It feels like that's putting this into a really awkward place in the tradeoff space. Trams work because they can scale higher than buses. That scale comes at the cost of more up-front infrastructure, much less flexibility, and needing dedicated lanes. So cities don't have trams everywhere, but they're only installed on routes that can support the scale.
For these you still have the up-front investment (just less of it) and inflexibility, but don't get the efficiencies of scale due to how small the capacity is.
Is this really just a bet that they can get autonomous tram-driving on city street approved a decade+ sooner than autonomous buses?
But rather, this is giving up the benefit trams have over buses, without gaining any new edge to replace it. So why is it a good tradeoff? And why now, not 20 years ago?
The autonomous driving angle is the only idea I have.
For comparison, the most frequent London underground service is 100 seconds per train and the system moves about 50k passengers an hour (based on a 21% increase representing 10k passengers, I couldn't find a direct figure), presumably that being both directions.
[0]: https://brtdata.org/location/latin_america/brazil/rio_de_jan...
PDF: https://www.bernmobil.ch/sites/default/files/2025-02/ah_0201...
Also, because of the expensive infrastructure that can only be used by trams, there’s a permanence there that prevents future politicians from ripping it out to put more cars on for a quick political win with drivers.
Going back to point 1: having a line means that any route needs to be properly planned because you never have an escape hatch of “just stick them on the road.” Example: where I live, the council installed a bus lane and a cycle lane. Where it pinches in (planning fuck up), it dumps all the traffic into a shared route with 2 roundabouts and 5 exits, each with an insane amount of traffic coming to or from them. Buses that are forced to use that route are always late. It takes me just as long to drive as it does to take the bus, faster if you factor in me waiting for a late bus.
Trams here in Berlin share the street with the cars on some streets. So, it's exactly like a bus that can get stuck in traffic (and they do). Dedicated tracks are also common but they take up a lot of space and it's expensive infrastructure to install. Mostly trams are limited to the former East Berlin, though they've started to spread to some parts on the west side.
With electrical buses and bus lanes, you get most of the advantages of trams. There are probably still some advantages to dedicated tram lines. But they are expensive to install. I'm not sure it's worth the investment.
> Also, because of the expensive infrastructure that can only be used by trams, there’s a permanence there that prevents future politicians from ripping it out to put more cars on for a quick political win with drivers.
A few things to further this:
- I’ve seen bus lanes get ripped out and moved around, you can see where the paint was cut off.
- Taxis use bus lanes, usually.
- People use bus lanes illegally if they’re not enforced with cameras (political cost of installing the cameras).
This is definitively not true. It's something people said about the Washington, DC streetcar and it turns out they are about to remove the streetcar in order to replace it with buses:
https://www.railwaygazette.com/light-rail-and-tram/dc-street...
I definitely agree that the dedicated right of way is the main thing. It's why some of San Francisco's trams are so slow outside of the city centre (where they run in a tunnel) and why Manchester's trams are so slow through the city centre (where they run at surface level sharing the street with pedestrians.)
I believe the new Trafford line improves things somewhat but Manchester really needs much more heavy rail capacity.
The ability for the tracks to be laid so shallow is in my view, the entire innovation and cost is the reason for this approach.
You can run them at high frequency though.
Having to hold on to something discards it from my preferred list of solutions.
It’s a worthwhile read BTW
I suspect these are too small to carry a significant number of passengers per hour
They’ll also probably never be autonomous as the challenge with autonomous is less the driving and more with passengers getting on and off, getting trapped etc
Even if all that falls through, I'm not gonna complain about it. We sorely need more public infrastructure in the UK. Even if an experiment like this fails, at least you actually get a tram line and experience out of it. Much better than a project which sucks up million then gets cancelled. (Cough cough HS2.)
Buses however are slow (in London about the same as walking) and (outside London) prone to vanishing on timetable changes. Closing a rail link is tricky, you can be confident that if you live near a tram stop it will be there in 10 years. 60% of our local (say 10 mile radius) buses have been removed in the last decade, removing entire villages from service.
A rail solution allows you to read, a bus throws you around everywhere and makes you sick.
I definitely feel like trams are a weird technical solution to a policy/perception problem. On a technical level I don't think there's that much to recommend them over buses with bus lanes. It's just that governments never put bus lanes the whole way like you are forced to do with a tram.
I can easily read a book on a tram. No chance on a bus (unless we want vomit all over the seats).
It's a nice bonus; not a reason to build trams.
Passenger UX: - railed vehicles only move and accelerate longitudinally (with a little centripetal force at the very predictable corners). Consequences: people will often choose to stand even while there are free seats. Trams are so smooth that standing feels comfortable. (If you preference is to sit, you benefit too.)
- modern trams have lower floors than any road vehicle can realistically achieve (especially if built for use on random roads). They're near flush with the curb at tram stops, which is nice for accessibility (prams, wheelchairs, people with granny-trolleys for shopping).
Pedestrian UX: - trams follow tram paths, predictably. Once you're used to them (which doesn't take long), you'll stand just centimeters from a passing tram and feel completely comfortable about it. As a pedestrian, no transit line is as easy to cross as a tram line. (Certainly not a bus lane!)
Land use: - since trams follow rails without any lateral deviation or wiggle (and bonus: they're rather narrow), dedicated tram lines require about 40% less land than bus lanes. Especially on streets where there might not be much free lane width to spare, that counts!
Tiny operating costs, negligible marginal costs: - there's a far higher ratio of passengers to driver in a tram - electricity over wire makes the marginal cost of energy to operate negligible. Once the infrastructure is there, and once the tram is running, the frequency of service can be increased and the operating cost can get arbitrarily cheap.
Transit capacity: - road intersections are the capacity bottleneck in any road grid. Behind them, queues form and grow (congestion) until a point where the expected time (much of it queuing in traffic) presents too high a cost for the marginal journey to happen. - trams can pass at same gauge while scaling up intersection capacity by about two orders of magnitude, allowing much more rapid movement of people with much less urban land and less infrastructure
(buses with dedicated lanes could hypothetically deliver this, if buses were as popular as trams and operated like trams in dedicated lanes)
Air pollution: - the primary source of most urban air pollution is road vehicle abrasion (tyres on roads, brake dust) and road vehicle combustion engines. Getting rid of combustion engines solves less than half that problem. To stop primary emission of particulates, you need to solve tyres and car brakes. Railed vehicles do that: clean air. - a large part of air pollution is secondary: particulates settle on the large road surfaces comprising much of our cities. Then road vehicles with large tyre surface area (and varying lateral positions) run over the surface, re-ejecting that dust up into the air.
That air pollution is killing people (estimates vary: somewhere from 'many months' to 'a few years' of life expectancy are lost to urban air pollution). Trams get rid of it completely.
___
The biggest problem with trams is that they require competent civic administration, with a steady pace of long term infrastructure investment (boom & bust would destroys the capacity to produce & maintain trams & infrastructure economically), financed at competitive rates. They also benefit from very high urban walkability in the vicinity of potential tram stops, and high density of development (including housing). Not many cities have that.
Some cities do, and their trams are a dream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4Ph-L4Mbt4
I also observe that this is an average speed, which night be useful for statistical summarization but is not as useful as knowing whether the portion of the route that you want to take is in the faster part or the slower part of the data readings.
For example, if I took a bus from Aldwych up Holborn to Euston I might expect that the first mile would indeed be walking pace but the second mile I would be zipping along. It's important as a bus rider to not let the slow parts color your perception of the whole ride.
[0] https://www.london.gov.uk/who-we-are/what-london-assembly-do...
British museum to Shakespeare’s globe is 32 minutes plus up to 8 minutes waiting for the bus if there’s no delays. 40 minutes to walk.
Last week for example I took a bus from near St Pauls to Trafalgar Square, the entire jouney took about half an hour for 1.5 miles.
I got exactly the opposite impression the first time I rode a tram in my life. The tram is really really shaky and the connection with the overhead line is flaky, leading to all sorts of strange noises.
My experience has been the opposite: every vehicle on rails has offered a superior ride quality to every vehicle on rubber tires. I can't read on a bus, but on a train it's no problem.
Buses meant for right-hand drive markets like the UK, Australia and Japan are (with very few exceptions) shaky, low-entry configuration two door junk, or double-decker one door junk.
If that's what you're used to, even the most rickety light rail system will feel luxurious by comparison.
Left-hand drive low-floor buses with three doors, and articulated models with four doors, which are intended for the European market, are as a general rule much more comfortable. If the buses you normally take fit the latter description, you'll probably find the average tram worse.
It's tiny, how it possibly carry all those 2x4s, powertools and sheets of plywood when I'm out doing manly things. I'd better go buy that monster truck so I can look like a real man.
Yes, this is smaller than the double-deckers in Coventry, that you can even do an eyeball comparison with if you watch the ironic publicity video mentioned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44217231 and keep your eyes peeled for the buses queued up at those temporary traffic lights in the background.
No, it's roughly on a par with the single-deckers, though, and there are quite a lot of those used by the local bus operators.
Those teeny tiny little carriages have a capacity a quarter of what the trams in my city provide. If one of them pulled up in peak hour here, I imagine it would fill up after two stops and be a nuisance from there on.
The tram they show in the animation also very much has a driver in the front.
If they can deliver on what they show in their demos, I don't see why the size of the trams or the infrastructure should be a problem. All the expensive stuff has been thought about, the system barely takes up any extra space, and the system is capable of scaling up by just sending more vehicles into service.
Lower flexibility is actually a feature when it comes to mass transit: People will build density along rail lines because they assume the town won't rip them up, making the rail line more valuable over time. A bus route can be cancelled the day after a disruptive mayor is voted into office.
I also don't see why you can't scale up the tram with additional cars, as long as you keep the lbs/sqft the same. 3 car trams are fine, 3 car busses are... not
At last they were not trying to use agile!
Another common pitfall seems to be engineering teams choosing agile when the business engagement model is waterfall. This puts you in the unfortunate situation of trying to change requirements without being able to get paid for those changes.
A nuclear power station built successfully using an Agile process would be something I'd like to read about.
At least in the US utility relocation also generally involves moving what was underneath to the side, so it can be accessed without disrupting the new transit line.
Battery powered trams have real potential, now that batteries with 5 to 7 minute charging and large numbers of charging cycles are a thing. That's compatible with typical end of line holding times. Steel wheel on steel rail is low friction, and you get most of the energy used to go uphill back when you go downhill. This could work out.
If you were going up and down hills, would you still use steel wheel in steel rail unless you had some sort of cable to work with? I always thought the Muni did relatively level routes for that reason? The Lausanne m2 for example uses rubber (well, ideally you’d be able to just balance the train going up with the train going down, but that only works for simple inclines with limited stops). Actually, a battery powered rubber wheeled tram service on some sort of steep incline like SF’s cable car routes could get some wicked regen going down.
Even if level, they could still get some regen from making stops.
I was told the tires are to reduce noise but I wonder if part of it is to handle some of the steeper sections like Vendome up to Villa Maria.
Care to point out a source that supports a hypothetical link between rubber wheels and lung cancer?
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1757501/
To preempt accusations that the automotive endproduct isn't represented by this study, I'll concede it's next to impossible to have conclusive studies on specific forms of road pollution, that is, the best one can do is find a link between (rail)cars and cancer but nothing more specific than that :)
--Until they replace rubber in wheels with something else, I guess. Meanwhile, feel free to accept the reindustrialization
The extent of impact is still being investigated, but we've known there is a carcinogenic link since before 2000.
> The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
As a counterpoint to "avoiding rubber tyred metro lines like the plague": Does this person also avoid all road tunnels or expressways underground? Since there are frequently multiple lanes in each direction, that would mean much more fine rubber particulates from car & truck tyres compared to a metro with much less frequent trains and only one track in each direction.Its not hard to find out where they are, Michelin is quite proud of them.
A rack rail is also an option, though tends towards the noisy and slow.
But yeah usually light rail keeps under 5%, and can’t really go above 10 on pure adhesion.
> While many streetcar lines were converted to bus lines after World War II, the J Church avoided this due to the private right-of-way it uses to climb the steepest grades on Church Street, between 18th Street and 22nd Street.[9]
Little bit of columns A and B
https://www.opensfhistory.org/osfhcrucible/2019/08/10/the-j-...
Revolutionary as the turning circle will be used at speed with passengers to traverse roundabouts in-lane. CVLR doesn't need turning loops, as the vehicles can be driven from either end.
LRT systems on which the existing minimum curve radius falls below 15 meters include:
• Boston—10 m (33 ft) and 13 m (43 ft) for the Green and Mattapan lines, respectively;
• Newark—10 m (33 ft);
• San Francisco—13 m (43 ft); and
• Toronto—11 m (36 ft).
https://onlinepubs.trb.org/Onlinepubs/tcrp/tcrp_rpt_02.pdf (1995)
Trams are one example of Light Rail, but so is the Docklands Light Railway in London (an exception to "on sight" - it's automatic), as opposed the the Tube (underground) which is Heavy. But the Welsh "metro" project's "tram-trains" (Stadler Citylink) are also Light, even though their tracks into the valleys are very much not urban in the usual sense - the full valleys journeys are over one hour with the current trains and go through mostly rural areas with small towns.
I’ll give you an important one as an example: door to door journey times. I support RTO, which is the best way to improve that metric for the average person, which is to say, I was hoping this would be a discussion for out of the box thinking. Or really, what do you invest millions of infrastructure bucks into? All of Uber was only a little more expensive than a single high speed rail line. Why can’t cities run ride share? Why would they run ride share worse than a train service?
And charges/charges more for the service rendered, and still makes a loss.
And if the city would charge for the taxi service... Why run it when other operators can and do? And multiple operators can effectively compete.
Sure, if you don't count the vehicles and the roads – the actual _transportation_ bit
Once you reach a certian density, cars just take up too much space on the road for the number of people they carry, and the only way to meaninfully reduce traffic congestion is to take people out of cars and onto higher-capacity transit.
We already know ride-sharing can't scale up unless your city has super low population density.
Heck, in US they don't even bother with cables or batteries, just put a diesel generator and a tank on electric trains for decades now.
But if you still believe I'm very wrong, please do elaborate.
> The vehicle is battery-powered, eliminating the need for overhead wires. It features an innovative turning system, enabling it to handle 15m radius curves. This allows for installation in tight corners within the existing highway. The Council intends for it to operate at a high frequency, providing a turn-up-and-go service. The vehicle has a capacity of 56, is comfortable and has low floors to enable passengers to embark and disembark easily. The vehicle has been developed to allow autonomous operation in future.
> The new track is laid just 30cm within the road’s surface, minimising the need to relocate pipes and cables, which is time-consuming and expensive. It achieves this by leveraging cutting-edge materials science, while still utilising standard rail parts to ensure ease of manufacture.