Money-printing does destroy the economy on a lag, specifically when the production has such catastrophic shortfall that it shows itself to be ponzi without tangible value or benefit. Value being based entirely in human action.
When that happens, its basically slave labor silently extracted from the population through inflation. Such things historically always trigger other cascading failures.
Indeed, the scale matters a lot. With that said, a ponzi always has beneficiaries.
> Such things historically always trigger other cascading failures.
With the help of war or without, it's up to the beneficiaries.
All the parasites ended up dying in that book when all the intelligent people decided to just step back and let natural human tendency and the momentum they created do what it was always going to do. All those people were deluded into thinking they could just make a law without paying respect to the mechanics that made things work. Ayn Rand though is also quite deluded in that her ideas don't work without eliminating inheritance and money-printing.
Slavery is intolerable in any form.
the capacity built for AI will remain even if AI gets written down, which means cheaper energy and datacenter stuff in that case for "the rest"
if AI makes as much money as these valuations assume then it means productivity increased and growth did happen
By the same argument, I don't think it's right to say without AI, GDP growth would be flat. That cash would likely go into other investments.
The question is if AI will make a return on the investment or not.
I think the comparison to stock buybacks is ludicrous.
Evidence?
Perhaps depends on what you mean with "ecosystem". Within the AI tech/hype, sure, there it's good. But for the economy as a whole? Is it that good? There are probably some benefits, but do they match the current valuations?
Most likely they don't, because hype cycles inherently overvaluate things for a while because they don't know what will stick. If things were not dramatically overvalued right now then investors would not be acting in their best interest.
Will it match a certain valuation within a certain time period? I guess I don’t really care, I’m not an investor.
[1] https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/operations/our-insight...
I love the way I keep getting downvoted on HN whenever I say anything about a subject about which I know a lot more about than the average person here (usually investment and finance).
In your comment I’m replying to, the first paragraph contributes meaningfully to the discussion; the second sounds a bit like lashing out, which might be why people react negatively.
That's the inherent nature of these voting based online platforms. They reward what the user base wants to hear over what is correct. This is especially apparent in matters with inherent nuance and uncertainty.
I also didn't say that the money disappear, I said the money may just end up getting parked in the modern day equivalent of dragon hoards. There's plenty of things to park idle money in hopes of returns.
I was just pointing out that the idea thaf it would just become investment in other parts of the economy is naive.
> I love the way I keep getting downvoted
I hadn't downvoted you, but I will do so now. I always downvote people that are butthurt about internet points.
You miss the point. What does the person who sold the assets in which the money is "parked" do with it? If they buy a bonds what does the seller of the bonds do with the money? Leave it in a bank account? The bank will lend the money to someone who will either spend the money (stimulating the economy) or reinvest it. They might buy another asset. If that asset is newly issued shares or bonds, the money will then go to a company planning to reinvest it. Anything else and it just pushes it another step to another person.
Eventually it goes back into the economy.
> I was just pointing out that the idea thaf it would just become investment in other parts of the economy is naive.
The naive assumption is that "parked" money somehow leaves the economy. its "parked" from the point of view of the person making the investment, but it has to go somewhere.
> I hadn't downvoted you, but I will do so now. I always downvote people that are butthurt about internet points.
How mature and charmingly expressed!
My point is that there is a lot of Dunning–Kruger in HN discussions of economics and finance.
I miss no point. I understand quite well that "parked money" still exusts. What you ignore is that value is sometimes "destroyed". Investiments that underperform or go in the red, loans that default, crashes in real estate, etc. if money is invested in stocks, and the stocks value go in freefall, the nominal amount of money that existed previously in the economy is the same, and everyone is still poorer because of it.
The massive AI hype is massively pumping a bull run in a very small sector of the economy (if this is a bubble is not something I can answer). A lot of money is moving around around a small subset of companies pumping revenues of one another in a circular fashion, which increases the value of those stocks (thus creating economic growth, real or otherwise). Without this mechanism, this value wouldn't have been created. It's anyone's guess how things would perform without it.
During a crash, the same amount of money that existed prior to the crash is still there. The crash still happens and the country can still go into recession.
> How mature and charmingly expressed!
Thank you. I, too, think I am mature and charming.
You also failed to understand that money put into an investment has to go somewhere pretty much immediately. If someone defaults on a loan they must have used the money, so someone else has it, so it is still not destroyed.
I explicitly did not talk about AI being a bubble.
You may understand of economics (at least you say so). But reading comprehension is not your forte.
> a subject about which I know a lot more about than the average person here
True or not, expressing it like that is just arrogant.
Did they park it in bonds over the past 10 years? I doubt it. Interest rates were ~0, VC funding was crazy, the money taps were open. They would have been less open without these buybacks.
It's not necessarily 1:1, it seems people are more willing to spend the cash on AI than they were on other things. But it's not 1:0 either.
In that way AI is 1000% better than crypto or real estate speculation.
Here's a though experiment. If you could invest today in a company that will result in the destruction of your town (say a mining company) but you got 1% higher return compared to others, you're saying that's a perfect investment and would do it right away?
And if the answer is yes to the above, you can make that a lot darker if you want. See how far your belief goes.
If you look at how the money people behaved since always, that's exactly what would happen.
Society works by balancing the interests of various groups, and there will be people with different opinions than yours, including some you don't like.
Then make them! I don’t have the confidence you have in this “scam”. For sure the valuations are inflated but I don’t think this infrastructure investment will be a waste.
How is new housing supply to arrive?
And AI is not "the small groups of people". It is a revolution, comparable to printing press and internet.
People have the same password across services. They share personal information. In a geopolitical climate as today's, where the currency of war is disruption, it can wreak havoc.
I'm just waiting for the slop to be so metastasized that our terminally ill "social networks" finally die, alongside with it.
Of course i'll be proven terribly wrong. But hey. hope.
In my opinion AI makes visible more structural issues that were always there, but we could ignore. People addicted to various stuff (being substances or social networks or watching sports), social communities disappearing (no more going to the pub, stay at home with your TV), growing inequality (because capital is not taxed as labor), strange beliefs (all the conspiracy theories, which existed before) and others.
Find a use for the new tool to improve the situation if you can, but I think that hating tools can lead you on dark paths.
I'm really struggling with this one. I think AI (generative and not) is surely fascinating. I should by rights be all up in it. I could definitely get it, I don't think I'm stupid in terms of technology. Regardless of the damage the laser-focus on one thing might (or might not) be doing to rest of industry (and the effect on society, which to be honest, I am conflicted on if we can blame the technology). And yet so much of it is all so...tedious and fake somehow, and just even keeping up with headlines is exhausting let along engaging with every LinkedIn "next huge thing that if you don't do you should find a bridge to live under soon".
It's like that guy who tells you constantly how rich and cool he is. Bro, if you're that cool, let your cool speak for itself. But I'm not sure I want to lend you a grand for your new car.
They would just as likely hoover up housing around the country or some such insanity to capitalize on the scarcity.
VC is actually a pretty effective vehicle to separate rich people from their money so society can try crazy things. You just don’t agree with this particular adventure and frankly there will never be the perfect alternative adventure.
I’m saying letting them go to space or turning sand into intelligence is infinitely better than buying land and charging us rent (what most rich people have done in history).
> They would just as likely hoover up housing around the country or some such insanity to capitalize on the scarcity.
Another core issue in a hyper-financialised economy, the money doesn't get invested in what would be best for society, it keeps chasing either risky endeavours or parked in presumed safe assets (such as housing), inflating away asset classes. Where are the incentives to invest in foundational areas which do compound to make a society have resilient growth, like infrastructure: energy, transportation, etc.? It feels like without government direction to spend in big projects there's simply no appetite from the private, hyper-financialised, system to do the work, unless there's potential to get 10-100x returns. Is that good for society at large?
If hyper-financialisation is not helping the overall economy, and society to become better, why the hell should we still (in the Western world) pursue that? If all it can do is increasingly chase the extremes: hyper-growth vs extremely safe assets, is it any good anymore?
At least in the American context everything from California High Speed rail to bloated defense spending has shown that VC’s are much better shepherds of their own money.
It was designed to lose this ability, and to lean onto private enterprises to do anything but in the past the government was able to rollout highways, go to the moon, build dams, bridges, power plants.
If both the government and VCs are now unreliable to shepherd capital to direct it to the improvement of society at large you might need to rethink the whole system, and work to nudge it into a better path.
But in general, there is a lot of extremely fascinating stuff, both to exploit and explore, for example in the context of traditional (non-transforeme-based) ML/DL methods. The methods are getting better year by year, and the hardware needed to do anything useful is getting cheaper.
So while it's true that after the initial fascination developers might not be that interested in GenAI, and some even deliberately decided not to use these tools at all in order to keep their skills fresh and avoid problems related with constant review fatigue, many tech folks are interested in AI in a wider context and are getting good results.
There is so much framework stuff, when I started coding I could mostly concentrate on the algorithm, now I have to do so much framework stuff, I feel like telling the LLM really only the actual algorithm, minus all the overhead, is much more "programming" than today's programming with the many many layers of "stuff" layered around what I actually want to do.
I find it a bit ironic though that our tool out of the excessive complexity is an even more complex tool, although, looking at biology and that programming in large longer-running projects already felt like it had plenty of elements that reminded me of how evolution works in biology, already leading to hard or even impossible to comprehend systems (like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18442637), the new direction is not that big of a surprise. We'll end up more like biology and medicine some day, with probabilistic methods and less direct knowledge and understanding of the ever more complex systems, and evolution of those systems based on "survival" (does what it is supposed to most of the time, we can work around the bugs, no way to debug in detail, survival of the fittest - what doesn't work is thrown away, what passes the tests is released).
Small systems that are truly "engineered" and thought through will remain valuable, but increasingly complex systems go the route shown by these new tools.
I see this development as part of a path towards being able to create and deal with ever more complex systems, not, or only partially, to replace what we have to create current ones. That AI (and what will develop out of it) can be used to create current systems too is a (for some, or many, nice) side effect, but I see the main benefit in the start of a new method to deal with ever more complexity.
I only ever see single-person or -team short-term experiences of LLM use for development. Obviously, since it is so new. But one important task of the tooling will only partially be to help that one person, or even team, to produce something that can be released. Much more important will be the long-term, like that decades-long software dev process they ended up with in my link above, with a lot of developers over time passing through still being able to extend it and fix issues years later. Right now it is solved in ways that are far from fun already, with many developers staying in those teams only long enough, or H1Bs who have little choice. If this could be done in a higher level way, with whatever "AI for software dev" will turn into over the next few decades, it could help immensely.
I was wondering about this a lot. While it's a truism the generalities are always useful whereas the specific gets deprecated with time, I was trying to get down deeper on why certain specifics age quickly whereas other seem to last.
I came up with the following:
* A good design that allows extending or building on top of it (UNIX, Kubernetes, HTML)
* Not being owned by a single company, no matter how big (negative examples: Silverlight, Flash, Delphi)
* Doing one thing, and being excellent at it (HAproxy)
* Just being good at what needs to be done in a given epoch, gaining universality, building ecosystem, and just flowing with it (Apache, Python)
Most things in JS ecosystem are quite short-lived dead ends so if I were a frontend engineer I might consider some shortcuts with LLMs because what's the point of learning something that might not even exist a year from now? OTOH, it would be a bad architectural decision to use stuff that you can't be sure it will be supported in 5 years from now, so...
No, I'm talking about core principles.
You just can't go on being incredibly specific. We already tried other approaches, "4th gen" languages were a thing in the 90s already, for example. I think the current kind of more statistical and NN approach is more promising. The completely deterministic computing is harder to scale, or you introduce problems such as seen in my example link over time, or it becomes non-deterministic and horrible to debug because the bigger the system you other things dominate more and more.
Again, this won't replace smaller software like we write today, this is for larger, ever longer lasting and more complex systems, approaching bio-complexity. There is just no way to debug something huge line by line, and benefits of modularization (and separation of the parts into components easier to handle) will be undermind4ed by long-term development following changing goals.
Just look at the difference in complexity of software form a mere forty, or twenty years ago and now. The majority of software was very young, and code size was measured in low mega-bytes. The systems explode in size, scale and complexity, and new stuff added over time is less likely to be added cleanly. Stuff will be "hacked on" somehow and released when it passes the tests well enough, just like in my example link which was for a 1990s DB system, and it will only get worse.
We need very different tools, trying to do this with our current source code and debugging methods already is a nightmare (again, see that link and the work description). We might be better off embracing more fuzzy statistical and NN methods. We can still write smaller components in more deterministic ways of today.
The terminology of AI has a strong link with LLMs/GenAI. Quite reasonable.
As for code/architecture/infrastructure I like those things too. You do have to shape your communications to the audience you are talking to though. A lot of the products have eliminated the demand for such jobs, and its a false elimination so there will be an overcorrection later in a whipsaw, but by that time I'll have changed careers because the jobs weren't there. I'm an architect, with 10+ years of experience, not a single job offer in 2 years with tens of thousands of submissions in that time.
If there is no economic opportunity you have to go where the jobs are. When executives play stupid games based in monopoly to drive wages down, they win stupid prizes.
Sometime around 2 years is the max time-frame before you get brain drain for these specialized fields, and when that happens those people stop contributing to the overall public parts of the sector entirely. They take their expertise, and use it for themselves only, because that is the only value it can provide and there's no winning when the economy becomes delusional and divorced from reality.
You have AI eliminating demand for specialized labor that requires at least 5 years of experience to operate competently, AI flooding the communication space with jammed speech (for hiring through a mechanism similar to RNA interference), and you have professional certificate providers retiring all benefits, and long-lasting certificates that prove competency on top of the coordinated layoffs by big tech in the same time period. Eliminating the certificate path as a viable option for the competent but un-accredited through university.
You've got a dead industry. Its dead, but it doesn't know it yet. Such is the problem with chaotic whipsaws and cascading failures that occur on a lag. By the time the problem is recognized, it will be too late to correct (because of hysteresis).
Such aggregate stupidity in collapsing the labor pool is why there is a silent collapse going on in the industry, and why so many people cannot find work.
The level of work that can be expected now in such places because of such ill will by industry is abyssal.
Given such fierce loss and arbitrarily enforced competition, who in their right mind would actually design resilient infrastructure properly; knowing it will chug away for years without issue after they lay you off with no intent towards maintenance (making money all that time).
A time is fast approaching where you won't find the people competent enough to know how to do the job right, at any price.
Not true. With this much money and more coming it means other roles will benefit too. The whole tech sector will grow - maybe less than AI specific, but still.
It's better than the alternative of no or negative growth.
Some comments assume the funds exist and will be spent elsewhere in the US or the markets they refer to but maybe not. If no AI, US funds could invest in Vietnam (that is receiving a FTSE market upgrade), China, EU or just about anywhere else.
Don't assume you'd benefit by wishing AI to begone. When you wanted crypto to go away you got AI.
I can't imagine how great/amazing it must be there now with AI being 17x that. Everyone where I live is financially stressed. Living in a community that isn't would be so nice. I am sure people in the bay area would miss this current feeling of prosperity/success/optimism to start a family if the bubble burst.
Maybe without the AI it'd be worse? COVID over-hiring lingered for a long time. A lot of the layoffs were due to that. Perhaps without AI and the over-supply for workers things could have crashed.
I don’t think hyper growth bubble vs economic depression are the only two options.
So I'm nitpicking here, but this seems to me to be an important nitpick: This is not true because money circulates.
The distinction is, one should not stop looking at only the first level effects, but the entire fields the money streams flow through.
It remains true that money flows in specific areas, but it is on a higher level than only the immediate first level spending, so the analysis has to be different too.
This is not about the body or the land, but about the blood or the water flowing through them.
Because it describes exactly the point which GGP tried to make (source: that was me). The assumption is that AI growth is great because without it, look at how low the non-AI growth is! But that argument is flawed because the resources (manpower, materials, manufacturing, energy, ...) absent the AI hypr would not vanish but be used for something else, so the growth in those other areas would be bigger. Granted, perhaps not as big (marginal gains and all that), but the painted picture is still skewed.
> since investor money is spent exactly once
In addition, I even pointed out that I was not posting about the main argument!
Quoting myself, again:
> So I'm nitpicking here
Eh... No?
The money flows on pretty quickly, unless they keep it as cash under their mattress.
Are you confusing it with any possible effects or work performed?
> generating enough returns
Ah I see the confusion.
No, they don't have to wait for "returns". We are talking about THAT money, the exact investor money they got. Which they will spend again. Even if they just keep it at the bank, it will be available to that bank to do something with.
The fate of that business does not matter, all that matters is that the investor money they took is going to continue to flow, outwards from them to whomever the company pays with that money. And so does everybody else.
The flow only stops when the money is lying around somewhere, and since that's the bank then at least the bank can do something with it. The flows truly stop when the whole economy is going down, when everybody cuts back on spending, and investments dry up too, so that the money is truly just lying around and nobody wants it.
Let's say this investment then raises the market cap of the company that was invested in by $5-10B. Loans are then taken out against that $5-10B of increased market cap. If the growth never materializes, then the investment ends up underwater and there's secondary effects that make the loan worth less than what was given; this is what the credit worthiness is supposed to measure, but with hyperinflated values and lots of money as collateral these loans are given great rates. Basically what ends up happening is extra virtual currency starts circulating mirroring the increased market cap due to that initial $1B investment. But if the return on investment doesn't materialize, this $5-10B of currency just vanishes into thin air and dwarfs the original $1B investment. Additionally, there's leveraged secondary and tertiary bets that get taken out that further magnify this circulating currency and magnifies the loss if things don't work out.
This is precisely what happened in the dot com and banking crises bubbles. These things have secondary parasitic effects that are ballooned through leveraged investments into affecting the broader worldwide economy and crossing industries and whatnot.
Let's stop right there.
First, this already shows You are responding to something in your mind, not mine. What I wrote is plain to see. Second, the rest of that sentence confirms that fear. You are not arguing with me and what I wrote, but with some ghost in your own head.
> seem to imply that because the initial investment cash always ends up circulating, no value is ever destroyed
I did not say that * at all*. And whatever you yourself interpret into plain statements is... yourself speaking.
Paying my staff to light money on fire means that some of the money will circulate, and my brilliant idea to decarbonize the economy by replacing coal with printed currency will result in some benefits (much much less than the costs), but fundamentally it is not a productive endeavor.
The AI Data center build out is much more useful than purely lighting money on fire, but if we overpay for more than it is actually ultimately worth, than it still was a bad idea.
At some point you have to grant people agency and accept that things spend money and time on things that are valuable to them.
We're talking about companies here, not people. And yet, it is kinda true—companies spend time and money on things that are valuable to the people at high level positions in the company and board. But that isn't the same as companies spending time and money on things that are valuable to the company.
This assumes only "the US" exists in this world. The AI hype would have been a thing regardless.
If the money doesn't go to the US it'd go to China or somewhere else. Just like with batteries you'd just lose the market if you don't invest.
I'd think investment banks, law firms and management consultancies must be doing very well in this inflated market. They get a piece of every financing deal and consulting engagement that drives these bilkion dollar spending decisions.
In other words, the AI hype comes at the cost of lower growth rates in other sectors of the economy?
It makes sense, since investor money is spent exactly once. If it goes to AI then it doesn't go elsewhere. And if it didn't go to AI then it would go elsewhere.
Sad for folks outside tech. But at least they can AI generate cat pictures now, and watch their tech friend use AI tooling to write software.