News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by miroljub on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:05AM (#45799822)
Off-Topic: Why Türkiye? Why not keep using Turkey in English?

I know they changed their name to Türkiye, but why would we change it in our languages? We still use Germany instead of Deutschland, India instead of Bharat, and Italy instead of Italia.

So why make an exception for Turkey?

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by argestes on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:09AM (#45799879)
Yeah, I'm from Turkey and it's really annoying for me to use a keyboard shortcuts to select "Türkiye" from dropdowns using year old "T", "U", "R" keys. Now in some websites it's "Turkey" and in some websites it's "Türkiye" I need to switch keyboard layouts just to select my country name.

Even though, website doesn't let me use my actual name since my name has non ascii characters so I need to try many times.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by danhau on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:34AM (#45800180)
This reminds me of my own struggles in locating my country in various dropdowns. Sometimes it‘s the trivial to find Austria, but sometimes Österreich under O and other times Österreich under Ö (sorted to the very bottom). Collation is fun!
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by sigio on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:47AM (#45801125)
I feel your pain, looking at 'The Netherlands', 'Netherlands/Nederland', Holland, and even once 'Kingdom of The Netherlands'
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by yongjik on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:16PM (#45806494)
Greetings from Korea, aka South Korea, aka Republic of Korea.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:17PM (#45807121)
I’ve noticed that South Koreans often use the term “Korea” to refer to their country, and I’ve always been curious: are they referring to all of Korea, or only the south?

For example, which of these statements would you be more likely to use colloquially?

(a) Korea’s population is about 80 million, or (b) Korea’s population is about 50 million.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by yongjik on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:58PM (#45807558)
The term could refer to either South Korea or Korea as a whole, depending on the context. As for your example, I think people would agree with (b) because when you're talking about populations people implicitly assume we're talking about a country.

On the other hand, people say "Korea's history reaches back thousands of years," and obviously here "Korea" means Korea as a whole (the country of South Korea wasn't founded until 1948!).

It gets extra confusing for Koreans because North Koreans use a different Korean word for "Korea" (either North Korea or Korea as a whole) - they are from two different historical names. So we can't even agree on how to call ourselves. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @12:23AM (#45807660)
Thanks for the explanation!

> I think people would agree with (b) because when you're talking about populations people implicitly assume we're talking about a country.

Yeah, that makes sense, but the confusing part for me is that, at least if my understanding is correct, the South Korean government doesn’t legally recognize the partition of Korea. So they think all those 80 million people are rightfully citizens of their country (that is, the Republic of Korea), even though 30 million are temporarily subject to an illegitimate regime. But I’m not sure if people actually think like this in practice.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by yongjik on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @01:15AM (#45819835)
Well, yeah, constitutionally speaking, Republic of Korea is the only rightful government with sovereignty over the whole Korean peninsula (and if you go across the border, you will here the same in reverse, except they recently decided to change their stance to "there are two countries and we're not related at all!").

But everyone understands that this is a legal fiction. Despite mutual hostility, the two Koreas are somewhat relaxed about interpretation: for example SK doesn't object to other nations establishing diplomatic relations with NK, and vice versa.

Depending on who you ask, you'll hear different views on how to reconcile the law with reality, ranging from "there is only one rightful government, and a group of commie rebels we should destroy" to "we should accept that there are two different nations" to "South Korea is but a colony of American Imperialists!" But anyway, everyone accepts that practically there are two countries, so when we're talking about any contemporary matters, we're usually just talking about South Korea. (Unless we're specifically interested in North Korea.)

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by Yizahi on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:49AM (#45801164)
Funnily, the actual pronunciation is easier now, and it (to me) sounds 99% close to Turkia. I don't get why they went with such complicated letter sequence for such a straightforward word. Though both languages are not native to me, so I may be wrong. But I was baffled this year, after discovering that incomprehensible Türkiye is actually Turkia.

PS: I'm going from this this video as a basis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYjVIaZA14c

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:19PM (#45807134)
Türkiye in Turkish contains sounds that can’t be pronounced in English, and does not sound much like “Turkia”. The closest English approximate pronunciation (which is what you hear in that video) does sound pretty close to Turkia, though.

> I don't get why they went with such complicated letter sequence for such a straightforward word.

The spelling wasn’t invented recently, it’s just the standard word for Turkey in the Turkish language.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by jones89176 on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:07AM (#45799844)
"Following an official letter submitted to the United Nations by the Republic of Türkiye, the country's name has been officially changed to Türkiye at the UN.

UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric said that a letter had been received on June 1 from the Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Cavuşoğlu addressed to Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, requesting the use of “Türkiye” instead of “Turkey” for all affairs." [1]

"Foreign Minister Cavuşoğlu said in a tweet that the move would "increase our country's brand value".

The country’s English language public broadcaster TRT World said, the move would help to disassociate the country’s image from the large bird of the same name."[2]

[1] https://turkiye.un.org/en/184798-turkeys-name-changed-t%C3%B... [2] https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/turkey-or-turkiye-why-th...

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by beardyw on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:26AM (#45800089)
> help to disassociate the country’s image from the large bird of the same name.

So easily done - what? You are going to roast a whole country? You are going on holiday in huge bird?

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:09AM (#45799870)
So what? The UN does not have the power to redefine what words mean in the English language, and neither does the Republic of Turkey. If Germany submitted an official letter somewhere purporting to change its English name to Deutschland, you should also not listen to them.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by happytoexplain on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:43AM (#45800284)
Why the hostility? It's not like they changed the name of the Black Sea to the Sea of Turkey. It's not a "fuck you" move. Just keep spelling it the old way if you care for some reason.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @01:23PM (#45802390)
> Why the hostility?

Because the attempted name change is being done purely to stroke the ego of a right-wing authoritarian nationalist strongman. Attempts by such people to remake language according to their whims should be resisted whenever possible.

> It's not like they changed the name of the Black Sea to the Sea of Turkey.

I'm sure Erdogan would do just that if there were any realistic possibility that anybody would actually follow it. The "Türkiye" name change is as much as he thinks he can get away with.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by miroljub on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:20AM (#45800734)
Exactly my point. And it doesn't apply only to English. There are 200+ languages and 8+ billion people in the world, and none of them is obliged to change the way they talk because someone doesn't like what a specific word means in one of those languages.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by throw4r3w21a3 on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:38PM (#45806612)
You are free to use their old name, and others are free to use their new name.

You could even make up a name if you want.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by xg15 on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:48AM (#45800343)
Not sure if it's a trend already that some countries are trying to exert more control over their own names, but I noticed the same with Belarus a few years ago. It used to be called "White Russia" in german, but at some point, the name vanished from both press articles and official publications and was replaced with Belarus. According to Wikipedia, there was a german government decision to change the official usage of the name, co-initiated by the Belarusian government. (This was before the war, so I assume the relations weren't yet as icy as they are today)

https://dgo-online.org/informieren/aktuelles/belarusisch-deu...

https://web.archive.org/web/20210924060241/https://geschicht... (in German)

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by miroljub on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:21AM (#45800754)
Which is kind of funny, since Belarus means exactly Whiterussia.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by ozgung on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:25AM (#45800070)
As a Turkish person I used to agree with you. Not anymore. My people don't want to be associated with an ugly bird and I respect that. Also we don't want an exception. We're ready to use Bharat, Deutschland or any other name in our language if those nations want that. Same for the city names. It's about respecting those countries and their people.

Fun fact: India is Hindistan in Turkish which literally means Land of Turkeys. Maybe we should really change. Bharat means spice which is a better name.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by rafram on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:49AM (#45800365)
India's main official name is India. Bharat (from Sanskrit) is coequal according to the constitution, and Hindustan (from Persian) is also sometimes used.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @01:23PM (#45802395)
That's mostly because English is one of the two official languages of India, and even the local native languages (at least as spoken by the English-educated middle class) are heavily influenced by English. Similar to how the Philippines are just called the Philippines (or Pilipinas, the closest approximation that is pronounceable in Tagalog), rather than a native-language name.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by OutOfHere on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:48AM (#45800351)
Turkiye is okay but Türkiye is not (in English).
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by redwood on Monday November 03, 2025 @01:31PM (#45802507)
It's a great bird.. in fact Benjamin Franklin proposed that it be the American bird. The bald eagle was chosen for whatever reason over that
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:52PM (#45805435)
Funny… turkeys (the bird) are called “dinde” in French, which means “from India” and is short for “poule d’Inde”: chicken from India.

Guinea pigs are called “cochon d’Inde” which means “pig from India”. In fact they are neither from India nor Guinea.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by jstummbillig on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:10AM (#45799888)
Do we?

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?geo=US&q=T%C3%BCrki... (US)

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=T%C3%BCrkiye,Turk... (global)

Some noise in the global trend recently (any guesses?) but does not seem like a huge adjustment.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by Bolwin on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:29AM (#45800875)
The diacritics are a bit annoying to type but if they've asked to be called Turkiye why not call them Turkiye?
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by miroljub on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:37AM (#45800991)
What kind of authority do they have over my language?
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by happytoexplain on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:46AM (#45801110)
I don't understand why so many people are so quick to interpret things as some kind of boot on their neck. The official names of places change - they're proper nouns. Nobody is invoking authority to control how you write the names of places.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by Tadpole9181 on Monday November 03, 2025 @02:23PM (#45803247)
To be fair, Erdogen is a literal boots-on-neck dictator and this entire spectacle is just another distraction / demonstration of political capita he is using to cling to power.

Nor does it even make sense. All languages have names for countries, that are not the true names of those countries. Its normal. Especially when Turkey's desired diacritics can't even be typed on our keyboards. Is it reasonable for Israel to say we must type the name with Hebrew characters? And suddenly we have to guess WTF news agencies are talking about.

The point of languages is to be understood, this is making it harder to understand to appease some authoritarian loser.

If Turkey were offensive, that's one thing. But it's not and there's no reason for it.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by throw4r3w21a3 on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:45PM (#45806651)
They have no authority over the English language.

They do have the right to request a specific name when used in an organization in which they are a part.

You are free to use whatever name you want, while those in the UN, and organizations that cover the UN, will use the name Türkiye.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by rayiner on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:13AM (#45799926)
We're laying the groundwork to globally search/replace "India" to "Bharat."
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by Hemospectrum on Monday November 03, 2025 @12:06PM (#45801382)
Looking forward to my next long flight where I can watch movies about Bharatna Jones.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by drivingmenuts on Monday November 03, 2025 @12:04PM (#45801356)
Not an American news agency - they're probably following a European standard.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by TyrianPurple on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:10AM (#45799891)
You don't want to make the Sultan mad. If he gets mad, he won't sell you rare earths.

All jokes aside, I'm pretty sure both are still used. Non Turks still use Turkey.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by m101 on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:08AM (#45799859)
It's because Erdogan is in charge and he's throwing his weight around because he knows he holds the cards on a number of geopolitical issues.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by helsinkiandrew on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:10AM (#45799889)
Because they want to be known as Türkiye and have been actively requesting. The United Nations officially agreed to recognize the country's new name in 2022.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:12AM (#45799909)
The UN does not have the power to determine how the English language is spoken and written.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by SpicyLemonZest on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:07AM (#45800579)
They don't, and nobody's patrolling the Internet to smack people who say Turkey. But in many areas of the world, names of places can be intensely politicized, so organizations like the article source ("the energy dedicated portal that aims to deliver up-to-date news and analysis across the energy agenda in 20+ countries in Central and Southeastern Europe") prefer as a matter of style to conform to official pronouncements. If they'd been around in 2019, they would have talked a lot about "FYROM" or "the former Yugoslav republic of Macedonia": an incredibly unwieldly name, one that has probably never been used colloquially, but was necessary in order to avoid taking sides between Greece and the country now known as North Macedonia.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by throw4r3w21a3 on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:41PM (#45806635)
No entity has that power, but that was not the question.

The question was not who enforces country names, but instead, why major news publications are using the name Türkiye.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by csomar on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:09AM (#45799871)
I think they changed it in the UN or something. Theoretically their name never changed as most of their neighbors always called them Turkia.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by miroljub on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:24AM (#45800800)
Can you remind me which language is the official language of the country called UN? I'd like to pass a C1 UN-language test so I can apply for UN-citizenship.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by m00dy on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:06AM (#45799839)
Because we are born to be exceptional.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by 0xEF on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:09AM (#45799880)
Respect?

If the people of that nation want their nation called something specific, cool. If they want to adopt/use the Anglicized version of their country's name, also cool. It's up to the people in that country, I guess.

Plus, you know, gobble gobble.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:22AM (#45800029)
> It's up to the people in that country, I guess

No, it is not. How English is spoken is determined collectively by the community of English-speakers, not by the Turkish government.

There is also the pretty major issue that native English speakers cannot even pronounce "Türkiye", nor easily type it. That's why use an English word for it, not a Turkish word -- because we speak English, not Turkish.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by MentatOnMelange on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:11AM (#45800613)
As a native english speaker, personally I have zero problem with this change. If the Turkish government was actually demanding other languages change the name that'd be weird, but its a request not a demand.
Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by 0xEF on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:52AM (#45800386)
> There is also the pretty major issue that native English speakers cannot even pronounce "Türkiye", nor easily type it.

Skill issue. I don't speak Turkish either, but it takes all of two minutes to look up and learn the pronunciation and how to type an umlaut over a U with a simple alt code. I mean, come on. The Turkish government isn't asking everyone to convert to Islam and get to a conversational level with the language, just say their country's name how they think it should be said. If a nation can't even ask of the world to do such a simple thing without native English speakers getting bent out of shape over it, then it might be time for some serious self-reflection.

But hey, downvote away if it makes you feel any better.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:24AM (#45800791)
> I don't speak Turkish either, but it takes all of two minutes to look up and learn the pronunciation

I really doubt that you are pronouncing it correctly. The word Türkiye contains multiple sounds that don't exist in English.

If you don't actually speak Turkish, you are surely just using some Anglicized approximate pronunciation, and in that case, why not just use the actual English word?

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by 0xEF on Monday November 03, 2025 @01:37PM (#45802594)
You do know that you can learn to make new sounds with your mouth, tongue and vocal chords right? You are aware that just because a particular language does not use a phoneme that does not eliminate your ability to reproduce it? I have a lot of fun learning how to make sounds and pronounce things properly from different languages, my latest being Danish, which is proving difficult but certainly far from impossible. Perhaps you should try it, sometime?

Despite your otherwise quality contributions to HN, you're coming off as a bit insane here. I hope you understand that, which is why I will continue to badger my point; there is no reason they can't ask that people use their preferred name. None. The only thing you do by continuing to argue against that point is push your own Anglicize-all-the-things notion of the world, which is certainly not shared by all, not even remotely.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by umanwizard on Monday November 03, 2025 @03:18PM (#45803876)
> You do know that you can learn to make new sounds with your mouth, tongue and vocal chords right?

Of course. I speak French at a pretty high level (the accent has gotten worse from disuse but in 2007 most people in France couldn't tell I was foreign); nevertheless, when I say "France" (while speaking English), I pronounce it the American way, not the French way, because switching to a different language for one word in your sentence would sound silly.

And that gets to why the purported Türkiye change bothers me: it's not even really a different name; it's pretty much the same name, only pronounced and spelled in Turkish rather than in English. Most name changes are done for some more serious purpose, like to resolve a genuinely important political dispute (in the case of Macedonia becoming North Macedonia), to make the name better fit English place naming conventions and actually be easier to say in English (Czech Republic to Czechia), to assert independence by discarding a foreign name imposed by former colonial masters (Swaziland to Eswatini), or to switch away from a totally different name in a foreign language used by the people who used to live there centuries ago (Constantinople to Istanbul). Or they happened long enough ago that the new name is established and I can't muster the energy to resist it now (Burma to Myanmar).

None of these reasons apply to Turkey; the purported name change is just a demand that everybody start using Turkish sounds and letters for the same name. Given the ideology of the person calling for this change (Erdogan), I can only conclude that it's entirely driven by a puerile sense of nationalism: "let's prove how strong we are by forcing everyone to use our language, if only for this one word!" It sounds ridiculous when put that way, but Erdogan is indeed a ridiculous person.

> The only thing you do by continuing to argue against that point is push your own Anglicize-all-the-things notion of the world, which is certainly not shared by all, not even remotely.

Well, it doesn't really have to do specifically with anglicization. English-speakers should continue calling it Turkey, French-speakers Turquie, German-speakers die Türkei, and so on.

Edit: to be clear, if I ever meet a real Turkish person who actually cares about this, I'll probably call it whatever they prefer, at least around them, out of politeness. But this has yet to happen. Every Turkish person I know still just calls it Turkey in English.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by blueflow on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:10AM (#45799892)
The Germany/Deutschland/Alemannia/Niemcy situation is utter garbage and its existence is a curse upon this world, not justification to do it to other countries, too.

Türkiye is Türkiye because it self-identifies as such.

Re:Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA by xg15 on Monday November 03, 2025 @12:05PM (#45801370)
I think just for kicks some group should start lobbying for the US to be called "Columbia" again.