News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:25PM (#46530343)
Is this with or without the increase in saturated fat he recommends? Or more red meat?

Health policy decisions would ideally be based on some sort of evidence, not the quackery he spouts.

Yes, some of his changes are an improvement. Most aren’t.

https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/5675784-kennedy-satura... https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/rfk-jr-upsets-foo...

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by stuffn on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:06PM (#46530967)
The most common argument coming from people like you is X is bad because a lack of evidence, and then you present Y as an absolute truth with zero evidence. This time you've linked two garbage websites, both controlled by special interests. You've also fallen into the common trope of discrediting someone's entire view because of another view (so-called "quackery"). Your opinion is relatively consistent with the reddit/HN zeitgeist. That is to say, you are wrong.

Since you present no actual evidence. I won't either. Instead I'll tell you what is coming out as the truth:

1. Carbohydrates and especially sugars contribute more to various disease processes, including CVD, hyperlipidemia, etc than fat or meat consumption. A trivial google search, which you are clearly capable of doing, would show you that.

2. Eggs are loaded with cholesterol and saturated fat. Egg guidelines have been moved almost as often as salt and sugar. Most doctors will not stop you from eating 2-3 eggs a day because the benefits far outweigh the risks.

3. A balanced diet is better than one that isn't. But if you have no choice meat and fat have the highest level of satiation-to-energy of any kind of food.

4. High levels of exercise in combination with a diet higher in foods that have high levels of nutrition (meat, eggs, butter, and green leafy vegetables) will produce less negative health effects than following the government's health guidelines on either exercise or nutrition.

5. The existence of cultures that subsist entirely on meat and fat invalidates your argument. The eskimos, in particular, have comparable life spans and yet hyperlipidemia is extremely common among them. CVD is not. One factor could be the energy consumption due to exercise and extreme cold. The fact obesity, heart disease, cancer, etc risks all rose with the proliferation of highly processed carbohydrate and the "fat-free" trend is further evidence that something is wrong.

6. It is hard to believe anything the government says on nutrition is valid. Back when people watched the news we heard coffee is bad/coffee is good, salt is bad/salt is good, fat is bad/fat is good, meat is bad/meat is good. You should ask yourself seriously if you're getting your information from valid sources or if you just believe whatever the youtube you watch says.

It is possible to overdo nearly anything. Saturated fat guidelines, along with cholesterol guidelines, are likely too low even for conservative values. That being said, the amount of processed carbohydrate you should eat daily should approach 0 and you should consider it to be more of a snack if you eat it at all.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:21PM (#46532001)
> Since you present no actual evidence.

It’s his food pyramid and his departments advice.

https://cdn.realfood.gov/DGA.pdf

As for him being a quack, that’s earned through his refusal to follow scientific guidance, and sacking the guidance available. You’re presumably aware of his views on fluoride and vaccines.

Re:Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for ... by CrimsonRain on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:32AM (#46539095)
What's wrong with not wanting flouride in my food and drink?