News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by bunji on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:23PM (#46221385)
The intended targets of the exploding papers weren't civilians. Very few actual civilians ended up hurt by the detonations, much fewer than attacks by conventional weapons. It's about as targeted an attack as one can achieve from a distance.

As an act of warfare, Israel did a splendid job on this. Thoroughly impressive work.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tw04 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:38PM (#46221610)
> Very few actual civilians ended up hurt by the detonations, much fewer than attacks by conventional weapons.

The reports are 4,000 wounded and 12 killed unintended targets in order to kill 42 targets.

On what planet is that “very few actual civilians”? I think you knew full well before posting that’s a ridiculous claim which is why you did it anonymously.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by worldsavior on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:08PM (#46223881)
> in order to kill 42 targets.

This is not correct. Each one that had this pager was connected to Hezbollah, i.e. a soldier of Hezbollah. This attack was meant to "disable" a very big portion of Hezbollah, which it did (4000 of them).

This is one of the most sophisticated attacks to avoid civilian casualty.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by j_maffe on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:25PM (#46224092)
> This is one of the most sophisticated attacks to avoid civilian casualty. 127 civilians Lebanese civilians killed since the ceasefire by the party you claim is avoiding civilian casualties, btw. very careful bunch
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:54PM (#46221855)
"The reports" are that 12 were killed total, not that 12 civilians were killed. Only 2 of the killed were civilians as far as I can tell. Several of those who people on Twitter tried to claim were civilians, including a doctor, were admitted by Hezbollah to be Hezbollah members and given Hezbollah funerals.

I've never heard of "42 targets", and given 12 people died total, obviously 42 targets were not killed.

You should provide some sourcing for your numbers.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:13PM (#46222156)
Incorrect. The reports are 42 total killed, 12 civilians including 2 children.

"Operation Grim Beeper" (seriously) on Wikipedia cites these numbers from Lebanese government.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Lebanon_electronic_device...

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:19PM (#46222248)
Fair enough, 12 total only includes the original pager attack, not the subsequent radio one. However, you seem to have made the same mistake. 42 people were killed total, but that does not mean that there were 42 targets.

In any case, if Hezbollah themselves admit that 1500 of their fighters were injured by the attack (according to your own source), it seems extremely dishonest to claim that all 4000 were civilians or that there were only 42 targets.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tw04 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:37PM (#46223429)
>42 people were killed total, but that does not mean that there were 42 targets.

So they only managed to hit 30 targets with 12 misfires… that makes it even worse.

> In any case, if Hezbollah themselves admit that 1500 of their fighters were injured by the attack (according to your own source)

That’s 1500 in addition to the 4,000 civilians. The fact they managed to wound 2.5x+ as many civilians as targets isn’t exactly making them look better…

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:21PM (#46222281)
I didn't say 42 targets.

Per the report: 42 dead, 12 of which were civilians. It follows that 30 were considered Hezbollah.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:23PM (#46222312)
Several of those initially claimed to be civilians were later acknowledged by Hezbollah, so that number is still a bit fuzzy.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:27PM (#46222364)
I'm not claiming absolute knowledge of numbers, just going off the public reports which are all we can go on.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by j_maffe on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:26PM (#46224099)
Source? Can't find anything stating this
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:26PM (#46222352)
The report is 4,000 civilians injured (which means they just didn't die -- people lost fingers, limbs, eyes, etc.)

Presumably if you have thousands of Hezbola people walking around within their homes, businesses, hopistals, shops, etc. it makes sense you'd have many civilian injuries when these went off. There wasn't a geo fence around them and if someone was in an NICU or preschool the explosions were indiscriminate.

So while there was some element of precision in placement of who had these pagers, there was zero awareness (by design) to where they actually were when they all exploded.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by mlyle on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:11PM (#46223055)
I haven't seen a report of 4000 civilians injured. I have seen a report of 4000 people injured across the two attacks, but presumably some fraction of these are targets.

42 killed, of whom Hezbollah said 12 were civilians (later admitting some of the 12 were fighters).

Historical average is about half of the wounded or killed in conflicts to be civilians. < 12/42 would be a relatively "good" ratio.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tw04 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:30PM (#46223330)
You didn’t see 4,000 because you didn’t look for it. It’s literally in the wikipedia article linked in the thread you’re responding to with multiple associated citations.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by neoromantique on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:23PM (#46224778)
The distinction is /civilians/.

You make an assumption that of the 4000 people wounded /all/ were civilians, which is odd, considering that explosive was in a device given out to Hezbollah members.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:43AM (#46228374)
To be clear, that claim of 4,000 comes from a member of Hezbollah:

> According to the Lebanese government, the attack killed 42 people,[11] including 12 civilians,[12] and injured 4,000 civilians (according to Mustafa Bairam, Minister of Labour and a member of Hezbollah).

The wikipedia page's other reference claiming that the majority of those injured were civilians is also vague. For instance, it writes, "On 26 September, Abdallah Bou Habib, Lebanon's Foreign Minister, confirmed that most of those carrying pagers were not fighters, but civilians like administrators"

The reference for that sentence is this, which reads: https://carnegieendowment.org/emissary/2024/09/israel-hezbol...

> It was an attack mostly on Hezbollah, but a lot of civilians got hurt in the process, because not everybody is sitting there fighting on the front. These are people who have pagers or have telephones. They are regular people. Some of them are also fighters, but not most of them. A lot of them are administrators working here and there. . . .

This is a very different claim that what the article reads. "Administrators" and "not fighters" is a very different thing than "civilian". A woman working in my building also works in the Army's HR department during the day. She's literally a member of the military, but it's also not wrong to say she is "not a fighter" and an "administrator".

In short, the idea that we have credible evidence that the 4,000 people who were injured (and more, importantly, those that were actually maimed rather than receiving light injuries) were mostly civilians doesn't seem to pan out.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by mlyle on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:25AM (#46228621)
The problem is, 2750 + 750 injured is less than 4000, and it doesn't make sense that none of the injured were targets but >30/42 of those killed were.

We're talking about a tiny amount of explosives in each pager. Sure, it could lightly wound a bystander under perfect circumstances, but it's not going to create a big confluence of major injuries. <6 grams of PETN--we're talking about a risk of injury at roughly arm's reach.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:37PM (#46222531)
but we have the benefit of seeing live videos from actual shops where these hezbollah members were, and you can see the explosion was small enough to not hurt anyone in the vicinity

even if very close, one of the videos shows a supermarket line, and no one around is hurt

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by neoromantique on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#46224758)
>I didn't say 42 targets.

You quite literally did.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:48AM (#46233736)
What? It's possible I had a previous typo, but please show me where I said that.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Tuesday December 16, 2025 @12:57PM (#46291812)
??
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by neoromantique on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:17PM (#46315626)
Sorry, I don't always check responses.

I checked and it was a mixup, I assumed you were the original poster(tw04).

I stand corrected.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:55PM (#46316128)
Appreciate the follow up and retraction. Thanks!
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:23PM (#46224774)
The figure of merit in a military strike is casualties, not KIA; it's the "wounded" part you actually care about (in fact, in some tactical situations, wounding is preferable to killing, as it ties up adversary logistical resources).

Since the pagers that were targeted were exclusively used by Hezbollah (which fought an actual civil war with the Lebanese security forces specifically in order to establish its own telecom network), I would be extraordinarily wary of any source that has claimed more injuries to noncombatants than to combatants.

You can still tell a story where the pager attack was unacceptable owing to civilian casualties: there could be so many civilian casualties that any number of combatant casualties wouldn't justify it. But if you're claiming that there were more casualties to noncombatants over small explosions from devices carried principally in the pockets of combatants, it is rational to draw the conclusion that your reasoning (and sourcing) is motivated.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by oa335 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:38PM (#46226990)
> it is rational to draw the conclusion that your reasoning (and sourcing) is motivated.

Have you provided any sources at all for you numerous claims throughout this thread? Would it also me rational to draw a the conclusion that someone who has provided no sources at all is also engaging in “motivated reasoning”? At least be consistent.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:45PM (#46227057)
(We're conversing in multiple different parts of this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46227021)
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by iberator on Thursday December 11, 2025 @03:44AM (#46229044)
Hezbollah is a legal political party in Lebanon. This is an important detail buddy.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:36AM (#46231887)
No, it isn't. Hezbollah is an occupying military force in Lebanon, responsive only to a minority of its population, that happens to have a political party attached. It is the IRGC's faction of the Lebanese Parliament, except to the extent that it operates its own parallel government when that body is inconvenient to it.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by kyboren on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:46PM (#46221729)
> The reports are 4,000 wounded and 12 killed unintended targets

Which reports? According to whom? Hezbollah?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by shykes on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:18PM (#46223991)
I vouched for your post because your question is legitimate and asked in an appropriate manner; there is no good reason to flag it.

The answer to your question is yes: the "4,000 civilians wounded" figure is attributed to Mustafa Bairam, a high-ranking Hezbollah member. I have not seem any corroborating sources. As far as I can tell every mention of that number, including Wikipedia, traces back to him. Obviously this is a highly biased source that should not be trusted blindly.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:11PM (#46222135)
For the IDF, a 28.6% civilian death rate is actually quite good. Their own classified data reveals an 83% civilian casualty rate in Gaza—nearly three times worse.

The Lebanon pager attack: 12 civilians (including 2 children) killed out of 42 total deaths (28.6% civilian casualty rate).

Gaza genocide: Leaked IDF intelligence documents show 8,900 militants killed out of 53,000 total deaths as of May 2025 (83% civilian casualty rate).

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:22PM (#46222293)
According to Hezbollah sources 1500 of their terrorists were taken out of commission due to this attack. Making the death ratio 42/1500 or 3% while if only taking the civilian ratio that's even lower.

Even the 12 civilian count is probably higher than reality because it is doubtful that 12 civilians had access to a military clandestine communication device

https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/hezbollahs-tunnels...

Regarding the leaked IDF document this was leaked to a minor blog yet cannot be seen anywhere.

But let's entertain it as real, these are 8000 named Hamas terrorists known for certain by one intelligence unit in the IDF to be dead. This only means the minimum amount of Hamas terrorists, this doesn't take into account the other armed groups in Gaza that had a prewar strength of 10,000s of terrorists or the Hamas members who are only known by uncertain intelligence to have been killed.

Taking that number and reducing it from the Hamas published death count (an organization that kidnapped babies for political goals, but is incapable of lying, and was caught faking death counts before) to get the civilian death count is very unscientific to be extremely mild

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ignoramous on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:45PM (#46223557)
> an organization that kidnapped babies for political goals

Oy vey, kidnappings is where we draw the line?

- https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2025/oct/08...

- https://interactive.aljazeera.com/aje/2024/israel-war-on-gaz... (800+ dead infants)

---

> But let's entertain it as real, these are 8000 named Hamas terrorists ... the minimum amount of Hamas terrorists ... Hamas published death count (... faking death counts before) ... very unscientific to be extremely mild.

  I have little direct evidence about the atrocities in the Spanish Civil War. I know that some were committed by the Republicans, and far more (they are still continuing) by the Fascists. But what impressed me then, and has impressed me ever since, is that atrocities are believed in or disbelieved in solely on grounds of political predilection.

  Everyone believes in the atrocities of the enemy and disbelieves in those of his own side, without ever bothering to examine the evidence. Recently I drew up a table of atrocities during the period between 1918 and the present; there was never a year when atrocities were not occurring somewhere or other, and there was hardly a single case when the Left and the Right believed in the same stories simultaneously. And stranger yet, at any moment the situation can suddenly reverse itself and yesterday's proved-to-the-hilt atrocity story can become a ridiculous lie, merely because the political landscape has changed.
https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwel...
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by guelo on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:05PM (#46223848)
> 1500 of their terrorists ...

I stopped reading there knowing you're biased.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:48PM (#46224350)
The article linked here calls Israel's attack "terrorist", so I only thought this might balance things a bit
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by busterarm on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:27PM (#46226081)
Hezbollah is designated as a terrorist organization by:

    Argentina
    Australia
    Austria
    Bahrain
    Canada
    Colombia
    Czech Republic
    Ecuador
    Estonia
    European Union
    France
    Germany
    Gulf Cooperation Council
    Guatemala
    Honduras
    Israel
    Kosovo
    Lithuania
    Netherlands
    New Zealand
    Paraguay
    Serbia
    Slovakia
    United Arab Emirates
    United Kingdom
    United States
but calling them terrorists is biased?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by guelo on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:55AM (#46228782)
They're military and political personnel. Terrorist designation is a made up political thing as Trump has made obvious. Hezbollah has done nothing that Israel hasn't also done.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by busterarm on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:49AM (#46233750)
Military personal wear uniforms, are clearly identifiable in their operations & movements and have standards of behavior in line with jus ad bellum & jus in bello.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tguvot on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:39PM (#46222571)
there is no classified idf data of 83% civilian casualty rate. there is data that idf can identify by name 17% of casualties as hamas/etc member. if there are 10 people with machine guns and rpg and you blow them up with a bomb, they don't become civilians just because you don't know their names
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:51AM (#46233780)
The IDF did not dispute this, so unclear why you are.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Friday December 12, 2025 @02:57AM (#46241886)
that's false

" It said “figures presented in the article are incorrect”, without specifying which data the Israeli military disputed. It also said the numbers “do not reflect the data available in the IDF’s systems”, without detailing which systems. "

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:53AM (#46233813)
Seems some say even the named may be fabricated:

>> Sources within the Israeli intelligence community cited in the report raised concerns about how deaths were categorized, with one source claiming people were sometimes "promoted to the rank of terrorist after their death" in the database. <<

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Friday December 12, 2025 @02:57AM (#46241882)
I am sorry but the source for all this information is two largely unknown blogs in Israel . I highly doubt their "sources within Israeli intelligence" are more than the opinions of one low ranking soldier (if even true)

if anything the low quality journalism displayed here only shows how previously respected newspapers are only left to selling what's left of their name and reputation for a few last anger clicks before being deprecated by regurgitating unverified information from other lower quality sources (X, blogs)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by xvedejas on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:27PM (#46224116)
You understate your point: the 83% rate is much, much more than 3x worse. To kill 100 intended targets, a 28.6% civilian death rate means you'll need to kill `N / (100 + N) = 0.286` (N = 40.06) civilians. With an 83% civilian death rate, to kill 100 intended targets, you need to kill `N / (100 + N) = 0.83` (N = 488) civilians. It is about 12x worse to have an 83% civilian death rate compared to a 28.6% rate.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:52AM (#46233789)
Thank you for that correction.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by xvedejas on Tuesday December 16, 2025 @05:33PM (#46295564)
I'll note that for two rates (a, b) the general formula for this kind of comparison would be:

    a (1-b) / (b (1-a))
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by fabian2k on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:20PM (#46222259)
The numbers you state are from the Lebanese government and Hizbollah. So I don't think we can assume they are accurate. I don't have any better numbers, though.

You specific argument though misuses even those numbers. 42 is the number of people actually killed. I couldn't figure out how many were targeted (how many pagers did explode), but I'd assume the number could be much higher than the number of deaths. Without that number we cannot determine how well targeted this was. I also don't think it is plausible that for every target you injure 100 bystanders. So I would assume the number of targets was at least an order of magnitude higher.

There's also another number from Hizbollah, that 1500 of their people were injured. But no idea it those would be included in the 4000 wounded number.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by sixstringninja on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:27PM (#46224117)
source?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by LarsDu88 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:36PM (#46221582)
People tend to easily forget that the civilian casualty ratio for conventional warfare is around 50%

These attacks killed and maimed children, but firing JDAMs kills and maims even more children.

Not excusing the Israeli military here... they definitely dropped a lot of JDAMs, unguided artillery, and indiscriminate autocannon munitions on Gaza.

But the specific point on the pager attacks being against civilians is not a great argument.

Another thing I will note is that a lot of Palestinian groups also use similar reasoning towards targeting the Israeli population on the basis of the fact there is mass conscription in place.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tw04 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:42PM (#46221662)
> People tend to easily forget that the civilian casualty ratio for conventional warfare is around 50%

Causality in war includes people that were only injured. This was far, far more than a 50% casualty rate. More like a 9552% casualty rate.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by sp4cec0wb0y on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:41PM (#46221640)
You're telling me that the 2,800 injured were mostly Hezbollah operatives? Was this sourced and verified anywhere? What is the rate of combatant to non-combatant casualties is this instance compared to "conventional weapons"?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by kyboren on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:53PM (#46221844)
These pagers weren't purchased in stores by civilians. You see, Hezbollah had a problem: Their phone network was totally compromised. Israel was using operatives' phones as tracking beacons. So Hezbollah purchased a few thousand pagers through specialty channels (which we now know had been compromised by Israel) to distribute to their commanders. They believed this would improve their security, because unlike the two-way radios in cell phones, pagers use a one-way broadcast radio, and there is no need to know or report the pager radio's location.

Given this context: A limited number of specialty electronics, acquired and distributed by Hezbollah as a means of military command and control, and subsequent to this operation Hezbollah's C2 was demonstrably neutered--you believe that the majority of injuries were innocent civilians?

Basic logic indicates that the vast majority of those killed and injured were, in fact, nodes in Hezbollah's command and control structure.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:43PM (#46222622)
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/pagers-drones-how-...

Here is Hezbollah boasting to Reuters before the pagers attack, about how it moved to using pagers and couriers to counter Israeli intelligence.

As you can guess, with the advent of mobile phones in the 2000s, pagers became obsolete in Lebanon

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:41PM (#46223486)
Unless you’re a Lebanese doctor?

Not to you specifically, but it is astounding how indiscriminate terrorism is lauded as “brilliant”. Is it because the victims were not of the white Judeo-Christian variety? Seriously trying to understand the mental gymnastics here.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:48PM (#46223606)
Doctors don't use pagers anymore, just like tech on calls used to and don't anymore. Mobile phones are far superior for that, and are very available anywhere in the world, and especially to doctors

Regarding whether that's brilliant, that is not my wording, but generally it was quite mild compared to the methods of Hezbollah and was highly successful in ending a war with very little bloodshed. The other alternative was tried in 2006 and in Gaza, and fighting a terror organization entrenched in an urban setting means bombings and killing civilians in the process. This was not the end result as Hezbollah fell apart relatively quickly afterwards, so I think it was good compared to any alternative for Lebanese and Israelis

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:55PM (#46223701)
Doctors still use pagers. I don’t know about Lebanon in particular, but I would wager they still use them there too.

The rest is a bunch of hypotheticals. I am also unsure where the conclusion that Hezbollah is dead is coming from. Was their operational capability degraded? Of course. Is the group dead? Absolutely not.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:12PM (#46223933)
Regarding the pagers in any case these were specially imported by hezbollah, so these were not used by doctors, even if we assume they only use pagers in Lebanon.

Regarding the group, it has signed a cease fire agreement with very unfavorable terms which essentially let Israel bomb any of its members or locations that violate the terms of the cease fire agreement and the lebanese army did not work to resolve, this happens on a weekly basis since the end of the war

If you compare this state to the state just prior to October 2023 where Hezbollah had setup a tent in Israeli territory which Israel was too afraid to do something about for months over fear of starting a war, then this is essentially a complete break up in my opinion.

Is it dead? no. it's alive enough to keep lebanon in its permanent failed state status due to fear of all other sects of civil war. But together with what happened to its patron, and the local popularity it lost it might break up completely

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:13PM (#46223950)
Hezbollah has a political/civilian arm.

This is my last reply in this thread.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:19PM (#46224010)
I am aware of that, and hopefully they will become a Lebanese political party without an armed wing, similar to all other political parties, which are most essentially led by former warlords involved in mass killings
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by sudosysgen on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:40PM (#46227006)
Hezbollah operates hospitals and medical services. It's not just a political party.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by blitzar on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:42PM (#46224283)
> Doctors don't use pagers anymore,

The UK's National Health Service (NHS) is widely considered the single largest user of pagers in the world, with over 130,000 devices in use as of recent years. This figure represented an estimated 10% of the total number of pagers remaining globally.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by fabian2k on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:08PM (#46223879)
They didn't put bombs in pagers that were freely sold. They put them into shipments for Hizbollah specifically.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:12PM (#46223929)
1. I was responding to the incorrect point that pagers are not used by civilians.

2. You are aware that Hezbollah has a civilian/political arm, right?

3. Surely Israel - the most moral country on the planet - painstakingly vetted pager possession before detonating them en masse?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by TiredOfLife on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:55PM (#46224431)
> Unless you’re a Lebanese doctor?

Where would a Lebanese doctor get an encrypted pager bought by Hezbollah and given to Hezbollah members with the explicit use for communicating with other Hezbollah members?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:04PM (#46224539)
Growing tired of repeating the same response to the same points. Please see on of my other replies to sibling comments.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by rat87 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:55PM (#46227120)
The idea that only criminals or terorists have pagers is ridiculous(you mentined doctors). But Israel didnt target pagers in Lebanon. They sold equipment for Hezbollah internal use om their own network (they convinced Hezbollah to pay a front company for the walkies).

That is the opposite of indicrimante.

as for

> white Judeo-Christian variety

Judeo Christian is a silly concept. Either say christian or say Abrahamic. While most casulties were affiliated with Hezbollah and therefore overwhelmingly Shia Muslim enough of the general public of Lebanon is Christian that they would make at least some of civilian bystanders injured. Also Lebanese people aren't any whiter in average skin color then the average Israeli

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:48PM (#46227789)
That's not the argument. Presumably a broad cross-section of Lebanese people have pagers. But only Hezbollah combatants had these pagers, which were specifically procured by Hezbollah through an idiosyncratic suppler, linked to Hezbollah's own military encrypted network, and triggered by a pager message encrypted to that network.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Thursday December 11, 2025 @06:17PM (#46238707)
> linked to Hezbollah's own military encrypted network, and triggered by a pager message encrypted to that network.

I am not sure where you’re getting this information from. For instance, you seem confident that this network used exclusively by the armed wing.

Regardless, absolutely none of this negates the fact that this was an indiscriminate terrorist attack.

If the sides were reversed, or if virtually any other state executed this kind of attack, it would be rightfully condemned. But Israel, as always, gets a pass. And it was indeed a brilliant plan, but only in how comically evil it was.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Lebanon_electronic_device...

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @06:33PM (#46238871)
The most obvious citation is Reuters, which did a whole article on this, including the specific circumstances in which the pagers exchanged hands. And, whatever the rest of the moral circumstances of the strike may have been, the fact of the devices being combatant communication equipment does mean that it was neither indiscriminate (it was in fact very discriminate) nor terroristic (it had combatant targets, not civilians).

The attacks can still be immoral for a host of other reasons. Pearl Harbor was deeply immoral. It was also not an indiscriminate terrorist attack. Words mean things.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:00PM (#46239136)
I have expanded in other comments in this same tree, but it was indiscriminate in timing, location, and possession (unless Israel individually verified possession).

If it were a “discriminate” attack as you claim, then we wouldn’t have seen thousands of civilians (non-combatants, Hezbollah affiliated or otherwise) being injured.

> Words mean things.

Small aside: not saying this applies to you specifically, but I have found that most people who use this adage (if you will) are quick to apply it to situations they don’t agree with, but become more flexible when it aligns with their interests.

The typical example I use is how Western politicians vehemently deny/denied usage of the term “genocide” or even “war crimes” for Gaza, but apply it liberally to Ukraine, even though the latter is objectively (by any metric) “less” of a genocide than Gaza is. Bernie Sanders only came around just a few months ago.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:02PM (#46239163)
I don't love "words mean things" and winced after I typed it, but I think we both understand what I meant by it.

My contention is that we did not in fact see thousands of noncombatants injured. I went into some pretty serious depth on this point elsewhere on the thread.

I think, for what it's worth, that I can pretty easily make the argument that Ukraine is a genocide and Gaza is not. In fact, I could say that about the Al Aqsa Flood as well! That argument will annoy the shit out of you. But I'd say that's because you've affixed undeserved gravity or finality to the term "genocide", as a sort of "worst possible crime". What Israel is doing in Gaza can be as bad as what Russia is doing in Ukraine without establishing genocidal intent (which Russia pretty clearly does have).

I think the push to label the Gaza campaign as a "genocide" has been a fairly spectacular own goal on the part of western Palestinian rights activists. Unless the situation on the ground changes (I grant that it could), people are just going to keep shooting that claim down, and advocates for Palestinians will be stuck explaining instead of persuading, against relatively powerful countervailing arguments.

The case for ethnic cleansing, atrocities, and widespread war crimes is trivial to make. It's just not enough for online advocates; it's like they're trying to get an in-game trophy for the term "genocide".

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:27PM (#46239368)
I understand we won’t come to an agreement here, but I wanted to respond to two of your points:

1. Re: the term genocide, do you know why Palestinians have been insisting on this specific word to be used? Because genocidal intent was clearly communicated from virtually day 1, and was backed by actions to prove this intent. Cabinet members were calling Palestinians “human animals” and “amalek” for God’s sake - and that’s not even close to the worst of it! Palestinians didn’t just wake up one day and say “well, it’s arbitrarily a genocide, and we want everyone to call it that”. And South Africa rightfully pursued a case at the ICJ. Firstly, because they recognized the shared suffering from their experience with apartheid, but most importantly, because they saw that there was a mountain of incontrovertible legal evidence to support their case.

1. Re: Ukraine, you simply cannot make that argument in good faith. Russia’s goals in Ukraine are in direct opposition to Israel’s goals in Gaza and the West Bank.

Russia ultimately wants to annex Ukraine to expand its influence and reinstate its past glory with the USSR. This requires that it absorb Ukrainians into Russia proper. Russia uses the shared culture and language as a justification in its propaganda, but I think there is a kernel of truth there when it comes to Russia’s motivations, particularly in eastern Ukraine. Given all this, genocide is a non-starter for Russia - how can you claim annexation when you are also working to genocide the local population?

On the other hand, Israel wants to cleanse the land of its people - in fact, the absolute last thing it wants to do is absorb Palestinians into Israel proper. From day 1, its intentions were crystal clear: Palestinians as a racial/ethnic group cannot remain in Gaza. They used all tools at their disposal in pursuit of this goal, including mass starvation, collective punishment, mass bombardment, forced relocation, and so on. Taken together with the statements made by top gov officials, this constitutes genocide.

This is all setting aside that Ukraine is a fully sovereign nation with an equipped and supported conventional military fighting a conventional war against a nation state aggressor.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:50PM (#46239556)
Let me say first of all: super chill response and I really appreciate that.

On point (1), I've got reason to question the claims of genocidal intent that get bandied about in these kinds of conversations. Yair Rosenberg wrote a piece for The Atlantic debunking one of the most frequently cited "amalek" claims. It's easy to find people on either side of the conflict espousing genocidal views, but harder to map specific actions to realistically genocidal intent (especially when the views are ascribed to people with no decisionmaking authority over how the campaign is being waged).

I hate having to be so hedgy but I'll do it anyways: none of that is to say that the Gaza campaign was waged ethically or with meaningful concern for civilian life, and I fervently hope many of its architects end up imprisoned for their roles in it. But that's a cards-on-the-table statement, not a clinical assessment.

On point (2) about Ukraine: Russian decisionmakers at the highest level have repudiated the existence of Ukrainian ethnicity; Russia has deliberately --- in ways I don't think map cleanly to how the IAF has prosecuted the war in Gaza --- targeted civilian populations (Bucha is an obvious example), and, most damningly, Russia embarked on a campaign of family separation and coerced adoption with the specific intent of disrupting Ukraining ethnicity.

You point out that Israel wants to "cleanse" the land (call it Greater Israel, from the Jordan river and including the Gaza strip) of Palestinians. I'm not as sure about that, but I can stipulate to it. That by itself does not constitute genocide!† (Ethnic cleansing? A crime against humanity? Very possibly!) Genocide as a concept does not encompass any link between blood and soil.

It really pisses Palestinian advocates off to hear this, and I get why, but there is by rights already a Palestinian state in the Levant: it's called Jordan, where Palestinians have, at multiple points over the last 50 years, made up a majority of the resident population. Similarly, if we're doing comparative statecraft, Assadist Syria successfully cleansed itself of its concentrated Palestinian population, over just the last 10-15 years. See how often you see Palestinian advocates make claims about Yarmouk camp, though. You start to understand why advocates for Israel (I am not one of those) are jaded about this whole thing.

† You get a similar thing about "apartheid", a term I'm more comfortable using with Israel, from people who correctly observe that Israeli Arab citizens, of whom there are a great many, have vastly more rights than black Africans had under apartheid, to the point where the term makes more sense applied to other larger, more salient ethnic divides elsewhere in the world. But like, preemptively: I'm with you, it's effectively an apartheid system in the West Bank.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Friday December 12, 2025 @11:06AM (#46245423)
This is the kind of discussion that I feel would be better to have in-person; I am not a great writer :)

Re: Israel & the term genocide, if you closely look at the combination of:

(1) the words that came/are coming out of the mouths of Israeli cabinet members, Knesset members, and the Israeli media (especially in Hebrew!)

(2) the policies enacted on the ground in Gaza and the West Bank

(3) the actions taken by the IDF in Gaza since Oct 7 (I won't enumerate them here)

(4) the clear cut plans for a "greater Israel"

(5) the extra-territorial conflicts & attacks (esp. the 12 day war and Qatar strike), and the ground invasions in Lebanon & Syria, the latter under the guise of "minority protection" (a tale as old as time)

You must conclude that Israel is at the very least committing war crimes, and is the least rational actor in the Middle East. Palestinians, their allies, and (at the nation state level) South Africa & observers took it a step further and argued that the sum of the above constitutes genocide.

> Russian decisionmakers at the highest level have repudiated the existence of Ukrainian ethnicity

What Russia is doing here - and what it did with the USSR - may constitute "cultural genocide", but this is not legally defined. Keep in mind that Israel also denies the existence of Palestinians and reduces them instead to "Arabs".

> in ways I don't think map cleanly to how the IAF has prosecuted the war in Gaza

Three questions that I find helpful when comparing the two situations generally:

1. Does Hamas have an air force or access to air defense systems? If not, does that make it easier or harder for mass killing to take place when compared to the situation in Ukraine?

2. Does Russia regularly level entire buildings - with civilians present - in exchange for so-called "high-value targets"? All AI-driven btw, giving us a glimpse into the future of warfare.

3. Does Russia control the entire border of Ukraine? And has it ever enforced a total blockade on all goods entering Ukraine?

> but there is by rights already a Palestinian state in the Levant: it's called Jordan, where Palestinians have, at multiple points over the last 50 years, made up a majority of the resident population.

It pisses off advocates because it actually ties back into how Israel erases the Palestinian national identity, and is a common hasbara talking point :)

From day 1, Jordan has been a malicious actor of sorts in opposition to the Palestinian national movement. The West Bank post-partition was supposed to be given to a Palestinian ("Arab") state, but Jordan invaded under the guise of protection, which was a valid excuse, but also an excellent opportunity to establish Transjordan. The Jordanians held control until 1967. In 1967, many Palestinians were forced to relocate to Jordan in a second Nakba (called the Naksa[1]). Soon after this, the PLO escalated its fight against the Jordanian monarchy, culminating in Black September. Today, there are a large number of self-described (very important!) Jordanian-Palestinians residing in Jordan, but they still have ties to Palestine, and claim it as their homeland even after multiple rounds of expulsion. In other words, even in Jordan, there still is a separate Palestinian national identity that lives on.

As far as the camps go in Palestine, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria, that's a separate topic of discussion. A big part of the continued existence of these refugee camps in Arab countries throughout modern history is the optimism of Palestinians & the host Arab states that a solution will be reached soon.

> from people who correctly observe that Israeli Arab citizens, of whom there are a great many, have vastly more rights than black Africans had under apartheid

South African apartheid is the model, but not the only form. I believe that there is sufficient evidence for the argument that Israeli Arab citizens do indeed live under apartheid, mainly due to the ethno-religious nature of citizenship in Israel proper.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naksa

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Friday December 12, 2025 @01:38PM (#46247179)
I think you're doing great, but I'll keep my response brief to avoid dragging you into a longer thread.

* I agree, Israel appears to me to be guilty of war crimes; quite a great many.

* We disagree about the black-letter genocidal intent Russia has exhibited in Ukraine. Organized mass kidnapping and coerced adoption of children is a per se genocidal action under the 1948 Genocide Convention.

* The US outclasses almost every armed service in the world to the same extent Israel outclassed Hamas (which no longer exists as a military force). That doesn't make US involvement in any given armed conflict genocidal or immoral.

* If your point was simply that Israel is capable of putting into practice genocidal intent, of course, I agree with that. They have a mechanical advantage in doing that, to the point where they shoulder additional burdens to avoid genocidal outcomes, and I preemptively agree they haven't satisfied those obligations. But flip it: Hamas has essentially no capability to successfully commit a genocide of Israelis. And yet their attack, under the Convention, was more clearly genocidal.

* I agree with you about the governance of Jordan! I think all the surrounding states share significant moral burden with regards to the Palestinian people,and launder it through Arab enmity towards Israel and Jewish ethnicity.

* I want to be very clear: I also believe the Palestinians have a moral claim to Gaza and the West Bank, and that there is no practical resolution to the Palestinian/Israeli conflict that won't involve two states on land Israel now controls. When I bring up the Jordan thing, I'm making a broader claim about the sustainability of Palestinian ethnic identity, not the "Palestinians should be remigrated into Jordan" argument the neo-Kahanists make. Kahanism is vile.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:15PM (#46222186)
The IDF is only able to kill 17 people they classify as "Hamas" for every 100 people they kill in Gaza (per their own internal reports). They have a self assessed 83% civilian kill rate.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by GopherState on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:46PM (#46222666)
Not true. The "classification" is combatants killed and identified by the IDF with first & last name. There's a larger un-identified group of combatants due to Hamas fighting in civilian clothes, and falsely claiming all deaths are civilian
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ada1981 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:40AM (#46233629)
>> The Israeli military did not dispute the existence of the database or dispute the data on Hamas and PIJ deaths when approached for comment... <<

https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2025/aug/21...

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Friday December 12, 2025 @03:00AM (#46241900)
that's false

it is said right there in your linked article that the IDF initially did not dispute the information when contacted by the no-name blog (does it mean it confirmed, refuse to answer or never talk about the authenticity of the information?)

Your article a few lines below says the IDF says this is false when contacted by the Guardian

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:44PM (#46222639)
It would probably be easier to classify them if they hadn't committed the war crime of not wearing uniforms
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Cyph0n on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:42PM (#46223516)
It would also be easier to classify Israeli deaths on Oct 7 if they weren’t all reservists and/or killed by their own country via Hannibal directive.

Do you see where your logic is going, or does it only apply to lesser victims?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:58PM (#46223740)
Not all Israelis (or most) are reservists and most of the civilians were murdered by Hamas death squads execution style, not by the fabled Hannibal directive

While Hamas does not wear uniform in combat and publishes its dead as civilians, so no, my logic holds

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by rat87 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:38PM (#46222547)
Most sides in most wars aren't expected to classify every person they killed. Identifying certain people as Hamas(and they could be wrong about some of them) doesn't mean that every single other person is not a member of Hamas, Islamic Jihad, or other millitant
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:02AM (#46227865)
"You're telling me that the 2,800 injured were mostly Hezbollah operatives?"

Yes, because these pagers were only used by Hezbollah and Israel was able to read the messages they sent on them so they could know if they were in use by a Hezbollah member.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zeofig on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:31PM (#46223341)
Yes, since conveniently the attacker also gets to define who is a civilian.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by baskin31 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:16PM (#46224690)
When one quotes Health Ministry for numbers of casualties and deaths, that is relying on HAMAS for information. To knowingly use sources that have demonstratbly be shown to be false, inaccurate, or misleading makes one also unreliable.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zeofig on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:00PM (#46225855)
HAMAS? We're talking about an attack in Lebanon my friend, not Palestine.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by orwin on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:50PM (#46221796)
The issue is using civil infrastructure as weapon, that could arguably be an act of terror. As pagers are rarely used in non-criminal settings, i guess this is somewhat okay in my opinion, but the callousness and overall reactions (proudness, smugness) of israelis and most of the west on this near-terror attack is in my opinion another proof of a lack of empathy that is starting to be pervasive in our societies.

I know people talk about the "entitlement epidemic", but entitlement is just another name from narcissism, in essence a lack of empathy. Which seems to be more and more socially acceptable and even rewarded (with internet points mostly), like your comment show (i'm not jumping on you, you are tamer than many, so i think it's a better exemple for my point than more violent ones).

And since that's the example we show our kids today, i'm now officially more worried about our society ability to handle social media than climate change.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by rat87 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:41PM (#46222602)
Pagers are used by more then just criminals(see doctors) and targeting random criminals as opposed to millitants wouldn't be justifiable. But these particular pager that were wired up were specifically intended only for Hezbollah internal use and were sold to Hezbollah by Israel through a third party front.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by viccis on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:00PM (#46224503)
Did it only focus on Hezbollah military officials? Hezbollah is a political party. This is like package bombing US congressmen, Presidential cabinet members, etc. Which would be considered a terrorist attack obviously (and was when Israel sent our politicians, including our President, mailbombs shortly after WW2)
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:32PM (#46224881)
It's technically and sort of a political party. It's also an occupying military force in Lebanon; it is foremost an instrument of the IRGC. It's useful to understand that Hezbollah is Shia-supremacist organization, and Shia muslims constitute a minority of the Lebanese population.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by viccis on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @06:55PM (#46225814)
That doesn't really distinguish it from Israel's government. s/Lebanon/Palestine/g, s/IRGC/USA/g, and s/Shia/Jewish/g
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:01PM (#46225869)
I don't agree, but we don't have to agree on this point to recognize the illegitimacy and coerciveness of Hezbollah and the IRGC. Even factoring Israel's most recent strikes in, the largest military losses Hezbollah has incurred in the last 10 years weren't with Israel, but rather in Syria, on behalf of the Assad regime, a client of the IRGC's, where Hezbollah (and the Lebanese security forces Hezbollah dragooned into the conflict) gleefully targeted civilian populations.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by baskin31 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:08PM (#46224579)
Does a political party shoot missiles over international borders and stockpile arms?