News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by imgabe on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:47AM (#45721599)
> noted that it would be harder to reach its internal target if its calculations included “secondary” use—water used in generating the electricity to power its data centres, according to the document.

Ok, when we're considering how much water a person uses, are we going to include the water used to grow the almonds you ate? Because agriculture is going to dwarf anything that data centers use.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by sxp on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:26AM (#45722053)
It put this in context, it takes about 1 gallon of water per 1g of almond [1]. And in California's dry climate, this water comes from groundwater that doesn't renew as fast as it's depleted. So the next time someone chastises you for your non-low flow showerhead that uses more than 2 almonds of water per minute, remember to put the numbers in context.

1. Numbers from a pro-almond group: https://www.almonds.org/why-almonds/growing-good/water-wise

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ricardbejarano on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:29AM (#45722092)
I don't know why, but the fact that a "pro-almond group" exists chuckled me up.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Ekaros on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:31AM (#45722114)
There is corruption for everything money touches...

I actually wonder if there is not single moderately sized industry that does not have some interest group...

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:43AM (#45722267)
Industry advocacy groups ≠ corruption.

They're basically necessary to do business in an advanced society that has rules governing every aspect of life. Those rules (even if good) often have unintended consequences and advocacy groups can help ensure that their industries are considered when rule-making.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by bitmasher9 on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:01PM (#45722530)
Lobbying as practiced by these advocacy groups is basically American flavored corruption. If the system were in place anywhere else we’d call it corruption, but it’s our system so we call it Lobbying.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by rcpt on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:03PM (#45723458)
Nah dude look at France and their farm owners
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by array_key_first on Monday October 27, 2025 @08:49PM (#45728148)
Yes but that ship has sailed, so now you need anti-corruption corruption to hopefully corrupt the corruption so it's less corrupt.

Like, the only reason "almond advocacy" even exists is because dairy and beef are some of the most lobbied and blessed industries in America. They can practically do whatever they want, whenever they want, so fuck you, pal.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by micromacrofoot on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:06PM (#45722609)
this assumes that the needs of both the workers and the owners (who pay for the lobbying) are aligned, and they're often not

lobbyists will advocate for taking the water right from under the noses of the workers, and the workers will turn around and praise their employer for maintaining their jobs... it's often some kind of perverse shell game

at the end of the day the owners fly off to wherever with a pile of money and the workers are left without jobs or water — these false dichotomies of "if it weren't for lobbyists all jobs would be regulated away" is often used to disenfranchise people from actually changing these systems

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:08PM (#45722628)
This assumes no such thing.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by micromacrofoot on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:57PM (#45723381)
You're right, it asserts it. Lobbying is not necessary, and in some other wealthy countries it would be considered bribery.

It only becomes advocacy when you take the money out of it.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:13PM (#45725103)
This is a Netflix-political-drama enthusiast's understanding of lobbying. Turn off House of Cards or whatever and try to build something.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by micromacrofoot on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:34PM (#45725324)
I've built enough things to know that you don't build understanding by insulting people. You seem to disagree with my position, but are unable to find the words to defend yours.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by hydrogen7800 on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:01PM (#45722529)
This sounds a bit sensationalized, and I'm not sure if it's the source from which I originally learned of the issue, but:

>In a series of secret meetings in 1994, the Resnicks seized control of California’s public water supply. Now they’ve built a business empire by selling it back to working people.

https://perfectunion.us/how-this-billionaire-couple-stole-ca...

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by voakbasda on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:47PM (#45723217)
When the water wars start, they will be the first against the wall.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by dylan604 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:41AM (#45722250)
If there is and you name it, the interest group will be formed.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by artursapek on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:43AM (#45722272)
Almond trees are stuck as almond trees forever. They can't switch to something else. Anywhere an investment in something is entrenched like this, you'll find lobbying.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mikrl on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:25PM (#45723807)
Is that the Almond Front of California, or the Californian Almond Front?
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @05:35PM (#45726595)
I'd non-ironically join that. Almonds are the bees knees. Almond milk is an atrocity though.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by daedrdev on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:54AM (#45722433)
Almonds alone are like half of all urban water use in california.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by daedrdev on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:01PM (#45724959)
More specifically, farming and urban use 50% of the water California gets (river outflows to the sea are the other main place water ends up) Urban use is 10% and farming is 40% of that total water input. Almonds alone are 7% of ALL water, almost as much as the 10% urban.

The level of subsidy the relatively unimportant crops get with their basically free water is astounding, especially considering the high urban prices of water

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:03AM (#45721793)
> are we going to include the water used to grow the almonds you ate?

Beef too. It uses the same amount of water but people eat 30x as much annually.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by rtaylorgarlock on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:20AM (#45721983)
And cheaper cow production, focused on grain-feeding, uses even more water than grass feeding; after spending a month in Switzerland, it's wild to see how addicted we Americans are to cheap beef.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by vjvjvjvjghv on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:21AM (#45721998)
We need our protein or we will die immediately.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by nradov on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:44AM (#45722296)
Ha ha, but seriously unlike other nutrients the human body can't really store protein reserves for any length of time. So you do need to keep taking in quite a bit every day or the body will break down muscle in order to sustain other tissues.

https://peterattiamd.com/rhondapatrick3/

The protein doesn't necessarily have to come from beef, although that is one of the highest quality sources in terms of digestibility (for most people) and essential amino acid balance.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by vjvjvjvjghv on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:20PM (#45725179)
You need protein for sure. But unless you want to win Mr Universe you will probably get enough through regular nutrition. And there are a lot of other things besides protein you need in your food. The current “Protein in everything” trend is just a fad created by industry
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by nradov on Monday October 27, 2025 @04:01PM (#45725612)
How much is "enough" exactly? Can you quantify that for us? There's a huge difference between enough to avoid acute malnutrition in a young person versus enough to optimize healthspan in an older person. Did you even listen to the podcast I linked above?

It is totally possible to get enough protein (by whatever metric you choose) through regular food. And yet the reality is that many people don't.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @06:01PM (#45726850)
> How much is "enough" exactly?

The upper limit seems to be 1g per lb (454g) of body weight. This is for people who lift heavy regularly to build and grow muscle. The lower bound is about 1/3 of that.

A 165 lb person needs about 55g of protein daily for maintenance. This is about one cup of black beans and 3 eggs. Huevos rancheros for breakfast will cover most or all of an average person's daily protein needs and that's before even counting the protein in the cheese or tomatoes.

While vegetables don't have much protein it still adds up. A single medium tomato has 1g, a potato has 3g, 1g in an onion, 0.5g in a carrot, and so on. Eat your daily portion of veggies and you can get maybe 10g of protein. That's nearly 20% of what you need!

Carb-heavy foods such as breads and rice also have some protein. More than veggies, less than lentils, eggs, dairy, and meat. A standard serving of pasta has 7g of protein. A cup of cooked brown rice has 5g.

All of this is to say even vegans who eat a healthy, varied diet are not deficient in protein. If they are ovo-lacto vegetarians it's a layup. They may need to supplement with whey and creatine or eat some chicken a few times a week if they want to squat 3 plates.

Insufficient protein is mostly not a problem in the first-world. The problem is eating crap. Eating grass-fed steaks every meal doesn't compensate for a crap diet.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by nradov on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:02PM (#45727371)
You're not accounting for protein quality and essential amino acids. You can't just add up grams. That's not how this works.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @08:39PM (#45728087)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_quality#Protein_source...

Lots of sources of complete protein on there besides beef. Don't limit yourself. A combination of quinoa, buckwheat, eggs, soy, pea, milk, whey, beans, and nuts will provide all the amino acids you need. Even beef, despite being a complete protein, is deficient in tryptophan.

I like meat. I'm not a militant vegetarian or vegan or anything like that. I dislike the laundering of people's love of eating meat as "essential for health", when it's anything but (special dietary needs aside). Eating meat is a mostly a choice.

I'll repeat again: varied diets are essential. A single protein source won't cut it. And most people get enough protein going just by raw numbers.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by nradov on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:14PM (#45728284)
I don't know why you felt the need to post that little rant. No one here claimed that people should only eat beef as their sole source of protein. You're arguing against a strawman.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:40PM (#45728409)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45722288

You've been pretty reasonable. Not everyone is.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by cthalupa on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:43PM (#45727688)
I'm very pro-protein - we just tend to see better metabolic health outcomes when we eat more of it. Diets with higher proportions of protein result in better body composition, less fat, less chance of diabetes, etc. I think the vast majority of people in America at least would be better off with higher protein diets.

But "Did you even listen to the podcast I linked above" is an insane thing to say in a random online conversation. No, you cannot expect people to listen to a whole podcast to make whatever random unsubstantiated point you have. Explain the important things you took away from the podcast and link it as a reference for if people disbelieve you for whatever reason.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:43AM (#45722265)
Do we need beef protein?

And also, what? You'll die if you don't eat meat today? That's news to all the world's vegetarians.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by artursapek on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:44AM (#45722288)
Yeah people who eat beef are actually healthier than vegetarians.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:13PM (#45722697)
This stands against the evidence. Beef is causally linked with the largest killers of Americans, including heart diabetes, diabetes, and obesity in general. "a mostly plant-based diet could prevent approximately 11 million deaths per year globally, and could sustainably produce enough food for the planet’s growing population without further damage to the environment." A "Mediterranean diet" is more healthy than the average American diet because it is more plant-based. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01406... https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/with-a-little-planning-v...
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:20PM (#45725176)
Beef is not causally linked to diabetes.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:54PM (#45727770)
There are proposed diabetic mechanisms which are exacerbated by cholesterol. Plant based food are completely devoid of cholesterol and have dramatically lower incidences of diabetes. So there you have a mechanism, and the demonstrable effect of abstaining from that source of food. What else do you want? https://diabetesjournals.org/diabetes/article/56/9/2328/1265... https://www.mdpi.com/2218-273X/13/2/224
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:04PM (#45734669)
A causal link.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by artursapek on Thursday October 30, 2025 @12:12PM (#45761646)
Grass fed beef is a plant based food :-)
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ben_w on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:59AM (#45722505)
The difference in life expectancy between the USA (where beef is heavily consumed) and India (where you may get lynched on suspicion of eating it) is 78.39 - 72 = 6.39 years at birth.

Most people attribute this difference to the GDP/capita ($89,600 vs. $12,132 PPP) or the number of doctors per capita (36.082 vs. 7.265 per 10k), not the diet.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Insanity on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:20PM (#45722790)
At the risk of stating the obvious, meat is not the only difference in diet.

But agreed that diet is also not the only link to longevity. Although a Mediterranean diet is higher on plant based foods, considered healthier, and those countries do have better life expectancy than USA.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by litenboll on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:55AM (#45722453)
Source?
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:48AM (#45722343)
Define "healthier".
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:47AM (#45722336)
"It's wild to see how Americans are able to procure an extremely high quality protein source inexpensively"
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by pas on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:03PM (#45722572)
without paying now for the externalities of its production
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by jspiral on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:23PM (#45722838)
how dare you, he spent a whole month in switzerland. what an exalted being
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by fainpul on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:51PM (#45723290)
It's pretty easy if you don't care about animal welfare and environmental issues. As soon as you care, prices go up steeply.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:19PM (#45725159)
American cows lead very good lives, up to including death. Better than pretty much any mammal on earth except for humans and 1st world pets.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by lotsofpulp on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:25AM (#45722036)
I wonder if cow milk products would be more expensive if people ate less beef.

Presumably, after a cow is done being used for milk, it can then be sold for meat.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by wikibob on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:30AM (#45722101)
Dairy cows don’t taste good. They’re used for the bottom of the barrel low grade ground meat. Think dog food.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by bryanlarsen on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:35AM (#45722174)
Old cows are generally very flavorful. They're more beefy and gamy than the young cattle we're used to eating. They're also stringy and tough.

So you wouldn't want an old cow steak, but a stew or burger made from an old cow can be awesome.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by christophilus on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:50AM (#45722386)
I guess it depends. I have a friend who has dairy cows, grass-fed, very well cared for. He names each one and hates to slaughter them, but when they are done producing, he does take them to the slaughter house. I bought a quarter of a cow from him a few years back, and it was excellent. It did have a hint of gaminess redolent of venison or lamb, but it was delicious.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by voakbasda on Monday October 27, 2025 @02:05PM (#45724335)
You are misinformed. I regularly eat our retired dairy cows. They taste absolutely excellent, but they were raised on pasture and ate top quality feed.

Dairy cows from commercial confinement dairies are a different matter. They eat almost exclusively grain and develop horrible health problems.

Yet the same can be said of any meat produced in a CAFO, when compared to that produced on most small farms. Garbage in, garbage out.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by davidw on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:29AM (#45722097)
My guess is that they have specialized breeds and how they're raised and fed and such, so that dairy cattle wouldn't make for good beef and vice versa. They probably do use them somehow, but maybe for dog food or some similar use.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by symbogra on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:37AM (#45722202)
As an american living in Switzerland its wild to see how scrawny most Europeans are due to lack of protein
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:43AM (#45722270)
They might just be normal weight people.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Chris2048 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:41AM (#45722241)
Did you miss a /s tag here?
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by meroes on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:49AM (#45722358)
It’s one of the things I noticed in France and Italy. Like after a few days you notice the mens’ silhouettes are alien. Not in a bad way, but noticeable.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Chris2048 on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:10PM (#45722651)
But due to lack of protein, vs less fat and sugar? I'm sure minus the fat, many American men would also lack muscle.

That said, Italy and France are known for smoking a lot, which supresses the appetite. Your original observation was swiss though (land of milk, chocolate and cheese)?

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by goopypoop on Monday October 27, 2025 @02:43PM (#45724759)
could be related to the "sexy Frenchman" stereotype
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by macinjosh on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:19AM (#45721976)
Beef is more nutrient efficient though and has better macros for human consumption. It has 4 times more protein, less fat, and no carbs. Seems to me at least Americans could do well to eat more beef and less products created from processed almonds mixed with refined vegetable oils and sugar.

Beef and milk are harvested ready to eat. Vegan substitutes are all highly processed. Processed food consumption is associated with greater cancer and diabetes risk.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:47AM (#45722322)
> It has 4 times more protein, less fat, and no carbs

Compared to an almond? Who the fuck eats almond steaks? It's a nonsensical comparison. If you want less fat and more protein per calorie, chicken beats beef. Chicken also has a lower water and carbon footprint.

> Vegan substitutes are all highly processed

Beans aren't "highly processed". Learn to cook and you'll understand that there are options besides processed food for vegetarians and vegans.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by WolfeReader on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:24AM (#45722031)
Factory-farmed beef is the worst source of pollution in the food industry. We definitely need less of that.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mikkupikku on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:23PM (#45722830)
"Factory-farmed beef" doesn't even exist. All cows get raised in fields for their first 12-18 months. The ""factory-farming"" is just a feed lot they get taken to for 3-6 months to eat grain before slaughter.

If you want to talk about pigs or chickens, that's an entirely different story. Those do get raised full life cycle in factory-like industrial facilities. But those aren't cows.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by wyre on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:29PM (#45723862)
You're going to have to cite strong sources or else this is either heavy cope or straight-up denial.

It is inconceivable that American's consume as much beef as they do, yet production has been able to scale without resorting to factory-farming. Every other commodity food is factory farmed. It's asinine to think beef is immune to that.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mikkupikku on Monday October 27, 2025 @02:11PM (#45724393)
Bro, get out of the city or just look at a map, America is absolutely enormous. There is no shortage of land to let cows graze on. Feedlots for cattle aren't even necessary at all, they're only used to increase profit.

What's really asinine is that you have such strong opinions about a subject you know nothing about and demand that other people do research for you.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by wyre on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:43PM (#45725424)
Cope harder, bro. Show me sources. Cattle is a massive industry and it should not be hard to find sources proving me wrong. Calves live on pasture for the first few months, but are then transferred to backgrounding farms, that are technically still pastures, but are fed a highly supplemented diet and have less room to roam. STFU about me not knowing what I'm talking about.

Feedlots are absolutely necessary at the levels that American's consume beef. It might look like there isn't a shortage of pasture for cows, but the truth is there is not enough land to transition to 100% grass-fed with American's level of consumption. [1]

[1] https://grazingfacts.com/land-use

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mikkupikku on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:24PM (#45734935)
> Calves live on pasture for the first few months, but are then transferred to backgrounding farms, that are technically still pastures, but are fed a highly supplemented diet and have less room to roam

Glad to see you finally looked it up and saw that I was right. Your attempt to save face is amusing though. From "factory farmed" to "the pastures are a bit small" is funny.

And no, feed lots aren't necessary. They make beef cheaper by making cows bigger, therefore making the industry more profitable, but if you did away with them Americans would still be eating enough beef to make urban vegan weenies seethe.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @05:34PM (#45726579)
You've never heard of free-range chickens?

I agree pigs are raised in abominable conditions.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mikkupikku on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:27PM (#45734977)
Not all pigs and chickens are "factory farmed" but most are. And unlike cows, the term is relatively meaningful and descriptive when applied to the way those are raised. Bro heard about how pigs and chickens get raised in tiny cages never seeing the light of day then assumed that's how it works for cows too, which he now realizes isn't the case because I shamed him into looking it up.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by gruez on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:20AM (#45721987)
Pork and chicken have better feed conversion ratios and water consumption
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by bryanlarsen on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:29AM (#45722084)
Cattle water consumption should be meaningless. If a cow is drinking water from a surface water source and breathing/sweating/peeing it out in a pasture, that's the same process that would be happening if humans didn't exist.

It isn't meaningless due to industrial farming. Chickens and pigs are even more likely to be industrially farmed than cattle are.

If we lowered our meat consumption by about 90% then we wouldn't need to industrially farm meat and the 10% would be much more ecologically justifiable.

Then the problem is that the soy we've replaced our meat with is industrially farmed...

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by hansvm on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:15PM (#45722728)
The problem is the assumption that cows (and other similarly intensive animals) would exist in the same quantity. You'd expect something like 5x less cow-like biomass without people intervening.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by triceratops on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:19PM (#45722776)
If humans didn't farm them there'd be far fewer cows alive and drinking water.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by bryanlarsen on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:33PM (#45723000)
And far more bison. Not the same, but similar.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by macinjosh on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:24AM (#45722027)
ok!
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by AstroBen on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:49AM (#45722364)
I highly recommend you read up on the actual research of what you're talking about. It points to the exact opposite of basically every sentence you wrote
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:48AM (#45722348)
Not all processed foods are created equal. Almost all of the elevated health risk from processed foods comes from processed meats and sugary drinks. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/06/well/eat/ultraprocessed-f... Whole grain breads are ultra-processed, and I don't think many are arguing against those. Beef has absolutely devastating effects on human health including elevated cancer risk, diabetes risk, dramatically higher incidences of heart disease (the greatest killer of Americans). Plant-based substitutes are scientifically shown to lead to better outcomes. Better yet, soy based whole foods are excellent for human health, contrary to the bro-science talking points. Turns out, beans are good for you! https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/the-bottom-line-on-ultra-proce... https://www.uclahealth.org/news/article/health-benefits-soy

This book is science, front to back, cementing the idea that animal products are not ideal for human health. https://www.amazon.com/Food-Revolution-Your-Diet-World/dp/16...

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by xboxnolifes on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:56PM (#45723358)
Only 30x? Y'all eat a lot of almonds.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by raxxorraxor on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:53AM (#45722418)
At least that is generally the case for calculating the ecological footprint of a person.

I am critical of this metric though, since the water isn't really lost in many cases. Especially if datacenters use water never meant for consumption.

If you look at it as a power generation problem it become much more plastic. That is of course as long as the water doesn't get expended in regions that lack it.

Although if you want to compare datacenter usage to agriculture, you could say that one is more essential than the other. Even if modern agriculture is a high tech industry that uses datacenters.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by LPisGood on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:55AM (#45722455)
I generally find criticism of water waste misplaced. Water’s lifecycle is cyclic. The water isn’t lost unless it is being salted or otherwise poisoned.

The real waste is the energy required to produce, clean, and transport the water that is being “wasted.”

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by pas on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:02PM (#45722549)
aquifers deplete, the water table lowers, wells dry up

sustainability, availability and maximum marginal price matters, just as with electric power generation

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by chemotaxis on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:41PM (#45723116)
Depletion of local water resources is a good thing to measure. But by and large, this is not what we're measuring. Instead, we're coming up with absurd statistics that imply any water put to beneficial use just disappears forever.

If your tap water comes from a river and flows back to a river, leaving it running mostly just wastes energy.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:03AM (#45721797)
Tangential to the point, I think we should be careful about the almond talking point. Insofar as it is used for milk, almond milk uses almost half as much water as dairy milk, uses 1/18 the land and emits 1/5 the amount of carbon. As food, it is eaten in such a vanishingly small quantity compared to other water-hungry foods (meat) as to be insignificant. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/environmental-footprint-m...
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by marcellus23 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:09AM (#45721879)
I thought the problem is that that growing almonds is usually done in arid regions, so the issue is not that it uses lots of water, but that it uses lots of water in areas that frequently experience droughts. This is an honest question (I truly don't know, although I suspect I can guess): are dairy farms also common in those areas?
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by lukeschlather on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:31AM (#45722110)
Just for a single point of comparison, California's alfalfa consumes 15% of the state's water. All that alfalfa is going to feed cattle. California only produces 9% of the USA's alfalfa so it's easy to say that this is a tremendous amount of water.

Almonds also consume 15% of California's water. But California produces 80% of the world's almonds. We're talking about an order of magnitude difference in water consumption, almonds are far more efficient and beef is both far more wasteful and far more common.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by thayne on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:09PM (#45722636)
World beef production is approx. 60x almond production by mass, and that doesn't include dairy. That isn't the whole story, because cattle use more water than just what is used to grow alfalfa, but you are comparing apples to oranges here.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by lukeschlather on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:30PM (#45722940)
I was drawing a point of comparison in response to the question about almonds disproportionately using scarce water resources in arid areas, which is a different question from overall water usage. My point was that almond water usage is literally only an issue in California, and that their water usage is not that extreme given the size of the market California serves.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by rcpt on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:05PM (#45723497)
You can check the per calorie stats.

Animal agriculture is wildly inefficient and honestly it's not surprising because you have to keep living moving animals around for it.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by mrguyorama on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:36PM (#45723033)
The comparison you are bringing up actually just gets to the heart of the issue.

California agricultural water is so fucking cheap, you can buy foreign land, start a farm, grow a bunch of grass, and ship it over to your country.

And that's cheaper than just growing grass locally.

That's insane

Most problems California has are the same: Systems that were initially designed and built a hundred or more years ago to support a state of like a hundred people, and an utter refusal to update those agreements because it would slightly inconvenience some really wealthy farms.

Growing Almonds and Alfalfa in California would be fine if they paid market rates for the water, and would therefore be more conscientious about using it and not wasting it, and that would dramatically improve the water situation of California and upstream places.

But it's way cheaper to pay for people to run absurd narratives on Fox News to make it a culture war issue so that you never have to care.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aux22FHTFXQ

The situation is so fucked up. It's a war of the rich against the richer. Wealthy farm corporations all have lobbying groups, and instead of lobbying for a more free market distribution of water, where they could have all they want as long as they pay for it, they run political campaigns to ensure California never reforms it's water rights system and continues to die of thirst while giving away 90% of it's water for rates decided 100 years ago. All the political agitation about water in California is over an absolute minuscule fraction of the water distribution, because actually fixing the problem would mean these farms paying market rates for water, which they do not currently do.

A microcosm of the US problem basically.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Yeul on Monday October 27, 2025 @04:39PM (#45726006)
Corporations never want to pay for the problems that they cause. They would rather go bankrupt and start a new company.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by rcpt on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:04PM (#45723471)
tbf some of the alfalfa is shipped to China it's not all used on cows here
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:40AM (#45722232)
Yes- about half of the total water siphoned from the Colorado river goes to cows. This number astounded me when I first read it, and I hope it has a similar effect on you. I don't like almond milk, for what it's worth, and I don't think we should ignore plant-based foods with a high climate impact, but animal agriculture is the most environmentally devastating institution we have individual power to transition from. https://www.npr.org/2024/09/09/nx-s1-5002090/colorado-river-...
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by HowardStark on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:31AM (#45722111)
It’s been some years but I recall that at one point probably around 2016-2017, California produced 80% of the world’s almonds. This was notable because at the same time, California was experiencing historic droughts.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by wongarsu on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:17AM (#45721951)
GP's point works just as well if you substitute almonds with diary milk or hamburger meat though. The specific water use of almonds is indeed completely tangential
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ilamont on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:12AM (#45721908)
Account created 10 minutes ago, hitting talking points of the almond growers industry association.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by litenboll on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:25AM (#45722042)
They are replying to talking points of the dairy industry.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by phs318u on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:18AM (#45721968)
Even if true, you’ve not countered a single point. Are there un-truths among those points? If so, let’s hear them.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Faelon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:37AM (#45722197)
I've read here for a long time but just made my account because I have been feeling very compelled by the data surrounding the huge economic effects of the animal agriculture industry and how otherwise pro-science and pro-data people find themselves with deeply entrenched unscientific viewpoints. Should I link my Google scholar to prevent people from seeing conspiracies everywhere??
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by hgomersall on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:09AM (#45721878)
Except that almond trees thrive in hot dry climates. Cows thrive in the rain.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by dylan604 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:54AM (#45722430)
But it's okay. This has been solved very recently as in last week. We are going to now be getting our beef from Argentina. Not only has the prices of beef issue been fixed, it'll also fix the country's water shortage issue as a bonus. /s
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by avalys on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:06AM (#45721831)
“Almond milk” is not milk. You know what else is less carbon-intensive than milk? Candy corn. But that is also _not milk_, and so equally irrelevant!
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by sixo on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:08AM (#45721855)
Almond milk is an economic substitute for dairy milk, making the comparison appropriate. No need to be dense about it.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ipsento606 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:31AM (#45722116)
Almond milk is not dairy milk, but it is absolutely "milk", in the sense of a white liquid derived from plants - a definition that has existed in English for hundreds of years.

The name "almond milk" has been used since at least the 1500s.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by zemvpferreira on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:09AM (#45721870)
I don’t drink ‘almond beverage’ but given the amount of uses it has substituting milk (and the amount of people that accept them) it seems like a very relevant comparison. Maybe I’m not sofisticated enough but I’m yet to see a candy corn mlik latte be ordered.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by jodrellblank on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:28AM (#45722076)
> I’m yet to see a candy corn mlik latte be ordered.

Not exactly the same, but can I interest you in a caramel-waffle-oat-milk latte?

https://mightydrinks.com/cdn/shop/files/Barista-CW.png

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by zemvpferreira on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:21PM (#45725185)
You certainly can sir!
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by throwaway-42808 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:23AM (#45722022)
But that's such a good idea though
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ben_w on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:47AM (#45722325)
> “Almond milk” is not milk. You know what else is less carbon-intensive than milk? Candy corn. But that is also _not milk_, and so equally irrelevant!

While almond milk is an incomplete substitute for bovine mammary secretions, it is so much closer than candy corn that it has been used as a substitute for the last 800 or so years, and shared the "milk"-ness in the name before we had an English language:

  The word “milk” has been used since around 1200 AD to refer to plant juices.
- https://www.ift.org/news-and-publications/food-technology-ma...

This makes this use of the word older than English people spelling the thing chickens lay as "eggs" rather than "eyren": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZ5znvym68k

The Romans called lettuce "lactūca", derived from lac (“milk”), because of the milky fluid in its stalks: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/lettuce

Similar examples abound.

For example, I grew up in the UK, where a standard Christmas seasonal food is the "mince pie", which is filled with "mincemeat". While this can be (and traditionally was) done with meat derivatives, in practice those sold in my lifetime have been almost entirely vegetarian. The etymology being when "meat" was the broad concept of food in general: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincemeat

Further examples of this: today we speak of the "flesh" and "skin" of an apple.

Personally, I don't like almond milk. But denying that something which got "milk" in its name due to it's use as a milk-like-thing, before our language evolved from cross-breeding medieval German with medieval French, to argue against someone who said "Insofar as it is used for milk", is a very small nit to be picking.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by AstroBen on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:58AM (#45722486)
I mean I'm drinking a coffee with almond milk right this second.. which coincidentally replaced the dairy milk

Candy corn in my coffee wouldn't taste anywhere near as good

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ribosometronome on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:41PM (#45724024)
I think the almond talking point takes hold because, like a lot of complaining about LLM usage, large parts of the blame gets directed elsewhere rather than the choices that we're all way more likely to be making and could influence. Like, it's 2025. Even the people most likely to be drinking almond milk have largely moved to oat, whose water usage is great.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by wyre on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:55PM (#45724204)
Almond's get brought up because it distracts from the fact that beef and dairy milk production uses a lot more water than almonds do.

No one wants to be reminded that their 4 oz burger they had for lunch used 460 gallons of water to produce.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by 827a on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:32AM (#45722135)
Yes: my understanding is that it’s rather common practice to at least make a best-effort estimation of all these secondary impacts.

It’s also absolutely true that “agricultural usage dominating data center usage” is a dirty little secret that a lot of people are very, very incentivized to keep secret. Amazon can’t outright say that, because uh whutabuht mah poor farmers.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:44AM (#45722285)
Farmers?? What about my mah poor stomach? I have to eat and I assume you do too.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by 827a on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:20PM (#45723735)
Sure, but:

1. Farmers oftentimes make zero effort to reduce their water usage. There's water reduction strategies they could employ, if they cared, but instead the vast multi-farm conglomerates invest their efforts in securing below-market, oftentimes monopolistic, control over water rights in their area, so they can use use an excess amount. Meanwhile, data center operators are (rightly) expected to engineer extremely sophisticated multi-millions of dollar systems to reduce their usage by even single digit percentages; an amount that some farms might consume in just one day.

2. Not all crops are built the same. Some, we rightly question "why are we growing this". Almonds are the canonical example; they consume utterly insane amounts of water, and the end result is: Almonds. A non-critical food that sits in some back corner of your grocery store. But, farmers like them because they sell for magnitudes more per pound than the more staple crops; its niche produce like almonds that can be the difference between a farm being profitable and unprofitable each year.

3. Many regions in the US have a climate that is just close enough to being able to grow things, like Alfala and Rice, year-round, so long as you utterly drench them in artifically-sourced water during the dry season when we shouldn't otherwise be able to grow them. There's a massive difference in natural sustainability of the seasonal farms in, say, the American midwest, versus the year-round industrial mega-farms of California.

Having grown up around farms my whole life: More people need to realize that the aw shucks poor farmer routine is just a play these usually extremely wealthy people use to justify any greedy, shitty behavior they can. Monopoly on water rights? Oh, so you want to starve? Yeah that's what I thought, as they sip a $400 bottle of wine in Nappa. Farms are quite possibly the most subsidized industry in all of America; while near-universally all farmers will fight tooth and nail for the elimination of subsidies and handouts for everyone else, if you even insinuate you'll take away their handouts, its war and "you're all going to starve" because you "don't appreciate farmers". They complain about America outsourcing all of its labor to other countries, while farming itself has become one of the most automated, labor-eliminating industries in the country, massive mega-conglomerate farms are now ran by three people piloting remote tractors and drones from their barn.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:10PM (#45725051)
This is a long rant about your perception of farmers which puts your hate and condescension of them on full display.

Idk (and idc) if it's a personal or political thing but either way I'm not engaging further.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ribosometronome on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:38PM (#45723990)
You don't have to eat everything.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by goopypoop on Monday October 27, 2025 @02:50PM (#45724825)
hey pal this is america
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by ponow on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:21PM (#45723760)
Categorical rejection of alternatives is premature without context.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by tracker1 on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:51PM (#45727754)
This also tends to include the rainwater that falls on the ground to grow the grass that cattle eat that would fall on the grass anyway, or that the cow farts aren't really more greenhouse emissions than the grass rotting out over the summer anyway. It's distortive.

IMO, water is a renewable resource and what should count is the use of water in scarce environments from scarce sources directly in excess of what gets renewed. If you're right by the Mississippi river and often see flooding in your region, I don't think using the water for cooling a reactor (steam as the byproduct) is necessarily something that should be considered a negative... it'll come back down as rain somewhere.

I'm not sure why Amazon is "using" so much water, assuming their cooling systems are a closed loop... otherwise, if using evaporation for cooling, like a reactor, it depends on the location, source and usage. "it's complicated"

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by 827a on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:58PM (#45728815)
> assuming their cooling systems are a closed loop

My understanding is that the closed-loop systems are rather new; like, "we started using these things in 2024 literally because everyone's been moaning about our AI water usage" new. I'd assume that many new constructions are starting to leverage them, but its not 100%, and existing DCs would be slow to upgrade.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by jppittma on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:20AM (#45721989)
That's a fair point. If you want to calculate the real total water usage of any person, you must first invent the universe. You have to cut it off somewhere.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by whatever1 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:11AM (#45721895)
Like the emissions we can have various scopes and different targets per scope.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by elygre on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:07AM (#45721843)
It sounds like we know the water usage for growing almonds.

It feels reasonable that we should have the same detail of information for data centers.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by RA_Fisher on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:29AM (#45722086)
> are we going to include the water used to grow the almonds you ate?

That’s a good idea. Like nutrition facts but for everyday economic climate decisions.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by yapyap on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:50AM (#45722382)
> Because agriculture is going to dwarf anything that data centers use

Will it though

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Chris2048 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:49AM (#45722374)
What does that mean though: "water used"? The only actual use of "water" is an E = mC^2 conversion to raw energy, or a chemical/location change such that it's locked-up/removed from availability permanently.

The water normally continues to exist, so presumably it's some other resource we are using. This may seem pedantic but it's not - raw groundwater, or unprocessed grey water is not potable as in "water a person uses" for drinking, which is a subset of the water a person uses overall (directly in showers etc, or by proxy in bought products, building materials etc).

In each case, water is more of a "carrier" for some other resource or property. If in CA the almonds go through a lot of water (is this due to perspiration? i.e. their cooling mechanism?), the water will still create clouds that I presume increases rainfall elsewhere? In fact, the water now holds more energy (from solar) that might be useful somehow.

Similar comments around "land usage", entirely depends on opportunity loss otherwise.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by jasonlotito on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:10AM (#45721880)
We can. We do. It depends on what you are trying to count. If you think there is a single number that will answer everything, no. Are you going to include all the water ancestors used? After all, without that water, I wouldn't be here.

You seem to think there is only one way to count. That's completely wrong. The important thing is whether you are clear about what you are counting and why.

Your comment is odd. But let me be the first to give you permission to count things how you want. Just make sure you explain the criteria and reasoning. Have a good day.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by imgabe on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:22AM (#45722011)
There is an honest way to count and that is to count the water directly used by the person or process in question. There are many other ways to count to make big scary number for clickbait article. I suppose we could also count all the water used by data center employees to take showers as "data center water usage" but that is dishonest. Those are people who exist and they are going to take showers whether they work at the data center or not.

Likewise, the power company is going to generate electricity regardless of whether a data center is there or not. The power company has various means of generating electricity available which use more or less water. The amount of water used in generating electricity is attributed to the power company, not the data center.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by iepathos on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:43PM (#45723143)
Kind of surprised I have to point this out. Power companies do not generate the same amount of power regardless of whether that power would be consumed on their grid or not. They increase generation based on demand. Whether that power comes from high water consumption generation is based on location which determines which power sources are available in the local grid. A major part of why indirect water consumption from power generation is included in the standard WUEsource - water usage effectiveness metric - is because it makes it clear what the impact will be when assessing data center location and size. In other words, it's important to choose locations near power generation that doesn't consume water heavily. Yes, the amount of water used in generating electricity and the efficiency there is controlled power companies choices for power generation at their locations. Data centers control the location they are built in and without an estimate of indirect water usage they cannot strategize locations with lower environmental impact.

Contrary to your belief that it is about clickbait, it's actually just about how to accurately evaluate environmental impact of data centers backed by science and basic logic.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by imgabe on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:19PM (#45723714)
A power company builds a generation plant of a certain size. That plant is going to run whether there is a data center or not. Maybe there is some incremental additional water usage if it is running at 85% capacity instead of 75% capacity but this is probably marginal compared to the plant running or not running at all.

Depending on the method of power generation, it might also need a certain consistent base load to run most efficiently, so adding in a data center that will be a consistent load running 24/7 could actually increase the efficiency.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by user3939382 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:26AM (#45722050)
Oh right are almonds actively extracting money from you because their business model is exploitative?
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by thayne on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:22PM (#45722825)
Does Amazon control the generation of this electricity? If so, then I definitely think it should be included, because it is something that Amazon has control over, and could possibly reduce water use.

If it is the power company, then the relevant metric is the amount of power consumed, as it would be up to the power company to find a more water-efficient way to produce power.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by didibus on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:24PM (#45722854)
I find this loses the point, because agriculture is essential. If we preserve water it's because we want to keep enough of it for essentials like agriculture and such. Not that agricultural practices shouldn't better conserve water, but it's the usage of water for non-essential things that I think most people find wasteful.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by CamperBob2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:32PM (#45722984)
It's not essential that almonds be grown in California.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Finnucane on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:52PM (#45723304)
I'd rather have the almonds than another data center.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by amelius on Monday October 27, 2025 @12:56PM (#45723360)
OK but rain water != tap water.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by CGMthrowaway on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:01PM (#45723424)
It's not rainwater. (it's not tapwater either)
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by rcpt on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:01PM (#45723429)
Knee jerk reaction for me every time I see "almonds"

One gallon of cow milk uses more water than one gallon of almond milk.

Re:Amazon strategised about keeping water use secret by Clent on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:21PM (#45723751)
Almond milk is 2% almond. Cow milk is 100% cow milk.

An gallon of raw almonds requires a massive amount of water.

Using numbers to create illusions of comparison is the marketing equivalent of parsley in your tooth.