News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by rdtsc on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:00AM (#46309675)
> Dr Escalera adds that she has also heard examples of companies posting jobs to obtain and sell data.

How is that not illegal? Pretending to offer jobs just to suck in resumes to some database just seems like it should be illegal. Or just like running scams is illegal but they are in another country "so tough luck, you'll never get us"?

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by josefrichter on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:25AM (#46309846)
I believe it actually is illegal, via a set of more general rules on data collection, on what constitutes a fraud, etc. May not be spelled out exactly like this specific use case, but still very likely covered by law. Just difficult to prove.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by randycupertino on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:05AM (#46310061)
I saw this post on reddit where some sketchy AI company (Alpheva AI) is posting jobs and requesting a screenshot of all applicants having left their app a 5-star review in the app store as part of the application process:

https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1pp0iej/thi...

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by cons0le on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:01AM (#46311642)
This is another thing were it clearly is illegal, but good luck actually trying to sue or get them to stop it. Worst case scenario they'll set up another cheap company on paper, and keep doing the same scam
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Xylakant on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:36AM (#46309909)
It certainly would be illegal in Europe under the GDPR - data collected for one purpose (handling of applications) cannot be used for another without explicit, informed consent.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by pydry on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:52AM (#46310348)
Im sure it isnt that hard to get candidates to tick another check box that says the data can be used for other stuff.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Xylakant on Thursday December 18, 2025 @04:14AM (#46310489)
The box would need to be off by default and clearly state the purpose. It would at least be possible to verify it exists and no example has been shown.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by cluckindan on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:36AM (#46311912)
”We and our 972 partners…”
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Y_Y on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:18AM (#46312256)
Corporations are people, and very promiscuous ones at that.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by reeredfdfdf on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:10AM (#46314519)
It may be illegal, but shady stuff certainly happens in EU too.

Recently investigative journalists here in Finland found out that a significant percentage of job postings over here are indeed fake. Unsurprisingly, worst offenders were recruitment companies, which sometimes listed fake jobs to generate a pool of applicants they can later offer to their clients. Doing this is easy, as no law requires these companies to disclose who their clients are when creating job postings. It's also very common for same position to get posted multiple times.

Other than wasting applicant's time, this behavior also messes up many statistics, which use job postings to determine how many open positions there are available. Basically the chances of finding a job are even worse for unemployed people than stats would imply.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Xylakant on Thursday December 18, 2025 @01:25PM (#46316514)
Oh, I agree that illegal stuff happens in the EU aplenty. The question was whether this is illegal and it almost certainly is. Job postings from recruiters - while morally reprehensible - may just skirt the law, but straight up using applications for profile building, marketing and other purposes almost certainly isn’t permitted
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by khelavastr on Thursday December 18, 2025 @04:39AM (#46310647)
Don't ignore free speech of job search applicants .!
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by terminalshort on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:35AM (#46309895)
It's technically fraud, but there aren't any damages.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by YmiYugy on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:32AM (#46310221)
This seems analogous to the following. A company asks users to fill out an online survey in exchange for participation in some raffle, except the company never pays out any prize. As with the job application there was never a guaranteed reward, but it's still easy to see the damage. The company induced to you to provide them with an economically valuable asset (filled out survey/application) for which you expected a fair chance at a reward. It seems plausible that you could claim damages at least up to the expected value.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Dayshine on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:34AM (#46311900)
Except a job offer is generally non binding, so they could interview you, offer the job, then withdraw it.

So never being offered a job because it doesn't exist doesn't lose you anything.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by jagoff on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:18AM (#46312269)
Spotted the HR worker posting ghost jobs
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by amypetrik8 on Friday December 19, 2025 @04:15PM (#46331014)
>So never being offered a job because it doesn't exist doesn't lose you anything.

Ah well look, if the job posting was just to collect resumes with zero intention to actually hire, you did lose some things:

- actual time spent applying to a job that was never open - emotional damage on focus to try to get this job - loss of free market value of your data (company profited from this data, when you could have profited from it) - damages for acquisition of your personal data under a fraudulent basis (when otherwise, maybe you did not want your data shared)

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by darreninthenet on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:22AM (#46310164)
In the UK at least Fraud doesn't require any damages, just an intent to gain something of value on the criminals side.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by moralestapia on Thursday December 18, 2025 @04:06AM (#46310440)
Your time might be worthless but mine isn't.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by terminalshort on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:46AM (#46311533)
Yeah, you go ahead and sue someone for the few minutes of your time it took to send in a application for a fake job. Then you'll really see what wasting time looks like.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by danaris on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:05AM (#46312150)
But this is part of the problem with crimes and enforcement in the modern age: sure, I might have only wasted a few minutes of my time. But I'm just one of hundreds or thousands of people who were tricked into wasting that time, by this one act.

Multiply this across all the fraudulent job postings, and it really starts to add up.

It's clear (to me, at least) that we need better laws to handle this sort of wide-but-shallow attack on people. It's analogous to spam.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by moralestapia on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:34AM (#46312433)
I recently learned of [1], which is a good example of "too small for me to sue" but still worth going through it collectively.

1: https://www.canadianbreadsettlement.ca/

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by palmotea on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:43AM (#46312524)
> Yeah, you go ahead and sue someone for the few minutes of your time it took to send in a application for a fake job. Then you'll really see what wasting time looks like.

1. That is exactly what class actions are for, because small damages multiplied by many people are big damages.

2. That's also why we need punitive damages, so someone can't get away with unlawful actions by deliberately coasting along under the threshold where it makes sense to sue. For instance, IIRC, you can collect something like $5000 from someone who doesn't put you on their "do not call list" when requested. That amount has nothing to do with the value of the "few minutes of your time it took to" answer a telemarketing call.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#46313726)
You are missing a point. The only thing it really does is force people to pursue other forms as online channel is too polluted for anyone with sense/options/skill ( or all of the above ). So it leaves desperate, optionless, those without skills and everyone else who fell through the cracks. Another system undermined for no clear benefit. It does not benefit the employer. It does not benefit the employee. It does benefit some data brokers.. and only then for a bit until the rest of the market catches up..

But was it worth it?

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by the_real_cher on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:24AM (#46309832)
Its straight up wire fraud.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by lovich on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:23AM (#46309824)
Because some animals are more equal than others and the government has decided that companies are not only citizens but the more equal group.

Half the shit companies do that gets them a fine would land any individual in jail for committing the same action, but we let them get away with just paying it off. Simultaneously we give those organizations the same rights.

It’s a system with three classes of citizen where the rich and corporations have a better right to responsibility ratio and the average human has a much worse ratio

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by VerifiedReports on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:30AM (#46309872)
Citizens United, a monumental betrayal of every citizen.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Y_Y on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:22AM (#46312322)
> The provisions of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 restricting unions, corporations, and profitable organizations from independent political spending and prohibiting the broadcasting of political media funded by them within sixty days of general elections or thirty days of primary elections violate the freedom of speech that is protected by the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. United States District Court for the District of Columbia reversed.

I'm sure we're on the same side, but I want to point out that that case didn't make a huge difference. By that I mean it removed a ban on political broadcasts near elections, most of the "money is speech, super pacs can do anything at all" stuff was already legal.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by red-iron-pine on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:46AM (#46313241)
> it removed a ban on political broadcasts near elections,

Propaganda works, and this was a BIG change, as it now let unlimited shady corpo money spam agit-prop with no consequence.

this was step 1 on living in a post-truth world.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by BobaFloutist on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:34PM (#46320333)
Right, but if you try to make a gentle, common-sense, broad consensus law and the Supreme Court squashes it as violating the constitution, that also prevents any potential future more stringent regulation.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by danaris on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:16AM (#46313583)
While this is true, the first such betrayal came in 1976, with Buckley v Valeo.

This was (AIUI) the US Supreme Court decision that established the precedent that money counts as protected speech.

So much of the rot that has occurred since then can be traced back to this.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by dredmorbius on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:13AM (#46314570)
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by lovich on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:11AM (#46310099)
To add onto this, the single exception I am aware of to this rule is the result of the gas explosions in Massachusetts.

In that case the company in charge, Columbia Gas, "exited" the market but all the scuttlebutt I heard in the area was that the Mass government was threatening the corporate execution of revoking their charter, which lead to Columbia gas selling their business off at a loss to Eversource

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NiSource#Massachusetts_gas_lin...

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by xhkkffbf on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:17AM (#46314638)
You do realize that the decisions at the corporations are made by people. You may try to draw a distinction between people and corporations, but in the end it was some person who decided to ghost someone.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by lovich on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:22PM (#46320767)
You do realize that the people making those decisions at corporations are largely shielded from the liability of said decisions, and that when companies are treated like citizens they almost never get equivalent punishment like human beings do.

I can draw a distinction between people and corporations because it’s literally encoded in the fucking law.

I actually don’t know how or why you would imply that such a distinction doesn’t exist.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by pjc50 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @05:23AM (#46310943)
America has no data protection law, apart from some hyper-specific ones: healthcare, video rental records. That makes all of this data sharing completely legal. As well as that, it is widely agreed there that lying is free speech.

It is not wire fraud because you do not pay to apply. (In general; places that charge applicants are even more scammy.)

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by pjc50 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @05:40AM (#46311067)
Exactly - no national, general data protection law. Although the California one looks pretty similar to the GDPR from the summary, it's not truly national.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by renegade-otter on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:31AM (#46311433)
Even if there was, under the current regime, the probability of it being enforced is near-zero, especially if you are in the good graces of the child king.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by _heimdall on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:44AM (#46311970)
The problem of enforcement doesn't fall only on the executive branch. They're tasked with executing laws passed by congress. Congress is ultimately a check on the executive, and if they care to have their laws enforced they do have actions they could take.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by pjc50 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:21AM (#46313002)
The branches (including SCOTUS) are not meaningfully different when they are controlled by the same party.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by _heimdall on Thursday December 18, 2025 @01:18PM (#46316403)
That's a very pessimistic view. That boils our system of three branches of government to a purely partisan game of capture the flag in which we all lose if one team captures all three at one.

SCOTUS is a bit different as it both isn't driven by political parties and justices have a history of more frequently breaking with the party they are seen as aligned with.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by ben_w on Friday December 19, 2025 @09:16AM (#46326090)
2024 has not been a year for optimism about the American system of checks and balances functioning as advertised.

Even more broadly, there's an old quote:

  There are four boxes to be used in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, and cartridge (or ammo). Please use in that order.
The soap box is under threat: https://reason.com/2025/12/18/this-tennessee-man-spent-37-da... and https://www.npr.org/2025/04/08/nx-s1-5349472/students-protes...

The ballot box is under threat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_backsliding_in_the_...

Judiciary is under threat: https://www.gov.harvard.edu/2025/07/24/the-u-s-judicial-cris... and https://judicature.duke.edu/articles/judicial-independence-t...

That just (to much the same horror and sense of unreality I had watching the 9/11 attacks unfold) leaves the ammo box.

Now, I'm British by birth, a country where even the police are not routinely armed, so the American view that weapons are a "fundamental right" is utterly alien to me, and this difference is one of the reasons why I never seriously considered moving to Silicon Valley at any point in my career.

Trump seems pro 2nd Amendment: is that because he is afraid and needs them to like him, or because isn't afraid as he has an army and a secret service to keep him safe, or does he just plain like guns and hasn't even thought about personal risk despite getting shot at?

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by _heimdall on Friday December 19, 2025 @03:14PM (#46330348)
Well no disagreement there, unfortunately.

I definitely agree our democracy seems to be under attack on multiple fronts, and at least the people I'm often around regardless of political affiliation seem to have lost sight of how our system is intended to work.

A violent civil war wouldn't surprise me, though I don't think we're close to it yet and I hope I never see it happen. Though I would prefer seeing that rather than seeing our system successfully destroyed and replaced with what seems to be coming up, an authoritarian socialism of one form or another.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by expedition32 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:43AM (#46313201)
Congres is a rabbit caught in the headlights of the MAGA cult but I admire your optimism.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by _heimdall on Thursday December 18, 2025 @01:19PM (#46316425)
Hah, oh it isn't optimism. I don't think congress will do anything about enforcement but that is nothing new.

My point was simply that we can't only blame the white house when laws go unenforced, the other branches of government are intentionally a check on the executive.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by red-iron-pine on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:53AM (#46313310)
it is de facto national because California has the most people and is insanely wealthy; there is no F500 company handling broad consumer data that does not have a presence or customers there.

there have already been CCPA enforcements against companies like Tractor Supply, Sephora, Honda, and Google (tho the GOOG was more of a "violated a lot of stuff including CCPA").

It doesn't have enough teeth to scare FAANGs, who have the money and technical ability to do whatever, but it can definitely keep companies in line.

source: did CCPA compliance and security at multiple F500

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by TeMPOraL on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:15AM (#46311752)
"healthcare, video rental records" wait what? One of these things, etc. Curious how that came to be? Is it like special rules for (IIRC) onions in finance?
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Nextgrid on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:11AM (#46312192)
Someone leaked some politician’s video rental history back in the day (there wasn’t even anything controversial): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by reustle on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:29AM (#46311418)
I think there’s a good chunk of the SF tech event scene built around pulling in qualified email addresses, too. “Apply to attend”
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by cons0le on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:59AM (#46311626)
Please stop thinking about laws, and think about enforcement. If the cops don't care about something, it's defecto legal. We have all sorts of fancy laws on the books that aren't enforced. Environmental regs, animal welfare regs, anti trust laws, white collar anti fraud laws. Data laws fall into this bucket. Nobody that would actually enforce those laws gives a dam. We won't be able to solve any of our problems with new laws, until we can actually enforce the laws already on the books
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by DrScientist on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:10AM (#46312877)
There are lots of forms of 'don't care'. Don't care because:

- they have limited resources and they are prioritising something else,

- there is little realistic chance of getting a conviction.

- it's not one of their politically set department targets

- they fundamentally don't think it should be illegal - say historic blasphemy laws still on the books.

Is your main concern resources or enforceability, lack of political focus or some combination of all of the above?

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by franktankbank on Thursday December 18, 2025 @09:43AM (#46313215)
This really has me thinking I ought to just delete my Linkedin. I can't say I've ever got anything out of it except spam and fomo. I don't even like to keep it up-to-date because someone is just ripping that information off.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by sparrish on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:44AM (#46315059)
FWIW - I deleted my linkedin about a year ago and I've received more spam since I deleted it than when it was active.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by nerdsniper on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:14AM (#46313562)
I believe a LinkedIn profile is mandatory to apply to YC. I could assume you might not be interested in applying to YC, but it’s an interesting fact, and might generalize somewhat for many other applications.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by franktankbank on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:41AM (#46314042)
I think that is a mutually beneficial signal probably.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by giardini on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:32PM (#46315831)
">If the cops don't care about something, it's defecto legal.<"

Ahhhh! A new English expression, "defecto legal". I like it! It could be the name of a popular website.

The proper term is "de facto": https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/de%20facto

A defect is a flaw, an error, and "defecto" is Spanish for the English "defect". The meaning of "defecto legal" (English) thus remains in the wind, TBD. But I look forward to it's landing.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by disqard on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:36PM (#46318297)
s/it's/its/g

You want the possessive ("its"), not the shortened form ("it is") which would make that sentence:

"...look forward to it is landing"

Thank you for sharing the Spanish interpretation, TIL :)

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by giardini on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:41PM (#46315958)
">* If the cops don't care about something, it's defecto legal. *<"

Ahhhh! A new English expression, "defecto legal". I like it! It should be the name of a website, defectolegal.com, for purposes TBD later.

The proper term is "de facto": https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/de%20facto

"Defecto" is Spanish for the English "defect", a flaw, an error.

Don't get me started about "giving a dam".

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by dogemaster2032 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:36PM (#46318298)
In English we don’t write commas or periods outside the quotes. The proper way is to write them inside the quotation.

- “defect,” a flaw, an error.

- about giving a dam.”

Don’t get me started about “for purposes TBD later.”

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by guffins on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:00PM (#46322139)
That’s only the case for American English. British English places periods and commas outside the quotes, unless part of a literal quotation.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by ConspiracyFact on Friday December 19, 2025 @01:18AM (#46322781)
The other person who replied to you noted that this is not true in British English, but beyond that, it appears to me that my generation (Millennials) essentially all came to the same conclusion, which is that punctuation should only be included in the quotation if it's literally part of the text being quoted. (This probably has something to do with the programming mindset.) If you write

>The senator said that the bill was "bloated."

your sentence itself doesn't have a period. In order to give it a period you'd have to write:

>The senator said that the bill was "bloated.".

But then you're saying that the senator described the bill using the (non-)word consisting of the nine characters 'b', 'l', 'o', 'a', 't', 'e', 'd', 'PERIOD'. We've decided that this doesn't make sense.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by dogemaster2032 on Saturday December 20, 2025 @02:27AM (#46334255)
Your point that this is a generational change is interesting and reminds me of boomers who still write double space after a period.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by AngryData on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:11PM (#46321127)
Follow the money, easy payouts for cops and courts is where 95% of enforcement goes. Drug possession is an instant $1000 profit for the local law enforcement, and possibly much more. And if they are poor and challenge it, the extra court fees and court lawyer are also profitable.

Fighting private lawyers is what costs courts money and is why the wealthy get way less criminal punishment.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by zingababba on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:08AM (#46313489)
I swear to god a couple of the interviews I have been in lately have felt more like free consultations rather than me applying for a job.