been taught the food pyramid in something like a couple of decades I think. Current model is something like the DailyPlate visual - a plate filled proportionally with various things.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by alphazard on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:13AM (#46528121)
Definitely agree with the concern here, but this is not a problem unique to the food pyramid. Children will be taught all kinds of propaganda if they attend a public school. It's part of the cost, just not the part that is taken from tax dollars.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by napkinartist on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:12AM (#46528095)
Who is being taught the food pyramid? Its been 20 years since it was discontinued. I don't know any children being taught it.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by shermantanktop on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:45AM (#46528659)
I've seen this over and over - adults assuming that what happens in schools today is the same their childhood experience in the classroom, frozen in time.

Parents of school-age children ranting and raving about how the school needs to stop doing X, when it hasn't been that way forever; and they cannot hear it, cannot absorb it, cannot stop talking about it. Something something childhood trauma.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by smileysteve on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:28AM (#46528348)
Anecdotally, only the "health focused" people around me understand that the food pyramid was for a different time and based on other interests.

And I don't think adults on a grand scale question it, or process nutrition labels.

Boomers in particular (who engrained Gen x and millennial diets) are most likely to follow grains (and margarine) diets.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by _heimdall on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:54AM (#46527830)
Don't public school lunches have to follow the food guide recommendations? Assuming that hasn't changed since I was in school, a recommendation based on something other than industry lobbying could help quite a bit with children's health and long term outlooks.

That said, I obviously don't know what this administration would propose as a new recommendation so I'm not implying it will be better. We'd have to see what they put out, if anything, to get an idea about that.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostphilosopher on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:04AM (#46527985)
Food pyramid was taught when I was in school, but that was before 2011 (as mentioned by another commenter) my own children are in school now and their school lunches align with more modern ideas (veggies and proteins). Certainly could still be improved but I recognize the cost, scale, delivery constraints, plus allergy considerations makes this non-trivial.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by _heimdall on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:41PM (#46532337)
Same, I was just assuming the MyPlate recommendations were similarly expected for public schools to follow.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:40AM (#46528558)
When people say that SNAP (food stamps) should "only be able to buy healthy foods", they have to be reminded what the government considers to be healthy and just importantly, what the government considers to be unhealthy. Since SNAP is a government program, it almost certainly would use government guidelines on what is healthy.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by _heimdall on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:43PM (#46532389)
I often hear that argument raised in response to the idea of SNAP covering things like sugary drinks and foods. I'm not sure how SNAP could follow guidelines and also pay for sugary drinks or candy (if those claims are accurate).
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by julkali on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:53AM (#46527806)
Source?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by harrall on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:43PM (#46529589)
I think the real problem is that a food pyramid is an oversimplification.

No matter what you do, “fruits” isn’t really a goal — it’s macronutrients and micronutrients like vitamins, fiber, etc.

So with or without lobbying, any food pyramid will always be wrong. A food pyramid exists because it is far more relatable than comparing nutrient labels and tabulating.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by GuB-42 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:57PM (#46529847)
I consider the traditional food pyramid, with grain at the base, to make a lot of economic sense.

The question is not "what's best for you", but "how to keep as many people as possible well fed and reasonably healthy". And an important part of it is that everyone gets enough calories, even the poor, and even during hard times.

Grain is an efficient source of calories, and grain products tend to have a good shelf life and don't need refrigeration. And ideal baseline for keeping people from starving.

But grain is good for calories, but not enough to keep people healthy, you also need vitamins, fiber, etc... So you introduce the second food group: fruits and vegetables. A bit more expensive and more involved than grain, but it provides most of the things grain don't.

Now, we are at a vegan diet, and experience has shown that it can be perfectly healthy, but in order for it to be, you need to do a significant amount of bookkeeping, and you may need some slightly exotic food to avoid deficiencies. So, not enough for the general population, so you introduce animal products. Even more expensive, but now you have everything you need, with good margins.

The top of the pyramid is for the products for which the needs are covered more efficiently by the lower layers.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by aziaziazi on Thursday January 08, 2026 @08:35AM (#46540785)
> a significant amount of bookkeeping [...] for the general population

True, but not really more or less than a diet including animal products: in both cases they'll be good by varying the sources of macronutrients. In fact most long-term, healthy vegans don't bother bookkeeping what they eat. Some athletes and weight-loss seeker does but it's not particular to plant-based diet.

Vegan bookeeping is a common fallacy. A while ago I had an odd conversation with a doctor that went like that:

- It's complicated, you'll need to count everything ! - Is it different with animal products ? - Oh yes no count I advise 1-2 serve of red meat every 2 weeks, 2-4 serve of fish per week, 1 serve of seafood once in a while 2 serves of chicken per week, adjusted if you workout. Also 2 diary product per day but avoid salty cheeses too often or in large quantity. - I count 1 pill of b12 per day.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bluGill on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:54AM (#46527820)
And most likely we will move too far in that direction in the near future. Too many people have their identity, religion, reputation, or paycheck invested in something about how they eat and so are unwilling to take an objective look at things. Instead they find studies that seem to fit their narrative and amplify them. They often will setup their experiments and data to get the results they want. And then we get into the reproducibility problem that science publications often have.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:49AM (#46527757)
If you do the opposite of whatever Kennedy recommends, you probably wouldn’t be too far off doing the right thing.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by al_borland on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:19PM (#46529201)
Eating nothing but processed foods, sugar, and heavily processed grains? That sounds like the opposite of what Kennedy recommends, which is a recipe for obesity and type 2 diabetes.

He’s got his problems, many of them, but eating real food without a bunch of processing seems like a fairly common sense thing.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by snemvalts on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:37PM (#46532276)
Red meat (a known carcinogen) at the top is gold. All that saturated fat the energy will come from (not from protein or veggies) will probably cause heart problems and plaque formation in arteries, not to mention insulin resistance just from increased FFAs in blood.

Vegetarians and vegans have lower T2D incidence on average FWIW.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by al_borland on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:36PM (#46534147)
> Vegetarians and vegans have lower T2D incidence on average FWIW.

Anecdotally, my dad tried vegetarianism for quite a while to address his T2D, but it had no effect. My mom cut out sugar and processed carbohydrates and her T2D was gone in ~3 months or so.

Following any diet is probably better than nothing at all, which could explain the lower incidence of T2D in that group vs the general public. I’d be more curious about the rates in vegetarians/vegans vs people who eat paleo or even carnivore.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by thinkcontext on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @07:15PM (#46535232)
> Anecdotally

Then it is of no interest

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by al_borland on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @09:55PM (#46536617)
There are studies that support it. Here is a meta analysis of low carb diets on T2D, the majority show it works, though as always, there is going to be some individual variability.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13098-025-01890-7

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by snemvalts on Thursday January 08, 2026 @05:54AM (#46539588)
Treating T2D and preventing T2D are completely different things from a dietary perspective. Same way you wouldn't give chemotherapy to a healthy person to prevent cancer
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by aldarion on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:55AM (#46542468)
Because they don't eat processed foods.

Also, red meat isn't a known carcinogen. Processed meat is. And plaque formation in arteries is a consequence of inflammation... which is caused by sugar, a.k.a. carbohydrates. Insulin resistance is also a consequence of increased carbohydrate consumption.

But as I said, it is a combination of fats and carbs that is the worst killed. Eliminating either one of those from the diet leads to an automatic improvement.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:25PM (#46530343)
Is this with or without the increase in saturated fat he recommends? Or more red meat?

Health policy decisions would ideally be based on some sort of evidence, not the quackery he spouts.

Yes, some of his changes are an improvement. Most aren’t.

https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/5675784-kennedy-satura... https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/rfk-jr-upsets-foo...

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by stuffn on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:06PM (#46530967)
The most common argument coming from people like you is X is bad because a lack of evidence, and then you present Y as an absolute truth with zero evidence. This time you've linked two garbage websites, both controlled by special interests. You've also fallen into the common trope of discrediting someone's entire view because of another view (so-called "quackery"). Your opinion is relatively consistent with the reddit/HN zeitgeist. That is to say, you are wrong.

Since you present no actual evidence. I won't either. Instead I'll tell you what is coming out as the truth:

1. Carbohydrates and especially sugars contribute more to various disease processes, including CVD, hyperlipidemia, etc than fat or meat consumption. A trivial google search, which you are clearly capable of doing, would show you that.

2. Eggs are loaded with cholesterol and saturated fat. Egg guidelines have been moved almost as often as salt and sugar. Most doctors will not stop you from eating 2-3 eggs a day because the benefits far outweigh the risks.

3. A balanced diet is better than one that isn't. But if you have no choice meat and fat have the highest level of satiation-to-energy of any kind of food.

4. High levels of exercise in combination with a diet higher in foods that have high levels of nutrition (meat, eggs, butter, and green leafy vegetables) will produce less negative health effects than following the government's health guidelines on either exercise or nutrition.

5. The existence of cultures that subsist entirely on meat and fat invalidates your argument. The eskimos, in particular, have comparable life spans and yet hyperlipidemia is extremely common among them. CVD is not. One factor could be the energy consumption due to exercise and extreme cold. The fact obesity, heart disease, cancer, etc risks all rose with the proliferation of highly processed carbohydrate and the "fat-free" trend is further evidence that something is wrong.

6. It is hard to believe anything the government says on nutrition is valid. Back when people watched the news we heard coffee is bad/coffee is good, salt is bad/salt is good, fat is bad/fat is good, meat is bad/meat is good. You should ask yourself seriously if you're getting your information from valid sources or if you just believe whatever the youtube you watch says.

It is possible to overdo nearly anything. Saturated fat guidelines, along with cholesterol guidelines, are likely too low even for conservative values. That being said, the amount of processed carbohydrate you should eat daily should approach 0 and you should consider it to be more of a snack if you eat it at all.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:21PM (#46532001)
> Since you present no actual evidence.

It’s his food pyramid and his departments advice.

https://cdn.realfood.gov/DGA.pdf

As for him being a quack, that’s earned through his refusal to follow scientific guidance, and sacking the guidance available. You’re presumably aware of his views on fluoride and vaccines.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by CrimsonRain on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:32AM (#46539095)
What's wrong with not wanting flouride in my food and drink?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by ericmcer on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:03PM (#46528952)
It's a "meme" that sugar is worse for you than fat?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by delichon on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:16PM (#46529170)

  meme, noun. Any unit of cultural information, such as a practice or idea, that is transmitted verbally or by repeated action from one mind to another -- Wordnik
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by 1121redblackgo on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:53PM (#46530776)
Yes and also a true meme.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by biophysboy on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:43AM (#46527668)
What annoys me the most is that sat fat is a huge way that sugary products are made more palatable to people. People love butter. It is every chef's 2nd favorite tool, just after salt.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bluGill on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:12AM (#46528096)
Butter is only a favorite because Lard has been some demonized that no chef would ever use it anymore.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by biophysboy on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:29AM (#46528377)
Chefs use animal fats all the time. They think about cooking temperature, flavor, etc to make decisions.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by gilrain on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:31AM (#46528420)
That, and the only readily available form of lard stinks of rancid hog.

Approximately nobody has access to high quality leaf lard like the food blogs champion.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bregma on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:40AM (#46528554)
Ever spread lard on toast? Do you prefer croissants made with lard? Is everyone's favourite dish these days lard chicken (I mean the Indian dish, not the Soul Food dish, which is of course popular in some locales).

Nope. Butter is favoured because it tastes unctuous. Nothing to do with Big Cow or any special interest lobby local to certain valleys in the USA. Except maybe Big Bacon Drippings, because if there's one thing better for a grill cheese than butter it's bacon grease (thick-sliced sourdough bread, sharp Cheddar cheese, a shmear of chili crisp)

Now, suet has been demonized to the point that nobody makes suet pudding any more. A shame, really.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by aziaziazi on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @11:55AM (#46528829)
> Butter is favoured because it tastes unctuous

Oily stuff tastes unctuous.

Butter is favored because most people had it in their youth. Some regions loves Nato and Chicken feet, others cheese and oysters. What's the most delicious? It depends of your own history.

I spread olive oil on my toast and prefer the croissants made with that as well. My favorite dish is fried tempeh.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by ericmcer on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:31PM (#46529368)
Wouldn't the preferred fat of a culture be spread between countries as they interacted then? Instead it has been fairly one directional with butter being adopted globally but other fats remaining niche (except Olive oil). Is that because of imperialism or is it because it is the best tasting one?
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by antiframe on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:58PM (#46529855)
Today, I am one of the Ten Thousand [1] that learned you can make croissants with olive oil. Thank you for that! I've always assumed the laminated dough required solid fats, but apparently any layering of fat and flour can make flaky goodness. I am guessing that liquid fats are probably harder to work with, and croissants are already tricky enough to get right: but I must try.

[1]: https://xkcd.com/1053/

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by D-Machine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:24PM (#46532045)
Yes, lamination can be done with almost any fat, but the more you laminate (more layers / folds), the more that liquid fats sort of absorb into the dough, and stop having the desired separating effect. So while oil layering works well for e.g. paratha-style roti, scallion pancakes, and things that only really get one or two "layers" or "folds", oil is just fine. But when you get to something like a croissant, or even just a rough puff pastry (e.g. https://www.seriouseats.com/old-fashioned-flaky-pie-dough-re...), liquid fats are usually a complete non-starter.

You might be able to achieve something if you can somehow freeze your olive oil and chill your dough, and work very quickly during lamination, but you should, even with a lot of work and tweaking, still expect to get a noticeably inferior product for something like croissants.

Depending on how picky you are/not, you might still be personally happy with the texture and taste, but don't expect to get even remotely close to an actual good butter croissant, by more objective standards. Here in Canada we had a minor problem with the butter texture due to what we feed our cows here ("buttergate"), and this was preventing professional bakers from achieving quality croissants with just the Canadian butter. This should make you highly skeptical that you can get anything good with something as different as olive oil.

Still, I do love the idea of an olive oil croissant, it would be delicious.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by antiframe on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @09:01PM (#46536183)
Okay, so as expected liquid fats are much harder to work with and lead to an inferior flake. But, I assumed it was nigh impossible to do. If I can get 20% of the way there with olive oil I would be at least willing to try.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by D-Machine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:31PM (#46536870)
You can definitely get to 20% without much trouble, maybe even 30-50%, if you do some freezing tricks. Though what such percentages mean is highly subjective.

I am thinking if an ideal butter croissant has some flaky fluffiness (perhaps if we define it as "trapped volume" between flakes), and we define this ideal flakiness to be 100%, then you can extremely easily get to 20% with just olive oil. Frankly I think you might even get close to 50% (defined in this way) provided you also start with a trustworthy recipe by mass and that aims for proper hydration (e.g. https://www.seriouseats.com/croissants-recipe-11863500) and work quickly with lots of chilling.

Just, subjectively, you might realize that 20-50%, defined this way, isn't much like a proper French croissant, and is more like a cheap doughy supermarket chain croissant—which I do still frankly enjoy sometimes anyway!

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by D-Machine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:33PM (#46532187)
Butter is NOT favored because most people had it in their youth, but because of its extremely distinct flavour.

"Unctuous" is certainly not specific enough, the reason butter (and ghee) is so delicious is its butteriness, i.e. it has a highly distinct taste. All properly rendered animal fats have highly distinct tastes and serve different purposes. Schmaltz tastes slightly of chicken, duck fat of duck, lard of pork, and tallow of beef.

But butter does NOT distinctly taste of beef, rather, it is reminiscent of slightly-aged milk (or, in the case of ghee, it may even strongly smell like certain kinds of aged cheese). There is, also, in butter, significant absorbed water content, and, to my palate, even a very subtle acidity that is not quite present in other rendered animal fats that give it a sort of brightness that make it work in things like butter-creams and other delicate or mild flavours (e.g. popcorn).

It is IMO this specifically "non-meaty" unctuousness that is the real draw of butter. Not some childhood nostalgia.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bluGill on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:39PM (#46529515)
I didn't say lard is always better. Different cooking styles demand different things.

Though my grandpa used lard on his bread in the great depression because they couldn't afford butter.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by yoz-y on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:16PM (#46533900)
As a kid I had both lard and butter on bread. Bras with lard and onions is amazing. But also that’s roughly the only combination of that works. Butter is way more versatile.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by bregma on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:32AM (#46542191)
Perhaps this is a different usage of the word "bra" than I am used to but it sounds uncomfortable.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by yoz-y on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:41PM (#46546897)
Haha. I’ll blame the iOS keyboard on this one.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by astura on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:43PM (#46529597)
Excuse me? The trendiest of restaurants around me advertise that they have beef fat fried fries/potatoes.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by api on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:51AM (#46527785)
I don't think they're totally wrong, but they will probably overcorrect. Saturated fat is healthy in moderation. Carbs are also fine in moderation, and carbs in particular come in high and low quality forms.

What's too bad is that these things come in package deals. If you want to question the old outdated and probably corrupted orthodoxy around the food pyramid, you also have to open the door to antivax idiots and quack influencers who think Measles is actually good for you and other nonsense.