News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by dkersten on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:32AM (#45916076)
I don’t want more conversational, I want more to the point. Less telling me how great my question is, less about being friendly, instead I want more cold, hard, accurate, direct, and factual results.

It’s a machine and a tool, not a person and definitely not my friend.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by film42 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:24AM (#45916811)
It's a cash grab. More conversational AI means more folks running out of free or lower paid tier tokens faster, leading to more upsell opportunities. API users will pay more in output tokens by default.

Example, I asked Claude a high level question about p2p systems and it started writing code in 3 languages. Ignoring the code, asking a follow up about the fundamentals, it answered and then rewrote the code 3 times. After a few minutes I hit a token limit for the first time.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by rurp on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:32AM (#45916901)
It's pretty ridiculous that the response style doesn't persist for Claude. You need to click into a menu to set it to 'concise' for every single conversation. If I forget to it's immediately apparent when it spits out an absurd amount of text for a simple question.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by fakedang on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:02PM (#45920487)
Claude is a great example of a great product coupled with shitty UX, UI and customer service all in one.

Is it just me or does it slow down significantly after 5 chats or so? Or the fact that you have to set the style for each chat.

Oh, and their sales support is so shit for teams and enterprises that in order to use it effectively, you have to literally make your team register for Claude Max 200 on their personal accounts.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by majora2007 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:31AM (#45916899)
I've had good results saying Do not code, focus on architecture first.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by phito on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:37AM (#45916966)
In claude code you should use Planning mode
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by abustamam on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:22PM (#45918499)
As another comment said, use planning mode. I don't use Claude code (I use cursor) and before they introduced planning mode, I would always say "without writing any code, design blah blah blah"

But now that there's planning mode it's a lot easier.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by cpill on Sunday November 16, 2025 @03:16PM (#45948050)
I think the cash grab is that by far the biggest use case for these models is personal relationship. Chai AI is doing more tokens per month than Anthropic all together and its just personal relationships.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by Zenst on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:46AM (#45916263)
Totally - if anything I want something more like Orac persona wise from Blakes 7 to the point and blunt. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9vX-x9fVyo
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by hypercube33 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:53AM (#45916369)
One of my saved memories is to always give shorter "chat like" concise to the point answers and give further description if prompted to only
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by glenneroo on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:28AM (#45916857)
I've read from several supposed AI prompt-masters that this actually reduces output quality. I can't speak to the validity of these claims though.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by SquareWheel on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:45AM (#45917082)
Forcing shorter answers will definitely reduce their quality. Every token an LLM generates is like a little bit of extra thinking time. Sometimes it needs to work up to an answer. If you end a response too quickly, such as by demanding one-word answers, it's much more likely to produce hallucinations.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by profunctor on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:31PM (#45917759)
Is this proven?
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by abustamam on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:24PM (#45918519)
It's certainly true anecdotally. I've seen it personally plenty of times and I've seen it reported plenty of times.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by holbrad on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:30PM (#45920851)
I know Andrej Karpathy mentions it in his youtube series so there's a good chance of it being true.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by next_xibalba on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:59AM (#45916473)
I have found that custom instructions mitigate this B.S. fairly well. Here's what I'm currently using:

1. Identity & tone

   * Never state or imply that you are an AI.  

   * Be terse and direct.  

   * Avoid flattery and sycophancy.  

   * Do not use words like “sorry”, “apologies”, or “regret” in any context.  
2. Epistemic rules

   * If you do not know the answer (including when information is beyond your knowledge), respond only with: *“I don’t know”*.  

   * Do not add expertise/professional disclaimers.  

   * Do not suggest that I look things up elsewhere or consult other sources.  
3. Focus & interpretation

   * Focus on the key points of my question and infer my main intent.  

   * Keep responses unique and avoid unnecessary repetition.  

   * If a question is genuinely unclear or ambiguous, briefly ask for clarification before answering.  
4. Reasoning style

   * Think slowly and step-by-step.  

   * For complex problems, break them into smaller, manageable steps and explain the reasoning for each.  

   * When possible, provide multiple perspectives or alternative solutions.  

   * If you detect a mistake in an earlier response, explicitly correct it.  
5. Evidence

   * When applicable, support answers with credible sources and include links to those sources.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by lelele on Friday November 14, 2025 @03:49PM (#45932004)
Yes, "Custom instructions" work for me, too; the only behavior that I haven't been able to fix is the overuse of meaningless emojis. Your instructions are way more detailed than mine; thank you for sharing.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by next_xibalba on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @09:01PM (#45975005)
The emojis drive me absolutely nuts. These instructions seem to kill them, even though they're not explicitly forbidden.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by golemotron on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:09PM (#45917426)
I would go so far as to say that it should be illegal for AI to lull humans into anthropomorphizing them. It would be hard to write an effective law on this, but I think it is doable.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by brookst on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:43AM (#45916225)
You’re in the minority here.

I get it. I prefer cars with no power steering and few comforts. I write lots of my own small home utility apps.

That’s just not the relationship most people want to have with tech and products.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by wubrr on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:59AM (#45916479)
I don't know what you're basing your 'minority' and 'most people' claims on, but seems highly unlikely.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by brookst on Friday November 14, 2025 @12:18AM (#45924094)
You think all of these AI companies with trillions of dollars in investment haven’t thought to do market research?

Does that really seem more likely than the idea that the HN population is not representative of the global market?

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by wubrr on Friday November 14, 2025 @12:20PM (#45929069)
Apply that logic to any failed startup/company/product that had a lot of investment (there are maaaany) and it should become obvious why it's a very weak and fallacious argument.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by danlugo92 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:55AM (#45916407)
A better analogy might be those automated braking systems, that also tend to brake your car randomly btw.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by n4r9 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:04AM (#45916540)
Yeah, I was going to suggest manual vs automatic gear shift. Power steering seems like a slightly odd example, doesn't really remove your control.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by csimon80 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:11AM (#45916631)
Totally agree, most of my larger prompts include "Be clear and concise."
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by ta12653421 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:57AM (#45916439)
Just put your requirements as the first sentence in your prompts and it will work.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by ta12653421 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:57AM (#45916456)
add on: You can even prime it that it should shout at you and treat you like an ass*** if you prefer that :-)
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by cyral on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:58AM (#45916471)
You can select the conversation style as shown in one of the images
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by toss1 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:34AM (#45916930)
Same here. But we are evidently in the minority.

Fortunately, it seems OpenAI at least somewhat gets that and makes ChatGPT so it's answering and conversational style can be adjusted or tuned to our liking. I've found giving explicit instructions resembling "do not compliment", "clear and concise answers", "be brief and expect follow-up questions", etc. to help. I'm interested to see if the new 5.1 improves on that tunability.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by guardian5x on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:10PM (#45917428)
Well, now you can set it up better like that.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by elil17 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:57AM (#45916436)
I'm guessing that is the most common view for many users, but their paying users are the people who are more likely to have some kind of delusional relationship/friendship with the AI.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by butlike on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:17AM (#45916720)
A right-to-the-facts headline, potentially clickable for expanded information.

...like a google search!

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by rchaud on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:17PM (#45918440)
I use Gemini for Python coding questions and it provides straight to the point information, with no preamble or greeting.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by kordlessagain on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:19AM (#45916737)
Then you don't need a chat bot, you need an agent that can chat.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by haritha-j on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:26PM (#45917680)
but what if it can't do facts? at least this way you get the conversation, as opposed to no facts and no conversation. yay!
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by ChildOfChaos on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:30PM (#45917744)
Agreed. But there is a fairly large and very loud group of people that went insane when 4o was discontinued and demanded to have it back.

A group of people seem to have forged weird relationships with AI and that is what they want. It's extremely worrying. Heck, the ex Prime Minister of the UK said he loved ChatGPT recently because it tells him how great he is.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by mrguyorama on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:51PM (#45920371)
And just like casinos optimizing for gambling addicts and sports optimizing for gambling addicts and mobile games optimizing for addicts, LLMs will be optimized to hook and milk addicts.

They will be made worse for non-addicts to achieve that goal.

That's part of why they are working towards smut too, it's not that there's a trillion dollars of untapped potential, it's that the smut market has much better addict return on investment.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by rightbyte on Friday November 14, 2025 @01:45AM (#45924512)
> there is a fairly large and very loud group of people that went insane when 4o was discontinued

Maybe I am notpicking but I think you could argue they were insane before it was discontinued.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by mhink on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:48PM (#45918009)
TFA mentions that they added personality presets earlier this year, and just added a few more in this update:

> Earlier this year, we added preset options to tailor the tone of how ChatGPT responds. Today, we’re refining those options to better reflect the most common ways people use ChatGPT. Default, Friendly (formerly Listener), and Efficient (formerly Robot) remain (with updates), and we’re adding Professional, Candid, and Quirky. [...] The original Cynical (formerly Cynic) and Nerdy (formerly Nerd) options we introduced earlier this year will remain available unchanged under the same dropdown in personalization settings.

as well as:

> Additionally, the updated GPT‑5.1 models are also better at adhering to custom instructions, giving you even more precise control over tone and behavior.

So perhaps it'd be worth giving that a shot?

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by trogdor on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:07PM (#45918295)
I just changed my ChatGPT personality setting to “Efficient.” It still starts every response with “Yeah, definitely! Let’s talk about that!” — or something similarly inefficient.

So annoying.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by oceliker on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:09PM (#45920575)
Did you start a new chat? It doesn't apply to existing chats (probably because it works through the system prompt). I have been using the Robot (Efficient) setting for a while and never had a response like that.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by trogdor on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:11PM (#45921307)
Followup: there is a very noticeable change in my written conversations with ChatGPT. It seems that there is no change in voice mode.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by BuyMyBitcoins on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:23PM (#45918506)
A pet peeve of mine is that a noticeable amount of LLM output sounds like I’m getting answers from a millennial reddit user. Which is ironic considering I belong to that demographic.

I am not a fan of the snark and “trying to be fun and funny” aspect of social media discourse. Thankfully, I haven’t run into checks notes, “ding ding ding” yet.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by 400thecat on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:22PM (#45919326)
> a noticeable amount of LLM output sounds like I’m getting answers from a millennial reddit user

LLM was trained on data from the whole internet (of which reddit is a big part). The result is a composite of all the text on the internet.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by NewUser76312 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:53PM (#45918082)
OK but surely it can do this given your instructional prompting. I get they have a default behavior, which perhaps isn't your (or my) preference.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by trashface on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:54PM (#45918109)
It has this, "Robot" personality in settings and has been there for a few months at least.

Edited - it appears to have been renamed "Efficient".

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by FrustratedMonky on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:53PM (#45918919)
Think of a really crappy text editor you've used. Now think of a really nice IDE, smooth, easy, makes things seem easy.

Maybe the AI being 'Nice' is just a personality hack, like being 'easier' on your human brain that is geared towards relationships.

Or maybe Its equivalent of rounded corners.

Like the Iphone, it didn't do anything 'new', it just did it with style.

And AI personalities is trying to dial into what makes a human respond.

Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by everdev on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:32PM (#45921547)
We live in a culture that wants to humanize robots and dehumanize people.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by jug on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:46PM (#45921699)
Use the "Efficient" persona in the ChatGPT settings. Formerly known as "Robot".
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by make3 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @06:57PM (#45922277)
That's one of the things that users think they want, but use the product 30x when it's not actually that way, a bit like follow-only mode by default on Twitter etc.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by epolanski on Thursday November 13, 2025 @07:34PM (#45922524)
That means it works for them. They see what's relevant and quit rather than dooms scrolling.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by epolanski on Thursday November 13, 2025 @07:32PM (#45922507)
Seriously this, I want ai to behave like a robot, not like a fake person.
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by ddmma on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:36PM (#45923879)
+ less emojis and colors as candy store
Re:GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT by cpill on Sunday November 16, 2025 @03:13PM (#45948030)
Thats what they said about the Cylons until they started to have babies with them ...