News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by terminalshort on Thursday December 18, 2025 @02:35AM (#46309895)
It's technically fraud, but there aren't any damages.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by YmiYugy on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:32AM (#46310221)
This seems analogous to the following. A company asks users to fill out an online survey in exchange for participation in some raffle, except the company never pays out any prize. As with the job application there was never a guaranteed reward, but it's still easy to see the damage. The company induced to you to provide them with an economically valuable asset (filled out survey/application) for which you expected a fair chance at a reward. It seems plausible that you could claim damages at least up to the expected value.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by Dayshine on Thursday December 18, 2025 @07:34AM (#46311900)
Except a job offer is generally non binding, so they could interview you, offer the job, then withdraw it.

So never being offered a job because it doesn't exist doesn't lose you anything.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by jagoff on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:18AM (#46312269)
Spotted the HR worker posting ghost jobs
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by amypetrik8 on Friday December 19, 2025 @04:15PM (#46331014)
>So never being offered a job because it doesn't exist doesn't lose you anything.

Ah well look, if the job posting was just to collect resumes with zero intention to actually hire, you did lose some things:

- actual time spent applying to a job that was never open - emotional damage on focus to try to get this job - loss of free market value of your data (company profited from this data, when you could have profited from it) - damages for acquisition of your personal data under a fraudulent basis (when otherwise, maybe you did not want your data shared)

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by darreninthenet on Thursday December 18, 2025 @03:22AM (#46310164)
In the UK at least Fraud doesn't require any damages, just an intent to gain something of value on the criminals side.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by moralestapia on Thursday December 18, 2025 @04:06AM (#46310440)
Your time might be worthless but mine isn't.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by terminalshort on Thursday December 18, 2025 @06:46AM (#46311533)
Yeah, you go ahead and sue someone for the few minutes of your time it took to send in a application for a fake job. Then you'll really see what wasting time looks like.
Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by danaris on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:05AM (#46312150)
But this is part of the problem with crimes and enforcement in the modern age: sure, I might have only wasted a few minutes of my time. But I'm just one of hundreds or thousands of people who were tricked into wasting that time, by this one act.

Multiply this across all the fraudulent job postings, and it really starts to add up.

It's clear (to me, at least) that we need better laws to handle this sort of wide-but-shallow attack on people. It's analogous to spam.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by moralestapia on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:34AM (#46312433)
I recently learned of [1], which is a good example of "too small for me to sue" but still worth going through it collectively.

1: https://www.canadianbreadsettlement.ca/

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by palmotea on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:43AM (#46312524)
> Yeah, you go ahead and sue someone for the few minutes of your time it took to send in a application for a fake job. Then you'll really see what wasting time looks like.

1. That is exactly what class actions are for, because small damages multiplied by many people are big damages.

2. That's also why we need punitive damages, so someone can't get away with unlawful actions by deliberately coasting along under the threshold where it makes sense to sue. For instance, IIRC, you can collect something like $5000 from someone who doesn't put you on their "do not call list" when requested. That amount has nothing to do with the value of the "few minutes of your time it took to" answer a telemarketing call.

Re:'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them by A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#46313726)
You are missing a point. The only thing it really does is force people to pursue other forms as online channel is too polluted for anyone with sense/options/skill ( or all of the above ). So it leaves desperate, optionless, those without skills and everyone else who fell through the cracks. Another system undermined for no clear benefit. It does not benefit the employer. It does not benefit the employee. It does benefit some data brokers.. and only then for a bit until the rest of the market catches up..

But was it worth it?