News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by lupusreal on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:56AM (#45424026)
The ad industry likes to say that their industry is clean and the people who buy ads for scams are the problem, but the truth is the entire industry is complicit with the scamming, and stuff like this shows it. If the ad industry were merely hapless victims of the scammers, rather than willful participants in the scamming, they'd be eager to receive reports of scams.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:17AM (#45424517)
I feel like there are almost two completely incompatible stories being sold by ad tech people. One is that "you shouldn't use an ad blocker, reputable websites have ads from Google and other reputable companies and they wouldn't be scams or malware". The other is that any time there's a story about malware and scams on reputable websites, they say: "there are so many ads being submitted, Google is doing their best but you can't expect them to successfully weed out every single bad ad".

The reality is, of course, that Google and its ilk doesn't give a single rat's ass about people falling from scams or getting infected by malware. Scams and malware pays better than "ethical" ads (to the degree that such a thing exists). It's a travesty that there are apparently no laws against their behavior.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jerf on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:53AM (#45427102)
This is the motte & bailey fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy

While it has gotten around the "logical fallacy community", for lack of a better term, in the last few years, it could still stand to be known by more people. It's become very popular. I think there are many who have subconsciously picked it up as just how things are done.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by hnlmorg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:38AM (#45424691)
> It's a travesty that there are apparently no laws against their behavior.

there is in the UK. And likely in most other jurisdictions too. But it's about penalizing the advertisers rather than the platform. Which clearly neither works at scale nor across borders.

This definitely feels like a better use case for an "online safety act" -- but instead we got censorship laws....

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:04AM (#45425610)
Because scams are a threat to the serfs, and people spreading the truth about global events and issues is a threat to the powerful. That's why I really don't bag on "slacktivists" anymore. I'm not saying there isn't SOME truth to the notion that people reliably pick the one kind of activism that doesn't require getting off the sofa, it's a fair critique. However even that kind of activism is now heavily policed around the humanitarian crisis that won't be named.

If it wasn't a threat, they wouldn't police it so hard.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jrmg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:58AM (#45424864)
It's a travesty that there are apparently no laws against their behavior.

In the USA I’m pretty sure advertising scams - even the more ‘benign’ ones like claiming a product does something it doesn’t do or lying about its efficiency - are illegal. There’s just no - or not nearly enough - enforcement.

https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:28AM (#45425174)
There's no meaningful difference in my mind between "there are no laws" and "there are technically laws but they're completely unenforced".
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by RajT88 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:43AM (#45425354)
There's a lot of that going around in the US these days.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:00AM (#45425553)
And everywhere else, honestly. It's not like banner ads on the web are particularly honest here in the EU/EEA.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by RajT88 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:52AM (#45426197)
I was referring specifically to, "laws not being enforced".
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:18AM (#45426631)
Both the EU and various EU/EEA members have laws related to misleading advertising on the books which seemingly aren't being enforced either.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by RajT88 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:00AM (#45434125)
Whoosh.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @01:03AM (#45434399)
You're gonna have to explain yourself, because I'm not getting it.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BlueTemplar on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @05:28AM (#45435872)
The difference in the comments here and in this other thread are interesting :

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45424888

(US infocoms, and Google in particular, aren't reputable companies any more. Ban them all.)

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by miltonlost on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:33AM (#45425241)
*no enforcement any longer. Back when we had Lina Khan at the FTC, she would have enforced it. Now we have a scammer-in-chief only enforcing laws against his political opponents
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by pavon on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:24AM (#45426724)
She started enforcing it against the most egregious offenders, but for every enforcement action, there were thousands that went unpunished. The problem is that FTC proceedings are very process heavy by design, which is what you want in some cases, but doesn't scale to widespread scam. We need to be prosecuting hundreds of thousands these cases every year if we want to make a dent and turn things around to fraud being a rare exception rather than a normal business model.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jrmg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:36AM (#45425270)
I agree the current administration is way worse than the previous one in almost every respect, but to argue that the previous one would’ve enforced this particular thing is obviously untrue.

The situation’s been like this for a few years now.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by miltonlost on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:55AM (#45425485)
Not fake ads, but Biden's FTC did go after fake reviewers and fake reviews: https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/us-ftc-fina...

If she had had more time, I could see Khan going after fake ads as well. There's nothing to me that suggests that she was deliberately ignoring fraudulent ads when she was extremely pro-consumer in nearly every other policy.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jrmg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:49AM (#45426171)
Agreed - I think it’s lack of resources. Congress would need to act to fix this.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:24PM (#45432523)
It's not even that there's no enforcement... you could talk to your state's AG. But their budgets aren't infinite, and the scammers are overseas as likely as not. Unless the scam rises above some (absurdly high) threshold or threatens someone very important/wealthy, it's going to be back-burnered.

The cost of enforcement would break every government's budget. The cost asymmetry is the problem.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by account42 on Monday October 06, 2025 @04:11AM (#45488874)
Budget is not the issue. When a crime is hard to police all you need to do is up the fines and other punishment so whatever enforcement you can afford acts as a deterrent for the rest.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:59AM (#45424876)
Google Tag Manager is a malware vector. It's very design is to distribute non-Google code through a supposedly trusted source. They are part of the problem and JS blocking is the only dependable safeguard.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by detourdog on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:14AM (#45425745)
My mail server easily gets the most phishing attempts from gmail. This is due to my unwillingness to blacklist Gmail. I report the abuse through there abuse page. The results in a slowdown while the abuser reformulates their sending process. I know this by watching the changes to the sending path in the header of the phishing attempts. The content and subject often don’t change but the header does.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:29AM (#45425921)
I bet that if you were using gmail, those phishing mails would end up in your trash ... which raises the question: why does Google allow people who Google's own spam-filter can detect are sending 99% spam to keep sending e-mail?
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by tbrownaw on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:36AM (#45424675)
> One is that "you shouldn't use an ad blocker, reputable websites have ads from Google and other reputable companies and they wouldn't be scams or malware".

But I don't care* about that, I care that they're visually obnoxious and sometimes slow.

* Well, usually. Way back when, there used to be occasional news about browser sandbox escapes.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mort96 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:59AM (#45425540)
I agree, I would be using an ad blocker even if all the ads were "only" annoying attempts at manipulating my behavior rather than scams and malware. But pointing out that ads can damage your computer or scam you out of money or information is a stronger pro-ad-blocking argument.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by bradlys on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:12AM (#45426553)
Genuinely curious: why do I always get scammy ads in iOS apps and Google products but I don’t see anywhere near the same amount on Instagram or TikTok?

Are Meta and TikTok better at filtering scammy ads out? Maybe their ML recommendation systems realize I’d never click on such an ad and the other platforms can’t figure that out.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by cm2012 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @01:24PM (#45428351)
IG, TikTok, Meta have a lot of data they can use to do good ad targeting that is harder to apply to Google/iOS apps. Also has to do with the ad format, placement, etc.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by bradlys on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @03:47PM (#45430350)
I get that but I’m surprised that Google doesn’t have that info too. Google’s ad biz is bigger than Meta’s.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by cm2012 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:42PM (#45433043)
Some formats are better than others. The Meta products comparable to GDN (audience network, various banner ad placements in its platforms) also kind of suck. Google wishes they had a feed based website, thats where people respond to direct respond ads in a big way.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by PaulHoule on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:32PM (#45427647)
It's been that way a long time with other media. I used to work out a lot during the day and would wind up watching TV in the daypart aimed at people who don't have their own money to spend on things and there were ads running for about a decade that were obviously a scam.

https://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/consumer-alerts/fraud-alert-nation...

When you heard the vocal equivalent of large type text every real person knew that it was time to get grandma away from the TV but... the people at the TV network didn't, law enforcement didn't, your congressman didn't, anybody in a position of power didn't. And no wonder people feel cynical, hate the media, distrust the cops, distrust politicians, feel "the game is rigged", etc.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by tracker1 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @04:05PM (#45430547)
It'd be relatively easy for Google to screen out and filter ads... Charge enough when creating an account or starting/changing a campaign. Then you can pay staff for manual review. They could charge $1000 for account creation (half of which you get back after the first year), then they charge even $20 at campaign creation/change... They can even provide context/feedback, "Sorry, but this seems misleading, doesn't relate to what you are linking, is scammy, etc." And have an additional "check" of each ad and target after a day, a week and a random point within each month. Charge an additional minimum of $20/mo per ad for (re)validation.

For the bulk of legit advertisers, this won't affect the bottom line of a given campaign and will keep out the scammers, etc. Leading to a much higher quality ecosystem. It would also give Google the potential for a higher percentage share of profits in the system. It would also likely reduce the CPM pricing though, possibly to a larger extent than profits from the validation system itself.

But it would be a much healthier overall system.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by Sophira on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:26AM (#45435557)
Until management realises they can skip the checks and come out $20 on top each time, with no complaints from advertisers.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by snailmailman on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @04:42PM (#45430978)
When google switched off uBlock origin, it took less than a week for my grandmother to call me in a panic because she clicked on a malicious Facebook ad.

Google disabled the Adblock, Facebook let the ad run on their site, and Microsoft hosted the malicious site on their cloud provider. Shoutout to Microsoft for taking the site down within the hour after I reported it- more than I can say for any of the blatantly illegal or scam ads I’ve seen on YouTube. but still, 3 big tech companies that could have definitely stopped this is they really wanted to.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by lelanthran on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:06PM (#45431805)
> When google switched off uBlock origin, it took less than a week for my grandmother to call me in a panic because she clicked on a malicious Facebook ad.

What did your grandmother need Chrome for? You couldn't find the 5m it would take to set her up with Firefox?

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by snailmailman on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:22PM (#45444276)
She uses a super cheap Chromebook. Unfortunately I don’t think Firefox can be easily installed on it? I don’t think it’s even x86. It’s a very limited device, but all it needs to be capable of is loading Facebook and a few other specific sites- so it “works”
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by chrisjj on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @07:19AM (#45436446)
> One is that "you shouldn't use an ad blocker, reputable websites have ads from Google and other reputable companies and they wouldn't be scams or malware".

As if people read only reuptable sites ...

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by account42 on Monday October 06, 2025 @04:08AM (#45488855)
The whole point of ads is to mislead and manipulate people into acting against their best interests. They are not colluding with scammers, they are the scammers. The whole business is inherently rotten and that's before getting to second order effects. It's a travesty that ads are tolerated at all.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jrmg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:04AM (#45424433)
For me, almost every YouTube ad is a scam.

Medical supplements or plans that make claims that clearly aren’t real, financial scams (crypto or get-rich-quick schemes), or product scams (this new device that ‘they’ don’t want you to know about can heat/cool your house in minutes for pennies!).

I’m pretty sure none of this is legal, and Google obviously doesn’t care.

FWIW I have ad personalization off - perhaps it’s a bit better for those who don’t?

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by chamomeal on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:12AM (#45424480)
I used to get SO MANY “heres how I make $6,000/day in passive income with chatGPT”. I reported am all, I know it never did anything
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by yifanl on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:47AM (#45424765)
I wonder if reporting them gives them more engagement, since that would mean you watched it and paid enough attention.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by 1-more on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @01:26PM (#45428394)
From when I worked in the video ad industry, the industry standard was that an impression was binary and seeing a single frame of the ad counted. IDK if YouTube follows the Interactive Advertising Bureau guidelines, but they probably do. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/xandr/industry-reference/i...
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by svieira on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:11AM (#45424476)
Quite a bit - I get ads for septic tanks because I have looked at them several times and tank companies continue to advertise for me because I might buy. I get ads for robot mowers because, again, I looked at them. I still see "the bottom of the barrel" ads occasionally, but it's very rare. Ad blitzes on the other hand ... (no, I don't want to build an app just-by-thinking-about-it) ...
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by ryandrake on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:27AM (#45426757)
At one point a few months ago, YouTube seems to have gotten the idea that I have some kind of bowel problem, and I'd constantly get ads about my "stuck poop." WTF? I'm watching a woodworking tutorial, I don't want to fucking hear about poop! Total bottom of the barrel.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by kbelder on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @01:19PM (#45428302)
Several months ago, my wife bought several bottles of pureed pumpkin babyfood, because small amounts added to catfood can treat some feline stomach issues.

Now, we're getting diaper commercials all over youtube. I assume we're flagged in some database as likely having a new child, but you can't ever know for sure.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by fragmede on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:54PM (#45440039)
https://myadcenter.google.com/personalizationoff

You can look up your Google ad profile and see if "pregnant" is one of your account's attributes. Facebook has a similar page somewhere.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by jrmg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:08PM (#45433913)
FWIW, those seem to be a current ‘trend’. I’m getting them with personalization switched off.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by mrweasel on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:48AM (#45424342)
That's a really good point. If the problem is the scammers, and they buy ads, then why won't they let us report it?
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by rchaud on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:04AM (#45425614)
Because they don't want to drive off business.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by DelightOne on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:06AM (#45424444)
I bet they tried an llm scam detector. It was too good so they didn't put it into production.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:19AM (#45425052)
i can write that in like 2 minutes in any language you want.

  `pseudo
  main(
      return True
  )`
There's a difference between "Need a tree cut down? I am licensed and bonded and cut down trees; call ###" and the sort of things that we all consider "ads". If someone can't see a difference, then that someone probably receives money from advertising.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by lupusreal on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:17PM (#45427425)
One of the few sorts of ads I'm okay with are those sort of ads for local businesses on the paper placemats at local restaurants. Those stick around and are seen by countless people so if it's a scam word will get around.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by kbelder on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @01:21PM (#45428317)
Well, that code would be over 95% accurate.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:27AM (#45424602)
It also doesn’t help that so many creators - even legitimate ones - now use injected ads that they don’t verify at all.

I remember listening to an episode of Better Offline a buddy sent me and anyone who knows about Ed knows that basically half his crusade is against bad AI implementation/“slop”/etc. He’s broadly against the current LLM rush.

First ad when I fired up the podcast episode was yet aother injected ad for yet another AI agent company as generic as the rest. Literally the organizations he’s railing against and calling wasteful. It was clearly because he handed off the advertising to one of these injection services.

Sidebar: these ads tend to perform terribly. Actual ad reads by the host(s) are the only thing that lead to meaningful conversions in podcasts.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by rchaud on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:08AM (#45425659)
If they post the episode on Youtube, download an audio stream of that file instead. No ads injected there.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:23AM (#45425113)
where are the ads injected? I use a couple of podcast "apps" and neither inject ads, all ads in podcasts are explicitly put into the audio file by the people making the podcast, even pre-roll and post-roll ads.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:37AM (#45425286)
That’s a (good) choice by the shows you listen to. There are plenty of ad injection services for podcasting, pretty sure Acast (popular hosting service) has it built in for instance. Search “DAI podcast” or “dynamic ad insertion podcast.”

The biggest giveaway is when the ads are dropped in the middle of someone talking. Pretty much any hits that are manually added are led into by the hosts if it’s mid-show.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by fknorangesite on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:45PM (#45427834)
> all ads in podcasts are explicitly put into the audio file by the people making the podcast

Yes, but those are dynamic too: if you go back and download old episodes, for example, you'll get the current run of ads.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @03:03PM (#45441836)
No, that's incorrect. Not one of the podcasts i listen to re-master their mp3s, the checksums stay the same. In fact, most of the podcasts i listen to have no ads at all. I wonder if there's some misunderstanding, here. If i go watch like an LTT video where they had a sponser, 5 years ago, that same "native ad" will be in the video. I'm specifically saying that the podcast apps i use do not inject ads, but podcasts themselves will do native advertising, i consider these completely different things.

https://podcastindex.org/apps podcasting 2.0 app index.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:17PM (#45446023)
Just to be clear, are you just saying the shows you listen to don’t do DAI, or are you doubting that DAI exists at all? I only ask because of your comment before the one I’m responding to here. It almost sounds like you think it isn’t possible or that no one does it.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by fknorangesite on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:21PM (#45446042)
Right? I'm confused. Saying "oh the ads are in the audio file" is exactly like saying that "the ads are in the html file."

It's not like the client app is inserting them.

I mean, I guess I can imagine an exceptionally-scummy podcast app, but that's not what we're talking about here.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Thursday October 02, 2025 @01:15AM (#45446508)
when i use either of my podcast apps, it fetches an mp3 file (or streams it) and there's no additional ads (read this as "no additional non-native ads") that "change" when i listen again in a year. This means the podcasts that i listen to, i suppose, are not hosted on hosting platforms that inject ads. Because, as i think needs to be reiterated, podcasts are just mp3 files. you can host them with caddy, or nginx, or apache, all pointing at some file(s) in ./www/html/mp3/ One does not need to host it on "Acast" or other "podcast hosting providers", a podcast is just an mp3 file, which can be automatically fetched by anything that can download both rss and mp3 formatted files.

at a certain point, one has to ask themselves if whatever media they're ingesting is worth the scum.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Thursday October 02, 2025 @11:55AM (#45451382)
Hosting services drop them in. You sign an agreement with them and they have agreement with advertisers who drop their spots into your show using DAI. Often it’s a straight up bid-system but the podcasters are not part of the process. This means that podcasters in a lot of situations don’t actually know what ads are being run on their show.

These ads are not just not baked into the audio file, they are legitimately a mystery to the people running the show sometimes. And I think that that’s kind of unconscionable tbh. Podcasts (especially early on) owe a lot of their success to the feeling of “authenticity,” they feel more personal and less “corporate” generally. Whether that’s reality or not we can of course debate, but it’s how audiences perceived them. The reason on air reads have been generally successful for podcasts is because of the trust between the podcast and the audience that has been built over time. This runs directly counter to it.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by fknorangesite on Thursday October 09, 2025 @03:31PM (#45532060)
Yeah. I know. That's what I was trying to explain to genewitch, but we're all just talking past each other.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Thursday October 02, 2025 @01:04AM (#45446460)
a "podcast" is just an mp3 file, usually fetched by finding the URL via an rss feed. I am asking, perhaps a bit cheekily, "who is putting ads in", because that isn't a "feature" of podcasts. Stop getting podcasts from places that put ads in, support "podcasters" that don't do this scummy crap.

It's just an mp3 file!

edit: I should point out that i pitched, to Apple, the ability to dynamically insert ads sometime around ipod 5th gen, 2005-2006, but not for podcasts, but for downloadable videos, like "last night's TV show". I'm sorry i did this. I don't mean i had the idea and said "hey this is an idea", i had the entire infrastructure documented, it was drop in and go. Whoops.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Thursday October 02, 2025 @09:45AM (#45449518)
I know what a podcast is, I have produced them for clients. I am honestly unsure what our discussion is about at this point.

DAI is a thing and my initial point several comments ago was that too many podcasts implement it, let advertisers drop their stuff in (not their own read), and never check what’s actually being run on their show. That’s all my point was about.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by GuinansEyebrows on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:34PM (#45427673)
Cool Zone Media podcasts kinda famously get farmed ads that run counter to their content. they claim they do what they can to influence that (ahem... Washington State Highway Patrol and all the gold scams come to mind) but i wonder if signing their souls away to ihm removed a lot of their agency in that regard.

and if you've ever listened to one of Robert's (CZM executive producer and host of some of their flagships) other podcasts you might understand why companies don't want him doing ad reads.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by BolexNOLA on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @01:42PM (#45428637)
What an un-fun reputation to have!

I’m not even against pre-recorded spots by whoever the sponsor is if that’s his deal though the conversion rate on those are not as good. It’s just the completely random ads that the podcaster(s) don’t even know are playing on their show. The entire reason advertising on podcasting was more effective in the 2010s and early 2020s was because there was a little more trust with their listeners, there’s a relationship at play even if it’s parasocial. If they were actively reading on air, I assumed that they vetted the company and it at least passed the smell test (though plenty sure didn’t, I would say the bar was a little higher than other media formats).

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by secondcoming on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:29AM (#45424611)
Websites get to control what ads are displayed. If a website integrates with Taboola they're explixitly opting in to these crap ads.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by conradfr on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:52AM (#45424806)
It doesn't work for adsense as they basically get a new account every day so you can't effectively block scams.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by edoceo on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:53AM (#45426228)
Google can't figure out rate-limiting and trust-leveling/ramp?

Sure they can; it just slows the money-pipe

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by conradfr on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:02PM (#45431197)
Google could but I was responding to "the website that integrates ads can".
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by hnlmorg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:40AM (#45424705)
What's YouTube's excuse?
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by secondcoming on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:46AM (#45424751)
They allow them, and people who have ad personalisation disabled are probably seeing more of them
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by hnlmorg on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:50AM (#45424797)
Yes, but YT obviously doesn't use Taboola and it's still infested with scam ads.
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by asdfwaafsfw on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:32PM (#45443091)
random question for you - do you still have your Dave Bull Great Wave and would you sell it?
Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by Intermernet on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:37AM (#45424682)
Just remember, advertising is responsible for the rage economy. It's responsible for platforming misinformation. It's responsible for screen-addiction in children. It's responsible for online scams. Just think of all of the proposed laws and regulations around the world that are trying to counter each of these problems and remember that the root cause, and enabler of all of them is advertising. It's truly an amplifier of enshittification, and one of the worst conduits of bad social behaviour ever invented. If you're in the ad / ad-tech industry, please seriously consider the effect you're having on the world.

I'm happy to pay for media, news, social networks etc. I don't purchase things based on anything other than personal recommendations and research. I have no use for advertising, and I have no desire or need for ad-supported platforms. I'm pretty sure I'm not alone. People say advertising works, and that justifies it. The thing is, advertising only works on enough people to justify it. Everyone else hates it with a passion, or studiously avoids it. I'm not sure if we're a majority or a minority, it doesn't matter, but we suffer advertising and wish it were gone.

Advertising needs to change. It would be nice if it just went away, but realistically that's not going to happen. It needs to be recognised as harmful and regulated as a harmful product.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by genewitch on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:17AM (#45425029)
Explicit (seriously, explicit) Bill Hicks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9h9wStdPkQY

We've known that advertising is "filling the world with bile and garbage" for decades.

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by ghurtado on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:48PM (#45427873)
> The ad industry likes to say that their industry is clean

First I've ever heard this, and I have been working in marketing all my life.

What exactly do you mean by this? Where have you heard it?

Re:Disqus Turned My Blog into an Ad Farm – So I Killed It by chrisjj on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:49AM (#45436275)
> The ad industry likes to say that their industry is clean and the people who buy ads for scams are the problem

Hmm. How are these people not part of the industry exactly?