News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by mrtksn on Sunday June 22, 2025 @11:40PM (#44352289)
This is the first time my iPhone 14 Pro felt inadequate.

The app is so heavy that the phone is overheating after the first photo. it consumes so much resources that’s the music was playing in the background stopped because my AirPods connection dropped. For the very first time on this phone I felt like I need an upgrade, it felt like the last days of my iPhone 6s. I didn’t know you can do that to an iPhone.

The photo quality is supperb though, obviously not DSLR replacement but it really gives you that feel. Apple’s own processing has become too boring, sometimes I use Halide just to have unprocessed raws.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by Aurornis on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:01AM (#44352352)
> The app is so heavy that the phone is overheating after the first photo.

I have the same phone and no such thing happened.

Do you mean the phone got slightly warm? That’s not overheating, it’s just what happens when you use an app that leverage the CPU for anything non-trivial. It’s not overheating.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by mrtksn on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:07AM (#44352380)
It's literally the app complaining about it: https://a.dropoverapp.com/cloud/download/b191e7b8-8dad-4fed-...

It will dim the screen soon that it's unusable outdoors. I wasn't able to capture a photo outdoors yesterday using this app because of this. The first photo slowly finished processing but the app crashed, lost the photo. Then the device was overheating, the screen dimmed to unusable the FPS dropped, the app become unresponsive and the music went away, the AirPods re-connected. Couldn't even try to capture a second one.

It wasn't even that hot, just 28C.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by Aurornis on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:07AM (#44352598)
Interesting. I can get the app to crash if I spam the photo button and queue up the maximum number (8) of background processing tasks. Feels like an OOM error if I had to guess. Can’t get any of the other things you experienced to occur, though I haven’t tried Bluetooth audio.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by josephg on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:10AM (#44352613)
I’d be shocked if this is an actual limitation of the hardware. Modern iPhones have plenty of horsepower for computational photography.

I bet this a software bug of some sort - like they’re using the cpu where it should be using Metal or something. Hopefully they can sort it out.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by khurs on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:02AM (#44353468)
iPhone have less ram though, compared to Pixels and androids in general.

https://iosref.com/ram-processor

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:25AM (#44352671)
Depends where it's being used. The phone can easily get that hot if you're shooting in sunlight.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by leptons on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:57AM (#44352561)
>For the very first time on this phone I felt like I need an upgrade, it felt like the last days of my iPhone 6s. I didn’t know you can do that to an iPhone.

Apple got caught purposely slowing down older model iPhones.

https://www.npr.org/2020/11/18/936268845/apple-agrees-to-pay...

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:24AM (#44352667)
Because of how aged batteries work, if you don't purposely slow down the phone sometimes it'll shut off, which is worse.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by throwaway14452 on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:01AM (#44352828)
Maybe Apple should use their proverbial ingenuity and inventiveness to invent a smartphone design that lets you open its back shell without screws to allow the user to replace their own battery, though I'm not sure if the technology for it is quite there yet.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by xp84 on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:05AM (#44353193)
Sure, 100%, though that's a separate topic to the ridiculous urban legend that came out of that story. Something still must be done when a user has a degraded battery that can't handle the full draw of the CPU.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by vbezhenar on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:19AM (#44353266)
It was literally court decision that led to the Apple implementing switch allowing users to switch their smartphones to unsafe mode.

I still think that Apple was right there by not implementing this switch, and judge was an idiot. But that's just me.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:12AM (#44352903)
Batteries last years and are already easily replaceable.

They're not even the only consumable part anyway.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by throwaway14452 on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:29AM (#44353007)
Last as in "works" is a very low bar, they are going to have severely reduced capacity, which also affects performance.

>Batteries ... are already easily replaceable

Is this[1] what easy looks like?

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0fUmW-2swg

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:49AM (#44353404)
> Last as in "works" is a very low bar, they are going to have severely reduced capacity, which also affects performance.

Batteries tend to degrade to about 85% quickly and then spend a long time at that capacity. Couldn't tell you why.

A USB battery is a more useful thing to have, for instance because you don't have to turn off the phone to use it.

> Is this[1] what easy looks like?

For something you'd do every 2-3 years, sure. He's put in some extra steps in that video I think.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by greenpresident on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:43AM (#44353081)
Ifixit score of 7 plus best parts availability of any phone makes for a great combination in my mind.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by xp84 on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:10AM (#44353228)
On the other hand, before the iPhone, literally every phone had a back cover that could be removed with bare hands and batteries held in by friction. After iPhone, all phones are sealed and require tiny screws to be removed, special adhesives to be defeated (god help you if you break off the stretchy adhesive strips), and of course seals to be replaced. And all this was done from the 2007 iPhone, over a decade before Apple did any IP67 rating of any kind, so none of it was done for waterproofing.

So, "Apple killed battery swappability" is a fair thing to say.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by Melatonic on Sunday June 29, 2025 @06:14PM (#44417004)
There are even phones now with proper IP ratings AND removable back covers. I believe the Samsung line of "industrial" or like commercial oriented phones and tablets (I think they're called XCover ?)
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by mrtksn on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:35AM (#44353043)
It's pretty easy for something you do every 2 years and you can get it done by someone else at reasonable price.

iPhones being hard to repair, let alone change the battery is such a ridiculous meme.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by sixothree on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:49AM (#44352777)
I don’t buy this excuse. I experienced it first hand with my iPhone 4. When moving from iOS 6 to 7 my phone became unusable. As did everyone’s. And there was no going back to iOS 6. It wasn’t the battery in any way. The upgrade basically made the phone unusable.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:02AM (#44352830)
Those are called performance bugs. That was a long time and a lot of software development cycle changes ago.

If it helps I believe the EU just made it illegal two days ago to release updates that make battery life worse. But I could've confused some of the details there.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by vbezhenar on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:23AM (#44353289)
It was not a bug. I have similar story with my iPhone 4S became unusable with iOS 7. It was never fixed. One day I managed to jailbreak it, rolling back to iOS 6 and was astonished how fast and smooth it is.

They just implemented iOS 7 with much more compute requirements, so only newer phones were able to run it smoothly. The progress of mobile CPUs these old days was crazy, so I don't really complain about it, it was inevitable.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by astrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:50AM (#44353409)
> They just implemented iOS 7 with much more compute requirements, so only newer phones were able to run it smoothly.

Yeah, that's a bug. Any regression on any supported device is a bug.

That was a very, very rushed release.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by sixothree on Thursday July 03, 2025 @01:53AM (#44452044)
Bugs can be fixed.

It certainly felt intentional. Considering the effect of the bug, I'd argue this falls into malice and not a simple oopsie bug.

This wasn't fixed. They never intended to fix it. It looked intentional from the user perspective.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by xp84 on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:19AM (#44353265)
Those are separate issues. No one ever proved Apple set out to do that. Sure, they do care as little as the next company how their older hardware runs a new OS, but it's silly to believe it's a conspiracy. Tell me, do you believe Apple (A) adds in a bunch of conditional code to trigger just older phones to infinitely loop to kill your performance? Or (B) that they deliberately add a bunch of poorly-performing code, but it's code that everyone has to run and only the newest phones can manage?

It seems like A would have been whistleblown by now, and B would be idiotic for them to do on purpose since it would make their new devices unnecessarily slow too.

My opinion is basically B but without malice, it's just that they're obsessed with tons of animation and other eye candy, and added a lot of bloat in those years in general, rushing code out the door out of a desire to hit iOS release dates and the synchronized iPhone release dates they used to have.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by leptons on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:15PM (#44359065)
> No one ever proved Apple set out to do that.

Yes, they did in fact prove that. That's why Apple had to pay $500 million dollars to settle, because they got caught doing shady shit.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by xp84 on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:22PM (#44359132)
They settled without admitting any wrongdoing of course, but what they "got caught doing" was simply not disclosing what was happening -- and that's the only thing they changed afterward.

It was still the correct course of action, and obviously not done maliciously -- a phone that was so slow it was annoying to use, and a phone that reboots 10x a day are equally 'incentive' to buy a new phone, so I fail to see how the throttling benefited Apple one bit.

In fact, I'd say the unreliable rebooting one would have provided stronger incentive to replace it vs. a slow one.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by leptons on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @01:54AM (#44363201)
The right thing to do is to offer a battery replacement program. Instead they went for the e-waste option.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by xp84 on Tuesday July 01, 2025 @07:25PM (#44438863)
But... they do offer a battery replacement program.

https://support.apple.com/iphone/repair/battery-replacement

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by sixothree on Thursday July 03, 2025 @01:55AM (#44452053)
Replacing the battery did not alleviate the issue in any way. I'd argue the battery was a red herring.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by leptons on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:40AM (#44353629)
Instead of offering to replace the batteries, or making a phone with an easy to replace battery, Apple chose the shady move and hid their "solution" from the public and just slowed down older phones.

>"In March, Apple agreed to pay up to $500 million to settle claims of intentionally slowing down older phones."

They got slapped on the wrist. This resulted in them making the batteries slightly easier to replace, but their batteries are still impossible to replace by the average iPhone owner.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by whywhywhywhy on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:09AM (#44355464)
The issue was they lied about it and said they were not slowing phones down until someone figure out they were in fact slowing down phones.

Now the reason is valid and should have been a toggle from the get go but they still told us they were not doing it when they were.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by qwopmaster on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:13AM (#44352628)
Same experience on 14 pro - it got noticeably hot after 2nd photo, and after 3rd the app crashed and OS was choppy for a few minutes. And that was indoors, in 22C and screen fairly dim. Never seen anything like it; as-is I’d avoid the app lest it actually damages something. The photos themselves do look better than apple’s default cam, but not by a huge amount. Most noticeable is better range, like a photo of a blue sky with a few clouds seen through your window that takes up a third of the photo, which by default is either very dim inside or mostly indistinct blue-gray or blown out if focusing inside. Super-resolution however, especially at 6x (double 14 pro’s 3x optical zoom) is actual wizardry.

On the other hand night photos seem like garbage - there’s a bit more stuff visible than on default 3sec night mode but the colors are nonsensical and details nonexistent, certainly nothing even remotely close to what adobe promises on their webpage.

All in all I’m not sure what use it is with the terrible performance, outside of long-range photos that you really want to shoot at 6x zoom and keep as much detail as possible.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by pantulis on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:28AM (#44353320)
Another datapoint with an 15 Pro Max. I shot a couple of pics indoors in my own room and got the message. Seems the app is continuosly processing what's coming from the sensor.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by Melatonic on Sunday June 29, 2025 @05:59PM (#44416868)
Sounds like the app is just not properly optimised yet.

The built in iOS camera app can do something sort of similar - you can set it to shoot in adobe raw (12mpx scaled down from the 48mpx sensor). Often the phone will shoot HDR by combining multiple photos. And in night mode (either manually activated or auto) it will stack (combine) multiple exposures for long exposure noise reduction and (maybe) exposure stacking. Setting it to a longer amount (max is 7 seconds I think) should thereotically combine more photos.

The adobe raw format can store this info (it's actually quite underrated - I first switched to iOS with the 15 pro and immediately tried to find a way to shoot a true "normal" raw like a .DNG). I'm very into photography and used to be a professional film editor and one my favourite hobbies is astrophotography (with a real camera and tripod).

The cool thing about adobe raw specifically is that the HDR stack is not baked into the file. If you open one in Lightroom mobile, for example, there is a slider under the far right "profiles" editing section. The slider defaults to the middle (50) which is basically the default stacked HDR look from Apple. Moving the slider all the way left will have it use a single exposure (normal raw - no HDR no stack). Anywhere in between will be a blend of the two. If you don't see the slider then you haven't properly opened the adobe raw file in Lightroom mobile (you may have opened a jpeg preview or accidently shot in .heif)

It's quite counterintuitive because "profiles" when editing a non adobe raw is a totally different function (more like adding preset looks). If the file was not taken in HDR then the slide will do nothing. I'm not exactly sure what moving the slider to the right does (it seems to increase the amount of HDR or something - I never use it).

I've noticed that when editing adobe raw on iOS messing with this slider seems to be by far the most CPU intensive aspect. Sometimes the image preview updates immediately and sometimes it takes awhile and the phone heats up. Sometimes the app just crashes. It might be using a similar algorithm to what the Adobe Indigo app is using here for image capture.

Editing raw files also kills my battery life faster than anything else I've done (which makes sense) considering that it's a fairly intensive process. This was also true on previous Android phones so it's not limited to iOS. I usually stop any music playing at the same time and make sure the phone is out of direct sun and it seems to handle heat buildup well when doing this. If it does heat up I remove the case and put it in front of my car AC vent or some other ventilated area and it cools relatively quick.

Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by vachina on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:32AM (#44354218)
Par for the course for an Adobe app. Bloated, slow and meh output.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by fortyseven on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @03:51AM (#44363810)
Weird how "superb" was misspelled as "meh" here.
Re:Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel... by Melatonic on Sunday June 29, 2025 @06:11PM (#44416982)
Agreed on some points but when used properly adobe apps usually have quite good output. There's a reason Photoshop has been the industry standard for so long.