Re:Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first ha...
by graemep on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @08:58AM
(#45515675)
You are shifting what you talked about. The comment I replied to was about tech companies putting money into stock buy backs instead of AI. You are no talking about AI being a bubble.
You also failed to understand that money put into an investment has to go somewhere pretty much immediately. If someone defaults on a loan they must have used the money, so someone else has it, so it is still not destroyed.
Re:Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first ha...
by surgical_fire on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @09:40AM
(#45516078)
> You are no talking about AI being a bubble.
I explicitly did not talk about AI being a bubble.
You may understand of economics (at least you say so). But reading comprehension is not your forte.
Re:Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first ha...
by teiferer on Thursday October 09, 2025 @02:41AM
(#45524306)
If this was true universally then the total amount monetary value in the economy was constant, apart from the feds printing some. But it's not. Value comes and goes. You can definitely lose money without it going elsewhere.
I miss no point. I understand quite well that "parked money" still exusts. What you ignore is that value is sometimes "destroyed". Investiments that underperform or go in the red, loans that default, crashes in real estate, etc. if money is invested in stocks, and the stocks value go in freefall, the nominal amount of money that existed previously in the economy is the same, and everyone is still poorer because of it.
The massive AI hype is massively pumping a bull run in a very small sector of the economy (if this is a bubble is not something I can answer). A lot of money is moving around around a small subset of companies pumping revenues of one another in a circular fashion, which increases the value of those stocks (thus creating economic growth, real or otherwise). Without this mechanism, this value wouldn't have been created. It's anyone's guess how things would perform without it.
During a crash, the same amount of money that existed prior to the crash is still there. The crash still happens and the country can still go into recession.
> How mature and charmingly expressed!
Thank you. I, too, think I am mature and charming.